Awesome onion chips (vs onion rings) good coney dogs, and perfect milk shakes. Loved how the onion chips were exactly the right size and easy to eat. It's been around for years, and is a favorite among NewPal residents but others come from far away places to enjoy a true mom'n pop drive-in. For the food and ice cream they serve, they do it well. This visit today was pleasant. Beautiful day for an outdoor experience. read more

See all

America , Americana lives most strongly in the heartland , Frosty Boy Drive -In is a strong example of the America that STILL EXISTS!! From the eye catching blue and white paint scheme to the iconic awning Frosty Boy invites you to experience what had been lost in so many cities and towns across the USA. this a true "Attraction eatery " in Indiana . Worth the drive wherever you come from . It is featured on Roadside Architecture.com 1) the FOOD menu harkens the lucky patrons to another time when life and liberty were different , excellent selections , every item on the menu is smile restoring good ! I've yet to see a frown on any person enjoying their expertly presented food choice ! 2) the Ice Creams !!! oh wow does this take me back ! kids in middle America used to get lucky enough to go to our local Dairy Queen , or Dairy Dream,Dairy Sweet or Polly Freeze in Georgetown In! While a few of these great locations still exist, FROSTY BOY is a classic example of great soft serve Americana dessert , feel good treats!! 3) plenty of parking access easy on and off the street nice level parking and plenty of under the awning classic seating . 4) Customer service is paramount , they greet you with eye contact and smiles and are genuinely nice and polite (very refreshing in today's world) the quickly and efficiently answer your questions and process your selections . 5) Cleanliness, not trash or debris falling from overfilled receptacles , no trash or messy spills noticeable anywhere . The over all ambience is truly American , truly Family friendly .. We absolutely love Frosty Boy and I personally love the anchor it gives me to another time when this sort of excellence was the norm . Well done Frosty Boy we will be back for years to come !!! read more

Frosty Boy Drive-In - Frosty Boy drive in ! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New Palestine, Indiana

I have been wanting a malt. I finally tried it and was disappointed. They do have dip for the cones which was exciting . I also got a slushie. They have a drive thru and you can park and walk uo to order at the window. read more

See all

Classic roadside joint with great food and ice cream. I'd recommend getting a burger, fries, and a shake. The pork tenderloin sandwich is really good, too. It's affordable and the service is fast. Go here on a hot summer day, you won't regret it! read more

Frosty Boy Drive-In - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New Palestine, Indiana

I mean seriously? Why do my fries look like this, they taste horrible. You bagged them knowing that you shouldn't be serving them, no mistake there. read more

Frosty Boy Drive-In - French Fries - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New Palestine, Indiana

Amazing ice cream, atmosphere, but I wish they would do something to speed up drive thru service as I would go more often if they would.

Fantastic Ince cream, food is very tasty too! The Service is delightful full of smiles year after year, and the place over all is New Palestine not so best kept secret to summer tradition read more

I was in new pal for work, and had to stop in at frosty boy, love them, it's quick friendly service with a decent amount of options, I was in an ice cream mood, so I got the flavor of the week, lemon, and it was a lemon whip! So tasty and perfect in the warm weather! Check them out if you can. read more

Frosty Boy Drive-In - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New Palestine, Indiana

WOW! These guys were lightning fast. I was in no hurry but they were fast at getting the food out. I went through the drive-thru. There is no speaker you place your order with a human. I was looking for a pork barbecue sandwich and onion rings and of course ice cream. They have onion chips on the menu but sadly they were out of them. So I got the crinkle-cut fries instead along with my pork barbecue sandwich and a marshmallow shake. After they take your order you park in front of the restaurant and they call your number out when it is time for you to come up to the window to pick it up. They were very quick in getting the food out and it was nice and hot! Hopefully next time I go they will have the onion chips. I will stop here again to try something else on the menu next time. read more

See all

Great food, and great service. Nice small town and Frosty Boy is a reminder of a bygone era. A great variety of ice cream treats and food cooked to order. read more

Great food and always made to order which means its always hot! Soft serve is the best, heavier and more creamy then any other place.

