Fumosa Bros Bakery

The nice folks at the Food Shack in Point Pleasant Beach sent us here after I admired their pork…read moreroll sandwich, which came on Mueller's raisin bread. There was about a five minute wait on a Sunday morning in mid-May -- a lot of people in the store and a lot of servers to serve them. Tried an excellent soft pretzel, two variations of their crumb cake squares (blueberry cheese and apple), a loaf of raisin bread and a large cannolo. Note that there are two kinds of raisin bread - and when I return I will stick to the smaller, more cake like variant which the Food Shack used. The larger, airier one I purchased was quite good, with a bit of sugar topping, but it is the smaller, sweeter loaf that is most crave worthy. The crumb cakes are also particularly excellent and justify a visit. Everything tastes as if the freshest, highest quality ingredients are used. The old fashioned decor and vibe add to the wholesome gestalt.

Got a beautiful cake for my Nana's birthday! Everyone loved it- super light and fluffy icing and…read morespongey cake! Picking it up was quick and easy, too. Needed a new place to get cakes since Fumosa in Ortley closed! Will definitely be back for more!

See all

Colonial Bakery

4.4(53 reviews)

1.9 mi

I remember coming here as a child and being excited for crumb cake, cupcakes, and donuts.. decades…read morelater this place still feels like home and is consistent as ever.

Overpriced for the quality. Good selection of cakes. Service, not consistent. All depends on the…read moreperson taking your order.

Our custom cake turned out great!

See all

Park Bakery

4.4(81 reviews)

2.4 mi

cant wait till i get down there, my first stop is the famous bakery!!!!!…read more Park Bakery here we come this weekend. Also the staff is so friendly and but the pecan danish is my favorite and of course the crumb cake!!!!

One of my favorite bakeries ever! The pastries are fresh baked and delicious, and incredibly…read morereasonable prices. Definitely worth a trip!

Crumb cake

See all

Finally made it to Park Bakery

Colonial Bakery

4.1(30 reviews)

0.6 mi

Lots of great baked items to choose from. I had to try the crumb cake, it's a must especially if…read moreyou have tried the other local competitors to see which you like the best. Crumb cake was delish but it has little to no "cake" it was mostly crumb. I also had the banana and strawberry smoothie with oat milk. It was refreshing on a hot summer day. I was in and out if there mid day and mid week in 10 min.

I ordered a cake for an engagement party, Sofia took my order and wrote my order down WRONG. I…read morewanted it to say congratulations Jaclyn and Dillon a she wrote happy birthday. When I went to pick it up and I saw they made a mistake they tried saying that I SAID happy birthday (why would I say that for an engagment party?) and I have in written emails of what i wanted on the cake. They offered to fix it, without a cake decorator present... and tried to give me this horrible monstrosity of a cake!! I wish they would have told me no cake decorator was present to fix it rather than someone who works behind the counter who isn't qualified to ice it. The workers who helped me, Kendra and Emily, ended up wiping the "happy engagement " with a different butter cream and tried to tell me its the same. You can clearly see they see differnt shades in the photo. The manager only offered half off after they ruined my cake and made me wait an hour only to be given this awful mess.

Crumb cake

See all

Crumb bun

Bella's Bagels

3.1(74 reviews)

1.5 mi

the bagels could be better, sometimes there's barely enough cream cheese and other times there's…read morelike a whole chunk that wasn't even spread evenly. the staff could also use customer service training as i was given attitude over my bagel. This place is overall a 0, spend your money where its worth

Unprofessional and rude staff who are all teenagers. Bagels are not good for its price.read more

Egg everything bagel, pork roll, egg, cheese, hot sauce, ketchup (ate first half before pic)

See all

Baked on the Beach

4.6(122 reviews)

20.4 mi

It's a wonderful bakery and everything is delicious. My friend and I made multiple trips to this…read morebakery over the summer. Our favorites are the beach bum cookie and the raspberry bar

Was craving chocolate chip cookies and baked on the beach met my needs. Crispy on the outside…read moreslightly soft on the inside with just the right about of chocolate chips - not too many or too little. And yes I do feel there can be too many. Friendly service and it smelled delicious inside.

Irish soda bread.

See all

Cinnamon roll

Obco Donuts

4.4(177 reviews)

2.8 mi

I don't know what kind of sorcery they're baking with, but the crumb cake was maybe the best I've…read moreever had. Cinnamon donut? Had me in a chokehold. I specifically love the coffee roll (glazed, cinnamon shareable spiral) and the boston creams - but they have so many good ones. These donuts are not only clearly made with love, but they taste good for days after. The best!

If you have a sweet tooth, this place is sure to satisfy. Although the donuts are a bit on the…read moreheavier side, they are tasty and flavorful. Be careful if you try to enjoy more than one at a time.

Cinnamon Jelly Donut

Back donut wall

See all

Special Order: Birthday Number Donuts

Donuts Plus

3.8(52 reviews)

2.1 mi

Hmmm... let me say from the outset I really dislike "cash only" establishments. These days I don't…read morecarry cash, and barely carry credit cards---everything is done on my phone using Apple Pay, like most of America in 2025. The donuts are pretty good, not great, and they are overpriced. The Taylor Ham, egg and cheese sandwich is just ok. Undercooked ham, soggy roll. It's a family run, seasonal shop and I wish them well but I think they need to clean up their act a bit and enter the modern era.

Yummy donuts!! Good service. Loved it. Will go again tomorrow morning to try something different!read more

HAD to stop!

See all

Big Apple Bakery

4.6(86 reviews)

20.7 mi

Best homemade Italian bread in the area. Pastries, cakes, cookies.. fresh and yummy! They also…read morecarry Italian frozen raviolis, manicotti, stuffed shells, etc! Outstanding service always with a smile!

I moved to Barnegat in March 2026 and needed a carrot cake for my cousin's birthday. I did a…read moresearch and Big Apple Bakery came up. I called and ordered the cake and my cousin said it was the best he's ever had. Since then, I've been back a few times to get bread and goodies for Easter and for a family visit. The owner and staff are very friendly and helpful. I highly recommend Big Apple Bakery. You won't be disappointed!!

Big Apple Bakery wedding cake for small, intimate daughter's wedding.

Gender reveal cake

See all

Another view of the best KLP in the US of A

Pondrelli's Italian Pastry Shop

3.8(26 reviews)

5.5 mi

Friendly.delicous.Beautiful designs And reasonable prices…read more Best bakery around Will be sure to tell all my friends to go here

I've only been there once and only for a box of mini Italian pastries but what we sampled in short…read morewas simply outstanding. Prices are reasonable the quality of the pastries was beyond anything I've had in South Jersey in sometime in fact I would rate it with anything I've had. Service was quick. Will definitely try it for other items in the future but for now this place is my go-to in South Jersey for Italian pastries.