Benvenuto Pizza Restaurant

I could barely even show y'all the pizza I didn't even make it home. I'm going back for a 2 nd as…read morewe speak

Service was poor, had a reservation and still waited to be seated outside. Once we were walking to…read moreour table we noticed it was pretty empty. Approximately 7 people were at two tables, the rest were empty. Food was okay, looked better in the photos on the menu, but whatever. The real disappointment came when they asked if we wanted coffee and dessert, we said yes put in our order for coffee the waiter asked what we wanted for dessert and he rambled off what they have and then said let me get the menu. We got the menu and decided what we wanted. While he was gone someone else dropped off our coffee and we never saw the waiter again. I was also looking forward to singing HBD to my son. Unfortunately, next thing we knew we got the bill. As I looked around I noticed the workers were busy with friends, they were hanging around like their night was done and it was just about 8:30 the place became a hangout. I get it, but hanging out at empty tables and ignoring customers?! Not good business. Hang out at the bar not in the dining area. My best guess is there was a table of young girls finishing up their dinner and the younger workers wanted to make friends with them. So my table was no longer important and neither was our dessert. Needless to say we won't be back.

Inside the dining area. Not too big.

Our personal size cheese and margherita pizzas. They were actually pretty big

See all

Luigi's Famiglia Cucina

4.5(197 reviews)

7.1 mi

Let me tell you a something!! We looked at several pizza restaurant reviews, yes they matter to…read moreme. I am so glad we paid attention to them because we would have missed out on the ABSOLUTE BEST PIZZA we have had. We are a group of 7 friends visiting from Ky and Ohio and we ordered the Americano (my personal favorite) the pepperoni was so delicious, the crust was such a compliment to the flavors on top! Also the Margherita was appreciated by our vegans. Then there was the 'make your own' pizza that had the most delicious pepperoni,mushrooms and onions. I can't say enough...then there was the salad.....what a salad. Luigi you gave us a wonderful memory of New York pizza!! We did a carry out but once I stepped inside, I wished we had chosen to eat inside...nice atmosphere. If you don't put forth the effort to eat HERE....YOUR LOSS :( Luigi....Thank you...Thank you...Thank you! Kentucky

The 10th time was as good as the first! This is my go to restaurant when I'm in this area. You…read moreare greeted before you are even completely in the door and the staff is attentive to your needs. What keeps me coming back is the friendly ambience and the delicious food. I don't have a favorite meal (maybe the osso Buco!). This last visit there was a new addition on the dessert menu of cheesecake and it reminded me of a well loved bakery in Germany. The cheesecake was extra fluffy and I can't say enough good things about it. The restaurant is family friendly, and my niece loves the pizza here (I do too!) Luigi and family, thank you for many delicious meals and we will see you soon

Dining room

Meatballs

See all

Cacciatori Pizza & Pasta -Mahopac

3.3(62 reviews)

3.0 mi

Locally owned & operated

Speaks Spanish

I probably wouldn't order anything else, but by the slice no one compares. They have the best…read morecheese slice you could ever order. I enjoy it so much.

I recently ordered angel hair pasta with bolognese. I originally reviewed this is a bad experience…read morebut I want to let you know that the owner made good on the meal and replaced the entire thing. He understood my concerns and I appreciate that. I have been a customer for many many years and because of a bad experience I was ready to quit. The owner went above and beyond making it right for me.

See all

d'Berto Pizzeria

3.8(30 reviews)

4.0 mi

Best pizza in the area! The crust is always soft, and the pizza isn't overly oily or greasy. We…read morelove both their regular pizza and white pizza. Their Gorgonzola salad is also one of my favorites--they're always very generous with the Gorgonzola, which I love. We usually order delivery, and it's always fast with friendly service. Definitely our go-to for pizza!

