Gelateria Gentile

429

719

5039

28 days ago

Food (5/5): Really good gelato. We got the straciatella and some caramel ice cream. Really solid flavors and gelato. Service (4/5): Short line when we got there but then quickly got busy. We were able to try a few flavors and no issues with the service. Ambiance (4/5): Nice gelato shop with some indoor and outdoor seating. They could use some more seating inside though. read more

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Damian W.

68

1157

522

12 days ago

Food 4.0/5.0 Service 3.0/5.0 Value 3.0/5.0 Decor 3.5/5.0 Overall 4.0/5.0 Good ice cream. Decent brioche. Staff was a little chatty (with each other) the day I stopped by. Good ice cream/gelato, would go back. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Jeongmin H.

360

440

881

2 months ago

Their gelato is super thick and rich. The mini cone that comes with each scoop is so adorable. It's a bit pricey but I think it's worth it! read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 1

Love this 2

Oh no 0

Grace L.

3

39

96

4 months ago

Actually good gelato. I don't think the pastries are anything remarkable, but definitely a reliable gelato spot with quick service and a cute interior! read more

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Jackie K.

63

254

710

4 months ago

The gelato was amazing and I'm not really an ice cream person. The place was clean and big with plenty of seating. The staff were nice. The cake was delicious. The flan as well. I want to go back and get a crepe. read more

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Cindy Z.

1789

3109

7211

10 months ago

While heading home after barhopping, we passed by this cute gelato spot and decided for a night cap. It's nice that they open until midnight as we were some of the last customers. They also let us sample some flavors. I decided on Pistachio and Milk for a Small Cup ($8.50). It even comes with a mini cone, which is adorable. The gelato is very creamy and authentic like you're in Italy. With that said, I found it rather pricey. Now that I think of it, somehow my total was $23 for two smalls when it should've only been $17+tip. read more

Helpful 3

Thanks 0

Love this 2

Oh no 2

Samantha G.

210

1384

1855

1 year ago

This is the best gelato I've had in the US! It reminded me of my trip to Italy with my husband! Be prepared to wait because this place is popular!! Ambiance: There is a bit of seating inside and outside, but the tables are pretty small! read more

Gelateria Gentile - Just like Italy! - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Gelateria Gentile - Lurisia Orange and mixed berries - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Helpful 2

Thanks 1

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Jai Y.

4

156

424

1 year ago

It was raining and somehow it made me crave gelatos. The best thing about that means there was no line. I got the mandarin & mixed berries. My wife got a dark chocolate with pomegranates and vanilla cream with lemon zest. It was delicious. I just wished the water cones weren't cones so I could place them down on a table. Also I wished we got to try more than 2 flavors max. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 1

Jordan N.

635

2455

2165

1 year ago

New York does gelatos well, and one place helping give this image is Gelateria Gentile. This cute corner shop, nicely lit in a largely residential neighborhood of Williamsburg at night, is open late and people flock here even late in the evening for after-dinner pleasure. But this place can be easily enjoyed during the day with their espresso-based drinks and pastry offerings. I also liked that they have waffle-cone "cups" as an option to the standard cups - but the standard cups do come with the cone put upside down on top of the ice cream so you won't be missing much. The chocolate ice cream was dark and rich - one of the best chocolate gelato I've had in a long time. I would order this again. For the unique flavors, I liked their "crema antica" which is their vanilla cream with lemon zest - I could eat this all the time since it's a simple yet not blasé flavor - perfect for anytime in the day, any day of the week. They had a multitude of flavors on the wall, and based on their flavors, and their pastries, I can definitely vouch that they're sticking with their Italian roots. I'll be back for sure. read more

Helpful 5

Thanks 1

Love this 2

Oh no 0

Isabella J.

2254

1587

8878

10 months ago

Who isn't a gelato fan? We popped in for a mid-afternoon treat with our daughter and our timing was just right. No line and no long wait. In fact, there was seating too! We hadn't done any prior research before going there, so it was a nice surprise to see that the owners are Pugliese, as my husbands family is as well. We enjoyed stracciatella gelato and mixed berry sorbetto for my three year old. They also had a small selection of Italian pastries that caught my eye. I might even order their panettone this holiday season to see if my Pugliese in-laws approve. read more

See all

Helpful 3

Thanks 1

Love this 4

Oh no 0

Alana K.

60

742

657

5 months ago

My friend and I came here on a Friday night to get gelato. I had a small cup with coffee and dark chocolate gelato. It was delicious, but expensive! A small cup cost almost $10. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Victoria K.

17

466

933

1 year ago

I somewhat expected more from this place since the line was out the door and the reviews are so high. I ordered the black cherry and the hazelnut. The hazelnut was the STAR-- it was so smooth and creamy, and if I were to go again I'd just get a jug of it. The black cherry was good enough, but I wish that flavor were more rich. The cream gelato was slightly icy. I also just wish there were more variety in flavors. The spread is pretty standard, so you'll find a classic, but would love some more options. The line moves pretty quickly, though! And it's open late which is always a plus. read more

Gelateria Gentile - Black Cherry and Hazelnut - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Helpful 1

Thanks 1

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Tiffany H.

161

763

4927

11 months ago

Great gelato place. Live the mini cubes topped on the gelato cup. So crispy gelato is creamy n perfect for hot summer nights. Usually long line but moves fast read more

See all

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Bridget D.

3

28

41

5 months ago

Will be dreaming about this whipped cream forever. Lovely spot for dessert in Williamsburg. The coffee flavor was amazing.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Andreas K.

