I'd like to start this off by saying if you are looking for jewelry this is definitely the place to go. They have a great selection and the staff is great. That being said my experience with buying watches from them hasn't gone as well as other people that have left reviews. I spent $26,000 on an engagement ring and had a watch serviced with them for another $1,100 all within the same month. I asked to be put on the list for 2 Rolexes and I haven't gotten so much as a call in about a year and a half. Again this is a great store I would recommend them to anyone and everyone in the Staten Island area looking for jewelry I just didn't have the same watch buying experience as other people leaving reviews. read more

See all

gorgeous place, really nice people, excellent repair. i wish i could afford more of what they sell!!!

Prior to visiting Gerald Peters, I have visited countless Rolex ADs where essentially the same message was conveyed- Little to no inventory with a long waitlist for popular Rolex models. Hearing this was pretty disappointing for me as my husband is a watch enthusiast and is interested in growing his collection. However, my first experience at Gerald Peters has been exceptionally amazing and the customer service received was above and beyond their competitors. Samantha O is the epitome of a professional sales associate. She was very welcoming, had a wealth of knowledge on Rolex watches, transparent with expectations, and was GENUINELY eager to help me find the perfect watch as my anniversary gift to my husband. The very next day after my initial visit, she texted me with an available model that was very close to the preferred/ideal configurations. This prompt action proved that she kept me in mind and was sincerely trying to source the perfect watch as my husband's anniversary gift! She has won me over as a new client and I look forward to purchasing several watches and jewelries from her! Also, so happy that they're located in Staten Island and I look forward to building a long relationship with Gerald Peters! read more

Was actively shopping for a Mens Rolex watch, knowing that there is a waiting list for the watch I was placed on a list unfortunately I purchased the watch at a another dealer in New York. I called them to order a women's Rolex watch and waited a short period of time and was notified by Alana a sales representative that the watch arrived. It was a pleasure dealing with her and the staff. Definitely would recommend Alana and the attentive staff a Gerald Peters. read more

Let me begin by saying that you are not going find a place like Gerald Peters a family operated luxury store. It's such a hidden gem where I started buy Rolexes. I bought from watches of Switzland in the past but I was never treated with the amount of time and day the store owner and sales manager gave me, but that's not something you would experience with Gerald Peters. I bought from Richard, he wholeheartedly took the time and care to listen to my story and helped me buy my grail watch. I just wanted to take a few min to Thank them. read more

This is by far the best jewelry store on the island. Go to Ricky (Sales Manager) I buy everything I get directly from him. He knows the industry and will sit down with you and tell you every detail about your jewelry. I personally like Hearts on Fire for the unmatched sparkle and there is no one better then Ricky a "HOF Champion" at explaining what Hearts on Fire diamonds are and what their company does. I bought my wife's engagement ring and my wedding band "HOF" with zero regrets about it - beautiful, unmatched quality. This place is also a Authorized Rolex dealer with exhibition pieces along with other amazing brands in stock like Breitling and Tag. I've bought two beautiful watches so far, one of them being a Rolex with amazing customer care, with messages from Ricky and the owner. You're really a client when you shop here and I will continue to shop here confidently. read more

Gerald Peters - Rolex Submariner (Starbucks) - Jewelry Near Me - Staten Island, New York

Worst customer service I've ever had. Horrible selection definitely will not be going back

Thank you Peter for helping me achieve a huge milestone in my life with my first Rolex. The experience you provided will never be forgotten. Thank you for taking the time to show me everything and answer my questions. I haven't taken it off since Saturday! I look forward to my next milestone with you. P.S. the kids love the bags!!!! I can't thank you enough and I really don't understand how anyone can give you or anyone there anything less than 5 stars. read more

Gerald Peters - Rolex Air King - Jewelry Near Me - Staten Island, New York

BIG Family operated jewelry store which is the only official Rolex dealer on the island ‍..They are very friendly and courteous yet they don't have much of a selection on Rolexes. Either Rolex massively cut their production and are not distributing them amongst their dealers or they just don't want to stock them being that they can't be discounted. I tried to negotiate a fair Price on a new watch yet it never worked out.. they do have an abundance of nice jewelry there so check them out read more

