Best pizza in town hands down. I order a personal Buffalo chicken pizza- NEVER disappoints. Fries are pretty good. I hope this place expands to full service dining one day. Definitely a gem. read more

See all

I like their thin pizza but EXPENSIVE when you are charged 'technology fee' of more than 4% for paying by credit card! What pizzeria charges for using credit card??? This place does! Not worth the trip .... read more

Great brick oven pizza in a strip mall but high prices at $25-30 for a 16 inch pie. Lots of different variations and toppings.

Second visit to this spot. Was underwhelmed with their level of service today. Came in at 6:45 on a Sunday for a fresh pie, salad and calamari. Was told that they close at 7pm. However heard another attendant answer a call and told them that their order would be over an hour to be delivered. I then asked him what time the restaurant closes and he responds 8pm. I then said the other guy said 7pm. He then says "oh we stop seating at 7pm but we stay open for deliveries." I kinda found that odd. Furthermore the attendant was very unapologetic about the misinformation. Sucks because they are literally around the corner from me. Hopefully tonight's food that I ordered from them will be worth the lack of service. read more

Outstanding pizza and more, superior quality. Terrific owner in James. Highly recommended !

Best Italian Cuisine in the area. With great prices. They have the absolute best canolas. read more

Genteel's Brick Oven Pizza is located in a tiny storefront inside a busy strip mall. The parking lot has a decent amount of spaces, but can be nearly full during peak hours. Inside the restaurant, there are a few tables to sit and eat at, as well as a long wooden ledge you can sit at if you're getting slices. It's a small, but cozy restaurant. The pizza was pretty average. The base and crust were a bit dry and slightly overcooked. Sauce and cheese were okay, but nothing to brag about. The sausage slice was also generic and featured an uneven distribution of the topping. Overall, there are better places to go in the area for quality pizza, but if you're hungry and in need of a quick bite, this establishment will do. read more

Genteel's Trattoria Pizzeria - Italian Near Me - Skillman, New Jersey

Went there tonight, first time, party of 4, we sat inside. Food was excellent! I had the works pizza and an amazing spinach salad! Best Italian I've had in Montgomery! Definitely try it out! read more

Oh my God I cannot tell you how much I love the tomato soup here. I love it so so much. Everyone is so nice here and it's just a nice small intimate restaurant. read more

I consider this the best of the normal take out pizza in Princeton. Better than Conte's, better than Alfonso's for sure. You could probably do better at a couple sit downs, but it's better than most. The folks are usually busy but always take care of my order quickly. I have eaten inside also, and they are really nice to my kids. read more

Read from some fellow Yelpers that this place serves good and large Italian dishes and decided to try it. Mind you it's not nana's home cooking but it's a good sit down and enjoy place. The pasta dishes were tasty (portions were huge). Ordered a chicken Parmesan and the sauce was very good. Unlike some restos, they actually use tomatoes and not too much tomato paste (which gives me heartburn). Also, got a white pizza and it was nice and chewy and not too thin and oily like some other places. Service was great and prompt throughout (thanks Michelle!). The nice owner James even came by and chatted and asked about the food which is always appreciated ! They will be moving 2 stores away in a few weeks which will have a wood burning oven. I will definitely come back. Don 't forget it's BYOB! read more

My kid tried a slice of Genteel's pizza from a school event where each family could take a whole pizza home and liked it so much, we ordered it for a party at home and there were very few leftovers. They were punctual on the order, gracious with the cheese and pepperoni's. Will definitely keep ordering from there. read more

First time I give a 1star review ever. I called Genteel at 7:10 pm and ordered 1 large pizza. The man on the phone asked me to spell my address in Princeton, two times, and then he told me the price and took my credit card numbers. He said the pizza will be delivered in 45 minutes. One hour 15 minutes later (!) the driver calls me and asks for the address again... Right after that, the restaurant manager calls me and starts yelling at me (!) saying that they don't deliver that far (how should I know?). 20 minutes later (!) the driver arrives finally. Of course the pizza is cold, but that was normal. What's not normal, was the quality of that quatro fromagi pizza. Tasteless cheese (of course no blue cheese) and gummy crust. Very disappointed by quality and service. read more

Ok, so mom was in town and paying but boy this place was delish! It's not too expensive, but it is SUPER tasty. We had the bruschetta to start with which was super unique in that it had apples and butternut squash on top - whaaaaat! Entrees were delish as well. :-) We made a reservation 1-2 days ahead of time and we walked right in even though they were turning away other people who were just stepping off of the Square. Would go back! read more