193

842

4459

11 months ago

Beautiful little gelateria in Brooklyn, and the icecream is unquestionably very delicious. Too bad only that they keep the material hidden in large vessels with lids that fail to stimulate the visual appetite. read more

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 1

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Ellen C.

26

189

709

11 months ago

Great gelato!! Their pistachio flavor was highlighted and recommended! Not too sweet, very creamy and flavorful! read more

Gelateria Gentile - Gelato Pint - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Nyra A.

0

1

5 months ago

My group and I had a really disappointing experience here, and feel like it needs to be said. The gelato itself might be fine, but the service completely ruined it for us. The woman who helped us was extremely rude, visibly annoyed, and honestly made us feel unwelcome from the moment we walked up. When I asked about the flavors, I had to repeat myself multiple times because she either ignored us or walked away mid-conversation. When she did respond, she rolled her eyes and gave me attitude like I was inconveniencing her just by being there. I understand everyone has off days, but this went beyond that, it felt unprofessional and disrespectful. Customer service matters, especially in a place where people come to enjoy themselves. Unfortunately, this experience left a really bad impression, and we won't be coming back. read more

Gelateria Gentile - The lady who was very rude! !! - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Sally X.

4

138

368

1 year ago

Amazing ice cream. I'm a fan of gelato and this is the real deal! The flavors are traditionally Italian gelato and delicious. I tend to order the cream based gelatos but this time I opted for the frutto de bosco (sorbet) to go with stracciatella and pistachio. The Williamsburg location is very quaint. Love the inside and great tables on the sidewalk. Service was excellent! read more

Gelateria Gentile - Frutto de basco, pistachio and stracciatella - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Gelateria Gentile - Interior - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Gelateria Gentile - Medium cup - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Payel K.

128

51

159

1 year ago

This review is regarding their TWO SAMPLES ONLY policy. I can't review how the gelato tasted because I couldn't get one. I sampled one flavor which wasn't to my liking and then asked if I could sample the milk chocolate & the dark chocolate to which I was told "No. we allow only two samples." Honestly, I find this ridiculous and have never come across a gelato/icecream shop that puts limits on tasting those minuscule samples. It is the hottest day in Brooklyn (90F), I walked all the way here and now I'm sitting in a corner crying instead of eating a gelato because I was refused a sample of what I want to get :( read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 2

Josephine L.

944

2700

4053

2 years ago

Cute spot for creamy gelati, but be prepared to walk and eat, as there isn't much seating. Thankfully, this is New York, not Tokyo, so walking and eating is socially acceptable. I love my ultra-white, ultra-creamy Fior di Latte, and this rendition was far better than Eataly's. My other half got the Spagnola, which came with delightfully tart sour cherry. Those feeling seasonal will likely enjoy the deeply nutmeg-y Pumpkin. Oh, and get all your choices in their cone cup. Because....Cone. Cup. read more

Helpful 5

Thanks 0

Love this 5

Oh no 0

Michael F.

0

6

2

4 months ago

We loved this spot ton celebrate mothers day. The flower decor the decoration of the bar and a wonderful winding stairs to a wine cellar from our seats something out of old Italy read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Marie S.

324

706

1139

2 years ago

Delicious desserts! I was looking for Italian pastries at 9pm last night and found Gentile Gelatieri Williamsburg on seamless.com. Their menu offers a selection Italian sodas, hot chocolate, coffee, expresso, cappuccino (and more), gelato, pastries, desserts and crepes. The selection reminded me of Italy. Everything I love. I'm always looking for gelato, especially since Grom gelato (a great fresh fruit gelato shop that was located over by Central Park Columbus Circle) closed its doors. I couldn't believe it when I found this place. Where have you been hiding? Lol. Plus they deliver. I tried : 1) The Pistacchio Crepe - pistachio spread and powdered sugar on top. It was one of the best crepes I've had in the city! The texture was so satisfying, the pistachio melts in your mouth; the flavors tasted homemade & very fresh. So good! 2) The Torta Nera - Dark Chocolate Sponged Cake. Delicious, moist and not too sweet. The photo online shows it topped with powdered sugar- mine arrived bare, no sugar. Luckily I had some powdered sugar and topped it myself. It was a simple dessert but sometimes you want something sweet and uncomplicated. The torta was the perfect contrast to the crepe. The crepe was the more impressive dessert though. Very different but both enjoyable. Gentile Gelatieri's website has an interesting section on the company's history. They've been a Gelatieri since 1880. Recipes have been "handed down for generations" Originally from Southern Italy they now have shops in New York, including this one in Williamsburg BK. More details are available on their website. read more

Helpful 14

Thanks 4

Love this 15

Oh no 0

Anthony R.

248

193

481

1 year ago

I've come here a few times already and every time I come, I always get a really good combination of flavors. You get up to 4 samples before making your order which is really nice on the staff because their menu is seasonal as well as some fixtures. For this particular night I got the hazelnut and the lemon and those flavors complemented each other very well - sour and sweet, slushy and gelato, light and thick. And it came with a small cone which I like the crunch. read more

Gelateria Gentile - Limon & Hazelnut - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Julia F.

146

324

149

11 months ago

I miss the gelaterias of my home country. Gentile is the closest alternative to hopping a plane for a taste of that creamy goodness. The Crema Antica is a must try - like cake batter with little pops of lemon zest - but quite honestly every flavor is a crowd pleaser. The lines are long especially on the weekends, but well worth the wait. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Deepika M.

