Tested the waters due to the frequent raving reviews on FB, and personally I wasn't impressed. I wish it lived up to the hype. The service was great, the facility is clean and tidy, but lacked flavor. Maybe an off day. Who knows? Would I try again? Eh. The lunch special is pretty solid. The slices and knots are large portions. read more

Frankies NY Pizza - Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Simpsonville, South Carolina

See all

This continues to be a favorite and fabulous pizza parlor. Soda does come in a can at two dollars each. There's a menu on the counter if you can't read the high one on the wall. Comfortable seating for 22 inside in a couple little seats outside. The pizza is piping hot and absolutely delicious! read more

See all

Our group of 7 visited Frankie's for dinner tonight. Driving into the parking lot, I wasn't sure if there was going to space inside for our group but they've got seating for about 40 inside. Their soda machine was down but they had cans available. I'm not sure if $2.50 for a can of soda was worth it so I opted for refillable iced tea. We ordered and food started coming out quickly. First they brought out my friends small Greek salad which was a great size and looked tasty. They brough out a little cup of their pepperoni chips for us to try, maybe unbeknownst to them that I had ordered a whole appetizer of them. They were basically baked pepperoni slices served with ranch (I enjoyed dipping them in marinara as well). My chicken parmesan sub was good. Two thinly pounded chicken breasts that had been breaded in fried. Put between two really good hoagie/grinder rolls. My only complain would be wanting more cheese and marinara. I found the sandwich to be just a touch dry without the extra sauce. Service was great. The place was busy with to go orders and our group was checked on regularly. Nice little spot. Worth a visit if you're in the area. read more

We got the small pepperoni, sausage, and mushroom pizza. It was the thinnest pizza I've ever eaten. Enjoyed it!

Moved from new york hard to find good pizza this place is great everyone loved it employees are nice they don't have apple pay read more

Frankies NY Pizza - Cannoli - Pizza Near Me - Simpsonville, South Carolina

True. New York style Pizza extremely good a bit pricey, but it's cheaper than going all the way to New York. For the real deal

I had a craving for a meatball sub and this was the spot. 5pm on Sunday and it was not at all busy. Ten minutes after ordering, I had it in my hands. Toasted and crunchy bread, melty cheese, hot meatballs and sauce. A good portion and not too expensive. The young girls who are working the register are polite and efficient. The restaurant is clean. It was a great sandwich and a great experience today. [Review 21128 overall - 1117 in South Carolina - 91 of 2024.] read more

See all

It's a hidden gem. Pizza is phenomenal and the prices are extremely reasonable and the best part you can buy it by the slice as well. The staff is super friendly and make it know that they appreciate your business. read more

We ordered 2 pizzas' to be delivered last night. 1 pizza was a cheese pizza with pepperoni and black olives, the other pizza was a cheese pizza with onions, mushrooms and green peppers. When delivered (right on time) both pizzas were dry, hard and barely warm. They were almost tasteless. Very large disappointment - we will never order a pizza from them again. The garlic knots were good, and we were thankful we had something to eat. read more

stopped tonight to eat a t Frankie's, greeted by great smiles and welcomes from Sophia , Angelina , and Vasoula. They always make us feel at home offering great service and great pizza! the wings are great as well. George the owner has given us tasty treats after our meals, letting us try other tasty items they offer. a great place to eat!! read more

In town visiting a friend, it was decided that it was going to be pizza night. Eager, not having had decent pizza in a while I pleased with the result.. To start we got delivery and not being from the area I'm not exactly sure how far it is to where we are just outside of Greenville, but I think it's a decent drive. The delivery dude made good time and the pizzas were nice and hot. We got one Sausage and peppers pie and a pepperoni pie. Presentation and packing were very good, not melted cheese sliding off the slices and not too greasy. My only complaint was the peppers could've been sliced a bit better and a bit more sausage, but they still tasted very good, as did the pepperoni. My friend, his family and I made short work of the two pies. My friend says this is his favorite pizza spot in the area and can see why. With fast delivery, good packing and nice tasting pizza, I recommend. read more