Excellent food! A pleasure always to pick up food. Service is exceptional as well. Thank YOU.read more

See all

Trattoria Sei

4.5(91 reviews)

3.0 mi

Excellent food!! Very nice interior. The servers are very attentive. I'd highly recommend this…read morerestaurant

Let me start by saying it's extremely hard to find a GOOD Italian restaurant in Northern…read moreWestchester. We decided to try Trattoria Sei because we are looking to have a graduation dinner for my daughter soon. From the moment we walked in we were welcomed and sat down immediately. I was impressed that for a Tuesday evening there were quite a few people eating dinner there. We started with the complimentary focaccia bread and it was delicious (wish we had more lol) Our entrees consisted of Eggplant Parmigiana and Chicken Parmigiana Alla Vodka. Both entrees were incredible! We are an Italian/American family so we know what good sauce/gravy is and we are extremely picky but both sauces exceeded our expectations!! The environment was warm and welcoming and we never felt rushed. We will definitely be back! Next time we will make sure to leave room for dessert, as the dessert menu looked sooo good! If you find yourself in the area do yourself a favor and check it out. The other restaurants around might offer a little more space or nicer views BUT trust me when I tell you, the food won't come close to Trattoria Sei!

Fresh ingredients and modern twists on classic Italian recipes at Trattoria Sei, Mahopac

Trattoria Sei, an Italian trattoria on Route 6 in Mahopac, New York.

See all

The bar at Trattoria Sei, an Italian trattoria on Route 6 in Mahopac, New York.

Trio Pizza

4.1(59 reviews)

2.5 mi

OMG, don't go here, some of the best pizza I've ever tasted and I've tasted them all! I want this…read moreplace all to myself, oh, the meatball hero parm, best I've ever had and their homemade bread and crust is absolutely insane! But DON'T GO!

Busy new establishment on Rt 6 (unsure if technically Somers, Baldwin Place, or Mahopac) The…read moreparking lot speaks for itself how many customers are quickly visiting Will update this review -- WIll update this review haven't tried the pizza as of yet. Saw MANY just purchasing this like it's going out of style! Their salads, on the other hand, although had addl toppings ordered (shrimp and chicken) were bland needing extra spices at home to give it some needed flavor. Even the dressing was as if you didn't add it at all. The FRESHNESS of the salad, though, was spot on fresh, yes it was! The volume of the ingredients : full Cannot take that away from them caution when entering/leaving the parking lot busy street!!

Burned Charred or over baked?

See all

Whatever cafe

5.0(3 reviews)

4.2 mi

The Flatbread was my favorite. Actually the boneless bbq chicken bites were. Come to think of it…read morethe cheeseburger was probably my favorite. It was all delicious !!

just had a slamming pizza. Chicken vodka, pizza. This place looks like a cool new clean takeout…read morespot. Definitely coming back.

Flatbread pizza

See all

Who of our happy customers enjoying Big Mac tacos.

Mario's Woodfired Neapolitan Pizza & Pasta

4.2(102 reviews)

2.6 mi

My order was ready upon my arrival, the white pie was perfect, the wings were fall of the bone ,…read morethe mushroom appetizer was delicious and lastly the grilled chicken and broccoli rabe wedge was very tasty...

A cozy Italian-American in Mahopac on Route 6, that is worth a trip from anywhere!…read more The review, may sound like hyperbole, but it's not! A friend mentioned it had good food, great prices, and table service and he was going down there, so we all stopped in for lunch. Great decision. The prices are very reasonable! One of the best Italian-American restaurant/pizzerias I've found in years; and I've eaten more than my share of pizza in many countries. Only top quality ingredients are used! We each ordered a different 12" pizza, one for each of us. In hindsight, we could've ordered one pizza that the three of could have shared and would we have been satiated! My significant other ordered a prosciutto and arugula pizza. She had one at Cancino's in Mexico City November 2019 and LOVED it. We've never seen it on another menu here. So, when she saw it on their menu, she ordered it right away! It was perfect! There was about 4 ounces of arugula and the $20 something a pound prosciutto on it. See the photo. No crispy cremated prosciutto chips nor wilted arugula arrived to the table. My friend had the red meat pizza. It looks like about a pound of sausage meat and a whole pepperoni was sliced and put on his pizza. He kept picking pepperoni off his pizza and putting it on ours. What we had looked like a normal pepperoni pizza; there was that much on his! There was a small group who ordered pasta dishes. They looked great also. Yelpers get a 10% discount.

