Fresca Cafe

Always my first stop when we come to visit Prescott…read more. Hands down the best service always and the most amazing food. Leaving pictures so you can see how great the food really is.

With a craving for pizza we found this place through a map search for restaurants as possible…read more The place is quaint with a Southwest ambiance. It was full of patrons for dinner and we were seated right away in a cozy booth. Strangely the table was far short of the seating. The menu is broad with all the typical Italian selections. We put in our drink order and I had a Argentine Malbec. It was rich and delicious. We started with an appetizer of Arancini. These traditional fried rice balls were huge, two of them. Mixed with peas and other tasty ingredients, the exterior were nice and crunchy. Cooked perfectly they were delicious with a cup of Marinara to pour over them. The pizza we ordered was the 18" Mediteraneo with grilled chicken, ricotta and mozzarella cheese and a pesto sauce. The 18" was very adequate sized for four hungry people with some left over. The pizza was good yet a bit off in that the cheese overpowered everything else. I do not recall eating any chicken or tasting the pesto. The ricotta seemed to be a unique ingredient yet it doesn't seem to set properly as if it was applied frozen (?) The service was extroadinary, so friendly and accommodating. The only mistep which is probably a kitchen problem is we waited and waited for the appetizer. When it finally arrived the pizza arrived literally right on top of it with not enough room on the table. I'd return to try some of their other Italian offerings.

Godfather

Godfather pizza

See all

Beers on tap

Bill's Pizza

4.1(931 reviews)

One of the very first places my daughter asks to go every time we get to Prescott. We love that you…read morecan just order pizza by the slice, they heat it up fresh right then, and we can take it over to the lawn in front of the old courthouse for the sweetest little picnic. It's become one of those simple traditions we always look forward to. They have such a great variety too, so everyone can find something they love, which makes it even better when visiting with family or friends.

OMG Loved It! Tasty pizza with amazing service!…read moreIf you go, ask for Robb! Coolest server ever! Love this place!! Gluten free pizza actually tastes like pizza!

Table in the back

The yummiest pizza in town!

See all

Inside

Limoncello Pizzeria Napoletana

4.0(808 reviews)

2.0 mi

My wife and I were very impressed with our visit to Limoncello…read more Our server Haley was the best, she knew the menu well and pointed us in the right direction for our order. The two drinks we got were very tasty (Limoncello Lemon drop & The Hugo). Being a Saturday night, it was understandably busy, but the wait staff was incredibly patient and helpful despite the circumstances. Also, all our food still came out very fast (granted, we didn't get pizza). The ambiance is awesome, with a pizza oven shaped and styled like a lemon!

Disappointed with our visit.... -Porcini mushroom / Sausage…read morepizza was ok. Crust, dough good but I really didn't like how the mushrooms were cut into slimy cubes. I expected larger actual mushroom looking pieces. Sausage was good but I couldn't get past the mushroom. $21.95 -Spinach salad (spinaci limone half) felt like a rip off. It was a small 1/2 plate of spinach with a few pecans and raisins. See picture..$7.99 -Amalfe drink was good $11.00 - Service at the bar was good. - There is also a credit card fee. Too many other good restaurants, Italian as well, in Prescott to go to. We won't be back....sorry we love family run businesses too.

Tiramisu - looked like a hot mess

See all

Amalfi

Two Mamas' Gourmet Pizzeria

3.9(424 reviews)

Service was friendly. We picked up a pizza to go because they close for business 30 min before…read morethey officially close. The pizza is OK. Not great. When they made the sauce oregano was evidently on sale. It is clearly the only dominant flavor in their sauce. Cook temp is also way too low. The crust doesn't crisp like a pizza should. I didn't check out the oven but i bet it doesn't include a fired tile platform. No char on the bottom of the crust at all. Its not somewhere i would return to by choice, and certainly not a destination but its edible.

We got a build your own pizza to go this evening. Thin crust medium was plenty for two people with…read morea few slices left over for lunch. We ordered by phone and the pizza was ready for pick up when we arrived. We decided to pick the pizza up early and reheat later (avoiding the evening rush). We have eaten here several times in the past, always a great place and one we always recommend to people visiting Prescott. Nice small town atmosphere in the restaurant.

Inside. Saturday near five

Deep dish pizza

See all

Hand tossed pepperoni and mushroom

Park Plaza Liquor and Deli

4.0(858 reviews)

2.1 mi

Always prompt and fast service Great selection of food and…read morebeverages Large beer selection on Tap

I wish I could leave a review, but I never got to try your food. You see, I ordered food through…read moreDoorDash, but the food never arrived. The Dasher, Joshua, delivered to the wrong address. I texted him, and he texted back apologizing, admitting he delivered to the wrong address. He said he would contact DoorDash and tell them to credit the account. I followed up with a call to DoorDash customer support. I explained the situation but was having difficulty understanding the representative due to her accent. I asked to speak with a manager. She put me on hold saying SHE would explain to the manager what happened. The manager came on the line for a brief moment, saying she was declining our refund, didn't care we never got the food, and said her decision was final. I would suggest your establishment stop using DoorDash as they do not reflect well on your establishment and don't care about your customers.

