We had a nice dinner here albeit limited choices for me on the menu. Our server was nice though it would have been nicer of him to tell us that they don't have a particular house red wine and not serve us the most expensive glass they offer :/ Anyway, I ordered a half plate of the mushroom risotto and my bf had the grilled filet of sole. Had the tortoni for dessert (ice cream w/ crushed almonds and a maraschino cherry on top) and a cappuccino. I look around and the patrons were out to either celebrate a big birthday or a special occasion thus the dressy atmosphere. Clean bathrooms, big parking lot, and comfy waiting area. Stop by if you don't want to dine at the other seedy places near the boardwalk. read more

Pasquelina pasta Yumz. Atmosphere, nice. Fried Calamari so so. Prices.. expensive but on the whole everything is good here. If you can get those little rice balls that they make for parties... do get them Delish and they are not on the reg menu but u can ask for them and I think u have to buy a 10 count or something but no worries, take um home and enjoy! They play a nice little guessing game at the end of ur dinner to possibly win it for free .. just guess a number and they pull one out of the bag... match it and you won ur dinner free! read more

If you're within 600 miles of this restaurant and don't go here you're an idiot. Seriously, it's amazing. My favorite time of year to go is around Christmas, they display a beautiful gold angel on the wall with wonderful wreaths... it's breathtaking. The food can't be beat, and the owners and staff are the nicest people in the world. read more

One of my all time favorites. It's like having dinner with family. I have known this family and have eaten at Gargiulo's since I'm a little girl. The food stays consistently good. Oh and now they have added music on weekends/holidays. I enjoy having dinner with live music. Can't wait to come back. read more

This is what I call old fashion grandmom's cooking. Let me start with the valet. Polite men who ask how is your day so far? Enjoy your dinner. Walk into the actual restaurant and the foyer/bar area reminded me of a Hotel (in a good way). Walk up steps and greeted by the hostess who had our table ready. Let me say this any where you sit in this restaurant is a great view. Angelo was our waiter, made me feel like I was a frequent patron. Who I believe was the owners came to our table to see if we were happy with our waiter, the service as well as the food. My husband and I were driving through New York were more than satisfied and will be definite frequent patrons. read more

If I need a place with great food, excellent service, warm and caring environment, and feel like I'm home - Then I go to Gargiulo's. It has been a staple for me and my family for years. My Wife LOVES their Cannolis I have had only great experience here, whether in the resturant or with the Catering. You will be treated like family and love every minute of it! read more

I hosted an event at Gargiulos Restaurant last weekend. It was a memorial for my brother who passed away suddenly a few months ago and it was a perfect event. The food, service, room and location were all exactly what I was looking for. It was easy to arrange, only 2 phone calls and it was a great value too. The last time I was there was for my brother's 16th birthday around 1975 and it is bigger and more grand but the food is still exceptional. I highly recommend... Everyone that attended was in total agreement that my very picky brother would have approved. THANKS Gargiulo's for helping to make what could have been a somber day much better. We will be back! read more

We took my dad here on a Saturday night for his birthday. Overall we had an OK experience. Most of the dishes were good, but a little pricey for the location and level of service. We paid restaurant prices for fast food service. The chicken and veal entrees averaged $18.00 and the seafood entrees averaged $22.00. Risotto's averaged $18.00 and the Pasta's averaged $15.00. We shared the Fish salad and the baked clam appetizer which were very good. We also had the hot antipasto which was very good as well. We shared the spaghetti Puttanesca which was very good. We also had the Lasagna; some pieces tasted Metallic and other pieces had no taste. It was not worth eating. We had the shrimp parmigiana, which was good although the sauce was a little bland. We also had The Veal Marsala which was very good especially the Marsala sauce. We also had the Eggplant Rollatini and that was good. The service was mediocre: the waiter was barely there, and we had to look for him when we wanted something, when the dishes were cleared no one removed the crumbs from our tablecloth, and while the other tables had a flower, ours didn't. The wait staff did not pay attention to the details. The wine list was limited. Overall, the food is 4 stars and the service is 2 stars, thereby I gave it 3 stars. read more

Took my friends here, from Long Island before a concert in Coney Island because of how wonderful it was last time. Unfortunately, I was unable to. They WOULDNT LET ME IN because I had shorts on. Shorts!! They do realize it's the summer, in Coney Island right?? I understand having a dress code, but this dress code is absurd. Even if it was a code I respected, at least let us know when we make the reservation, not after we traveled all this way. Very very very disappointed. read more