14

263

541

1 year ago

Nice cozy neighbors gelateria with more seat behind. Clean white and elegant space, lots of flavors to try from. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Tiffany G.

239

283

274

1 year ago

It's good--but like not $8 per scoop good. I got the crema antica and the pistachio. If you get a small scoop you get 2 flavors. They also only let you try 2 flavors. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Cristina J.

72

199

904

2 years ago

Stopped by for a quick gelato bite and man was it fresh and tasty. Such a cute little vibe place with quick service and seating all around. They even have Italian pastries and carbonated Italian beverages read more

See all

Helpful 1

Thanks 1

Love this 2

Oh no 0

Elizabeth X.

112

641

1448

2 years ago

Great gelato place and well loved. Staff is swift. Flavors are good - Cherry was the favorite. Seating available outside. Water available self serve. read more

See all

Helpful 1

Thanks 1

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Rae A.

46

692

1626

2 years ago

Stopped by after a birthday dinner to celebrate with a sweet treat. I think they limit a few samples per person but they are pretty generous with the scoops. I enjoyed the one w the chocolate chips and the dark chocolate. I could not tell you the names of these flavors off the top of my head but follow your heart. I had lovely company and enjoyed my gelato and especially the tiny cones that they served it with. Amazing time and perfectly romantic. read more

Helpful 3

Thanks 1

Love this 2

Oh no 0

Jennifer N.

680

1995

3009

2 years ago

I like the creamyness of the gelato here but it does err on the super sweet side (and I have a sweet tooth too). read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Julia S.

0

13

16

1 year ago

I usually love this place. the gelato is incredible. but the last 2 times i've been there my cup was barely filled. granted the place was packed (on a Tuesday at 9 pm, weird) but this is the second time the portion size has been so so little. for the total of 2 cups being 18-19 dollars, it's unacceptable. not sure i'll be back. read more

Gelateria Gentile - portion size is so little - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Gelateria Gentile - FROM A PREVIOUS VISIT - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Gelateria Gentile - also from weeks ago (with a few spoonfuls already taken) - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Carrie T.

285

389

106

4 months ago

Great service, cute shop, nothing very special unfortunately. We had the kiwi. Gelato is just ok.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Sheena T.

358

821

618

3 years ago

Closest to authentic gelato you can find in Brooklyn. They have the trademark flavors in all Italian lingo - tutti frutti, nocciola, etc. They also top your gelato off with a mini cone as well! I always opt for almond, coconut, and yogurt as they are my classic favorites. Not too sweet, not too heavy, and always a favorite treat after dinner. Been a solid regular here and come here when I crave more authentic Italian gelato. read more

Helpful 2

Thanks 1

Love this 2

Oh no 0

Roop K.

106

616

716

3 years ago

Stumbled on this place walking around Williamsburg after dinner looking for van leuwen actually. So glad we found this instead, they have such simple yet amazingly done flavours. Definitely be ready to wait a little , two samples per person only, and you get a mini cone with the cup. I got hazelnut and chocolate - lovely flavours and cream and not too heavy. read more

See all

Helpful 5

Thanks 0

Love this 3

Oh no 0

Ryan C.

0

49

0

4 months ago

Giovanni and the staff are lovely, but go for the bocconattos. Pick any, you can't go wrong. Current fav is the Pugliese.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Ruby C.

174

625

5336

3 years ago

Pistachio & nocciola (hazelnut) gelato tasted premium, nutty and extremely creamy. Each order serves with a complimentary mini cone, surprisingly crispy and not stale! The portion was small and a bit pricey ($8.17/2 favors in a cup), but the store was spacious, cozy and clean. Most importantly, there's a restroom!! read more

Gelateria Gentile - Pistachio, Nocciola (Hazelnut) - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Helpful 4

Thanks 0

Love this 2

Oh no 0

Su-jen Y.

114

482

1716

2 years ago

Love a good gelato. I got the pistachio and hazelnut flavors and both were good. 100% would come again. read more

Gelateria Gentile - Pistachio and hazelnut - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Jahnavi U.

66

548

1426

3 years ago

It's so nice to discover new dessert places in Williamsburg. After dinner last Friday, my friends and I were in the mood for something sweet. It's always a good sign when you see a big line in front of a dessert place and this place had one wrapped around the storefront. We decided to join the line and asked the people waiting in line for suggestions and it paid off. This place serves up good gelato. They have a variety of flavors. You get 2 tastings before picking your final choice. I figured go big or go home and so opted for the Cono cialdo with 3 scoops of gelato: spagnola (vanilla and amarena cherry) , fondente (dark chocolate) , and croccantino al Rhum (vanilla swirled and topped with caramel and sprinkled with chopped nuts and there's rum in it). All of the gelato flavors I picked were delicious. My husband got the affogato with chocolate and vanilla gelato topped with whipped cream. Coincidentally, my friend ended up getting the same flavors I did and loved them. I will definitely bookmark this place to go back on occasion to try their other flavors. read more

Gelateria Gentile - Desserts besides gelato - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Gelateria Gentile - Affogato with a scoop of vanilla and chocolate gelato and whipped cream - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Gelateria Gentile - Cono cialdo with 3 scoops of gelato: spagnola, fondente, and croccantino al Rhum - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Brian M.

