Gappys is always consistently delicious, reasonably priced and always has great service! I highly recommend for a casual family dinner, to go orders or 1am late night slice. read more

Italian Restaurants in the Carmel, NY area are a dime-a-dozen. Therefore Gappy's is worth its equal share @ .83 cents. Gappy's is a place i support for every other reason but the food. Gappy's is run by a local family and is staffed by a mixture of veteran employees and high school kids. These employees are friendly and treat customers with the highest level of service. What i'm saying is that when i enter and depart from this establishment i am treated like a gentlemen with greetings and salutations. I'm not saying all gentlemen should be greeted upon arrival; but i stand firm on being saluted upon leaving a room. -i will guarantee that nearly 88% of my previous statement is 100% true. As a god damn patriot, i support local business's that bust ass and employ wonderful folks while maintaining a family friendly dining environment. I'll be brief about the food being that not much can be said: -Pizza (P) - Sauce and cheese lacking in flavor. Crust is the appropriate thickness but hits the mouth a bit doughy. Despite these qualities the slices are highly edible and satisfying. -Philly Cheese Steak (PCS) - An Italianized version. I ordered PCS once and enjoyed it, despite being half-mocked by the cashier about my choice of "a little mayo and ketchup" on my sam-guy. For some reason my comeback to the 16 year old girl was "I think i'm entitled to some condiment action!" I was stoned. -Calamari Rings (CR) - Yes. Rings. Cheap frozen rings probably from a low end food distributor somewhere in the Bronx. They were terrible but I ordered them again a couple months later with the skewed notion that Gappy's switched distributors knowing they needed to up the octo-ante. I'm stupid. -Large Salad (LS) - Iceberg, tomato, some other stuff. You know. JOKE: What was the Jewish snowman's last name? Iceberg! -Spaghetti and Marinara (S&M) - BORING. -Dowser Seltzer - White label, in a plastic bottle, lots of bubbles. -FIN- And squid-ante wouldn't have worked. So yes i know what calamari is composed of; as all gentlemen should. read more

I really wanted to love this place. It's midway between my father house and my work and I was hoping Gappys could become a weekly dinner spot for us. We are both lovers of Italian food. The parking lot is made of dirt and in March was inches deep with mud and potholes. My car was a mess when I left. I was met a the door by a very friendly waiter who took my drink order as I sat with my Dad. Seltzer with lime. It came about 15 minutes later, the third time I asked. Same thing for the bread, asked 3 times before it came. We had to ask for every drink refill and for the check. The waiter put his hand on my plate and asked if I was done when I still had my fork in my mouth. It was as if it was everyone's first day at work or they were high, something was off. The food was ok, the meatballs were fantastic. It's the service that was the deal breaker. In my opinion if you have an Italian restaurant in this area you have to nail it. There are so many fantastic Italian restaurants locally that we don't need to bother giving this one a second chance. read more

This place has gone down hill. It continues to be successful on fried food and courteous service. Pizza is soooooo mediocre, I think frozen pizza is better! read more

My family and I love Gappys! So delicious! Staff is great! Definitely our go to pizza place!

Good Italian food & a popular for locals. At times getting a table can be difficult. Good prices, outdoor seating area in nice weather. Although parking lot is partially dirt; still a good deal. read more

The service was decent & mostly friendly. The food was undesirably heavy, the grilled balsamic chicken wrap sounded vaguely healthy & at least semi light was none of these, the grilled chicken was dry and overdone, the wrap needed greens. It was unflavorful despite much attempt with sauce & onions. Thoroughly disappointed despite giving it a chance :/ read more

My brothers have been raving about Gappy's for quite some time so took my wife and son and couldn't be happier. This is definitely one of those diamonds in the ruff! Love the laid back feel it has and the staff are friendly and always making sure you are enjoying your meal Pizza is excellent with a nice crust,right amount of cheese and sauce is delicious! Had their shrimp parm and it was to die for! Met one of the owners who was at the register and she is truly a pleasure and friendly. My son is a great judge and for him to love the food speaks volumes! portions are large and trust me you'll take food home.Yep Gappy's is a diamond in the ruff serving up quality food,great price with awesome staff who great you with a smile and are happy to serve you! read more

By far the best 'NY style' pizza iver ever had. Thin crust, lots of cheese and oil. Always satisfied. And gets order ready in 15-20 min usually. Perfectly located right off the highway for those lazy nights when you just dont wanna put too much effort into food. Prices are a little high with 13$ for the regular cheese pizza large pie. But still get it everytime. Good customer service, very homely vibe from this family run place. read more