Intimate dining near the kitchen.

Complimentary warm Italian bread

See all

Close up of the ceiling.

Frank's Pizzeria

4.4(66 reviews)

7.0 mi

Stopped by on our way up to New England from Virginia. We always love trying new places when we…read moretravel and the pizza was perfect. Greasy and floppy in the best way.

Iconic local pizza place with onsite owner that really cares…read more Get a slice & a coke. Then some ice-cream for dessert. You'll feel like a kid again.

Vodka grandma and a regular slice

See all

Too well done - didn't ask for this but ate it

Four Brothers Restaurant & Pizza

3.2(146 reviews)

3.3 mi

Trendy meets classic Italian with a view. Live music had people dancing early on a Saturday…read moreevening. Larger menu for an Italian restaurant. Fresh bread and the sauces had tons of great flavor. Great for big groups also.

So we decided to come back since the weather was nice and we could sit outside. The ambience is…read morereally nice, especially if you sit outside by the water. Tonight they had live entertainment, which was nice, but I have to say I wasn't too thrilled with the food. I ordered the veal was a bit tough. The spinach look like it came from a frozen box. and wasn't too crazy about the fish. I don't think the place is horrible, but it's not the best food I've had.

See more unrecommended reviews

Beautiful potted flowers --- well maintained as you can see!

Fried Calalmari

Four Brothers Restaurant & Pizza - Patio/side entrance area(not always is the door opened) of Four Brothers Restaurant. This patio is very visible from the parking area.

See all

Patio/side entrance area(not always is the door opened) of Four Brothers Restaurant. This patio is very visible from the parking area.

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

46 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Lisa L.

0

1

2

10 years ago

My fiancé and I moved to the area two months ago. We came here on a Thursday night for her birthday. It was the perfect setting and experience for a date night! The staff is outstanding! Every single staff member treated us like they had known us for years. They made excellent recommendations while being conscious of food allergies. Our waiter, spent time with us as though we were the only people in the place (we weren't). The food was absolutely perfect. I recommend the Chicken scarp and the chicken martini best dishes so far!!! They won't disappoint. Desert was excellent. The waiter delivered it to the table with a candle and a birthday card. Great great great! Thank you to a wonderful establishment for a wonderful date and birthday! Will deff be back again. read more

Linda L.

121

7

35

13 years ago

Today i went to Benevenuto's to order take out. i was greeted with a warm welcome and a hug from the owners . you are not only treated as a return customers , but you treated like family what a way to be welcomed and what a wonderful feeling.( if more businesses treated their customers like the world would be a nicer place). while waiting i was treated to the most delicious and heavenly desert. a slice of Nutella Pizza , made with the Benvenuto's famous pizza dough and covered in the chocolate hazelnut nutella spread with sliced bananas, Blueberries and raspberries and topped with dollups of whipcream and pretty as a picture. i highly recommend this desert its a perfect ending for any dinner party and function that you may have . you will truly love it !!!! read more

David G.

35

1

0

9 years ago

I'm always impressed with the food and service here and keep coming back to try different items. I have over 25 years experience in the restaurant business and am surprised and delighted to find an establishment where the staff is pleasant, alert, and knowledgeable; hot breads served hot; food excellent (rare steak served rare); and prices quite reasonable. The owners are on hand to greet me with a handshake, and upon leaving usually ask for any comments on the food or service. The dining area is small but spotless and child friendly. They do have a couple of tables for outside dining and do a considerable take-out business. read more

Amanda G.

0

8

2

10 years ago

I have to same for a small pizzeria you will be surprised by what comes out of that kitchen. I been coming here for the past few years and it just a great place. They have pizza and any kind of Italian meals u could ask for. They have so many different specials on weekends pasta, salmon, steak and its always soo delicious. Staffs are very good and so friendly. They are usually always busy but i always make a reservation. I love coming here to have some great Italian food. Great owners. Keep it up guys and i will be back every weekend as always. Try it and i promise it you wont be disappointed. Amazing place. read more

Ashley M.