681

429

4886

3 years ago

This was a pleasant surprise, I've been walking past all the crowds anytime I'm in the area and want to know what the hype was. They have a great selection of gelato in many flavors. They also sell coffee, pastries, cakes and they have a chart to help you through any allergies. I had an ice cream sugar cone and you have a choice of 2 flavors. They also have free samples if you are unsure. Everyone was friendly, helpful and the store is very clean. I highly recommend them. Just be prepared that you may have to wait a few minutes to get in. The lime does move fast! read more

Gelateria Gentile - CREMINO AL FIORDILATTE CREMINO AMARENA CROCCANTE - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Gelateria Gentile - Outside crowds - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Gelateria Gentile - Ice cream cakes - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Gelateria Gentile - Allergies?? No problem. - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Gelateria Gentile - Inside - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Sophia N.

2.4 mi•Bedford Stuyvesant

77

439

573

2 years ago

Cute little gelato store! They have a variety of traditional gelato flavors and both flavors were creamy and delicious. We took our gelato to a nearby park and ate it while looking at the skyline. They are open pretty late if you are looking for a late night sweet treat! read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Page 1 of 9

See more reviews

More info about Gelateria Gentile

253 Wythe Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11249
Williamsburg - North Side
Directions
(347) 599-0646
Call Now
Order Takeout or Delivery
Start Order
Visit Website
http://www.gelateriagentile.com

Full menu

Hours

What time does Gelateria Gentile open?

Gelateria Gentile opens at 8:00 AM on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday and Friday.Gelateria Gentile opens at 9:00 AM on Saturday and Sunday.

What time does Gelateria Gentile close?

Gelateria Gentile closes at 12:00 AM (Next day) on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday and Sunday.Gelateria Gentile closes at 12:30 AM (Next day) on Friday and Saturday.

Mon-Thu 8:00 AM - 12:00 AM (Next day)Fri 8:00 AM - 12:30 AM (Next day)Sat 9:00 AM - 12:30 AM (Next day)Sun 9:00 AM - 12:00 AM (Next day)

Payment methods

Does Gelateria Gentile take credit cards?

Yes, Gelateria Gentile takes credit cards.

Food & Alcohol

Does Gelateria Gentile have catering options?

Yes, Gelateria Gentile does have catering options.

Does Gelateria Gentile have a happy hour?

No, Gelateria Gentile does not have a happy hour.

Does Gelateria Gentile serve alcohol?

No, Gelateria Gentile does not serve alcohol.

Indoor Amenities

Does Gelateria Gentile allow dogs?

No, Gelateria Gentile does not allow dogs.

Does Gelateria Gentile have TVs?

Yes, Gelateria Gentile has TVs.

Outdoor Amenities

Does Gelateria Gentile have bike parking?

Yes, Gelateria Gentile has bike parking.

Does Gelateria Gentile have outdoor seating?

Yes, Gelateria Gentile has outdoor seating options.

Does Gelateria Gentile have parking?

Yes, Gelateria Gentile has parking options. Street Parking

Other Amenities

Is Gelateria Gentile wheelchair accessible?

Yes, Gelateria Gentile is wheelchair accessible.

Does Gelateria Gentile have free WiFi?

Yes, Gelateria Gentile has free WiFi.

From the Business

Specialties

Artisanal gelato

History

Established in 1880.

Gelateria gentile is a five generations family owned gelato business established in 1880 in Bari Italy

More Info

Health Score

Gelateria Gentile Reviews in Other Languages

Italian
1 Review

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Coffee & Tea 27,814 times last month within 5 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Explore benefits

Brown Butter Creamery

4.4(26 reviews)

I came here because I was in the area for another place and I'm so happy I stopped in. First this…read moreplace feels homey, a step back in time. The staff is also very friendly and patient. It was my first time there and I wanted to try different flavors. There is a limit to how many flavors you can try. I decided on the passion fruit and a vanilla based ice cream with brittle or something it was quite delicious. I am still thinking about the ice cream. I have a lot of ice cream but this once was very memorable. The freshness and texture of the ice cream, it was smooth and the added texture of the mix in was so good, the perfect scoop and it gave it a nice flavor as well. It is definitely worth a trip back to Brooklyn.

My nephew wanted ice cream, and my sister came to visit him for the day. Of course, i came to yelp…read moreto see what or where is the closest. I saw that this was in walking distance from my home, so we decided to take the walk for some ice cream. After viewing their socials, we decided that it was a good place to enjoy a cool treat on a hot day. They didn't disappoint. First, it's gelato, which is a bit different. My nephew wasn't enthused. He really wanted another type of icee. Me and my sister instead got a cone with cookies and cream, and i opted for the double chocolate and vanilla. The flavors were amazing! It was so rich and it didn't melt right away which was cool. The chocolate tasted just like a brownie. It was perfect, and the vanilla was a nice way to offset all that chocolate. The small cup comes with 2 scoops i believe. My sister enjoyed her cone as well. I will return to this spot. I enjoyed it. The service was cool. The customer service was brief as it was getting crowded. So we got out the way of others and went on to enjoy our day. Pics below.