Great Italian restaurant in Coney Island. This place has been around since 1907! It's like a big catering hall too. You walk up stairs and almost feel like you're on a big stage. A little high end, but good food. Love the old photos on the wall, looks like lots of cool events happened here around the 1930's. Cool bar too. read more

Wow. What can I say about this place. We were denied access to the inside dining area due to our attire and all I can say is thank God! We were seated at table one in the Pizza Garden. We would have missed the colorful characters Louie, Lucy, little John and the entire waitstaff. The energy and atmosphere was amazing. The place was slammed and they had people bogarting tables yet they managed to maintain a positive attitude while being so amazingly Italian, boisterous and exuding just the best that people in the service industry have to offer. We had the best time. When we get back to Coney Island we will definitely stop back by. Thank you for an epic evening. read more

Mixed reviews as I've been there only twice for special events. I can't remember how good the first time was, but in November 2017 i thought the food was dry, appetizers were no good, drinks watered down and the waiting staff was horrible. Only good thing was the outside entertainment. Very disappointed and I won't be spreading the word to party here. read more

This place is like a hole in the wall joint, but it isn't. It's a catering hall and a restaurant in one. The dining area is very spacious and quite elegant. You are expected to come in dressed nicely with the pants only rule in play. The food was priced just like other italian restaurants to my surprise. Each dish was presented nicely but I wish the portions were a tad larger. I would recommend the baked clams here. read more

beautiful, charming and elegant but simple transporting atmosphere - DELICIOUS fresh food in every course, makes you want to take your time and stay a while and definitely return. Can't wait for the magic of the Holiday Season there ! read more

Going here is always an event for my family, even though it's frequent. Old-school charm with updated style; there is no other restaurant like it. Make reservations because they are always packed with regulars. After visiting once you'll want to be one too. The dining room is awesome, the owners are priceless, and the entire staff makes you feel at home. Drinks are delicious and the food is incomparable. Service is consistently warm and exquisite. Cesare, we love you! Now if only they'd free the lobsters onto the nearby beach... read more

The Good: We had the Veal Portafoglio (Veal, Mushrooms, Asparagus), and the Chicken Francese. Both were delicious. The staff was attentive, polite, and great at their job. Never waited for water, drinks, food, service, etc. Very nice. The bread was served warm and was really fresh. It's how bread should taste in my opinion and bread that good can be a challenge to find(even in Brooklyn). It came with butter, but I should have asked for extra virgin olive oil. Needs improvement: The salad that came with the meal was a little disappointing as it only contained Iceberg lettuce and tomatoes. That was not on the same level as the rest of the dinner. Update: Thank you Nino for commenting, and listening to my feedback. Great staff and restaurant. Looking forward to going back. Cheers. read more

My review is based on service not the food... My office was having an event at the Cyclones Stadium and needed a cake to celebrate a special occasion. I am so disappointed in the fact that there are NO Italian bakeries left in Coney Island (I'm originally from CI and there were at least 2 when I left in 2001). Anyhow, I remembered Gargiulo's was right up the block from the stadium so we decided to call and see if they'd be able to handle getting a cake for us. Sure enough, they did us the favor! I love places that go out of their way to make people happy. The cake was amazing. Thank you!! read more

Even Though we have not eating there yet i have no doubt in my mind that the five stars will remain. I called the restaurant a few days ago to see if they would be able to accommodate 20 of us for my dads 70 th birthday the woman was very polite and told me someone would get back to me shortly. Later that evening i received a call from Anthony who i think is one of the owners and he said he would be able to accommodate us . I was so relieved it was not easy finding a restaurant last minute to accommodate 20 people on a Saturday night , I then was back in contact with Nino who is one of the owners who spent a hr, on the phone with me discussing the menu and how he was going to make it a very special day for my pop , We are so excited to share this special day with you guys Thanks . Frank read more

Lucy and the staff at Gargiulo's are tremendous. They go over the top to ensure their guests are happy. I was there attending a large event and the food was delicious, hot and well prepared. Thank you Gargiulo's! read more

I have nothing but good things to say about this place. We found this place by luck , almost a miracle. What a wonderful experience. Anthony was the best host, Matthew's desserts: phenomenal, and Chez's service: beyond excellent. Food was delicious and tasty wine! Such a great experience, cannot wait to go back! read more