Quality has gone down over the years. There's a pizza place right up route 52 from them three brother which is worlds better. Gappy's slices are large and messy they don't know the meaning of thin and crispy. If you like your pizza floppy and weighed down by grease cheese and toppings this is your place. If you like a better quality and in my opinion better sauce go up the road two minutes to three brothers. read more

Great pizza! We've eaten here a few times and have yet to be disappointed. The one thing that bothers me... I ordered a medium pizza. "We don't have medium. We have personal, small and large." So you have a medium, you just call it a small. read more

I enthusiastically use the word "hole in the wall" to describe Gappy's. It's such a gem that I can't believe I didn't stumble into here sooner. I've only ever ordered pizza and found it to be filling and delicious. The waitstaff is incredibly friendly and very quick in responding to any requests, the owner comes by your table to say hello. All in all, a great dining experience. It's not the kind of place you come on a date but it sure is a great place to come with family and friends for home cooking. Get the ziti pizza. What a delish dish! read more

Food is excellent over at Gappys! Wait staff could use a little more training though. I recommend they're stuffed shells! Delicious, pizza is obviously great as well! read more

This place never fails. It is always like coming home when you walk through the door. The chicken parm is enough for 2 days and delightful. Don't pass exit 17 on 84. read more

Greatest pizza in Carmel. The service there is good, but it's a bit old-looking which I like. The slices are gigantic bigger than needed; I like the the chicken noodle soup better though. read more

I had a chicken parm the other night and loved it!!! Pizza is really great too!!! George is always so friendly and goes out of his way to say hello!! So happy to have found this place so close to home. read more

If this review was from years ago, it would be a 5 star gushing account on how much I loved the pizza here. Now, meh. We used to order white pizzas every time any one of the kids (aka my siblings and I) were home at the parent's. The white pizza with eggplant and garlic used to rock our world. Sadly, they seem to be losing their touch. Too doughy. The magic is gone. read more

It's the go to pizza in the area. I have also had usual pizzeria things like chicken parm, garlic knots, even wings. Everything is top notch. I'm editing my response because their help is awful. The food is good tho read more

I just had a baby shower for my daughter and had it catered from Gappy's. I was a little skeptical because in the past, I've only eaten their pizza which was good. Well there was no need for me to worry! EVERYONE raved about the food and kept asking where I got it from. I was so happy that everything tasted so good! Everyone had plenty to eat and I had another line forming for leftovers, once I put out the take home trays. Kudos to Gappy's for making my party a complete success! read more

This place never disappoints. It is a local hole in the wall type of place. Not fancy at all. But the food is abundant, tastes good and very reasonable. read more

There really aren't enough good things to say about Gappy's Pizza on Route 52 in Stormville. The pizza is incredible. Perfectly cooked and full of toppings you'll never be disappointed picking up a pie here. This is really just the tip of the iceberg. I can't tell you how many events my family has had catered by Gappy's. Trays of penne a la vodka, stuffed shells, chicken & eggplant parm, garlic knots really any type of Italian dish you can imagine. We've even had 3 foot American wedges here and they are probably the best in the area. They even have fantastic salads (if you're into that type of thing ). There's a real family vibe inside and the owner is just an awesome dude. On top of all this they stay open until 2 AM Thursday-Saturday. It's also not a bad place to drop in and have a couple beers and watch a game while you are waiting for your food. Truly the cream of the crop in terms of pizza and more in the Carmel, Kent, and Stormville areas. Here's to many more years of fantastic service! read more

Good pizza, good for takeout. Haven't had the chance to dine in the restaurant part yet, but for take-out it's been great so far!

Eh, what can I say....standard Italian featured dishes. Would love to have some variety in the dishes or specials. Place is great for take out on the nights you can't slave at stove. Easy in Easy Out. Would recommend the penne ala vodka, sauce is not to heavy just right. read more

The pizza. Do you like soft spongy tasteless dough. This is your place. The pizza is on and off, sometimes its acceptable, most of the times its not, I am cursing to myself as i am eating it that my 8 years old makes a better pie as a homework assignment for home ec.. Last time I was there you could not see the white paint anymore. Its been 6 months so maybe they cleaned it up but they got a dirty air problem. The walls top to bottom are covered with black soot. If that is the way they keep the place where you eat, whats the kitchen look like? The parking lot is always mobbed so this must not bother most of the local population but if you want good pizza go to Tuscaneros in Danbury or Fortuna down the street. Rendendoz is better. Salad is ok, other American Italian like chick parm is ok if you like standard marinara sauce and don't know what real italian food is supposed to look or taste like. Cheap place so for around here, its an option. I live 2 minutes from there and drive to Danbury or Brewster ( gaitanos) for Pizza. Wish I did not have to. read more