Inside

See all

L'albero Dei Gelati

4.5(333 reviews)

3.2 mi•Park Slope

We came here one night and have now been back 3 times in less than 2 weeks. I feel like that says…read moresomething lol especially since the drive here is about 40 min. They allow up to 2 samples of their flavors per person and when we arrived on a Friday night around 8pm with our toddler, there was a line wrapped around the corner. I went to the park with our little one while my husband waited on the line. The gelato is creamy and delicious and the fruit flavors are bold and refreshing! We got the Pistachio as well as the mango, blueberry and strawberry flavors. The child cup is 6.50 with 1 flavor, the regular size with up to 2 flavors is $8, the 3 flavor cup is 9 and I think I stopped looking lol but a pint is $14. The prices you see are also inclusive of tax - European style, which we appreciated. It is a bit pricey for what look like teeny cups, but the ingredients are organic where they can be and it has all been consistently delicious. They also pack the cups pretty well. We'll definitely be back and I'm sure the lines will only continue to grow as summer comes. Enjoy! :)

The sidewalk-facing display at L'albero dei Gelati makes it an easy place to stop in, especially on…read morewarm days. I like that their menu is a mix of classic gelato flavors and combinations are more unexpected. Recently, I visited and tried the goat cheese with strawberry coulis. It was creamy, tangy, and not overly sweet. I ended up coming back two days later for another scoop! They also offered my dog a treat while we were there, which was nice. There are a few outdoor tables too if you want to stay and enjoy your gelato.

0.5 mi•Williamsburg - South Side

Parmigiano Reggiano with Arugula Delicious!!

See all

Serendipity BK

4.8(63 reviews)

•$

I went to this gelato spot a while back with a group on one of my many walks. The place is small,…read moreand there were a couple of people inside sipping coffee and enjoying their gelato. As I'm really in that part of Brooklyn, I decided to get the medium size, which is up to two flavors, and it was $7.95 plus tax. My flavors of choice were the saffron and the pistachio, as it has been a while since I have had that combination. In general, the gelato is of good quality, being soft but not too much, and it wasn't overly sweet. The pistachio on top was good with some pieces inside for a bit of crunch, though I would say in terms of other fancy gelatos, it's a bit worse than Venchi, as the pistachio flavor isn't as strong. The saffron was the better of the two, being floral enough without being overbearing. Not much else to say here, as I only had those flavors, but I hope they do well.

We were looking for a lighter option for dessert after lunch at Peter Luger and this did not…read moredisappoint. The pistachio and hazelnut gelatos were creamy and flavorful and they make it right on-site. Everyone was really nice and it was a super cute place to come grab a sweet treat or a coffee. Would definitely return.

0.9 mi•Williamsburg - North Side

Two scoop sorbet

See all

Interior

Fortunato Brothers

3.9(577 reviews)

Delicious pastry, coffee and Italian classics like St. Joseph's pastry…read more Coffee is delicious as well.

The prices are low, the cakes are small so it's perfect to try a few things. I got the chocolate…read moremoose and the only part I enjoyed was the white frosted lining under the chocolate shell. The rest of the cake was stale

2.7 mi•Bedford Stuyvesant

Clerk: How can i help you? My Brain: Rainbow Cookie 24 something per pound...

See all

Pastries and cookies display

Saraghina Bakery

3.9(105 reviews)

Saraghina has a rotating assortment of daily baked goods, and they also even sell olive oil by…read moreweight, and other curated specialty food items. The standout item is definitely the focaccia. The olive focaccia in particular was excellent: crispy on the outside, soft and airy inside, and packed with flavor. They also rotate other flavored foccacias that come out closer to lunch, which honestly gives you a reason to come back later in the day. The almond croissant was solid too, flaky and well-balanced without being overly sweet. They also sell giant chocolate chip cookies the size of your face- cool for the wow factor, and it's a 3.5/5 for flavor and texture- I wouldn't get again. The "raisin croissant" was a letdown. It's really more like soft swirled bread than an actual croissant, so adjust expectations accordingly. They also have a raspberry-filled croissant if you like filled breads. Seating inside is very limited- basically just a tiny high-top situation. Warning, it gets pretty busy on weekend mornings (line crawls down the block sometimes!).

I walk by this bakery daily almost. I've never stepped foot in it until a few days ago. I ordered a…read morecroissant, and a chocolate chip cookie. The croissant was nice and flaky, buttery as well it nice. I also ordered a chocolate chip cookie which had sea salt on the top of it. It was pretty good. It's a crunchy kind of cookie. The salt was a nice touch. It wasn't overpowering at all. It kinda made the chocolate flavor a bit less powerful (which i don't like, but also don't mind lol). No pics of croissant. See pics below.

2.4 mi•Cobble Hill, Boerum Hill

Inside

Bangin!!!

See all

Mia's Bakery

4.3(1.3k reviews)

I love Mia's Bakery. I went so many times during my two months in Brooklyn and even came back a…read moremonth later just to have it again. I've been to both locations--the Times Square one is much smaller, but the Brooklyn location is amazing with a nice sit-down area. I always go back to my favorite, the tres leches cupcakes. I've also tried the lobster tail--it's delicious. Definitely loved it!

Stopped by early Saturday morning to pick up some Blackout Cake slices for a birthday. There is…read moremetered parking in front and residential parking on close by. I had no problem finding parking. They had a few people ordering at the front, and a few people eating in the back. I perused the available cake (and pie) slices and other smaller baked goods, but did not see the Blackout Cake Slice! When I asked the staff, they regretfully informed me that they did not have slices that day, so I went with the next best option... an 8" cake! I didn't get any writing on the cake, as I already had a Happy Birthday candle, and I didn't want to add extra icing to the cake. I liked how well they package the cake. The box was large enough, and they line the bag with a thin piece of cardboard to stabilize the box. I'm not a big sweets person, but I enjoyed the chocolate-y richness of the cake. The cake itself was moist and the pudding held everything together well. I would be back to try their Strawberry Shortcake and other desserts.

