This store used to be good. Clean with the owner Tad on-site and friendly. The store has been sold, it is very dirty,old, and worn out . The employees look like they are homeless. I saw one "cook" take the garbage out and come back and cook my breakfast sandwich without changing his gloves. I threw out my sandwich without even opening it up. This place is gross . I will never come back. The Provo store is very clean and the one I will go to from now on. read more

Amazing place and supper yummy 10/10 people were super nice and all the cakes were even better read more

Been going to Gandolfo's for decades. I keep going back because it's like "cheers" where everyone knows your name. The sandwich I like the most is roast beef and since it's deli style the bread, oil and vinegar, and sauces make the sandwich authentic (to me). I also will have a broccoli salad or pasta shells depending on the day. I love Gandolfo's and assure you will too. Jeff C - a local read more

I quickly grabbed a couple of items at Gandolfo's this afternoon. It was everything you'd expect from a NYC type deli. The sandwiches were good. The pastrami doesn't seem made in-house which is disappointing. I feel like that cuts a lot of corners. Also, seems like they warm up sandwiches either on the grill or in a microwave. Not a lot of things being made from scratch. Do they make their bread in-house? Doubtful. Do they make anything in-house? Doubtful. I wish they would do some of these things. That's how you get five stars from me. read more

See all

When a DoorDash order comes in, it should be treated like the customer is in the restaurant ordering. "30 minutes to hand-off to dasher" and dasher had to wait in store for a long time. It's not ok. If I was standing there myself, I guarantee it would not have taken 30 minutes. Breakfast sandwiches just made me forget why I'm complaining. Wow. I Love these sandwiches. !!! read more

Incredible fkn sandwich man. Phenomenal. It was just wayyyy too small of a serving to be over 9 dollars. I understand there's inflation and you're using fresh ingredients and all that jazz but somethin gotta give. 4 stars. Also- no unsweet tea. But fuck that sandwich was tight. read more

So my wife told me I needed to try this place as well as some family members. I loved my breakfast sandwich. It tasted amazing. Usually, the food is decently quick to come out (I've been 3 times in the space of 1 week already). Everyone was nice, and I loved the news segments and sports clippings from over the years. Be aware if you get this sandwich, the seeds go everywhere. read more

Gandolfo's New York Deli - Upstate Breakfast Sandwich with a hash brown - Delis Near Me - American Fork, Utah

Great and fast service, the food was cooked perfectly, I will be back. The restaurant was clean and the people were friendly. read more

Always delicious food and service. Just get the chocolate cake, even for breakfast. You'll thank me later!!

Pros: * Clever branding-everything is very "New York" * Location-easy access, plenty of parking * Massive selection of menu items-much more than sandwiches * Friendly service-the young man taking our order was terrific Cons: * Dirty store-sticky cabinets under the soda fountain * Napkins not near straws and condiments-had to go search for them by the cashier * Dry bread (I took off the top, it was that bad * Wilted lettuce-had to pick out several pieces that had gone bad read more

See all

Beyond kind and helpful with ordering for children. Clean environment and many options. Thanks Gandolfo's!

John was very welcoming and just an overall happy guy! The customer service was on point as well!!

Delicious, as always! Quick service. My favorite place to go to start my day with a warm breakfast sandwich.

Can we all just agree that Gandolfos has the best sandwiches in the state?? And they have been making them for decades! I have never been let down by a sandwich at Gandi's. Everything from the urban cowboy to the buffalo bill is amazing. And don't even get me started on the breakfast sandwiches! Legit breakfast sandwiches made hot all day long. I crave the Eastport daily. I love this place. I have introduced lots of friends to this place and they all agree. Gandi's is the best for sandwiches, hands down. read more

Gandolfo's New York Deli - The Eastport Breakfast Sandwich: how the gods start their day. - Delis Near Me - American Fork, Utah

Their sandwiches are awesome! My favorite location was the Provo one but it seems to have closed since. Highly recommend the Urban Cowboy! read more

I love sandwiches at Gandolfos! Many are my favorite! I really enjoyed my Meatball Hero sandwich today. It was so cheesy and yummy!

High quality food! The service is amazing! Sandwiches are so delicious and gourmet for breakfast and for lunch! You will not be disappointed! read more

Good old Gandys is always there for my breakfast needs. It was my brother sister bonding time growing up and the sandwiches taste the same as they did 10 years ago (to my recollection). My go to is The Crew cause you can't go wrong with bacon AND sausage. They have breakfast all day which is seriously amazing because it is the best meal of the day and the quality of their food is top notch. The employees are always in good spirit and don't seem to let much ruin their day. read more

Gandolfo's New York Deli - The crew - Delis Near Me - American Fork, Utah

See all

0/5 if I could. It was our first time trying this deli and it was a 20+ minute wait for two bagel sandwiches. We had sat in a booth then a worker came up and said "we're reserving this for a party, so please sit somewhere else". It's a walk-in deli and they closed off half the deli on Christmas Eve weekend. After waiting for our food, we were forced to eat in our car because of the seating nightmare - they forgot the grape jelly on a sausage, American cheese and grape jelly bagel sandwich. Not worth going back in to wait and stand because we can't sit down so we left. Unfortunately, wouldn't recommend to anyone. read more

Bomb a** restaurant. Nice a** staff. They take my order, and they give me a sandwich that's better than any of the local chains. Is the bread made in house? Probably not. Did they slaughter and butcher a pig in the back for their pastrami? Also probably not. But hey, you'd have to be some snobby New Yorker sucking crap right out of a sweaty almost-Italian guy (who claims to be full Italian) to really care about any of that. Also the atmosphere is fun. Big ol Statue of Liberty? I love it, New York baby. The 9/11 table is a lot, but I guess I do sit at it every time. I don't think its a problem. This place smacks, and if you love yourself, you'll get a piano man. Go visit this restaurant. read more

Fantastic restaurant great staff and amazing food. The staff is fast and very friendly, the restaurant feels clean which is nice for a gas station restaurant read more

I grew up in New York so I was spectacle but it was pretty good! Not a NY deli but definitely good for Utah!

