Prices keep going up, but their quality of food and staff keep going down. They've always nickeled and dimed you to death, but now it's way worse. It's sad when Crosby's gas station pizza is 10x better than tasta. This is a pizza and wings area. There are so many great places to eat at instead of them. I wish they would notice that they are even losing loyal boomers and people who just eat there out of nostalgia. A lot of local police eat there, but my friend on JPD says half of them just do it out of tradition and wanting to support a local place not out of actually liking it anymore. I don't know what happened, but you can't blame covid because they started going down hill years before covid. Maybe covid will be the last nail in their coffin if they don't get their act back together. 10 years ago I'd say they were top 5 in town now they are at the absolute bottom of the list. Ranking pizzas around Jamestown, Falconer, and Lakewood: 1. Perfect Pizza 2. Sauce 3. La Cocina del a nona (they raised prices big time too, but they are still great quality,flavor, and staff) 4. Allen st diner 5. Danny B's 6. Lena's (A lot like perfect pizza, but the crust is doughy bubble gum sometimes) 7. Honest John's 8. Wegmans cafe as well as take and bake 9. Group therapy 10. Crosby's gas station in Falconer and Randolph 11. Pizza Express 12. Blairs 13. Little Caesars 14. Walmart take and bake 15. Aldi's take and bake 16. Brick city 17. Tops take and bake 18. Dominos in Falconer (Lakewood location is garbage and burns everything) 19. 711 (all premade) 20. Subway pizza sub 21. Tasta Honorable mentions outside of the area that have better pizza than falconer Tasta: Napoli in Warren PA Big John's in Randolph Ashville general store pizza logs in Ashville Hughes hotel in Little Valley read more

Tasta Pizza - Banana peppers are not that great. Heavy breading and not much flavor - Pizza Near Me - Falconer, New York

See all

Very rude staff, dirty dining area. Just avoid this place. I had bad vibes from the minute we walked in. Wish we would've gone somewhere else. Pizza was gross And greasy. read more

Ordered a pepperoni pizza and some wings. My fiancé bit into a wing and there was a shred of metal in the wing. If he swallowed it, it could have led to a trip to the ER. He called and told them what happened, and they laughed at him and did not seem to care one bit. read more

Tasta Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Falconer, New York

Avoid this circus at all costs! I've always hated their pizza. It's stale dough over floured, insanely greasy, and stingy as hell with the cheese even when you pay extra for extra cheese you just get the amount that comes on a regular pizza from far better local pizza places like perfect pizza and Lena's pizza. I only like their old dad wings. Which they raised their price on substantially and started giving out smaller wings. $30 for 20 small wings is a joke. I was talked into getting their pizza and wing special which was wrongly priced on their website. It came out to over $40 for a 16 inch pizza and wings so they messed up like as always. I get there and stand in line waiting while they all stand around and gossip with other customers. I finally get waited on and they tell me that my order doesn't exust6. I argued and then they looked through the computer and said "oh we already gave it to someone else." Are you serious??? This is the 2nd time they gave my order to someone else!!!! Last time there was a 45 minute wait while they remade my last order they gave to someone else and THEY STILL CHARGED ME FULL PRICE!!! They are trash. read more

foods always good but the service is terrible. asked for a cup for my daughters drink to go and they said the y didn't have any when i saw them behind the counter... they're just downright RUDE. read more

Ordered a pepperoni, sausage, and onion Calzone and it was soggy , too much sauce and barely any toppings not to mention absolutely NO CHEESE!! I am in town visiting and will NEVER EAT HERE AGAIN!! Worse Calzone I've ever had!!! read more

I used to work there as I was finishing my senior year in high school (2022 graduate) and stayed for a little after high school l. I'm going to tell you about this place with all the details I know. 1) The owner is a downright jerk who treats his employees other than his daughter and son like absolute trash (call names, tells them they aren't going to make it there and overall is just rude.), which I why I quit because he called me a retard repeatedly and I was sick and he told me just go home and yelled at me for being sick so I never went back for my shift. The fryers don't ever get cleaned when I worked there so I don't know if they cleaned up them before opening or not but there is a chance the grease is constantly reused. One time I was working fryers (which I was always prepping the pizzas) and I had accidentally dropped a wing. I was going to replace it and make a new one but Mike (the owner) said no just put it back on there. Disgusted I gave him a weird look and he said we don't have time for that. As for the staff we all try our best to seem happy and kind but with Mike constantly yelling at us and calling us names we tend to get mad or upset. One time me and another coworker were having a bad day and we had an argument Mike looked at both of us and said if we want to leave we are more than obligated to walk and in that moment I wanted to so bad but I didn't because I was 17 helping pay bills and save for a car. I then downloaded Indeed (job site) looking for a new job. I came across Burger King was hiring so I applied. They me told me they wanted to interview me and I was set my chance to leave. Going back to the whole sick day I earlier mentioned, I constantly kept going to the bathroom to puke. Mike eventually got mad that I was sick and told me to just go home and started yelling. I was so pissed that I literally looked at him and said I won't be fucking back for my job. I went to Burger King asking to do my interview and they said "wait till Sunday because the girl who does the interviews wasn't there" so Sunday I came back and got the job immediately. I started there the next day and Mike called asking if I was coming in for my shift. I very annoyed said "no I found a new job but best of luck and hung up." So if you were ever considering going there DON'T they are disgusting there. read more

wings were okay, took forever to get a hold of them and when I finally did the guy on the phone must've been too high to hear me because I had to yell into the phone multiple times for multiple different things. once we got our food we got back home and our calzone was completely wrong. very disappointed and definitely WOULD NOT recommend. read more