0

1

0

7 years ago

The phones girls are a pleasure to talk to. Whenever I call they make sure that I get whatever I ask for, even when it's a complicated order. It is hard to hear sometimes but I guess it's just the phones but they always answer very nicely. And the food is delicious! if I order for pick up I am greeted directly as I walk in and it instantly feels like home, from the people behind the counter, to the waitresses and even the phone girls we are always in conversation. The bus boys always seem to be running around and let me tell you they get the job done perfectly. Definitely recommend this family business. read more

M. K.

0

1

0

8 years ago

Absolutely Amazing!!! I love brick oven pizza and calzones are my weakness. This place is the bomb though. I've ordered to-go a few times now and absolutely every time I was blown away by how delicious it was. The perfect amount of cheese, and if you get a pizza the balance of cheese, sauce and toppings is on point! Even if I got home and waited a bit, it's still just as delicious as eating it as soon as I picked it up. I definitely want to come dine in sometime, because I can only imagine how great it is when you get it fresh from the oven. Thanks for providing such wonderful food! read more

Agron L.

0

2

0

14 years ago

I've been and visited Benvenuto's so many times and the food there is excellent, the service is fantastic. I so far tried pollo sorrentino , chicken Francese, pene Ala vodka and they were all big and delicious dishes. Also the margherita pizza there is awesome, buffalo chicken with ranch slice is really really good. I live in NYC and every weekend I drive up here and have dinner sometimes alone and sometimes with my family. I highly recommend Benvenuto's to everyone. Thanks, George, NYC read more

Ben N.

57

5

1

8 years ago

First time trying this place and I left the happiest person. They have a great menu with a lot of choices, pizza, wedges, wraps and meals. I got the chicken scarp and it was the best, the white lemon sauce was just really great. The staffs are super friendly and great service. They have huge meals so be ready to take some home. I can't wait till I come back and try more amazing meals. Try it 100% everything will taste amazing... definitely will be back again.. read more

Saranda K.

0

2

1

2 years ago

Benvenuto Pizza Restaurant in Mahopac, NY, offers a delightful experience with its delicious, authentic Italian pizzas and welcoming atmosphere. The crust is perfectly crispy, the toppings are fresh, and the flavors are spot-on. Besides pizza, their pasta dishes and salads are also top-notch. The friendly staff and cozy setting make it a great spot for both casual dinners and family gatherings. Don't miss their signature Margherita pizza - it's a must-try! read more

Emily D.

0

3

1

10 years ago

This is another great night we had here. I had another big party of 10 and everything was outstanding. Always so friendly staff and great owners. They always have our table set up nice and very clean. I love the painting they have its deff something different from other places. Meals are really big and too good, amazing choice of pizza. I would deff recommend this place to anyone. Thank you so much again guy for making my party so special. read more

John A C.

4

1

11 years ago

saturday night i had a very delious lamb martini as part of one of their delious entrays .it was out of this world. a little history about this restaurant.it is family owned and operated by this lovely family.they are extremely accomendating .my hate goes off to their expertise.in own and operating the restaurant. a little footnote.it is my favorite italian restaurant in mahopac ny.please continue with all your great success.thankyou read more

Jackie W.

0

1

0

9 years ago

We were heading back downstate on the Taconic Parkway looking for a lunch spot and found Benvenuto by accident. What a happy accident! The pizza was delicious - both regular and specialty slices. I had the spinach, artichoke thin crust - it was fabulous! And the owner/staff were incredibly friendly. Highly recommend if you are travelling through or live in the Mahopac area! Molto delizioso! read more

Rajmonda K.

2

7

74

2 years ago

My favorite place!!! Great food, the staff is amazing, they are extremely friendly and professional. The service is always on point. The food is always fresh. Ive been coming here for years and they are always consistent with their pizza as well as their dishes. The Chicken Scarp here is the best I've ever had hands down! Definitely recommend this place to anyone with no hesitation. read more

J B.

