It is a brave thing to try and sell pizza in Hamilton when Papa's and DeLorenzo's are practically within shouting distance. That is like opening a lemonade stand between two Niagara Falls. And yet Nonno Sal's keeps the ovens hot and the lights on. There's something admirable about that. Persistence is a virtue, and so is knowing exactly what you are. Nonno Sal's isn't chasing the high end pizza pilgrim. You won't find philosophical arguments about char or hydration levels happening here. What you will find is a fairly dependable pie with thin crust that holds up, a good layer of cheese, and sauce that tastes like someone has been making it the same way for awhile. The slices fold without complaint and the toppings behave themselves. It's the sort of pizza you bring home on a Friday when everyone is tired and nobody wants to cook or a speech. The prices are kinder to your wallet than the famous spots nearby, and that matters. Not every meal needs to be a religious experience. Sometimes food just needs to feed five people without causing regret. The sandwiches and salads are solid citizens too. Nothing showy, just competent and filling. They even still do a nice version of Peppers and Eggs, which is a throwback I can appreciate. The dining area has a few old Formica tables that look like they have seen a few Little League celebrations, but not much regular use. You can eat there if you like, but this is a takeout joint through and through. In a world that rewards spectacle, Nonno Sal's rewards appetite and respects your budget. It knows its job and does it. That's more than can be said for most things anymore. Four stars for staying in your lane and driving it well. read more

Nonno Sal's Pizza - Small dining area - Italian Near Me - Trenton, New Jersey

Located in a small strip mall shop on Route 33 near the border of Robbinsville and Hamilton is Nonno Sal's Pizza. It's one of those places that can be easily missed if you're not looking for it, as there is no signage along the road to indicate a pizza place (not one that I could see having passed by many times over the years). Italian eateries and pizza parlors are a dime a dozen in the area, however this one is mainly suited for take out, with a few tables off to the side to eat a slice or have a quick no frills lunch. It's definitely not a fancy place you'd want to dine in at, despite having a full menu of pizza and Italian dishes. We kept things simple by ordering a large plain cheese pizza and a chicken parmigiana sandwich. The pizza was slightly above average for a central NJ pizzeria, with decent sauce, cheese, and crust. It was a slightly thinner base and crust as compared to more doughy and thicker counterparts in the area. The chicken parm sandwich was similarly above average with decent ingredients. Everything was satisfying and on par for a good central NJ pizza experience. I'd rate my overall experience a solid 3.5/5, but happy to round up since the person working the counter was kind and thanked me when I went to pick up. read more

See all

We ordered pizza for pick up and really did not like it. It was flavorless. We came in person another time and the pizza at the front where you could get slices just looked so old like they have been sitting there for a while that we just left. read more

Solid plain pizza. I really liked the sauce. It had a good amount of sweetness to it. By the time we got the pizza to eat, it was a little cold. And we weren't in a place to be able to reheat it. Would love to try again with a nice hot pizza. read more

Nonno Sal's Pizza - margherita pizza - Italian Near Me - Trenton, New Jersey

Got dinner from here today and really liked it! I ordered some buffalo wings and tacked on a slice of cheese pizza when I picked up my order because I wanted to get a more complete survey of the food. One of my only complaints is that they took ~15 minutes longer than expected to prepare my order, so I was standing around bored for a while once I arrived at the restaurant. That being said, the cashier was apologetic, and it's always nice to get fresh, hot food, so I can't complain too much :) The pizza was OK, but nowhere close to the quality of some of the other pizza places in Robbinsville. The buffalo wings, though, were delicious, and I was really impressed by the price point. I can definitely see myself coming back here when I have a craving for some wings! read more

New favorite pizza place in the area - the kids insist we order from here only. The Brooklyn is a pizza of our dreams - buttery fresh mozzarella, bright basil and amazing sauce. The regular pizza is also a hit - sauce to cheese ratio perfect, with emphasis on cheese. Love to order from here and makes our nights in quarantine a little more special when we have the delicious hot pizza from here. read more

The facility is surprisingly dirty. I ate here on a Sunday morning because there were no other options and I was under a time constraint. Decent chicken parm sandwich but I would not return because of the filth. read more

Nonno Sal's Pizza - a restaurant counter - Italian Near Me - Trenton, New Jersey

Small place in a strip mall. Not much to look at. But the pizza is excellent and expect a wait. One of the best in the area and that's saying a lot. read more

My go to place for good pizza. I love the Sicilian. Order from them several times a month and have never had a bad experience.