2.0 mi•Clinton Hill, Bedford Stuyvesant

Tiramisu

See all

Baby Shark cake

Dreamery BK

4.1(15 reviews)

Pro tip: Get all the soft serve twists!! Literally every single flavor is a must try. Couldn't pick…read morea favorite and the best part about it... I didn't need to limit myself to just one. How often can you get horchata, mango, pistachio, raspberry, vanilla, and chocolate in one soft serve cup? Dreamery BK lives up to its name. It is a dreamy spot in Brooklyn with cute knick knacks and people all around.

I came here on a nice Sunny afternoon for an ice cream date with my nephew. I want to preface this…read moreby saying that I'm always on the look out for non-diary products. I don't eat nuts so I'm very particular about the non dairy products I consume. This was DELICIOUS. My favorite flavor has to be coffee. The staff were extremely nice and friendly. They let us try various flavors as it was my first time visiting the shop. They have soft serve ice cream as well if the regular one is not your thing. They even have a cute toppings bar in the back for the ice cream. Neighborhood gem!

Over the soft serve machines

Storefront

See all

Self Serve Soft Serve

F Monteleone Bakery & Cafe

4.3(219 reviews)

2.9 mi•Carroll Gardens

Whoa!! This pastry: espresso/ gelato shop is a don't miss it spot! They make large and mini…read moreversions of all things traditional. I don't know what kind of chocolate they use but it is the best! I've order specialty pastries and imported chocolate and vanilla but here it is in one place. Bring your kids, family and visiting guests. This is what the fakes try to imitate. Trust me you haven't had real pastry until you stop here. Price was so inexpensive. A huge container of fresh gelato was only $15.

I'm a sucker for a bakery, so as soon as we walked by - we back tracked and walked in. The mini…read morelobster tails were delicious, as were the key lime tarts. We got thumbprint cookies and something that reminded me of a Kouign Amann, which were also great. My biggest disappointment was the tiramisu as I found that almost inedible. I'm not sure if it was just a bad batch or what, but it was sour, dry, and the bitter from the chocolate only enhanced the undesirable. The shop is a small space with plenty of options to choose from and staff is quick, but nothing is labeled so be ready to point/ask.

Mango Mousse and Chocolate Raspberry Mousse. So good.

Gluten free cookies + 1 non GF hazelnut cream puff

See all

Yummy cross bun

Ample Hills Creamery

4.5(1.7k reviews)

2.6 mi•Prospect Heights

WILL BE BACK FOR THEIR CORN ON THE RUN! A sweet corn icecream with pieces of crumble with a…read moreblueberry swirl. I loved this ice cream spot, all their flavors had a great base and great mix-ins. You'll be able to sample flavors too! The cookie au lait, coffee base icecream is essentially a coffee cookies n creme and was delicious.

This was my first visit to Ample Hills but not my last. The flavors were great. The butter pecan…read morepie was amazing. The staff were very friendly and service was on point. The noise level is what I would expect on a hot summer day. If you're looking for good ice cream in this area Ample Hills is the place.

0.8 mi•Williamsburg - North Side

Ooeyer and Gooeyer on top!

Welcome back, Ample Hills! This is a kid's cup.

See all

Nonna D's Oatmeal Lace, oh captain, my captain

Chillato

4.3(3 reviews)

Congratulation on business on Leonard St. The neighborhood is getting busy and busier. I'm so glad…read moreand feel amazing that on that street has more commercial store, restaurant and bar because it is not even a main street. Maybe the rent is cheaper, I have no idea but I'm glad something developing in the neighborhood. My most concern is What is your actually target? Yes, school is nearby but mostly are still residential. $13 for ice cream is seem not reasonable for kids. If you are in North side maybe it will be ok but, on this street, LOL. Open in the afternoon? I went in and wanted to support a local business, but the price and the service isn't like I expected. To the owner, are you just investing and didn't concern or pay attention on your staff? the staff isn't care about customers; she just works day by day. My suggestion, yes, this street might be a commercial area in the future but if you want to expand and make better place you must have a restroom for your customers. What kind of restaurant or cafe that has customer dine in and no restroom for them. It is turn off. That is my suggestion for your future development if you are still here.

Popped in after dinner in the area. The place is small but the people behind the counter were…read morewelcoming and friendly. There weren't a ton of options but what we tried was tasty (stracciatella and cookies & cream). Worth the try if you're in the area.

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

18 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Susan R.

125

111

0

2 years ago

As someone who's always on the lookout for the next sweet indulgence, Gelateria Gentile has quickly become my ultimate dessert destination. Every time I visit, I'm treated to the most velvety, creamy gelato that's bursting with flavor in every bite. On my last visit, I tried the salted caramel gelato, and it was absolute perfection--rich, smooth, and just the right balance of sweet and salty. It's definitely one of my new favorites! But what truly sets this place apart isn't just the amazing desserts; it's the warmth and hospitality of the staff. Every time I come in, they greet me with a smile and are always eager to offer suggestions based on what I might like. It's clear they take great pride in their work and genuinely care about providing a great experience for their customers. They've even recommended some amazing seasonal flavors I wouldn't have tried otherwise, and I'm so glad I listened! I also love to pair my gelato with a comforting cup of tea, which perfectly complements the rich flavors of the dessert. Whether I'm in the mood for a refreshing iced tea or a soothing hot brew, the tea selection never disappoints. Gelateria Gentile is truly a spot where you can relax, enjoy fantastic treats, and feel like part of the family. It's become my go-to for whenever I need a little indulgence, and I'm already planning my next visit! read more

Lina L.