Frankies NY Pizza - Pizza box - Pizza Near Me - Simpsonville, South Carolina

See all

Whenever I come from Georgia to visit my mother I always look forward to ordering the Charlotte from Frankie's. Tonight I ordered through their Slice app as recommended. The pizza and mozzarella sticks arrived in a timely manner but both were cold. The pizza crust tasted like cardboard. Next time I come down I will try ordering directly from Frankie's. read more

Oh my goodness my Calzone is freakin fantastic!!! It is the perfect amount cheese and their signature sauce! read more

Frankies NY Pizza - Pepperoni and Mushroom Calzone - Pizza Near Me - Simpsonville, South Carolina

Pizza is great!! Restaurant is clean! Staff is so friendly! We love to eat at Frankie's! read more

Pizza was delicious!!!! Huge slice and hot out of the oven. If I close my eyes, I would think I was in New York.

We love Frankie's for take out! It's always fresh and pizzas are some of the best in Greenville!

The food was absolutely delicious! We are very picky with pizza and glad we found our spot. it was perfectly cooked even the kids loved it! Great wings and the homemade cannolis were one of the best. Excellent service and staff very polite. read more

Reviewing our Nov 19th takeout order from Frankies Pizza - Five Forks, Simpsonville We ordered 2 pizzas and wings. The pizzas we ordered were large cheese and pepperoni and a Hope pizza. The pizzas we received were a large Sicilian cheese and pepperoni and a Billy the Bull pizza. We like Frankie's pizza but those are pretty big mistakes read more

Got the lunch special. Cannot beat the price. Slices are huge. Great deal. Highly recommended

Nearly 2 hours for a cheese pizza. Pathetic. It's not like this is some gourmet dish. It's a cheese pizza. Avoid

Greenville has a ton of NY style pizza places which is odd, because I live in Columbia and we have maybe two? Eating through these places up here is hard because they all claim to have the best NY Style Pizza or the most authentic. Frankie's is good. I'll stop it there, really. You're not going to come here and get blown away by their slices, but they're solid enough to come back frequently. I've had slices all along the Southeast and even the Northeast up in Boston. This could compete right up there with those. It just wouldn't be in the top 3 or 5. It's kind of rare to see pizza places down South offer slices. Pizza places can be really weird about that, but Frankie's does it and props to them. I'd check them out. read more

Frankies NY Pizza - Slices - Pizza Near Me - Simpsonville, South Carolina

5 stars for customer service while taking my delivery order, 5 stars for delivery from the owner, 5 stars for amazing ranch dressing, and 5 stars for piping hot pizza with fresh ingredients. I ordered 14" Frankies Special and highly recommend if you are wanting a perfect combo of fresh yet flavorful vegetables, dynamic meat toppings, and "can stand up to bending your pizza slice" cheese. You won't be disappointed. I will be ordering more of Frankies Pizza. read more

We moved from Florida to SC a year ago and have been looking for a "true" italian style pizza joint and this place is the best. the pizza was the best we've had since moving here. I would recommend this place to everyone. The service was also fast and super friendly. read more

My wife talked me into trying again even though I was pretty set on not returning. The driver was wearing a good mask today and wearing it correctly. This driver was practicing covid precautions and we appreciated it very much. I guess they just have one driver who won't wear a mask so now I'm not sure about ordering again because we won't know if we will get a driver like today being careful or one like the time before with no mask at all. read more

Home Run. Slam Dunk. Knock it out the Park. This pizza is hands down the go to pizza. Now I have a top 3 of pizza places in Greenville. The only thing is, they forgot my marinara for my garlic knots and I ordered extra marinara at that. Other than that dont sleep on this place. Oh and the cheesesteak- top notch! No pic cause I ate it too fast and a few of the knots are missing cause I ate those quick. read more

Frankies NY Pizza - Garlic knots - Pizza Near Me - Simpsonville, South Carolina

See all

Absolutely the best. Amazing pizza and cheese steak. The staff is absolutely wonderful and super friendly. Been in Florida for 6 years and nothing comes even in close. The BEST read more

Frankies NY Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Simpsonville, South Carolina

See all

We stumbled upon this place when we were frantically trying to find some pizza to feed the kids while we were in town looking for homes. Pizza was great NY style Pizza. Cheesiest calzone I've ever had. Great spot. And now we live 5 mins away so we've made it a a regular spot. Staff was friendly. Feels like a typical Ny walk in pizza spot. No complaints. read more

