Decided to come in and try the Stromboli. I got the sausage roll and my friend got the Stromboli roll. I got to try both and they are fantastic! The seasoning on the roll is perfect. The inside is cheesy and delicious! Service was friendly and food came out Jan timely manner. Highly recommend! read more

Frewsburger Pizza Shop - Sausage roll strombolis - Pizza Near Me - Frewsburg, New York

2.5 they can't follow simple directions and gave me a dried biscuit of a bun and hard dry hockey pucks for chicken. We tried it because none of us had ever tried it and it was right across from the bowling alley we spent a few hours at. I ordered a Buffalo chicken tender sub with extra ranch, provelone cheese, Buffalo sauce, no onion, no tomatoes. I got no Buffalo sauce at all. Extremely light ranch. Extremely overcooked hard dry gross chicken. Tomatoes. Over toasted dry bun. I got up and asked for a cup of Buffalo sauce and a cup of ranch. I was given ranch and just a cup of hot sauce not Buffalo. I just took it because obviously I was somehow asking way too much of the place. Nothing saved it. I threw more than half of the sub away it way dry hard and gross. The Hawaiian was okay not good not bad. It needed more cheese for sure. We'd get it again in a pinch, but wouldn't go out of our way. Torn older plastic table clothes. Carvings in the wooden walls. Talking to a few locals at the gas station kitty corner to the pizza shop about it being a lack luster experience they agreed that the chicken finger sub sucks. They said they only get wings there 90% of the time rarely ever pizza. All three locals in the gas station said the honey mustard wings and medium wings are their best things on the menu. We might try them again to see if the wings are okay. All 3 of us were very unimpressed. read more

Ordered chicken wings with extra sauce... unfortunately they were over cooked very dry and no extra sauce... Well be finding another place for chicken wings. No worth the money I spent read more

Pleasantly surprised by the quality and taste of this pizza shop. Thumbs up I was skeptical going in but found the pizza to be very good

Just stopped in for a convenient lunch while passing through town. Friendly, quick service and a rather well worn counter and dining area that some might not like but that I associate with good neighborhood pizza shops and deli's... If only the pizza was good... Not to say that it's bad exactly but just not to my liking. The crust is a little on the thick side for my taste and the sauce is a bit too sweet. Even the cheese, which is generous, isn't just quite right. To be fair, some people might like their pizza like this and that's great. Just not for me. I don't like to be negative regarding a nice little local business so I will add that I saw several other dishes that looked great. I would try them again... Just something other than the pizza. read more

Pizza and pretzels were very good. We will be back when we are in the area. We took the pretzels to a family outing and they were a hit win win read more

Had heard good things about this place so we decided to order take out on our way home from Jamestown. Delicious pizza. Thick, chewy crust with a good red sauce. Wings were crispy, even after a 40 min ride home. We chose the gold fever sauce after being told it's like a spicy honey mustard, it didn't disappoint. It's one of the best honey mustard sauces I've had. The place was clean, the young kids behind the counter were friendly, and the service was fast. There was a side room with tables and chairs. Didn't get to look in, but it looked clean from what I could see. Prices were on par with my local pizza joints. Would definitely recommend. read more

See all

Just heads or pizza for the very first time absolutely fantastic!! Fast, friendly and clean

Great pizza!! Come here on work break multiple times a week, employees are friendly and helpful always. Highly recommend, you'll be back over and over again!! read more

Frewsburger Pizza Shop - Pizza Near Me - Frewsburg, New York

AWESOMESAUCE!! Everything here is great!! My favorite thing is the cheeseburger belly bomb... It's sooooo good and the pizza crust is phenomenal!! read more

Delicious and fresh. We had a meatball sub and turkey club..All of it was fresh and they didn't skimp on the ingredients.. Don't need to ask for extra they give you plenty and it is really, really good... read more

Highly recommend any of the stromboli's! Cinnamon poppers and icing are a great dessert and you get a mountain of them for 3.99. Little cinnamon sugar donuts. Order at the counter and they bring it out to your table when ready, pay when you are done. Or order take out! Friendly service. Fresh ingredients. Can't beat it! read more

Frewsburger Pizza Shop - Cinnamon poppers with icing, bacon cheese fries, cheesy bread, chicken wing roll with AAALLLL THE CHEESE!! - Pizza Near Me - Frewsburg, New York

See all

Tasty and unique offerings. Enjoyed the Taco salad pizza and honey mustard chicken pizza. A must stop.

Was recommended to try taco pizza with hot sauce-- we voted a 5/5 as being loved! Very filling and tasty! Will definitely purchase again. Friendly workers too! read more

Delicious pizza with generous toppings. The wings are great, I'm always a sucker for spicy honey mustard wings and these did not disappoint. For a little pizza joint, they were worth the stop. read more

The Frewsburger is the best pizza shop around! They have amazing pizza with a slightly sweet sauce and a thick, fluffy crust. Their stombolis, subs and other products are just as amazing! Try it and you'll be hooked read more

This has to be our favorite place to get pizza and wings! Centrally located in frewsburg, it's only a few minutes from jamestown and falconer making this spot ideal for great pizza! They have a clean restaurant if you want to stay and eat. We generally take our pizza home and it's always hot when we get it home. It's the best tasting sauce and they only use the most fresh toppings! We have never been disappointed! Try the chicken wing pizza the next time you are there!! read more

Excellent pizzas! I love the sweeter sauce and the dough is perfect. The fact that they use deck ovens instead of a conveyor makes a huge, noticeable difference. The only problem I have is the pricing. It is a little steep when compared to some others in the area. But, this will remain my favorite spot. read more