My husband and I have eaten here numerous times when we come into town. Wonderful place to meet other family members and comfortable setting. Many good choices on the menu and the food is always great. The staff is patient and helpful. Love it! read more

Compared to the other pizza places in the area, not the best to go to. I've had both the wings and the pizza. The pizza was okay but the wings I had was not good. The staff is friendly but doesn't get rid of the fact that the food is very average. read more

I have been a loooong time customer of Tasta Pizza going there since High school 25+ years ago but I have noticed lately the quality of food and the friendliness of the staff are both in decline. I've given them many many chances to get better but they don't. My boneless wings were dried out and over cooked and if that's a pound of chicken bites I'd like to weigh myself on that scale... pizza sub was over cooked as well and the girl behind the counter covered in tattoos was less then happy I was there ordering food. To bad this use to be the place to go now it's just a disappointment! They have never been the cheapest place to eat but it was always worth it because the food was so good. Good bye tasta pizza I have already missed you. read more

What happened to this place? There is no pride anymore in their food. Most of it looks like it came from the dumpster. Saddened by the change in things. Won't be returning. read more

Gee. Some of the reviews? I eat at or take out quite frequently there. Owner can come across as grumpy, but he's a good guy. Food is always good and the people always friendly. My fav pizza place in the area. read more

I ate here a few times. Decent pizza. Got a sub. Found a decent size piece of wood and hair in the meat of a combo sub. Went in and was actually calm to see what was going on. Got called a liar and treated terrible. I'll never eat here again. I was only upset because my 4 year old got a piece and it made his mouth bleed. Good luck to whom ever likes the place read more

We have been there a few times, and the staff have never been rude, and the food has always been hot, and delivered as soon as it comes out. The food has always been good for us! The fish fry is good for the price, and the owner always checks to see if everything is OK. We have no complaints and love their boneless chicken wings. Sending out for food tonight and there! read more

We just ordered a few subs for our roadtrip. We went to pick up and I barely was acknowledged by the woman behind the counter. Besides the subs we bought some adult drinks and some chips. I left and remembered I didn't have water for my little guy. I took his clean cup and ran back in to ask for some water and asked the man behind the counter if we could put some water in it. His response was priceless, "We don't have water," he says. I say, "you don't have tap water?" He says, "NO, I only have bottled water." "I told him I would just go to the bathroom to fill it up." Are you kidding me? If I didn't just run in without my purse, and wasn't talked to like I was stealing something, I maybe would have purchased his $1.99 bottle of water. Rude, cold and crappy customer service. I gave them 2-stars because their subs are ok. Small businesses only survive in small towns if they have good food and great service. Good luck! read more

Worst sub ever was not even edible! Lettuce and tomato were rotten and bacon was disgusting

Got subs. Burnt. Usually no complaints, but lately, subs were made wrong..then this time, burnt.

It's no New York style pizza, but these pies are delicious. Their wings ain't bad neither. Every time we go in, the manager (owner, perhaps?) is right nice and friendly to us. He always seems to have been working over time when we get there to pick up our food, but he's always still working hard to make sure everyone gets what they ordered in a timely fashion and at top quality. read more

My wife, son and I were there on 12/5/15 at their brand new location just down the street. Nice place, great staff and great wings!!! They also have Bud Light in both bottle and draft m. Pizza comes in pies and sheets and they have subs. I will definitely be back!!! read more

They have really good food. Its a nice place to eat. Prices are good. But, ive ordered take out maybe a dozen times, and they constantly get details wrong. I asked if i could get my 2 orders of wings saucy. It was read back to me "saucy". I get them, not a drop of sauce in the box. Asked for their awesome pepper relish on a party pizza once. None. Not any. Luckily their foods good because their communication are horrendous. Check your food before you leave. But enjoy it if its right, awesome food read more

Over charged. We ordered Tray pizza $45.75, 2-2litter of pop $6.00, 1 water $2.00. Total $54.45. My husband was charged $74. The girl never gave my husband the receipt. I guess she got a nice tip. read more

Very unpleased with them. Just live a block away so we order two times a week if not more! The last month this is the kind of service we receive...1 order a sub and got something totally different 2 got two subs with hair in them! 3 called them ahead of time to see how late they were open was told 10 and when we called at 9:10 they were close! 4 the last straw why we won't order again for their mediocre food is that I called for an order, spoke to some gave them my order...told me 25 min. I show up and no one has any Clue of the order!!!!4 strikes your out...plenty of pizza and sub joints around...LATER!...don't wast your time and money!! read more