0

36

19

9 years ago

Wow!!!!! What a find. Walked into This pizza restaurant not knowing I am walking into a restaurant. The pizza was delicious in addition to that I had the Talapia which was the freshest fish I have had. My wife had a lamb chop and it was delicious. I highly recommend this place. Don't be fooled it's not just a pizzeria. The food is comparable to fine dining. read more

Lisa G.

0

1

0

10 years ago

This place is just outstanding!!! My husband and i had a personal pie to start with it was just soo good the crust was to die for. Than we got our meals omgg they are hug and so fresh. Just everything was really good. Great people and also service was great. Small place but you will be surprise with this place how good it is. I will deff be back. thank you guys read more

Ben D.

0

1

11 years ago

This place 100% deserves a 5 star!!!!! I came here last night with my family for dinner and i never been so happy with my food! They have huge and amazing meals!!! Everything is soo fresh! They have a nice dinning room! They have pizza and real food! Amazing service& everyone is very friendly.. I will deff be back . 100% recommend it ! read more

Kathleen D.

0

2

1

9 years ago

First time here and I have to say I am speechless!!! They have a lot of delicious food. Pasta, chicken, pizza, seafood and more!! I had their Chicken scarp omgg the best I have ever had. Sooo yummy. Service is outstanding and everyone is very friendly. I can't wait to be back. Definitely try it so worth it. Keep up the good work. read more

Vanessa G.

0

2

0

8 years ago

The best pizza we've ever had.... really!!!! And we are from NYC! We were heading to Albany and took a turn for a quick bite and we were pleasantly surprised but this hidden gem. Food was amazing, staff was very friendly. Quality food for a reasonable price. Don't miss out if you are near Mahopac, you would be not disappointed! read more

B K.

121

5

1

4 years ago

Quick drive through the area glad to run across Benvenuto Pizza, owner is very outgoing, people person personality, counter staff was friendly as well. Had my slices to go my goodness the pizza was amazing and the size of the slices never seen 2 slices filled the whole small pizza box!! Definitely on my radar for future stops read more

David L.

60

8

0

12 years ago

I love Benvenuto! I had a hard time finding a place up here that delivers such amazing food for such great prices. I love the pasta bolognese and the gnocchi. Delivery is great and people are very kind and amiable. For quick Italian that is delicious in the area Benvenuto tops the charts. read more

Benvenuto Pizza Restaurant - italian - Updated September 2026

People who viewed Benvenuto Pizza Restaurant also viewed

Avellino's Pizzeria & Restaurant

4.6

(35 reviews)

Family Style Italian Pizzeria and Restaurant There food is…read moreamazing and delicious The service in Avellino"s is great The menu has choices for all to choose from Location right on Albany Post Road in Montrose NY Staff are friendly local people so you feel like family

Absolutely the BEST pizza around, always fresh and always delicious. Quick delivery is a bonus.read more

Forno Brickoven Pizzeria

4.2

(85 reviews)

The Food is GREAT !!! The food is hot when delivered great customer service delivery is great the…read moreStaff is Great alsoI have been ordering from this pizza place for over WOW 10years

We love Forno's and order from here very frequently. I order a lot of pasta. I came to Yelp to see…read moreif there were photos of some of the ones i havent tried and did not see any. So im taking it into my own hands - every time i order, ill be sharing the photos. You're welcome. Ive tried pasta, pizza, lasagna, chicken dishes - all very tasty! Delivery is always pretty quick too.

