Schiavoni's Market is family-owned market. It is a hidden gem for all your grocery needs in Sag…read moreHarbor. They provide a fresh selection of meats in the butcher section. Additionally, they offer salads, lunch meats, vegetables, produce, cheeses, and much more. It is an excellent place to pick up something when heading to the beach or returning home.

So over priced and you ALWAYS need to check the dates on products. Spent $6 on a small kombucha for…read moreit to have expired in November 2024. Thank god I noticed it looked weird and checked the date before drinking. It's happened more times than I can remember that there has been expired food on the shelves. I've also found produce that has mold contaminating whatever fruits and veg that they are next to. It's ridiculous to have such expansive items that are already expired on the shelves. I've gotten sick from the hot plate food and everything is soaked in grease. Also rude workers.

Purchased this apple cranberry bread today from Greenport IGS and 1/3 of the top was green with…read moremold. It's not like you could miss it

What a Cool market right in the center of town! Good for…read morepicking up just about anything and everything! Buy one thing, to everything you need-this is the place to be for groceries, desserts and/or even the beer of your choice. They have a pretty good selection for a small market. Wish there were more in the area, but again, great place. Great location and parking. In the center of town with shops, restaurant, bars and just about everything!

I have been living in this town for years and I choose to go to the IGA in Amagansett due to the…read morelack of options and quality of produce compared to Amagansett IGA even though that location is not the best either. Living in such a wealthy area on Long Island you would think our grocery stores would be top of the line. That is farthest from the truth. I have been to better grocery stores in much lower income neighborhoods than the ones we have in the Hamptons. I particularly had enough tonight and could not keep this bottled up. I had a late night craving for the white cheddar Cheetos puffs. Every grocery store but the one in my town carries them. I don't ever eat junk food, but I had a desperate craving tonight. They have let me down. I hate that there is mostly self check out now. It is cold and soulless compared to the relationships you build with the people in front of you. My family and I miss the old staff... they were wonderful. Do better Montauk IGA. Bring back normal checkouts instead of this computer BS. Two self check outs stations were enough. Do better on the inventory.

Title: The Human Raincloud of the Montauk IGA…read more I've been shopping at the Montauk IGA for years and can say, without hesitation, that it's usually a shining example of small-town warmth and friendliness. The staff is famously helpful, cheerful, and welcoming -- which is why encountering Dayanara at the checkout feels like suddenly stepping into a thunderstorm in the middle of a sunny day. It's as if her job description reads: "Scowl, sigh heavily, and make customers question all their life choices." She manages to inject rudeness into the most basic exchanges, going out of her way to be curt, unhelpful, and generally unpleasant. If Montauk ever needed a mascot for passive-aggressive hostility, she'd be overqualified. This isn't a case of someone having a bad day -- this is a professional commitment to being a human sandpaper strip. The contrast with the rest of the staff is so stark it's almost performance art. For the sake of the store's otherwise stellar reputation, she should be moved into a role that doesn't involve live humans. Stock room. Night shift. Mars. Anywhere but the checkout lane. IGA Montauk, keep doing what you do best -- just maybe reassign your resident mood assassin before she convinces visitors that "Montauk charm" is a myth.

Amazing options for groceries and cooked food! Everything in the hamptons is so expensive and this…read moregrocery is no exception but compaired to all of them I feel like this one has a better price because you can still get a fair amount of food for less then $20. I mostly get some cooked stuff here like their fried chicken, shrimp, rice and more and it was delicious! Their grocery items is pretty expensive. I remember getting less than 10 items for $100+ already. Then again its the Hamptons. I really like that they also have space to eat outdoors. Staff are friendly and very helpful too. If you're visiting around here, this is a good place to grab some cooked stuff and bring it to the beach or picnic!

Javier, the sweetest soul I've ever met, helped me find everything I needed for my family's dinner…read more He was incredibly attentive and patient with my limited knowledge of cheese. I'm glad to know that Citerella hires such a great team!

We live near Harbor Market and it's a real go to for us in Sag, but the prepared food at Cavaniolas…read moreis spectacular, best in Sag. Recommend: Crab cakes Broccoli rabe MEATLOAF OMG what this is insane Meatballs Caprese salad Pretty much all the desserts Lobster salad ( note it is NINETY FIVE dollars a pound. Is this above the gold standard? It might be. It's outrageous but it's tasty.) They are also very nice here, significantly more so than the cheese shop next door. Still you can complete all your fancy shopping in one place at Cavaniolas.

Yum! If their panini…read moreare so good that you still enjoy them on a 95 degree day, you know they're doing something right. Wanted to spend a half day walking around Sag Harbor and was looking for a place to grab lunch to go. High quality ingredients and friendly staff that directed us to a good place nearby to sit and eat. We only ordered sandwiches but they had a variety of sweet and savory items ready to go, which would have made for a wonderful picnic had it been a bit cooler outside.

Angela is the best! The best BAC on a hard roll on the North Fork! Be sure to take a piece of…read morecrumble with you for later

I stopped in before going fishing and this sweet older woman took my order. She then admonished a…read moreregular for not saying hi to her as he sat down at a picnic table inside. He replied, "you were busy! If you weren't doing anything, I'd jump over the counter and give you a kiss!" This amused the woman. She takes your name and tells the cook, please make this for (insert name here)". There's something very sweet to it all. Gone are the days of getting a sandwich for under $10 anywhere. Most sandwiches run from $ 11-14, but they're interesting, like a chicken cordon bleu. They do have a BLT for less and grilled cheese for under $6. I chose the turkey with mozzarella, bacon, and thousand island on a garlic roll and was really pleasantly surprised by how good it was. As far as a general store, there are really limited choices. There are maybe two cans of beans, one bottle of ketchup, a few candles sold by a local maker, but this place seems more of a a homey deli with other limited choices. I'll definitely be back!!

For as long as I remember I've been coming to the IGA- first George's and now SI IGA…read moreOne of the best things about the market was the MUSIC!! It was so much fun to walk down the aisles listening to great classic rock! And then boom-- the music stopped and it became the most unbearable pop and hip hop -- I now try to wear ear plugs and make my purchases as fast as possible to escape the terrible loud droning awful music Please IGA--- bring back the Dead, the Stones and Jimi and all the greats! And make the SI IGA unique and cool again!! But 4 stars cause it is a great local market, bad music and all--- staff are friendly and helpful and food is fresh!

Small island supermarket this place does not disappoint. Was pleasantly surprised to see they…read morecarried everything we wanted and more! Prices higher than at home of course but we'll worth it for the convenience. Very nice clean store

Whenever I'm in Greenport, I always go to this establishment. They have the most amazing selections…read moreof vinegar and oils you can imagine. I tend to go with the citrus flavors in my oils. It covers all bases from salads to even cooking with fish, etc. fabulous place.

I like this place for all the different vinegars. They are very high quality and I love the…read moredifferent flavors. They have good snacks as well, like the truffle oil popcorn, which is quite strong - eat in small quantities! You can actually bring your bottles back and have them refilled so you don't have to purchase new ones each time. I really appreciate this aspect. We visit every summer and I go every year.