On October 27 , 2025 it was a Monday. I food shop every Monday at Hannafords on Route 22 Pawling NY…read more, I went to the Deli Department waited a couple of minutes then an employee came out and said can I help you I said to her a Pound of Genoa Salami sliced this Please. She said we are closed I looked at my watch it was 5:32 p.m. I said at 5:32 p.m. your closed. I found it odd that a Deli department was close so early. It was disappointing.

On a recent after work evening, I came to pick up some custom cut steaks. The butcher was taking…read morehis break. No problem I waited around 15 minutes. When the butcher came back from his break, he proceeded to serve a customer who arrived after me. I didn't make a scene, but after he served that customer, I asked him why he took that customer before me. He sheepishly said - "it's been really crazy." Very disappointing service.

Insane prices low quality inventory need I say more? Go look in the veggie section in the bottom…read morewhere the water collects...

Decent store staff is usually fairly friendly I go here just about everyday on my lunch break…read moreprices are kind of high by the location is convenient store could be cleaner but sometimes it's not so bad! The produce is normally fresh and well kept so I have no complaints with that!

I was born & raised in Millbrook. Although I no longer reside in Millbrook every Christmas season I…read morefaithfully make an annual trek to Marona's to buy their homemade breakfast sausage for our holiday breakfasts. For over 70 decades I've enjoyed the tasty sausage - until this year, 2024. It was so apparent when I fried the sausage something had changed. In the past there was a light layer of grease from the sausage fat. This year there was no grease, only water. The pan filled with 1/3" of water that had to be drained to properly fry the sausage. The taste was even worse! Gone were the spices that, in the past, contributed to the delicious taste. The sausage is now very bland and tasteless. My husband even commented the sausage tasted like cardboard with no flavor at all. The cooked sausage and another package in the refrigerator went in the trash. Sad to say but after over 7 decades, good bye Marona's. There will be no more annual treks to buy what used to be the best breakfast sausage you could find. So sad.

I love this little market I discovered Matthew who introduced me to rib eye I really thought…read moresirloin was the ultimate But the rib eye he cuts is incredible I am now a convert As well as his knowledge and passion for his work he is a true professional and because of him I will drive from Ancramdale to but nears at this fear market Also they gave the best granola! All the house made items are a win win Great service and jewel of a market

With a friendly & approachable staff and GM, the store is a focal point of our community. It's a…read moregreat place to shop, with a fantastic variety of baked goods, hot foods, chicken, etc etc. The store itself is clean and Marty the robot is always roving! Great displays and endcaps too!!!

We were passing through yesterday, 07/08/26, to grab a few items…read more This afternoon I wanted to make cheese and crackers, but when I opened the cheese, it was full of mold! (See photo) No manager worth his salt would ever allow such a product to remain on the shelf! SHAME ON YOU!

Sunflower Market feels like such an intentional and thoughtful take on a grocery store. It's kind…read moreof like a Catskills version of Erewhon in LA -- beautifully curated, elevated, and full of personality. The products are clearly chosen with care, with so many local goods and unique finds you don't see everywhere else. My sister and I actually turned to each other while shopping and said, "If we lived here, we'd probably be here every single day." It's that good. A true gem of a market!

Hmm, can't believe I haven't reviewed Sunflower yet. Seems like they have been going through some…read moregrowing pains in recent years. The newest iteration is good. Food is fresh. Staff is helpful. It seems meat and fish departments have expanded, with more variety than before. Very easy to get ingredients for a nice meal here. The only problem, as many others have noted, is the prices! Coming from NYC, where the price of groceries has been sky high since Covid, this is so disheartening. Prices here seem even higher than NYC in some cases. So, good in a pinch, but don't plan on doing all your shopping here unless you are made of money.

The deli is pretty good. We stopped in for sandwiches. They don't have Salmon packets. We were…read moresuper sad about that.

Stopped in while hiking on the Appalachian Trail for a resupply. Had them make a sandwich on a…read moreciabatta roll. The sandwich was amazing. It weighed almost 5 pounds and was on $13. Grabbed a beer and ate and drank out behind the store on some metal chairs.

Could not be more disappointed with grand opening. Prices extremely high. Fresh donuts so awful…read more Tasted like dry peanut butter. They were coconut. Will not be back.

It was way better when it was a Hannaford…read more Tops management got rid of baggers for some reason and the checkout workers won't bag the groceries without being asked. It's very odd. Best solution would be to bring back baggers and allow them to accept tips. Produce is often not fresh. Employees are very good; friendly and helpful.

The products and people at Brookby are top notch. The raw milk is easier to digest than pasteurized…read moremilk. The cheese curds are better than any I've found in stores---more cheddary. They are kind and accommodating. They often have things that aren't on the website, and they will adjust your order if you ask. Items I like most: fresco cheese, cheese curds, apple sauce, peanut butter, and milk. The candy is really good! They stock things like body scrubs and lovely containers too. I often forget things when I order online, then I add them when I get there. Their ability to shift their store in response to Covid was remarkable. I feel safe there. They and their customers are always wearing masks. At most, one other car is there. If so, they always wait until you finish. Bring a box for easier transfer. I never have, but I think that would be helpful. I have so many boxes right now too.

Love this place. It's so cute and the owners are so nice. They invite people to come see the cows…read more Best milk and meat...I'm serious. I've stopped buying milk and meats at grocery stores because the quality doesn't even compare. They also offer local honey and goods and it's just absolutely amazing.

This is a small, family operated grocery and deli. The family is very kind if you take the time to…read moresmile and get to know them. The prices are what you would expect from an operation this size, especially without high traffic; this is not a big box supermaket like Stop & Shop. But you will find what you need. Often times I've stopped at Ben's deli and they never had what it was I was looking for, whether syrup, ketchup, etc. You're likely to find it here and it saves you a longer trip. I hope things improve for them if the college project down the road moves forward.

Always an eerie feeling in this place. It's dark, unorganized, shelves barely stocked, over-priced…read moreand dirty. Looks like at one time they may have had business from the hospital and since the closing, they've went downhill. Being the only local option they should take more pride in their appearance. Seems their biggest stocked item is beer - what a shame.

The peanut butter coffee is pretty amazing. The also have a nice selection of delectable treats and…read moretheir ready to serve bar is also a taste of awesome.

Great farm market for fruits and veggies. They have some desserts too. They currently have great…read morepeaches. There should be apples coming very soon. I love the cheese section with so many types of cheese. The garden center is beautiful. Orchids are currently 40 percent off.