It should be illegal to spend a Friday lunch like I did today at Frosty Boy in New Palestine - dipping onion chips in catsup and cooling down with some strawberry whip! #Getlostindiana You just don't #find places like this much anymore... read more

Frosty Boy Drive-In - Strawberry Whip - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New Palestine, Indiana

Frosty Boy is a staple in the New Pal area. They have great ice cream and I love their slushies. I have tried their food, it's basically like ball park food. The food is made as you order and it comes out fast! I love to sit outside and enjoy a twist ice cream cone in the patio area. read more

My boyfriend used to come here as a kid so he insisted we stopped :) The service was very friendly from my experience! Our food took about 10 mins after we ordered, they did make our drinks before our food so our slushie were a little melted but no biggie! I got a bacon cheeseburger with a small fry and a small salted caramel malt. Food was good to me very fresh, a good place to stop for a quick bite. read more

Frosty Boy Drive-In - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New Palestine, Indiana

See all

This restaurant was a nice stop. They have burgers, hot dogs, chicken fingers, ice cream, icees, floats.....I ordered the barbecue sandwich with bacon and cheese with a side of fries. It was delicious. The highlight of my meal however, was the Lemon Whip. It was so good. Reminded me of Hawaii's Pineapple Whip. The restaurant has a decent sized parking area. They do not come to your vehicle to take your order like some drive ins do. You have to get out and place your order or go through the drive through. It did not take long for me to get my food. The staff there is also very friendly. Once you get you food you have a few options. You can either take it home, eat in your vehicle, or sit at one of their picnic tables in front of the place. This place has a great selection of food, slushees, ice cream and drinks. The service there is outstanding. I high recommend checking this spot out. read more

Always fresh cooked food, yummy ice-cream & friendly fun atmosphere. Reasonable prices great variety for everyone & pretty speedy considering they are always busy. Great home town treats served with smiles! read more

I have lived in New Pal almost my whole life. And it's an annual tradition to stop at least once a season to get food or even just get an ice cream. I don't live in New Pal anymore, but my parents still do so I still try and stop once a year. I didn't get ice cream or a flurry this time but did grab some grub. It's still so good and how I remember it growing up. I just ordered a plain cheeseburger with a small fry and a medium coke and a side of cheese sauce. My ice cream go to is usually a vanilla cone with crunch or a cookie dough flurry. Wish I would have gotten one of those to end my meal but alas. Anyway definitely delicious and definitely recommend for anyone going through town or stopping by to see visit people. read more

Frosty Boy Drive-In - Cheeseburger, fries with cheese cup and medium coke - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New Palestine, Indiana

Frosty boy is a local classic. Stopped in this evening and the service was good and staff was very friendly. They were still pretty busy close to closing time, and you could tell the staff was all working very hard to get orders out in a timely manner. I got a hot fudge sundae with cheesecake and it was delicious! read more

Hit up Frosty Boy for the first time this season. I had only been one time in the past, a few years ago. This place is the epitome of local, hometown, soft serve shop. It usually pretty busy and there is a good reason for it. The food is as expected for an ice cream shop. My burger was very good. The fries were very crispy and just need a little salt. I got the Cookie Monster flurry and it was awesome. Blended well, lots of mix ins, mixed in. If you are looking for a nice local ice cream stop, check them out! read more

See all

Took my dog, Max, down to Frosty Boy to get him some ice cream. I ended up buying an ice cream cone. I couldn't believe how reasonable their prices were. The young lady who took my order was very polite. Max and I will go back. read more

The food was soooo creamyyyyyyyyyyyy and delicious it filled me up soooo gooooodddddd

I've never spit out a cheeseburger until today. Plus after waiting 20 minutes for a single cheeseburger, no fries or anything else. Truly was the most disgusting burger I've ever had. I can still taste the grease. Gross. read more

This is a staple in New Pal. The ice cream is very good. The food is delish and they offer so many different treats. It is a great place to hang out with friends or after team events. The staff is friendly and courteous. read more

Don't bother with going through the drive thru. They make you park the walk up to get your food. Extremely slow service and rude employees

Great place love the food definitely should try!!! I recommend the Oreo flurry good service

Went here tonight and the service was terrible. The employees do a good job there just aren't enough of them. You can probably drive to the nearest Dairy Queen, order your food, and drive home in the amount of time it takes to get your order here. This place is getting by on being the only game in town. If a good ice cream place moved into town they'd be in trouble. To the food. It's nothing great. It's not awful but definitely not worth the wait. If you're going by during the day and there's no line maybe give it a shot. But if you go when it's busy my suggestion would be to keep on driving because you'll be disappointed. read more

The best salted Carmel shake ever. The whip of the week is always fantastic. Super good slushees... we keep coming back for more! The food is good too. worth the long lines.. I promise! read more