Forno Trattoria

3.5

(15 reviews)

Huge slices. Great specialty slices. Can always tell a pizzerias weight in gold by their plain…read moreslice, and fornos plain slice hits the mark. Great lunch specials, awesome bang for your buck

Friendly workers. Penne à la vodka is top notch. Very quick on the phone and food is hot!read more

Mike & Joe's Wood Fired Pizza & Pasta

3.5

(112 reviews)

I could barely even show y'all the pizza I didn't even make it home. I'm going back for a 2 nd as…read morewe speak

Service was poor, had a reservation and still waited to be seated outside. Once we were walking to…read moreour table we noticed it was pretty empty. Approximately 7 people were at two tables, the rest were empty. Food was okay, looked better in the photos on the menu, but whatever. The real disappointment came when they asked if we wanted coffee and dessert, we said yes put in our order for coffee the waiter asked what we wanted for dessert and he rambled off what they have and then said let me get the menu. We got the menu and decided what we wanted. While he was gone someone else dropped off our coffee and we never saw the waiter again. I was also looking forward to singing HBD to my son. Unfortunately, next thing we knew we got the bill. As I looked around I noticed the workers were busy with friends, they were hanging around like their night was done and it was just about 8:30 the place became a hangout. I get it, but hanging out at empty tables and ignoring customers?! Not good business. Hang out at the bar not in the dining area. My best guess is there was a table of young girls finishing up their dinner and the younger workers wanted to make friends with them. So my table was no longer important and neither was our dessert. Needless to say we won't be back.

Benvenuto’s II

4.2

(81 reviews)

Simply incredible. I travel a lot within NY because I'm a salesman and I eat a lot of pizza. But, I…read morehave to say this Pizza is top of the line. I love Pizza, and this place has figured out how to deliver a quality product!

I don't know what happened to this place but it's become awful. We ordered a grandma's pie that…read moreused to be delicious. Now it's just like a Sicilian pie. Last time I went there, the food was mediocre at best. They used to give you a little salad. They don't get that anymore. I don't know what happened. This place has gone downhill really fast. Why would you change how you make the pizzas when they used to be delicious?

Amici's Pizzeria & Restaurant

3.6

(112 reviews)

4 stars on my first serving of Amici's margherita pizza and garlic knots. Based on food delivery. I…read moreate a slice of margherita first. It was still hot and oven fresh. I carefully ate it so I didn't burn the roof of my mouth from the hot cheese and tomato sauce. The ratio of crusty bottom to pillowy mid-section to cheese to sauce was perfectly equal. Every bite was a perfect bite. And the garlic knots. Those are the first I enjoyed seconds of. It was pillowy thus light, tossed in minced garlic and oil. That garlic though...I used the knot to scrap the loose garlic in the container it came in. Yum! The dough here is not heavy. I had to stop after 2 slices. So good!!

Most meals are good.Do not order veal cutlet, parm.It's like shoe leather, they ordered the wedge,…read moreand it was terrible

Bella's Pizza & Pasta

4.1

(34 reviews)

Wow. This place has been hiding in plain sight. When everyone asks where in the general area to get…read moresome good pizza- this is where I am telling them to go. Have tried a variety and all are excellent. If you like a crispy crust with lots of toppings, this is the place for you. Give it a try. The place is small and only has a couple of tables so it's not eat-in. But the workers are so nice and friendly. Always serving with a smile.

The pizza used to be the best but it's now awful. I have tried to give them numerous chances but…read moreit still really bad. I wish they would use the same ingredients that they used to. What a shame!

Westbrook Pizzeria

3.8

(44 reviews)

Delirious as always Today's lunch was…read more Hot Ham and cheese Grilled Croissant and it was huge. Great price for the amount of food you get plus a Chefs Salad Which I plan on having for dinner too.. it was delivered to the job I was on and the delivery guy is a real gentleman and very kind. Give that man a raise.

I am in love with this place. Their food has always been consistently outstanding. From pizza to…read moresandwiches to entrees you can't go wrong. They have great specials throughout the week and for holidays/special occasions. Their Chicken BLT pizza is one of my favorites.

d'Berto Pizzeria

3.8

(30 reviews)

Best pizza in the area! The crust is always soft, and the pizza isn't overly oily or greasy. We…read morelove both their regular pizza and white pizza. Their Gorgonzola salad is also one of my favorites--they're always very generous with the Gorgonzola, which I love. We usually order delivery, and it's always fast with friendly service. Definitely our go-to for pizza!

Excellent food! A pleasure always to pick up food. Service is exceptional as well. Thank YOU.read more

Napoli's Pizza Restaurant

4.0

(62 reviews)