Freddy's was my only pizza on a recent trip to NYC. After reading the menu I had to go with the Grandma Alla Vodka Pie. Loved the crust, loved the vodka sauce, and loved the fresh mozzarella. I ate way too much. It was too good. Very close to where I stay in Bayside. I will be back! read more

See all

Good pizza! We usually order a Sicilian pie with half pepperoni and half plain, and it's always fresh and delicious. I especially love the sesame seed crust. The only downside is that they don't currently offer local delivery, but honestly, the pizza is worth the drive to pick it up. Definitely recommend! read more

Most reliable plain slice. The main reason I love Vodka grandma pizza. Always hits the spot. The service is friendly and quick. Clean location, always find street parking. read more

Freddy's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Whitestone, New York

Freddy's is one of the greats in Whitestone. I'm Thu king that the founders sold but the quality remains. My usual order is a plain slice and an old fashioneded slice. Both didn't disappoint. Thin but crispy crust, a good lance of semi-sweet tomato sauce and mozzarella. The old fashioned slice used fresh mozzarella. read more

Freddy's Pizzeria - Plain and old fashioned slices - Pizza Near Me - Whitestone, New York

The new owners completely changed the pizza. I miss the old Freddy''s...the flavor just isn't the same anymore. I'm not really looking for basil and fancy toppings; I loved the classic pizza they used to make. I definitely miss the old taste, and the prices too. We always bought Freddy's, but sadly we'll be going elsewhere. The place looks cute, but it just isn't hitting the mark for me. The pizza is too floppy, doughy and just not that good in my opinion. I understand that businesses evolve, but this feels like a completely different restaurant now. Labeling Freddys and still stating since 1961 seems off. Just change the name at this point. Freddy's used to be a great hidden gem with simple, delicious pizza, and that's what kept us coming back. While some people may enjoy the new direction, it's just not what I loved about the original. It's disappointing to see such a big change, and unfortunately, I don't think we'll be returning. read more

They have redecorated and it's super cute! My son had the upside down Sicilian and loved it. I split the Freddy hero with my other son and we were blown away! We I'll definitely be back! read more

See all

Amazing food service ambience amazing quality definitely give this place a try if you're in a Whitestone area blows everyone out of the water read more

See all

My first time trying this pizza and now I have my spot. Thin crispy and delicious-exactly what a NY slice should taste like. Staff is so nice and accommodating, place is clean, highly recommend! read more

I grew up with Freddie's, the original Freddie's owner sold the place and new owners have changed the recipes and it's totally different. The sauce is definitely different. I would not recommend this place anymore. read more

We got the famous vodka grandmas pie and it was delicious. They definitely know what they are doing here and I highly recommend Freddy's.

I don't know how they do it but every slice is delicious. Had their upside down and regular slice. So freaking good. Then had their vodka slice and fell in love. The service is friendly and fast. The location is cool and clean but small. I'm planing to go again this week. read more

When passing Whitestone on the Cross Island....my heart always pulls me off the exit and to Freddy's. I grew up down the street....and nothing at Freddy's has changed.... Same pizza I had growing up...classic slice and a slice of Sicilian....and a root beer....perfection ! Same taste, same sauce, takes me back 40 years.... Perfect spot for a great pizza lunch at great prices for two slices and a soda under $10. Highly recommend, always. read more

Freddy's Pizzeria - The old school way ! Classic and Sicilian ! - Pizza Near Me - Whitestone, New York

See all

Garbage. We have been ordering from Freddy's forever for a reason until now. $101 for 3 pies and they are all dough. I don't understand why change a good thing? When you are from Whitestone and have relied on Freddy's forever there is no reason to change it for the worse. read more

Ordered pizza for delivery pizza was good as always delivery was fast, previously I would hesitate ordering from Freddys because of the delivery time read more

Quite a unique find-- sesame seed crusted Sicilian pizza! Recommended by a chef friend of mine, and I was eager to try it. This is above average neighborhood pizza, both the round pie and the Sicilian. Sicilian: Crunchy crust that reminds me of focaccia bread. The sesame underside gives each bite a toasty flavor that complements the square. Very cheesy with sweet tomato sauce that tastes fresh. Not greasy, and you don't feel heavy after eating it. Round: Decent crunch with nice structure. Balanced pizza that isn't greasy. Would love to get pepperoni next time to compare! Delivery on a Saturday evening was only 20 minutes! Very impressive and would definitely eat from here again! read more