Good ice cream and desserts, but I wouldn't recommend any of their food items. I think they found a source for the absolute, cheapest, bad tasting hot dog in the country. Worse than Oscar Meyer! read more

This is just outstanding drive in food and ice cream. Quintessentially American food - tenders were great, cheeseburger satisfying, great fries, everything made to order, and flurry was excellent. Just so damn satisfying! read more

Been coming here since I was a kid. Frosty Boy has always been a must every summer and I've always looked forward to opening day year after year. We've given them numerous chances this year already but the only thing consistent this year is the rude staff and incorrect orders. The younger kids seem nice enough and to really be trying, but something is off. The manager or whomever she is, hasn't only been rude to us but we have observed her barking orders at the kids and being rude to them as well. She is setting the whole tone of the environment and it's rubbing off on the staff. I just miss the days when you could visit and be treated and helped by friendly faces, get your food in less than a half hour, not have to beg for ketchup and get 3 packs and have to keep going to ask for more, the manager didn't come to the table and paw on your food because she screwed your order up... I could go on and on but I won't. I even waited a couple weeks since the last fiasco to cool down before I reviewed because I didn't want to be too harsh! I'm really not sure if the woman we have had issues with is a manager or owner but hopefully something changes because this is not the old small town Frosty Boy we grew up with and loved! Customer service is a thing of the past I guess and if this would have been one incident I could chalk it up to a bad day, but this seems to be this ladies whole personality. As for the food, always check your order before you leave because they get mixed up or are missing items often and the hot dogs are an odd color, consistency and just yuck. read more

Always love their ice cream but the chili dog was average. I recommend getting the cheeseburger if you're getting any sort of food item.

I've only had their ice cream and it has been good. Complaint on services. They charge you $1 for a cup of water and there are no restrooms. They have outdoor tables to sit and it's shady, so a plus on that. read more

We decided to hit up this local ice cream shop in New Palestine, IN after a day of thrifting at a flea market. My favorite dessert is the pineapple whip, but they were only offering Lemon Whip this month. They tend to change the whip flavor every month. So instead of a whip, I ordered a medium chocolate malt and some onion rings. My husband ordered a strawberry shake, mom ordered a peach slushee and sister ordered a chocolate malt and a cheeseburger. The food is pretty standard all-American pop and heat up in the microwave but it always taste good to me. The shakes, malts, cones, slushees, and whips are always delicious. read more

Anyone in the area knows frosty boy is a must in the warm months! It's the old fashion- sit outside, talk with friends and family, enjoy the ice cream kind of place. The prices are pretty old-fashioned too! You can get great ice cream, food and drinks for a very low price. We actually ordered burgers, and onion chips along with our ice cream and Coke float. We loved everything! We would go back for the burger and onion chips alone, although they're known for their ice cream products. Parking can be a bit tricky after ball games on a Saturday, or when there are large crowds... So be prepared for that. They also have a drive-through if you want to get it to go. Not much else to do in the small town, but if you're anywhere nearby, it's worth the drive. read more

See all

Awesome service, great food, place can get busy AF sometimes, but most people will share a table with you. Ice cream is on point, get a tenderloin and a chocolate shake you won't be disappointed. I read more

Had the absolute most disrespectful girl this evening when we got our order. I asked them to add extra flavoring, offered to pay for it and she opened with window handed it back to me and said "I made this correctly already". Then proceeded to argue with me about it not being made like I always get it (for over two years), and then yelled "HE WANTS THE MANAGER" and walked off. Manager was zero help. Didn't even apologize for her employees actions when I mentioned how rude she was and also argued with us about it being made correctly. All I wanted was extra flavor and offered to pay for it! I didn't need all the sass! We have frequented this place for a decade and this made me 100% certain we will never return. read more

Always great food. Always great ice cream. The drive thru is a bonus. New Palestine's treat. read more

Had to stop, it had to be an icon and popular stop in New Pal. Showing homes there all day and drove by 3 times, had to be a sign so I finally stopped. Cheeseburger & Fries, my thighs didn't need them but it was pretty tasty for a quickie read more

Frosty Boy Drive-In - the outside of a restaurant - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New Palestine, Indiana

I like that I can order any menu item from Dairy Queen and no one corrects me, they just do their best to make something similar. Also saw a girl eating a crunch cone with a snake around her neck once. It was pretty good size too. +5 ambience. read more

This place is a classic and never disappoints. I have been going to Frosty Boy for the last 40 years. It was my favorite as a kid after church or basketball. It's a family tradition that I now share with my kids! This place is pure Americana. read more