I came here a couple weeks ago with some family to meet my great uncle for his birthday. He chose Gargiulo's because he lives in the area and likes coming here. This was my first time here and I wasn't disappointed. We came for lunch around 1 on a Saturday. We were seated right away without reservations cause it was an off hour. It is a fancy and nice restaurant so I can't come in wearing beach clothes. I say this because it is located like on block down from Coney Island. I ordered a spaghetti dish with clams and it was delicious. The service and the waiter were great and helpful. I enjoyed my visit and may be back in the future if I am in the area again read more

I am Italian-American and originally from this neighborhood. In the 35 years I have lived in Manhattan, lots has changed, but not Gargiulo's. It typifies PERFECT Italian-American food. Recommendations: all red sauce pastas, baked clams, veal, antipastos - any old school southern Italian items are great. And, it's not terribly expensive when you consider every portion is enough for 2-3 non-Italian-Americans. Go here to experience a little of the past before it's gone forever. read more

Very Disappointed, fried calamari was chewy, stuffed flounder had no taste. 50 dollar bottle of wine, I found for 14 on line. I had a reservation and they still had us wait 45 minutes on a Sunday night. read more

I'm shocked this place got the reviews that it did. I could not be more disappointed in the service. The food is the same as any other mediocre Italian restaurant. 3 of the orders were forgotten had to ask twice for others. I will never come back again and I would strongly encourage other to not come either. It's Thursday night mind you the staff was by no means overwhelmed. Got offered a free beer because he forgot to bring it during my main course. So as we were about to leave he apologized and gives me one on the house. Was really excited for this. read more

Soo tried to eat here with my wife for easter...not only was the limited menu off putting..( didn't let us know when making the reservation btw) but my steak (medium) was rare..and wife's medium well steak was also pretty rare...soo disappointed...they wanted to make it right wich I appreciated...but just totally killed the mood read more

Visited for 1st time this past Saturday to celebrate our HS reunion from Bishop McDonnell Memorial. What a memorable day it was from beginning to end. The restaurant was well decorated very inviting. The food was deliciously prepared. From The fish to the pasta to the veggies and chicken. All great! Flavorful chicken Marsala, pasta dishes, eggplant and much more. I would recommend a great dinner with family or friends at this establishment! read more

Gargiulo's - A little of everything. Mmmmmm - Italian Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Gargiulo's is both classy and classic; because of this, dining here is a special experience. It is a respectable place, where you should take care to bring your manners, yet at the same time, warm enough to make diners feel welcomed. For these reasons, plus the obvious--delicious authentic cuisine--I choose to celebrate life's occasions here: Family dinners, date nights, my daughter's christening and first birthday... All carried out with such care and professionalism. I'm profoundly impressed by their fine attention to detail, their warmth, and expertise. I have so many wonderful memories here, and I look forward to creating many more, in this beautiful, beautiful place. read more

Did not eat here. We walked in, spent about 10 minutes at the entrance. Waiters walked by, saw us, and continued about their day. It was not busy. There was one table. They are clearly not interested in garnering or attracting business. read more

I got really excited about going to this place and aesthetically it was quite pleasing the service is the only reason I'm giving them two stars but the food was plain Jane disgusting I don't even want to get into detail about it everything is just disgusting I've been to pizzerias that have better quality Italian food then this place. First and last time. read more

Some of the most delicious and authentic Italian food in Brooklyn. My favorite is the shrimp risotto, fried calamari and the baked clams but I have tried many a dishes and have loved them all! The dining hall has been redone and modernized making it a great spot for a dinner, a date night out or a small celebration with family and friends. I will be having my wedding reception in their reception hall in back of the restaurant here next year and can't wait! The cocktail room and reception rooms are spacious and gorgeous. The menu options are plentiful and I am confident the food and drink will be amongst the best part of our wedding. Even better, I love that they only host one event at a time so the space will be all ours! The staff is always friendly and willing to make suggestions or recommendations for food. Also don't forget to play the game at the end of your meal for a chance to win it free! read more

Nice service at the bar. However, my food was awful. My pasta was supposed to be artichoke with prosciutto. There wasn't a scrap of prosciuotto in it and the manager was telling me that there was. My friend had to ask for ice 5 times before she received it. I will not be going back. Unfortunately I've been here before and had good meals. read more

This is a must visit. Great Italian food. Place has been there for over 100yrs. Ask for special s or "off menu dishes".