See all

I have been going to Freddy's since I was 10yrs old. I have to take 1-2 stars down due to the service and food. The new people working at the front need some training and to really listen what customers are saying. I ordered 1 slice and 2 sicillian slices to go, I see him put 1 sicillian and 1 slice into the oven. He comes to me and I give him a friendly reminder it is 2 sicillian and 1 slice, he replied with a little attitude and said "I KNOW", then charge me 10.85, sounds right. Now I am waiting and thinking when he pull the food out, he going to be missing 1 sicillian, sure enough when time to box my food, boom 1 missing sicillian. Worse, he pull out the food, put it in the box and let get cold while he makes me wait for another sicillian to be heated. In terms of the food...sad...it not the same as before...sad..very sad.... the pizza has been changed to what it was originally...sad ..very sad... Overall, the person in the front really need to think about what is his job and check his attitude...the people in this neighbourhood are all trying to be helpful.... The pizza, went down..sad ..sad read more

Freddy's pizza is always perfection, perfect crispy crust, thickness is just right, sauce is delicious. Their old fashioned and Sicilian are both phenomenal and you can never go wrong with a regular pie. We also always order food as well, penne vodka-excellent, their grilled chicken Chicken francese and chicken cutlets -wonderful. Chicken rolls, eggplant rolls-winners. get the side of sauce! my kids love their chicken tenders with honey mustard. Side of sauteed broccoli always cooked perfect and garlicky. read more

I'm solely basing this review off of the regular slice only! I haven't tried any other of their items but I can tell you that the slice is damn near perfect! It's perfect size, good price ($3.25) and it tastes great! It's saucy, cheesy and not floppy. The service was good too. The guys were polite and quick. The place was empty because it was Sunday and rainy but it was clean. Definitely a return for me! read more

Freddy's Pizzeria - Regular slice. Really good! - Pizza Near Me - Whitestone, New York

Pretty solid pizzeria that has been in Whitestone forever! I have been here multiple times over the years. Is it my favorite? No, but they have beaten most of the other pizzerias in the area, so there is that. The inside is very nice and clean for a pizzeria. It feels like a pizzeria when you walk in. Nice, bright, but still has a classic pizzeria feel to it. It feels like a half step up from other pizzerias. Food is pretty solid. No real complaints. I have stuck with the za most of the time, I haven't had the opportunity to try their dinners or anything like that. Their pizza is pretty good. A nice crust, needs a tad bit more flavor, a little dry as well. But dunk the crust in sauce, and bang zoom! Their sauce has got a really great flavor as well, not too acidic. Their cheese is pretty good! Needs a tad bit more salt or something to make it perfect. But good overall. Staff has always been friendly whenever I have gone. All in all a really solid pizzeria in Whitestone. If you don't go to Pizza Chef in the shopping center, this is your next best bet! read more

Freddy's is a staple of Whitestone. They are a must at least once. Been in business over 40 years and still running. This is just one of those places that will ALWAYS have mixed reviews and a spot in the hearts of locals forever. They need to do something about that old register though lol read more

Grandma vodka & old fashion pizza are amazing !!! Sicilian is perfect as well with the sesame seed bottom. Go to pizza spot

Tried Freddy's last weekend after stumbling on Portnoy's review of the place. Had a regular slice, a vodka grandma, and garlic knots. The vodka grandma was very good - super saucy and flavorful, and definitely something worth returning for. The knots were garlicky and oily and delicious. The plain slide was solid - but more of a four star than five star slice, and any pizza place should be judged on their regular slices. Could be that it was the last one from a pie in the showcase, so it was sitting for a bit, but I didn't think it lived up to Dave's hype from a fresh pie. read more

Freddy's Pizzeria - Vodka Grandma, Regular slice - Pizza Near Me - Whitestone, New York

Best Sicilian in Queens always amazing and consistent- an automatic go to anytime I'm close to it

Been eating Freddy's Pizza since aI was 22 years old. I am now 78. Best friend n Whitestone