Alright sandwich place. Not the best but could be a little more generous with the meat. I had a Rueben sandwich but it had very little meat on it. It was a half size with pieces here and there of meat. Delicious tasting. They do take phone orders. But may not have it ready when you arrive. read more

If you want the best sandwiches in town this is the place to go! They have a wide variety of cold and hot sandwiches. The breakfast sandwiches, oh my hell are the best things I have ever had. I will go fishing and camping down at Utah lake. I will get the Dagwood for dinner which is huge and I can usually eat some for lunch the next day! I will get the crew to save for breakfast. If you want to tackle a whole day of fishing or anything. You need the crew in your belly! The staff is super nice! Check them out you won't be disappointed! read more

Gandolfo's New York Deli - New decor! - Delis Near Me - American Fork, Utah

See all

Employees are very kind and genuine. Sandwiches are very good. Got breakfast sandwich, loved it.

Love this place, great food, quick friendly service, they have great coupon code offerings on yelp, all of it just makes for a good quick lunch or dinner. Try the meatball sandwich it's delightful :) we will be back to the AF location read more

I love Gandolfo's for breakfast. Super tasty and for a really great price. My grandpa loved taking me here and that makes it all the better. He was a picky man when it came to restaurants and fast food. That's how I know this place is the best! Definitely recommend! read more

The restaurant in American Fork was filthy when we visited. After we ordered we noticed that every table was dirty and needed to be wiped down. We asked if they could clean the tables and was told by the employee that was helping us that they were too busy! In addition to the employee helping us, there were 4 other employees laughing and joking by the grill. We were the only customers in the restaurant but they were too busy to wipe down the tables. The men's room was disgusting. Trash overflowing, toilet and sink soiled dirty. The floors in the dining room were disgusting with food and debris all over under tables. The fountain machine and condiment rack was disgusting clearly had not been cleaned in who knows how long. I am attaching just a few pictures leaving some of the most poor conditions off. Giving them the benefit of the doubt. We reached out to franchise owner via email to express our concerns and he (or an auto reply) immediately responded thanks and saying he would address it. I have previously had good experiences at this deli so this was extremely disappointing. In my mind, they need more engaged management. I appreciate the owner contacting us immediately about our concern. The food was good as usual it was the cleanliness of this location that was disappointing. Because of his response we will give this location another chance. read more

See all

Stopped here for lunch and was not impressed. We both grabbed a sub and it was nothing to brag about. The one thing I can't stand is warm mushy lettuce and this sub had it. The walls and floors are dirty, table rocked and was also dirty when we sat down. Not a place we will come back to. read more

The food was pretty good, BUT THE PLACE JUST SO WEIRD, definitely the weirdest vibe to be in, it was a couple months ago though so maybe I'll revisit and re-rate read more

Just an OK sandwich shop. We were the only ones in the store and it took 3 workers much too long to make our meal. The food was just average as well. I can get a better sandwich meal with an added cookie for cheaper at Jimmy Johns. It just isn't worth the money. The sandwich also seemed poorly made (see photo). While not bad, you can do better elsewhere. read more

Gandolfo's New York Deli - Poorly made sandwich - Delis Near Me - American Fork, Utah

In town for baseball. Close to field and was able to order through yelp and pick up. Used Apple Pay. Sandwiches were good size and tasty. Would definitely come back read more

This sandwich shop slaps. I'm hooked on their hot pastrami sandwiches. Amazing flavors and every time I'm done eating here I am planning my next trip back. Best sandwiches in UT. Hands down. The HIGHLY recommend you get the Reuben or Carnegie with Russian dressing. read more

Super good food, really can't beat the breakfast sandwiches l super comfort food in my opinion

Always good and they act like they care. Get the breakfast sandwich called the upstate. You can watch tv while you eat as well. Overall I am a regular cause it's so good. read more

Gandolfo's New York Deli - Delis Near Me - American Fork, Utah

I found basically one good use for these sandwiches... they can aid in colonscopy prep and do taste better than that big jug and probably cleanse your system better anyway. Considering that happened to my 2 roommates that ate with me, it's not a good sign. Hard pass. read more

Pretty good east coast flavored sandwiches. One of the better sandwich places out there.

Great sandwiches!! They fulfilled my order and were friendly and nice. I used to work here and these sandwiches are quality!

Dropped in to grab a gift card for my nephew and decided to try a breakfast sandwich. Great food, the owner was fantastic and helpful and the chocolate cake is amazing. read more

Love Gandy's! The chocolate cake is amazing! They serve breakfast all day. I don't like their Kaiser Rolls, which is what most of the breakfast sandwiches come on, but I just want ask for it on a bagel. They take call-in orders, and even advertise so on their door, but even if you don't call in, they are usually still pretty fast! Get the Radio City or Manorville, both good, great on bagels! 4 stars because every time I get lunch sandwiches the bread is dry, avocados are brown, etc, but breakfast here is always amazing! GET THE CHOCOLATE CAKE!!! Side note: this is not the location attached to the gas station--that one is Orem on 800 North. read more