Truffle Bacon Mac cheese -insane! So good!

See all

Spiced Greek

The Grumpy Sicilian

3.7(143 reviews)

1.9 mi

We had business in town and wanted to grab a bite to eat... but avoiding the fast food,…read morevending-machine garbage. There was a parking spot immediately 8n front of The Grumpy Sicilian so I thought "Why not?" Good choice. None of us wanted a big meal so we risked getting just a slice -- which was delicious! I feared that it might be dried out, but judging from the traffic, the pizza was freshly baked and the town foot traffic made short work of the pie. In other words, it was freshly baked and disappeared fast. Excellent pizza, too. Good vibes, cool place, excellent food... and I like that they kept a parking spot open for our arrival!

I've been on the hunt for good chicken parm, did not find it here. So far the best parm I've got…read morewas at Rosa's, the parm here is like 3/5 very mediocre. Tried the parm with fries and was unpleasantly surprised to get mouthfuls of dry, flavorless starch from the thick cut soggy fries. There's a reason they use thin cut for stuff like carne asada fries and marinara does not go well with french fries in my opinion. So why the 5 stars? The grumpy slice is some of the best pizza I've ever had. I thought it looked questionable that they seemed to just reheat pizza that was sitting on the display counter, but the taste and texture were perfection. And only $5 for a slice. Only place you'll get cheaper pizza is at a gas station.

Don't have any pics of the food because I always eat it before I remember to snap a shot

Pizza

See all

Granite Mountain Pizza Company

4.2(130 reviews)

3.9 mi

My 80 year old mother said it was the best pizza she has ever had! My 4 picky children said the…read moresame. Hands down amazing pizza and even better service. We will be coming here every time we are in Prescott!

We had our order delivered. We ordered the jalapeño cheese…read morebread but received plain garlic bread. The garlic bread is thin and does not have much flavor. They also do not include a dipping sauce. We also ordered a meat lover pizza. They are generous with the toppings but the crust is flavorless and tough. The same can be said about our build your own pizza. I also did not receive the family size greek salad that we ordered. Over all the experience was very disappointing.

Restaurant Interior

Mediterranean

See all

Spring salad

Papa's Italian Restaurant

4.6(1.2k reviews)

I regret not taking photos of this place, as from looking through past reviews I see they…read morepainstakingly change the decor around to fit the relevant holidays. Hundreds of dangling roses draped from the ceiling which gave the restaurant a very romantic and homey feel. It was very exciting and inviting to be inside there! But the food is the center of attention here. From the opening well-garlic'ed bread to Mama's Meatballs to the mammoth-sized calzone (filled with ingredients) and a perfect Old Fashioned, everything was fantastic. I also had a tiramisu which was also excellent. Service was very friendly and prompt. Simply put, I'll go here every time I get to Prescott from here on out!!

Fri 5/29/26 Haven't been here in a couple yrs…read more I had lasagna, if that was Italian sausage in it, it didn't taste like it, it was pretty bland My girlfriend had shrimp scampi that was pretty bland too We had moscato wine and Port wine and ice cream for dessert Jamie and her son provided excellent service and was very attentive. I love the ambience there. The price was very fair $88 Let's step up the sausage to real Italian sausage and will be back

Baked Ziti

See all

House Salad

Streets of New York

3.4(157 reviews)

Best pizza I have had in the area yet The service staff…read morecouldn't be nicer. Great New York ambiance with the hip vibe!

Hidden away in the Sprouts shopping center is Streets of New York. This restaurant offers…read moreexceptionally fast and attentive servers and generous servings of fresh food. We come here often. My husband and I love the crispy salads. You can micromanage a slice of pizza or a whole one. There's pasta offerings as well as delicious sandwiches. There's always plenty of lunch specials if you're on a budget. The rewards program is great too. The restaurant appears very clean and well staffed and managed. It's a restaurant not to be missed!

Spaghetti portion was chintzy ....pizza was good

Mediterranean pizza

See all

The top pizzas was ok the bottom one is the burnt which mgr says is good to eat .... You choose ?

Rosati's Pizza

3.6(180 reviews)

1.9 mi

Just had an Italian Beef, juicy w/extra giardiniera and Aus Jus to go. I had been here closer to…read morewhen they just opened. Back then the beef was loaded with fat which I removed to make a decent sandwich. Now, the beef is super lean and awesome! As a Chicago born Ital Beef addict, this is the best in Prescott! You would have to go to Luke's in Phoenix to get better. Nicely done Rosati's!

This is a small town Italian pizza shop. Limited seating and does get very busy…read more We ordered a thin crust, pizza and lasagna. The lasagna was fabulous. The thin crust pizza was delicious. However, it had way too much cheese on it. Our server seemed very distracted and not very knowledgeable of the menu. The napkin holder on our table showed a dessert sampler platter which we asked her about and she had no idea that it even existed. At the same time as she was giving us our check. So she completely missed the upsell of offering us dessert and seemed to want to rush us out. Overall, I would give it a 3.5 stars out of five. The food was solid and would probably get takeout next time.