Well, yes, of course. Locals grab dinner for take out or stop in on busy nights with the kids during the after school chaos of dance class (upstairs) or youth sports. Perfect NY style pizza, full dinners (sausage and brocolli rabe over penne is my favorite.) Casual and clean atmosphere. read more

really wanted to like this place. it is close by & was very clean when we entered. waitress was friendly & attentive. I had the chicken scampi which was a huge disappointment. it was like a bland watered down white Alfredo sauce. It came with angel hair pasta and the entire plate was swimming in this sauce. It was like soup & I could have used a spoon. No joking! The chicken was tender but tasteless. my friend had the tortellini with pink sauce & said it was good. this place supposedly has a 4.6 rating but my meal was not close. Perhaps they had a new cook but they need to rethink their chicken scampi read more

First I will say that the food from here tastes very good. However, the experiences that my and my friends have been having over the past year have been terrible. On at least three occasions we have received salads with dried out chicken on top...almost like it was overcooked or reheated. When we would call and complain about it, we were met with attitude and a reluctance to make a new salad. On four different occasions we received our to-go orders with dirty utensils. Our last experience I think is the final straw for me. We ordered the pasta fagioli soup. As my friend was eating hers, she felt something strange in her mouth...and then pulled out a piece of metal!!!!! It looks like a piece from a metal scrubber used to wash the pans. Totally gross and unacceptable! read more

Three Brothers Restaurant & Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Carmel, New York

Delicious pizza and food! Very polite and always spot on. I look forward to take out night when we order from there

The food is amazing. And the costumer service is great! It's right next to my daughter's dance school and a piece of pizza from this place makes my day so much better! read more

Be sure to I've ordered from this place twice now. First time the food was perfect, the food was made exactly how I ordered and on time. The second time I got a bottle of soda that was opened. I also didn't specify that I wanted my chicken piccata over pasta. So I received pasta with red sauce and another plate of chicken piccata. My husband ordered penne alla vodka with chicken but didn't specify he wanted chicken cutlet instead of grilled chicken. I suggest being very specific with all orders to fully enjoy your food. read more

The pizza is always top notch! We have also eaten in restaurant on multiple occasions. Staff are very nice and the service is exceptional. Great kids menu with appropriate size portions. Nice interior, clean restaurant. read more

The food is great! I have not been disappointed with anything I've ordered here. Great service & friendly staff! read more

Three Brothers Restaurant & Pizzeria - Chicken alla Rosa- Delicious!!! - Pizza Near Me - Carmel, New York

See all

Pizza is terrible. Floppy and never cooked fully. I even asked for it to be well done and crispy. Undercooked and disgusting. Tried them a few times since I'm working in the area, and this keeps happening. Won't go back don't recommend. Gross. read more

We love this place it's the best!!! Always consistent and quality excellent!! I would recommend this place in a heartbeat!! read more

Anything I ever ordered from here was good quality & taste for the price. They have made some mix ups in the past on take out orders, that is the only negative thing I can say about this restaurant. read more

Probably one of the best pizza restaurants I've ever been too, and being from the NYC area, that is a bold statement. The salad was fantastic, and the dressing was amazing. My wife had the philly cheese steak, which she said was great too (I sampled and agreed.) French fries were cooked perfectly. Definitely coming back next time were in the area. Staff was real friendly too. read more

Three Brothers Restaurant & Pizzeria - Nothing left on the plate! - Pizza Near Me - Carmel, New York

Their penne alla vodka is insane! I highly highly recommend. Love this spot. The staff is friendly and service is always great. Also a great location right off of I-84. I will definitely be back. read more

So far the best pizza I've found in the Kent/Holmes area. Nice crust, not floppy, not quite thin crust. FRESH mushrooms! Good price for 'the works' with 5 toppings. Will definitely be back here soon. read more

Three Brothers Restaurant & Pizzeria - Pepperoni, mushrooms, olives, onions, bacon - yum! - Pizza Near Me - Carmel, New York

My boyfriend and I went here on a random outing. This place is so cute and so awesome! The staff is extremely friendly and very accommodating. Walking in you can tell it's a friendly place. My boyfriend got some pizza and I got a soup and salad. The food tastes really good although it tastes kind of like the microwave food. Needless the price for the food was more than fair. They make zepollis that taste amazing and for three dollars out get quite a lot. All in all a great pizza place. Will be going again in the future. read more

See all

We lived up here 20+ years and we thought we would try this place for the first time based on other recommendations. We ordered for pick up. Went in picked up the food only to find out once we got home an entire entree was missing. They made it right by having someone deliver the missing entree. What I was a bit confused was the total cost? I was told it was $40.63 on the phone and then when I looked at the charge on my card was over $50? As for the food the club sandwich was not your traditional sandwhich on sandwich bread but on a hero type of bread. Was pretty good. All the remainder of the food on a scale from 1-10, would rate at about a 7-8. This was the first visit but at this point we are undecided if we will order again. read more

Great food, great people that own and work there. Reasonably priced, go there often. Good for a take out pizza or a sit down dinner.