95

636

1641

2 years ago

If you're ready to be daunted by a menu that could double as a French vocabulary test, then Gelateria Gentile is a must-visit. Walking in, we were instantly overwhelmed by the fancy French names for the gelato flavors. Thankfully, the ever-helpful staff pointed out a translation guide at the front, decoding the mysterious French terms into plain English. Crisis averted! The staff here are incredibly friendly and patient, letting us sample various flavors to find our perfect match. I ended up with a scoop of yogurt and orange gelato paired with limone gelato. Surprisingly, these two worked like a charm together. The yogurt and orange gelato boasted a creamy consistency, while the limone was delightfully icy. The yogurt and orange gelato was exceptional! The tartness hit the spot and made it a true standout. The limone gelato was also tart and refreshingly sour, perfect for those hot summer days when you need a zesty kick. Gelateria Gentile offers not just a gelato, but an experience. The friendly staff and their willingness to let you sample until you find your match is top-notch. Will be back. read more

Anthony T.

70

32

0

2 years ago

Although Gelateria Gentile's West Village location may be small in size, it more than makes up for it with its undeniable charm. The cozy and intimate setting enhances the authenticity of the experience, making every visit feel warm and inviting. From the moment you step inside, you're transported to a little corner of Italy, where the focus is on high-quality gelato and traditional craftsmanship. Whether you're stopping by for a quick treat or lingering over a cup of coffee, the welcoming atmosphere ensures that each visit feels like a special occasion. read more

Stephanie Q.

1

15

3 years ago

Such a cute shop! They have so many different flavors and it tastes great! I went with my family and friends and they all loved it. It felt like I was in Italy again. We were supposed to go to another ice cream shop but it was a bit of a far walk from the restaurant we were previously at so we ran into this gelato shop gem and we are so glad we did! They serve them with a cone which makes them so aesthetically cute for an instagram pic. They also have some seats where you can hang out and enjoy your gelato. read more

Gunther K.

278

51

385

2 years ago

Gelateria Gentile in Williamsburg is a gem for gelato lovers. I ordered an affogato, and it was superb. The gelato was rich and creamy, with a deep, authentic flavor that paired perfectly with the bold espresso. The atmosphere is cozy and inviting, making it a great spot to enjoy a sweet treat. The staff is friendly and efficient, ensuring a pleasant visit. Whether you're a local or just visiting, Gelateria Gentile is a must-visit for an indulgent and delicious dessert experience. read more

Yonathan L.

13

24

0

5 years ago

Gelateria Gentile has some of the most delicious Gelato I've ever had. You can get yours in a couple different size cones or a cup. They do granitas, frappes, etc. Back to the gelato, they have a lot of different flavors. I've had the banana (great), chocolate (even better), peanut, coconut, etc.... The lists of flavors is very long. Staffing here is friendly. Sometimes they get very crowded, but the line moves pretty quickly. read more

telco h.

0

137

9

4 years ago

It's not that good. The decor is fine, the staff are fine, every time (twice) we go in there, b/c Amareno is not open yet, the gelato is just not good. Apple and lemon taste chemically. The standout failure is the banana. It is literally a sugar bomb, sugary to the point where it is impossible to eat. It's not a one star or a rage review, it's just that they are simply not as good as their competition. read more

Hirohisa T.

0

30

2

2 years ago

I didn't really like the iced coffee so much. I also noticed on their listing online they still have that outdated gender neutral bathroom nonsense. I guess this place didn't get the memo. People are tired of seeing this nonsense. It's made up and not real. Just put restrooms - like everyone else always did. Newsflash... read more

Soren V.

0

3

3 months ago

I must give it to Gentile, this was one of the best ice cream I ever had in my life!! If you're walking at night in UWS I recommend to not sleep on this spot. Perfect to have a nice dessert after dinner and perfect in the summer weather. I had the almond ice cream and it was delicious! read more

Roman M.

31

12

11

6 years ago

By far my favorite gelato shop. I've been driving to the one in studio city for over a year because I don't know any other place that serves truly authentic gelato. I am so excited to finally have them open a shop closer to home. Amazing staff, amazing dessert, just the best. read more

Cystal C.

0

4

0

8 years ago

This is simply the best gelato in the US! They have three locations -- two in Italy, and now one in Williamsburg. I am so jealous that I don't live in Brooklyn, but it gives me reason to plan my next trip! read more

Stephanie G.

0

28

2

4 years ago

Completely delicious, amazing gelato AND they have several non dairy options. I had apricot and chocolate--both non dairy, and was in heaven. This place is worth a trip and the possibly long line. read more

Taleea M.

0

2

4

5 years ago

The place was so nice and they had good ice cream and l like there music and they had nice seating also and l rate them 10/10 stars read more

Thomas M.

0

11

0

8 years ago

Everyone suggested me this new ice cream place in Williamsburg. Totally agree, amazing!! Chocolate is delicious. read more

Harpreet S.

0

15

0

2 years ago

The taste is okay but not the best service. I like the ice cream. Ice cream is good! The rest to Ignore. read more

Riley M.

0

5

0

4 years ago

Life changingly good - staff was great, and the banana was fantastic!! highly recommend!

Lauren P.

11

3

0

10 years ago

Fabio! Where have you gone? We miss your gelato so much!!!!! And Summer's coming.....

John C.

5

119

2

11 years ago

Best gelato in all of New York, nothing even comes close.