We just moved here and struggled to find good pizza until we found Nonno Sal's! Since then we have tried so many different items on the menu and every one of them is made just like my grandmother's! Same sauce we've passed down for many generations. Literally the only place I will eat pasta and sauce and it's perfect! Always very busy but all good places are! read more

HORRIBLE FOOD. SO disgusted with my experience with both this establishment AND SLICE. $50 order, vodka rigatoni pizza with sausage and ricotta, Italian "hoagie" and two orders of calamari. Asked for pepperoni on the hoagie. Got THREE PIECES of pepperoni, barely any meat and a roll that was as stale and as hard as a rock. Completely inedible. Literally threw away the entire hoagie. For that three pieces of pepperoni I was charged an additional $10, bringing my total to $60. The sandwich itself is $7. The pizza. NO RICOTTA. Bland "vodka" sauce. Nothing more than macaroni and bread with barely any sausage, even though I ordered AND PAID for DOUBLE sausage. Calamari was like rubber. Soggy and chewy all at once. NEVER AGAIN. Made the mistake of ordering through Slice instead of Grubhub. Once more, NEVER AGAIN. Their response to my complaints? A $4 credit to the restaurant. Seriously????? The extra charge for an inedible hoagie was more than the credit for a sandwich we couldn't eat, credit for a restaurant we will NEVER order from again. USELESS. HORRIBLE EXPERIENCE STAY AWAY FROM BOTH NONNA SAL'S AND SLICE. You're welcome. read more

Nonno Sal's Pizza - Inedible hoagie. DISGUSTING, rock hard bread barely any meat. - Italian Near Me - Trenton, New Jersey

See all

Nonno Sal's is a tiny pizza shop on Rt. 33, with three tables and a large counter. It is basically a take out place, but I like to eat my pizza hot, so I grabbed the back table under the TV and ordered two plain slices to test the waters. The joint is a bit unkempt and has the feel of a place that needs some TLC. The pizza is average for the area - firm crust, adequate sauce/cheese ratio, but has an oil drip out the back end of a folded slice. Can't speak to anything else on the menu as my first test is always the slice deuce to see how much attention is paid to the primary product. Not enough, I'm afraid; so I doubt I'll be back to try anything else. read more

Nonno Sal's Pizza - Italian Near Me - Trenton, New Jersey

See all

This pizza place is delicious! We have ordered from here several times and good experience each time. A lot of the pizza places in the area have shortened their hours or reduced the number of days they are open, this restaurant is hanging in there. In a neighborhood with tons of pizza places this one definitely sets itself apart. read more

The have the absolute best Brooklyn pie!! This is now my go to pizza place. The tomatoes are sweet and the fresh mozzarella is delicious. I highly recommend this Nonno Sals!! read more

Excellent pizza and excellent service. We asked for thin crust and lightly cooked on the bottom and got exactly what we asked for!

Never Disappoints!! Have never stepped inside the actual restaurant, we always get delivery, but every time, they do not disappoint. Prices are great, portions are huge and it's always good food. We have tried everything from apps to salads to sandwiches to pasta dishes and everything is always hot, fresh and really good. Highly recommend Nonno Sal's for your date nights in! read more

Great job as usual Nonna Sals! You guys always deliver! Food was great and thanks for being open!! We usually get dinners and they are great but we got cheese steaks and they were great, too! Thanks for all you do! read more

Nonno Sals is wonderful, flavorful Italian food and pizza. Affordable and gracious portions. Their meatballs are tender and delicious.

Excellent Chicken Parm dinner , especially for only $12. Comes over pasta with a freshly made side salad (or soup). Great taste !!

Great take out meals and very reasonable! Recommendations the egg plant parmesan dinner and the NONNO SALS special chicken.