We stopped by for a quick bite while driving upstate. The pizza was absolutely delicious and fresh. The service was very good. It seems to be liked by the locals. Highly recommended! read more

If I could give this place -0 I would! 1st & last time will come here! I didn't need a colonoscopy prep, but this pizzas oil kept me in bathroom all night. Grew up in Bronx, I KNOW great pizza. I've also ate my share of eeh pizza. This however was disgusting! Threw it in garbage. Never saw so much oil! Place had balls to charge $4 for Xtra garlic. I've NEVER been charged for Xtra garlic. $4 for garlic on a "personal " sized pizza! Wouldn't be charged like this in N.Y.C. Owner was unapologetic & arrogant. Never again! read more

See all

I was there since day one! when the three brothers all greeted me. Friendly environment with really good dinners! At reasonable prices. I highly recommend this establishment. Marko Town of Kent NY read more

Great pasta dishes, absolutely awful pizza. The baked ziti, sausage rolls and eggplant parm are possibly the best I've ever had. The pizza, on the other hand, is gross - avoid if at all possible. read more

My family & I ordered 3 trays of food for my sons Communion on August 8, 2020. We ordered full tray of Chicken Francaise, Penne Ala Vodka, and half tray of Eggplant Rollintini. We had 12 people at our house & Everyone was raving on how delicious the food was. The chicken franchise was perfect, just the right amount of Lemon. The penne was perfectly cooked, full of flavor!!! The eggplant was not bitter at all, the tomato sauce was so yummy & so much cheese. The cheese was stringy & delicious! What little leftovers were left, everyone wanted some. We only order our pizza from there as well. We moved up here from lower Westchester & I couldn't find pizza I liked until I tried theirs. Hands down the best I've tasted up here. Thank you to the owners for a delicious meal for my sons 1st Holy Communion. Very very satisfied. read more

Ordered lasagna, personal pie and a cannolie. It took well over an hour to arrive, the food was cold and they forgot the cannoli. Definately advise against ordering from this place read more

I regularly order their pizza, pasta, and salad for my family and we couldn't be happier. Portions and quality are always above and beyond. Can't recommend this place enough! read more

This is a limited review because I ordered take-out. I can say that the meatball parm. hero was disappointing. It was slopped with so much sauce & so little sliced pieces of meatball that it fell apart after two bites. The caesar salad was a tin full of chopped romaine lettuce will hard as a rock croutons and a nondescript dressing on the side. I've had a lot better at other local pizza places. read more

We moved to the area from Westchester over the summer so our pizza expectations are pretty high. We have ordered here quite a few times and overall, the food is pretty good. Just last night we ordered chicken parm dinners and they were delicious. Our only complaint was twice we ordered an extra cheese pie but when we opened the box it just looked like an average regular pie. We noticed that with another nearby pizzaria as well. When you say extra cheese, more times than not you're expecting it to be thick and gooey so that was disappointing. But it was still delicious. The flavor of the sauce is pretty good and portions are good. Just also wish when you order dinners it would come with both a pasta and salad. A lot of the places around where we use to live do that. read more

This is honestly the besat place for food usually i would order pizza and they prepare it amazingly i definitely would recommend to order pizza or pasta great for dinner dates etc read more

Just got pizza and calamari to go weren't to happy the first time but thought we would give it another shot. this was deffinitly the last time. to many other good places around. read more

We love mostly all of the food here. The eggplant parmagiana is probably the best I've ever had. The shrimp parmagiana dinner, greek salad and arugula beet goat cheese salad are a few favorites. Their tomato sauce is SO GOOD. I took away a star because the meatballs could be better and once I ordered a greek salad and they put regular black olives in it instead of kalamata. We often order delivery and their pizza both plain and with toppings are delicious. read more