Let's face it all the pizza places in the area suck. I have been craving a good place and upon reading reviews of this being one of the better places in the area I stopped in on my lunch break. Granted I don't get a lot of time I walked in expecting to see a big variety and saw that they only had about four different types of pizza. So disappointing I walked out, as nothing caught my eye. What a waste of my lunch break again I am left looking for a good pizza place read more

Great thin crust pizza! My parents are super picky but they really liked it. Will be our go to pizza spot in Montgomery from now on :) discount for paying in cash for orders above a certain amount read more

Best pizza that I have eaten. We been coming here every week for about a year. We love this little spot, good customer service, friendly environment, and delicious pizza. We have also met some nice customers overtime. Because we kept seeing the same customers over and over each week that we were there. They have always been nice to my wife and my child. read more

Ordered a soup for take out - it was obvious with the wait time that the soup of the day was not ready. The soup was a thin liquid, and tasted as if they added milk to a marinara sauce - simply horrible. So I paid over $5 for soup that was thrown away. Wish I could give negative stars. read more

Went tonight unexpectedly when the restaurant we drove into Princeton to had an outrageous wait. We were a table of seven, and they could seat us right away, so we decided to give it a try. We had teenage boys with us, and they ordered "personal" size pizzas, as did my husband. My parents and I ordered pasta dishes. When our waiter brought out our order, he told us that the kitchen had mistakenly omitted our younger son's order, so his pizza would be another 5 minutes or so, and he apologized profusely and told us they already took it off the bill. He was incredibly nice about it, and in all honesty we had PLENTY of food to keep everyone happy while our son waited. The "personal" pizzas were huge! The pasta dishes were all very good as well. All of the food was very enjoyable. As we finished up, the waiter came back to let us know that the cook had made us a complimentary order of Zeppolis to further apologize for the delay in our son's pizza order! I don't know that anything could have made my son happier - they are his favorite carnival food (and mine!) I don't give a lot of 5-star reviews on Yelp, but I was so impressed by the service here. Our experience was very nice, and I definitely hope to go back. read more

Decent enough. Nothing to rave about but I will go back out of convenience. Pizza had a decent sauce. Penne vodka was also decent.

The place is quick for pizza delivery and there pizza are delicious. Plenty of choices of pizza and toppings. To dine, there are not a lot of space to sit. When i got there no one was here yet, so we were served quickly. They give us a free appetizer and my course was delicious. The menu has good and fresh variety of dishes. Would go there again. read more

Genteel's Trattoria Pizzeria - Free garlic bread and tomato sauce appetizer. - Italian Near Me - Skillman, New Jersey

See all

Standard italian fare done well. Huge portions, very inexpensive (too much so) and the owner is just a nice guy. Too nice IMHO and he needs to select and manage his staff better. They remodeled and it looks great. As far as pizza/pasta goes this place is on point. The owner can cook and he cares about his food. It shows. I do think the restaurant needs to be managed better. The food and decor is nice and I go cause its tasty, but I also like supporting that establishment, this has not tainted my review though. Once they get the operational aspects down I think the place has great potential. read more

Our office likes having pizza parties and we were disappointed with our selections in the area, until we found this place. Great food, great service! read more

This place has really good food. We had their pizza first, margarita. The ingredients are good, the sauce is perfect, not sweet nor bitter. The crust is nice bc it has a unique crispness that really makes the texture perfect with a bit of crunch and chew. We'had their white pizza that is also really delicious and recently tried a pasta dish, linguini with sun-dried tomatoes and spinach in a light alfredo. The pasta was cooked perfect, the sauce was tastey and wasn't overly heavy. A nice place to have in Montgomery. read more

Genteel's Trattoria Pizzeria - Linguini with sun dried tomatoes and spinach in light alfredo sauce - Italian Near Me - Skillman, New Jersey

See all

Really like this place! Came here for lunch the other day. The staff is very friendly and the portions are big and reasonably priced. This place is very nice on the inside. The decor looks very new. I ordered the spinach salad and it was a little over $6. I wasn't expecting such a huge portion. Spinach leaves, crispy bacon, eggs, generous helpings of tomato, and huge slices of mozzarella cheese, all topped in a delicious vinaigrette dressing. Probably one of the best salads I ever had to be completely honest. Anyway, I hear the pizza is good, so I will have to cone back and try a slice. read more