I haven't ever been impressed with Tasta. The food isn't great and the owner is miserable and cheap. They charge for every little thing. The larger businesses in falconer place a lot of orders with this place and he should appreciate it a little more. read more

My father Placed an order online the total came to 29.96$ so that is what my dad gave me to go get our order I went in an attempted to pay the owner argued with me and told me that the total was 35 and some change so I showed her the confirmation email sent to my father clearly stating the total of 29.96 and she told me that my father must have done something wrong and that I needed to pay the total she has provided of over 35$ my dad called and expressed his concern and questioned why they didn't call them and let him know that the price had changed as she claimed there was a glitch on the computer she was also very rude to my father so eventually we just said that we didn't want the pizza after being publicly yelled at by the business owner for their business's error. she said that we were still responsible for the money. Nagging us over and over. I have experience working in a restaurant one of the most important things is that the customer is always right. I felt attacked upset and confused. If I am told one total I expect to pay that if your website quotes me less than the actually price that is on you and your business not my father. Incredibly rude do not recommend and will Definetly not be visiting this place again. read more

Tasta Pizza - the menu for the tasta pizza - Pizza Near Me - Falconer, New York

Stopped in on the evening of Friday 4/29 about 9:00pm. Ordered a turkey & capacola sub. The guy behind the register asked if I wanted it toasted. I said yes, just toast the bun, he said we toast the bun, meat, & cheese. I repeated my request to just toast the bun, I was then told "we don't do that". Really, you refuse to not put the cheese and meat on the bun before you toast it? I was asking for less labor, and I didn't want a hot sub. We promptly put down our menus and left. It's a shame, the new location is nice, however not accommodating a simple customer request lost us as customers. My party tonight was only 2, but I will post this review on every food app I can think of to make sure more than the 2 in our party know how bad the service is. read more

A friend and I decided to check out the new location for this pizza place that we've never tried . Staff seemed cold and told my friend that a glass of water with her meal would be 1.99. We were never asked how our meal was nor thanked for coming. The food was mediocre at best. We won't be going back... read more

Tasta gets a thumbs up from me. It's a falconer institution. Nice atmosphere. Lots of big TVs. Food is good. Service is friendly. I think it exceeds what you would expect from a small town pizza place. read more

$10 for a medium pizza. I've had frozen that taste better but it won't kill you. They also serve subs. Maybe try those. That, or prepare yourself for mediocrity. read more

The 17 inch toasted Assorted Sub is the way to go! A LOT of food for an extremely fair price. Pizza and wings are very respectable as well. We only get to go to the area about once a year but the majority of the staff still remembers our faces and are always friendly. The new location is better suited for larger groups but the staff and restaurant still have the small pizzeria ambiance. read more

This place has grade B food at best and the staff are rude. We stopped in for pizza on our way to work went to our table then the counter and placed our order. What appeared to be the owner softly talked to the counter waiter - we thought she was asking her to clean off our table as it had crumbs etc on it. But no - told us we couldn't have our coffee in the restaurant and said we had to take it out. This is not a coffee shop and thought this was a bit aggressive. Then we figured part of this out - no tap water available only bottled water. I am a business owner and am all for turning a profit but this was ridiculous. I politely responded to the owner that this could impact us returning here. The response was " there are signs up and as long as you know where I am coming from" - didn't make much sense to me but I know there are a lot of other tastier pizza places I will be going to besides this one! read more

I really don't like leaving bad reviews (especially about small locally owned businesses) but I felt I had to tonight. Besides not being checked on through the whole meal, even though the server had plenty of time to chat with another table (there were only three tables total), the food quality was poor. The loaded fries had a very off flavor (as in the cheese or bacon were bad) and the chicken finger salad was actually a single chicken finger (if that) cut into extremely small slivers and thrown on top of a side salad plate size of shredded lettuce. I almost sent it back thinking it couldn't be the right thing. We also couldn't order water for the table (bottles only) which is just strange. The pizza was really greasy (although the flavor was fine) and the best thing on the table were the wings (old dad seasoning). None of us had been there before, and maybe it was an off night, but with so many pizza places to go to in town we wouldn't go back or recommend it. read more

The last few times I was here it was great but ever since they moved they became extremely disorganized I order my food and never got half of it and ended getting my money back from the missing food, I waited a good three hours for the food when I finally just threw in the towel. This place still has great food and friendly staff but lacks organization, overall I would eat here once they get settled in and organized, the place has a lot potential but needs work overall I'll give it a 3. read more

Wings were good and cheap..even if I got BBQ instead of the butter garlic I ordered....Jalapeno poppers were great ,,,tacos not bad..But I did notice..not very friendly at all...I wouldn't dare to try the pizza..I live close to the city...nuff said read more