Love the food here! They are located two doors down from where my partner works and we are there a couple times a day during his shifts. They have great salads, the wraps are excellent and the pasta and sauces are always delicious! We are always buying a couple of slices at a time each day. Always a great selection for walk ins. We have never gotten delivery because we are always there and they are on my way home from work, but they say they will deliver to Hamilton near the Kmart. So one of these days I will finally take advantage of that! If you are looking for a new pizza place you have to try Nonno Sals! You won't be disappointed! read more

I cannot say enough good things. I order delivery regularly. The food arrives within the promised timeframe and it is hot. We primarily get the pizza which is far and away the best in the area. We have also had buffalo wings, mozzarella sticks, tiramisu, cheese steaks, among other menu items, none of which disappointed. When we do visit the physical location while not much to look at it is clean and the staff courteous and friendly. We will continue to indulge. read more

Nonno Sal's Pizza - Appetizer menu with all good things. - Italian Near Me - Trenton, New Jersey

I understand there are busy times but the Slice app said it was a 60 minute wait for delivery. After 20 mins I received an email stating 90 minutes but it took about 2 hours for my delivery to arrive. This is unacceptable for 2 pizzas, 1 salad & a 2 liter of soda. I called the restaurant to voice my concerns with the time after the 2hr mark hit and the person that answered said oh yeah we are busy. I understand that but 2 hours is awful & no one tried to make it right either. The food was delicious as always but after 2 hours anything would have tasted good. read more

Friendly staff, good pizza, and amazing wings! The place is small on the inside So Id recommend calling ahead or getting delivery. The prices are fair and the pizza is just as good as the local competition. While the pizza is good, I primarily stick to the wings. Hands down they have the best wings in the area! Great jumbo wings and a terrific sauce. read more

If I could give no stars I would just because of my gross experience. I went in just to grab a slice while on errands. After they pulled it out she pulled the slice off my plate and put it on a clean plate with her bare hands. Then I asked her for a new slice that she didn't touch with her hands. She dumped the slice that she had her grubby hands all over back on the tray for someone else to eat. At that point I asked for my money back and told her that I just cannot eat food that she uses her bare hands on. She looked at me like I had 3 heads. Beware! read more

This is our Pizza Friday go to. Great pizza, and good sides and snacks. Delivery is always on time and love being able to order online!!

I love Nonna Sals! The staff are great guys, the pizza is excellent, the fried mushrooms are cooked perfect, the cheese fries are smothered in cheese sauce unlike other places where the cheese Is barely existent and the California burgers are on point. I eat here at least 3 times a week for the past 2 years and have never been disappointed! read more

This is my favorite pizza in hamilton so far. Nonna Sal special pizza is delicious. Think crust long Sicilian

It's going to be a major no for me. Ordered food tonight along with the rest of my co workers. I got the fettuccine Alfredo with s side salad. The salad was okay. The lettuce was a bit brown to me and my co workers. As far as the fettuccine goes it had to be the worst I've ever had. It was like I was eating just sauce and noodles. It had no season to it. No black pepper or garlic. I'm so mad at myself for even trying this place. Never again read more

I have ordered many pizzas and have never been disappointed. Love their meals too, fresh not precooked and reheated and you get plenty to share. Not an eat in place, unless it's a quick slice. read more

Great Pizza and Great Meals. We only use them for our take out. We have used a lot of places in Hamilton but this is our favorite. The broccoli pie is the best. read more

Our favorite Italian fast food place in the area! I'm Italian and recognize good Italian food. We had them cater several events and have gotten rave reviews! Their also very reasonable and provide ample servings. Their also honest about how much is needed according to party size. Very satisfied customers. read more

Keep the expectations in check. They have decent pizza, and deliver. I stick to the Sicilian pizza, and they have it at my house in 30 min. It's always consistent and cooked properly. If you are looking for high end Italian, you are in the wrong place. If you need to feed the family with some quick pizza or something, this is your place. read more

A health code nightmare! No one speaks english and seems to have just come from mexico where they have no idea what a health code is. With no gloves, handling a mop and then your food. I canceled my order and they couldnt comprehend or speak english as to why I would not want my food. And i get an attitude from the stocky guy. I am sure there are bonified american citizens that would love to have a job that knows this countries health codes. read more

Highly recommend the thin crusted Brooklyn Pie, there delivery is quick and hot! Great little Hamilton spot.

Excellent pizza, among the best in the Robbinsville area. Prices are reasonable too. Definitely worth a try.

This is one sad looking place. It is not inviting to eat a slice or 2 or even to wait for a pie. The pizza here is flavorless and not what you come to expect for the area. Plenty of great places in the area for a great slice...within a half mile from this place. read more

My office ordered today for the 1st time and let me just say the food was absolutely amazing!!!! Everything arrived fresh and warm being ready to eat!!!! Keep it up and my company will continue to order from you!! read more

food used to be really good! new owners now... chicken parm was frozen chicken... ok for fast food