SURPRISE: They are OPEN on SUNDAY. We took a chance today on a small margherita and loved it! Plenty big for 2 folks. Really nice crust- not too thin and not too thick but quite tasty. Sauce and cheese were great- gooey and a bit oily in the best possible way. We are still "sheltering" so the nice people were accommodating and popped pizza in our truck. We will definitely go back for more. read more

Fantastic pizza, friendly staff and always consistent. I really appreciate the fact that I when I order take out and bring a few pies home, the pies stay intact, meaning they use just right amount of cheese and sauce so that pie does not come as a sloppy mess. Highly recommend this place if you are in Montgomery/Skillman area. Last night I ordered two pies, one large and one small, and when I got there the kind woman who was working the register told me that they had mistakenly made two larges but would charge me for the sizes I had ordered. Very cool of them and a total win for me, as I now have extra pizza for the days ahead : ) read more

Stopped in for take out. Salads served with minimal dressing on the side, no plastic utensils added. Minimal meaning less than 1 and 1/2 tablespoons of oil and vinegar. They were however fresh. Slices of pizza were room temperature and we ate them within 2 minutes of walking out the door. Dining area appeared very clean. read more

Really good food, just be prepared to be patient! Delivery took over an hour- even though I was told 40 minutes. We did dine-in as well and had a similar experience- really good food, it just takes a while. read more

Always fresh ingredients and made with care. We have been going to Genteel's for many years. Our family really likes their brick oven pizzas! Our favorite pizza in town. read more

I have been wanting to try this place for a while now. Tonight me and my husband are glad we went. I had the eggplant rollitini and it was amazing. Very fresh ingredients good portion as well. Im very picky about my Italian food and definitely was very happy. I also got the Caesar salad that came with my meal and it was by far one of the best i have had to date. The romaine lettuce was so fresh and super crisp. Definitely will be going here again . The prices were good especially for the decent size portions. Cant wait to try the pizza. read more

We've been here 5 times with family in tow. Consistently good pasta. The bolognese sauce is one of the best I have ever tried. BYO

We went to this place, a mile down the road, because they had a restaurant.com certificate. While it looks like a basic pizza parlor from outside, it has a nice restaurant and the decor in similar to something you would see in the city, older building decorated with an old world charm - really sweet. It is a byob, which is a plus sometimes. Being someone who cooks well and often, I am usually a critic. I ordered egglplant rollantini and it was excellent. It was cooked homestyle, and the ricotta was fresh ricotta, almost unheard even in the 'top' restaurants in the Princeton/Montgomery area; I knkow the tast immediately. The filling also had spinach - not frozen but fresh baby spinach. The sause was a delicious tomator based marinara. My fiance had scallops with risotto and vegetables. We both eat healthy and always fresh ingredients - that said, he was very impressed with the preparation and flavor of his food. We will definitely try here again. Truly a great casual place with a 'real' family cooking the food. You can tell by the preparation and taste. read more

Stopped in on a whim one evening and was pleasantly surprised. We ordered a pizza and a chicken entree and both were very good with plenty of fresh ingredients. Perhaps most notable was the friendly, accommodating service - a big notch above many area pizza places. It's a BYOB, and don't be shy about asking for a shaker of oregano, etc. be brought to the table if you'd prefer a bit more flavor. read more

The 2 slice and soda deal is a great bargain. Pizza was decent but the crust a bit too thick for me but ok and the sauce and cheese were very good. My wife got some spaghetti and meatballs to go. There was no salad or even bread with it which was kind of disappointing, especially Italian bread. The portion size was rather small compared to other places. The sauce was more like a paste and did not have much flavor to it and although they provided 4 half meatballs they had a bit too much salt. But the price was fair but I'd rather pay more for a larger portion. Overall nice place, staff is great. read more

Awesome meatball parm sandwich, don't miss out on it. I asked Jimmy what he suggested and he delivered. We also sat down to eat and it was very comfortable. read more

Great pizza and side dishes with excellent service I recommend this to all people who like pizza and good service!!

We ordered Genteel's pizza in bulk for our kids birthday party because our Church orders from them and it was always good. They gave a very good discount for the large order we placed and were extremely accommodating. I would recommend them if you want an easy party menu with no hassle. :) read more

Pizza was good just ask for it well done. The wings were the smallest wings I have ever seen. Overall not a bad place to grab a pie and they deliver which is rare in this area. Whenever I am in Princeton this is where I order my pizza from. As far as the wings go they were good just extremely tiny it was almost like a joke how small they were. read more

I've been to Genteels a few times since Rudolfo's changed hands. The thin crust pie has been dependable. Friendly and attentive staff. Looking forward to trying out the menu. read more