Gelateria Gentile - coffee - Updated September 2026

People who viewed Gelateria Gentile also viewed

Figo Il Gelato Italiano

4.8

(16 reviews)

super yummy gelato and perfect for a warm day! I got the dubai chocolate and anissa flavors and…read morethey were super duper yummy! The gelato is super smooth and fresh and the customer service was great. The interior was clean and spacious, with lots of seating. There is also a good amount of seating outdoors. I will say this is on the pricier side, at $9.50 for a regular cup. It did hit the spot though.

On a warm spring day after McCarren Park it's a must!…read more I love the ferrero rocher and the mimosa sorbet is actually made with some Prosecco! This place definitely blends in with the neighborhood vibes and people watching is great here!

Serendipity BK

4.8

(63 reviews)

•$

I went to this gelato spot a while back with a group on one of my many walks. The place is small,…read moreand there were a couple of people inside sipping coffee and enjoying their gelato. As I'm really in that part of Brooklyn, I decided to get the medium size, which is up to two flavors, and it was $7.95 plus tax. My flavors of choice were the saffron and the pistachio, as it has been a while since I have had that combination. In general, the gelato is of good quality, being soft but not too much, and it wasn't overly sweet. The pistachio on top was good with some pieces inside for a bit of crunch, though I would say in terms of other fancy gelatos, it's a bit worse than Venchi, as the pistachio flavor isn't as strong. The saffron was the better of the two, being floral enough without being overbearing. Not much else to say here, as I only had those flavors, but I hope they do well.

We were looking for a lighter option for dessert after lunch at Peter Luger and this did not…read moredisappoint. The pistachio and hazelnut gelatos were creamy and flavorful and they make it right on-site. Everyone was really nice and it was a super cute place to come grab a sweet treat or a coffee. Would definitely return.

Bertoni Gelato

4.8

(19 reviews)

walked in on a whim and discovered possibly the best gelato in brooklyn!…read more so many flavors and the staff are happy to help you with samples. bertoni even has a yogurt flavor which i typically only find in europe! it is perfectly tart. definitely a new go to in the neighborhood.

This is, to my knowledge, the first location in the US outside of Miami for this Argentine…read moregelateria chain. It's in a quaint little area of Williamsburg, right near Domino Park, and I presume they'll do well when the weather is warm. There was a nice person working here when I stopped by, and the space inside is nice. Along with gelato, they also sell a handful of mostly Italian pastries and a selection of coffee and teas. They offer many samples, though presumably fewer once they get big lines. I tried a handful of flavors, and my preferences, in order, were: Dulce de leche, hazelnut, passion fruit, and pistachio. I liked them all, but the dulce de leche was particularly outstanding, with pieces of chocolate caramel inside and enough salt to tone down the sweetness. In terms of more traditional flavors, the hazelnut was better than the pistachio, though both were nice. I usually prefer pistachio, but I liked the hazelnut's roasted flavor more here, with pistachio being stronger at other gelato places, including the fancier chains Gentile, Venchi, and a few other smaller places like Pamina. The passion fruit had a good balance of sour and sweet. In general, the gelato had a very nice, creamy texture, with only a slight preference for the outstanding Rivareno in Tribeca and Gentile, but both spots offer much smaller portions at similar prices. I eventually got a medium-sized cup, which comes with two choices for $8.50. There is also a large option with 3 flavors for $9.50, and it was a very decent portion size. The medium size was also packed, and I think they should add a small (or call it a kids' size) for a bit less. You can see the previous paragraph regarding both flavors (I got the dulce and hazelnut) and gelato textures. I slightly prefer other places for flavor, but this place strikes the right balance between portion sizes and overall quality. Would recommend.

OddFellows Ice Cream - Domino Park

4.0

(55 reviews)

I had the blueberry lime or something like that and it was perfect balance of sweet and zesty…read more Small shack but was fast

Pros: convenient location, right in the dumbo area, you can pick up ice cream and just bring it…read moreover to the park by the water. They also have a decent variety of flavors, we got the strawberry cheesecake and key lime pie. The ice cream was creamy! Cons: the waffle cone was soggy The pricing is kind of sneaky. The double was $9.64. Then the tipping options were 20%, 25%, 28%! On ice cream we order at the counter and then pick up!! That's kinda wild! The tables were also not clean enough for us to sit on. So I would say this place is a hit or miss.

Patisserie Tomoko

4.4

(477 reviews)

place is pretty happening…read more 5 stars because their pastries were pretty decent. ordered over $100 worth of treats and drinks because I needed to attend and bring it all to a dinner. front person still gave me an attitude- not sure why. it could be one off because another staff member seemed friendly to others. This review will reflect only the baked goods, and atmosphere. (sometimes people are having a bad day, who knows.) Decor was very nice, Saturday was pretty busy. I will come back and maybe find someone else to help me instead.

Had this place bookmarked for a long time and I finally tried it last weekend. I came here on a…read moreSunday at around 2 with my husband. The counter was emptied when we first came but it filled up pretty quickly. We just got a matcha latte and one prix fixe menu to share. For the main dessert, we picked the chocolate and hojicha soufflé. The chocolate soufflé was light and airy and not too sweet. It paired very well with the hojicha ice cream and caramel apple on the side. Overall, all the dessert was pretty good but everything was very small and I don't think it tasted that good that it worth $30. The service was also not that great. My husband and I were a little confused when we first got into the store and we weren't sure if we needed to be seated. A lady that worked there saw us but never greeted us nor gave us water until we asked. It took a while for someone to acknowledge us and it just made us felt a little uncomfortable.

Martha's Country Bakery

4.2

(1.2k reviews)