Another awesome meal at Gappys place is jam packed food is delicious George makes the best pizza in town read more

Gappy's Pizza - Italian Near Me - Carmel, New York

Service: Contrary to many of the other reviewers here- I actually found the service to be excellent. Our server was a young man and he greeted us immediately with menus when we walked in, and his service throughout the entire meal was top notch. Food:The pizza we ordered was the Margherita. Unfortunately the use of garlic in a jar was overpowering and dominated the pizza. It is not a garlic flavor I enjoy.I was impressed that they used the fresh mozzarella- and plenty of it..I also found the canned tomatoes to be rather tart/acidic and in need of seasoning.The crust was mediocre. Perhaps the plain cheese pizza would be to my liking... I'd go back, but not for the Margherita. The place is actually kind of cute inside-it was better than I expected based on other reviews I'd read. read more

Gappy's pizza is very good. The crust is flavorful with a wonderful chewy texture. The toppings are plentiful and the sauce is sweet and spicy with a fresh tomato taste. The cheese is plentiful and the pepperoni has a wonderful spiciness to it. Nothing bland about this pizza. The baked ziti is unbelievable! Get it with the spicy sausage for a real treat. I actually got 3 meals from one take-out portion. We have tried many items on the menu and each time decide we have a new favorite! The salads have always been fresh. Whether you eat in or get take-out, the staff is always friendly and smiling. The large parking lot gets packed on the weekends for a reason! If you are in the mood for a casual atmosphere, friendly staff and patrons, and good pizza or an Italian dish, Gappy's is the place to go. read more

Amazing pizza, especially for the location! Perfect takeout situation! We live in the area and were so happy to have had this place around the corner! read more

My husband and I are new to the area and ordered take out pizza from here. The plain pizza was soggy and undercooked. Not a lot of flavor. The buffalo chicken pizza was just as awful. Frozen breaded chicken cutlets tossed in hot sauce, and scattered on top of a regular pizza? Who wants marinara sauce with their buffalo chicken? Not at all what we expected. We will not be going back despite its convenient location. Gappy's? More like Crappy's. read more

Delicious and friendly service. Two important things being a customer. Not to mention perfect location!

I have recently moved to the area and have been going to Gappy's a lot recently since it seems to be the only restaurant close by. I was very shocked to overhear one day, how rudely one of the workers was speaking to their coworker and then even more surprised when I came to find out he was the owner!!!!! That type of attitude is exactly what draws me as well as other customers far away. I would rather drive the 20 minutes to another restaurant than give my business to somewhere with such a negative feel. On another occasion, after knowing who the owner is, I was able to witness with my own eyes, him caressing and saying VERY provocative things to the waitress and girl at the front counter. I don't know about you but thats how I heard another restaurant owner in this town got his place shut down. Being so careless, even in front of customers is ridiculous. I will never step foot in this establishment even again and I hope others do to. Sexual harassment is nothing to joke around about. read more

Excellent food. Great prices. Eggplant parm is my go to meal. But everything rocks ! Great staff too !!!

We have been going there for years, and the food and service was very good at a good price. The place itself isn't very pleasing to look at, but that was okay. We went there last night and the food was AWFUL right down to the fly in my son's water. When confronting the waitress about it, she said that it wasn't there when she poured it. Well, I certainly did not put it there...I was so grossed out. We paid our bill and got the hell out of there and we will NEVER go back. read more

All time favorite pizza place. Been my favorite since they opened. Loved the buffalo chicken pizza.

Right off the highway...Great service, great pizza and wings and ice cold beer! Thank you for the great service.

Gappys Pizza is the best right off the I84 highway.. Goodfood reasonable prices at real big slices of regular pizza

Don't understand the reviews. Moved to the area about 1 year ago and tried Grappy's - it was OK. It was not busy and the waiter was friendly and personable. Went back when the parking lot was full service was slow and the food was bad. Ordered a pasta dish with veal, asparagus and artichoke hearts - the pasta was pre-cooked and mushy, the asparagus was mushy and the artichoke hearts were cold - right from the can. The dish has a mild chicken broth based sauce that was bland and tasteless. The portions are large, perhaps that is what people here like. read more

Great food, great service. Unbelievable value.

What can you say about this reliable eatery...good family place, always good for pizza, pasta or sub. Good takeout too

Pizzeria not so good food, the pizza was horrible. we even went back a 2nd time and it still was horrible, their food was awful. I dont get it why they are busy. Its not very clean either, maybe its the bar...They are nice and all but the food is horrible read more