I don't know if there are new owners or what happened, but it was terrible. It was unequivocally the worst pizza we have ever had. I'm not sure how it's even possible to make a pepperoni pizza and a cheese pizza to taste that bad. I think the crust might even be pre-made, and the sauce tasted like ketchup. read more

Great pizza that taste closes to NJ pizza. If anyone from the Northeast looking for their hometown pizza, this is the closest you will get to it in taste. Only bad part is the wait time for your pizza. It gets extremely crowded on Thursday and Fridays so if you need to, you should order the pizza an hour ahead. I still at times have to wait 15-20 mins after getting there so be prepared to wait. Hopefully the owner thinks about expanding the place or moving to a bigger location and get more oven to help with the flow of people on these days. But overall, this is a great place to get your pizza. read more

Horrible... Burnt No cheese 80$ for 2 pizzas Disgusting... Dogs wouldn't even eat it read more

Pizzas are good when they're hot. I live 3 miles away and my pizza was delivered barely warm. Service is meh. They used to be so much better. read more

Garbage pizza. Cut cardboard add ketchup processed cheese the least amount of pepperoni you have Simpsonville's New Yorks finest. I kept going and only got better at being cardboard read more

Frankie's is our go-to restaurant in the area. Great pizza and wings! We love supporting local small businesses, and the staff there is fantastic! read more

Great pizza! Courteous staff. Prompt delivery. A winner! My "go to" pizza place. I recommend them read more

I've read the reviews and they are all over the place, hitting both extremes with divergent opinions. Now, I am no pizza expert, but having just spent 11 years in Upstate NY with a Sister In-Law in the city whom we visited frequently I know a thing or two about "NY Style Pizza" & the various takes on pizza within NY based on your region or Burb. So honestly I do not understand some of the prior reviews, of which some appear to be written out of spite. Regardless, from my own evaluation I have nothing negative to say about the "attitude" of the staff to include the owner who was nothing but friendly and talkative with me. Now for the food. I can not speak to any of the other menu items for I have not tried them yet. But, the pie is tasty and is thin crust NY pizza that I'm use to. Granted the slices are not as large as I'm use to, but you can still fold eat and enjoy. I would recommend the pie. It's pretty dam tasty. read more

Frankies NY Pizza - My son eating his favorite pie. Great thin crust NY style pizza!!! - Pizza Near Me - Simpsonville, South Carolina

We ordered a large 18" pepperoni NY style pizza with cheesy bread tonight. We came here about a week ago to try and get a pizza, but since they're doing curbside only the wait was over 50 minutes for a pizza. Glad we decided to come back! We called it in and only had to wait about 5 minutes. The pizza didn't disappoint and their french garlic style cheesy bread was really good too! My sister lives in Buffalo, NY and we eat pizza there every time we go visit. This pizza was pretty up to par with authentic NY pizza in the flavor, sauce/topping ratio, plenty of cheese, and insanely large slices that you fold in half to scarf down. The price was VERY affordable for what you get too. I'd recommend! read more

Frankies NY Pizza - Cheesy Bread - Pizza Near Me - Simpsonville, South Carolina

See all

located in a small strip mall this is a rare find of pretty darn close to NY/NJ Pizza. Cost is a little more than I think they should charge BUT I still buy it on a regular basis. Only place I've found that was close was their sister place, Bada Bing. Crust is different but still tastes like home. Best in the area IMO read more

Best pizza in the area, by far. Closest I can get to New York pizza. A little pricey but worth the extra cost if its once in awhile.

The pizza here is BY FAR the best in the area. The New York style pizza is always perfectly cooked. The end. read more

I'm not some pizza expert like Dave from barstool sports nor do I have a degree in this stuff but I'm fat and I'll let my credibility weigh in from that. I have high standards for food and don't eat anywhere or everywhere when I'm hungry but this place hit the spot. Got their cheese pizza and garlic knots. Both were extremely delicious! Crust a perfect crunchy but a chewy, cheese was fresh and one of the few pizza places that doesn't churn my stomach after I consume it. Best pizza I've had since moving from the west coast. You won't be disappointed and kind of surprised by the low reviews to be honest. read more