Great pizza. Real nice people.thank you Joe. Real good Sicilian. Love the sesame seeds on the bottom. Also a great old fashioned with the fresh mozzarella. read more

Solid regular slice pizza. Better than average for sure. Try the vodka grandma slice. It was an interesting test and if you're into that sort of thing you'd love it. read more

Freddy's Pizzeria - Regular cheese slice and a vodka grandma square - Pizza Near Me - Whitestone, New York

pretty good food but the yellow rabbit who was luring kids into the backroom was offputing, so are the animatronics

Freddie's pizzeria has been a staple in the Whitestone community for decades. Their pizza and dishes are delicious. Food served quickly and the small restaurant has a nice family feel. The pizza is fresh, good ingredients and tasty. Worth a try. NO inside dining at this time due to COVID restrictions . read more

Freddy's Pizzeria - Yummy - Pizza Near Me - Whitestone, New York

See all

Going to Freddy's since I was single digits and 76 now love their pizza Great service and easy parking but you must pay for it read more

I've been going to this pizzeria since before Apple Pay was a thought and they have the best pizza in whitestone.

The Pizza here is really good! I had a Sicilian and regular slice both Not greasy and not salty! I'm 8 months pregnant and very very picky! Pizzerias like this clean and with quality products are hard to find! Definitely a GEM in Whitestone! read more

Freddy's Pizzeria - Delicious - Pizza Near Me - Whitestone, New York

I love this pizzeria, The Buffalo slice is my favorite, the wings are the best in the neighborhood also, it's my go to for lunch

I absolutely love Freddy's, I've been coming here since I was a kid and it's still the best pizza I've ever had!! The service is always so friendly, and the quality of the food is consistently amazing that I always find myself going out of my way to stop by at Freddy's for a slice or two. read more

Freddy's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Whitestone, New York

Just fantastic pizza. My daughter has a thing nearby and so we're in Whitestone every week, and we're at Freddy's nearly every time for dinner. Look, this is NYC so there's good pizza everywhere--but there are spots that everyone knows about and wants to tell you about. This place is a hidden gem. Their pizza is just absurdly good. And the longer we go, the more we realize Freddy's punches way above its weight class. There are places in Brooklyn and Manhattan probably paying 80x the rent and bragging 80x as hard on their Twitter about being on top ten lists, and they can't touch Freddy's. I'm ambivalent about this; I want more people to know about this place, but happy they don't so we can always get a place to sit. No one cares what some sports blog full of troll interns has to say about pizza. Just go eat there if you want to know what's up. A shining example of NYC pizza, quintessential if you will. read more

Freddy's Pizzeria - Vodka slice. Pure magic. - Pizza Near Me - Whitestone, New York

Pizza place that's been around since I was a kid. Solid place in the village. Tastes even better when super hungry. Had the vodka grandma Sicilian slice too, which was delicious. read more

Freddy's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Whitestone, New York

Absolutely love this place since I was a kid . Eggplant parmigiana dish , Absolutely my favorite !! Always consistent, and what can I say , the best I have ever had !! read more

Great pizza! Sicilian is amazing and the owners are great! Friendly and attentive - so appreciative with kids!

Freddy's is my favorite pizzeria. In the last 8-9 years of going there I can't complain about anything. Everything is always fresh, delicious and quick. If you haven't tried their Sicilian yet then make sure you try it the next time you go! read more

Freddy's Pizzeria - The best fried raviolis - Pizza Near Me - Whitestone, New York

See all

Pizza here WAAAAAAYYYY overrated. Second time trying it First time was almost too oily to eat. Literally dripping with oil. Fast forward to second time pizza was nasty tasted like reheated day old pizza. This was fresh AND I waited an hour and 20 minutes for delivery. Never been more disappointed. With a pizzeria then here. I can't for the life of me figure out why people love it so much. For me I WON'T be going back that's for certain. read more

This place is a joke on more than one occasion I've tried to order food 45-30 minutes before their closing time (9:30 on a Friday) and they tell me they are done making that for the day. Well you are done making me anything, because this pizza places food is nothing special compared with the ten other restaurants near it. I'll call any one of their competitors and they'll make a pie just as good, right up to 10 min before they close. I litterly left this place after they wouldn't make a pizza, called a different place and picked it up 15 min later. read more