We have been there a few times and had my daughters sweet 16 party there. I remember that the food was great, the service, superb and atmosphere fabulous. Well,15 years have gone by and her boyfriend wanted to say "Will you marry me?" in a special place. I suggested he speak to Nino, and set it up. Nino did everything possible to make this a memorable dinner for our families. And it was. Again, food was exceptional, delicious Italian food cooked to order, service surpassed by no other, and a family type atmosphere when he popped the question. The entire restaurant cheered and clanged glasses. It was a night we will all remember. Thank you, Nino and the Gargiulo family for making another outstanding memory for my family. read more

I just had my daughters baby shower at Gargiulos. They couldn't do more to make my family and our guests feel more welcomed and treated us to a wonderful experience. The cake witch I ordered from the in house Baker was exceptional. The food as always excellent. The staff was professional and very attentive. This restaurant is one of Brooklyn's finest and most elegant restaurants. Thank you for a great time and making this day memorable. read more

I rarely take to yelp to review a restaurant, but I have never felt so awkward or out of place in an establishment in all of my life. I wish I read the reviews prior to going inside. My sister and I were walking along the street and were lured by the pretty outdoor seating and pizza being made outdoors. It was quickly apparent that the hostess did not want to seat us and asked if we had reservations for a nearly empty seating area. After reading some of the reviews, perhaps this was for our attire (which while beach ready, was not sloppy). It also took an excessive amount of time to get served and it seemed as if no one actually wanted to serve us in general. It's apparent a certain crowd frequents this space, and while that is fine for those chosen few, I felt none of that hospitality. I find it interesting that a large number of reviewers feel this negative vibe from this restaurant and perhaps that is something that needs to be addressed. I'm disappointed because this could have been a great place to go while visiting Coney Island (which I do ever summer), but this will be a hard pass from me! read more

I love this place! The food is delicious and the service is great. Friendly and cool atmosphere. The owners make you feel at home. Will be eating many more dinners here with my loved ones. read more

I took my wife to Gargiulo's for Valentines Day and what a marvelous time we had together. As always, the staff performed their task perfectly and with cheer. The ambiance was perfect for such an occasion including live music which was appropriate, engaging, and talented. My wife and I were both pleased with our experience even before the food arrived. Speaking of food, the seafood here is incredibly delicious. I took photos of our dishes but they do not give justice to the presentation, aroma, and palette enchanting experience my wife and I had that evening. The atmosphere, the staff, the food all were exceptional and I highly recommend for any occasion. read more

See all

Pretty good food , clean , typical Italian style place . Service is pretty good too usually . Live music for the most part unless it's a private event then it's different . Generally dressy attire . read more

We had a very early dinner at Gargiulos and I can tell you that the service by Angelo was very enjoyable, fast, and humorous. He has a great personality and you feel like you have known him for years. The appetizers were great, baked clams and a Ceasar salad,but the dinners were even better. My wife had the 3lb. lobster, broiled,that she described as to be very juicy, and tender, grilled to perfection! I had my favorite, Chicken Scarpariello on the bone with sausage, potatoes, cherry peppers. All I can say is My complements to the chef. For desert try the Tiramisu, it's fantastic. My wife was never a fan of the dessert, but today she couldn't put her fork down. Maybe next time she'll order her own and leave mine alone! Job well done! read more

This evening was so disappointing. I know I know this is a childhood staple. Back in the day the, creme of the creme if you will. However, times have changed and apparently this place has too. Food was terrible. They couldn't even get my stuffed artichoke right. It was basically raw. Breadcrumbs probably thrown on right out of the Progresso container before it was delivered to my table. The leaves were no better. Texture was uncooked. My veal chop lacked flavor and was served alone on a huge plate with no sense of presentation. Oh I happened to forget it was accompanied by a cold potato croquette which looked so out of place. Resembled a tater tot. The hot appetizer was far from appetizing. This place has not remained consistent with the quality of their food, but you know what has , their prices. Just not worth paying those prices for this quality. I do hate to see places like these disappear from Brooklyn, but YTD this place doesn't serve anything other than a good memory. Their dining room was decorated beautifully. The service was okay. Sorry looking for positives. read more