Superb jeweler! Has been so helpful to me and my family. Prices are good and repair service is superb, even had my Mother-In-Law watch the repair of her engagement ring. Would not go anywhere else. read more

Bad customer service no smile no greeting no nothing!When we asked what's the best deal you could do on a Rolex Daytona the sales lady said no discount zero nada in an unpleasant tone acting like people can't afford it. Will rather buy elsewhere even if it cost more! To the store management (if you are reading this): Train your staffs better they need to learn how to smile at people, I'm not going to spend 18K at a place where I don't even feel welcome! There are plenty of Rolex ADs all over NYC (you guys are not the only one)! read more

GREAT EXPERIENCE! FAMILY OPERATED! I official found a jewelry store to make "ALL" my future purchases. Want to say thank you to Gerald Amerosi Jr (Vice President), Richard Wubnig (Director of Sales), and their team for the purchase of my Rolex! I have been looking for a Submariner for sometime and they made that dream come true and yes they are an authorized dealer for Rolex... I've been in Rolex stores all over New York and some in New Jersey that had your typical Date just, Day date, and etc. Gerald Peters had models I couldn't believe. Most importantly there staff go above and beyond and make the process seamless. They're craftsman of their trade and know what they're talking about! For those of you looking to make a purchase on Rolex brand alone do your home work. A lot of these models for Rolex are hard to come by now a days! Rolex sells it self and does not cater or drop the bar for penny pinchers. Expecting or asking for a discount at any authorized dealer on a Rolex like a chrono or sports models I feel is ridiculous! Be greatful if that dealer is able to get you the model your looking for! Gerald Peters is my go to dealer and very blessed for their customer service! Respectfully, Christopher J read more

I brought a diamond ring in to replace cracked and missing diamonds ! That being said I went to pick it up a week after I took it in to be repaired and I noticed that diamonds were still missing ! The owner said that he would take care of it and he apologized ! I was very patient and today I returned again to pick up my diamond ring(3 days later) !!!! Well the ring still had cracked diamonds and his reply to me was " we couldn't fix all the diamonds " excuse me ? When I left the rIng I asked that the ring be repaired in it's entirety! I didn't ask for the jeweler to fix the diamonds that he saw fit ! I was then told that the ring was old !!!! I received the ring 2 years ago from my husband. It was a 25th wedding anniversary present and it was purchased at B&A!!!! Old ???? The unprofessional attitude that I experienced today at Gerald Peters Jewelers was unprecedented! I will never bring anything to be repaired again and I wouldn't recommend them to anyone ! Go to Goff Jewelers or better yet go to the chinese guy by subway to repair your jewelry ... you'll get better service ! Thank you ! Missing B&A Jewelers !! read more

Donna was very helpful, she knew how to help us find what we were looking for. The store gives off a luxurious appearance and they seem to have an extensive variety. read more

Thanks to Richard helps me getting a blue datejust is a beautiful time piece and gave me good deal on a necklace, will come back for you Richard! read more

Great service, kind, and patient with customers unlike other jewelry shops in the area.

Always a great experience here! Alana and Carlene are extremely helpful and very knowledgeable.

I'm so in love with my engagement ring! My fiancé can't say enough great things about Gerald Peters and more so Ricky, who helped him with the whole process. After we got engaged, we stopped by the store and the staff ( not just Ricky who helped my fiancé ) started clapping and congratulating us! This is a great place and I can't wait to go pick out our wedding bands! read more

Anna is a wonderful sales consultant. We came in one day to browse for engagement rings, and she worked with my husband to find me a beautiful Hearts on Fire halo ring. I am constantly getting compliments on how well it sparkles. She is always friendly, and remembers us when we come in for other things. Really recommend this shop read more

They have a really nice selection of Alex & Ani bracelets and Pandora charms. All of the staff are beyond helpful and friendly. The store is very nicely kept and I appreciate the professionalism. read more

I went to Gerald Peters to purchase an engagement ring for my girlfriend at the time (now my fiancée). That's where I met Donna who was absolutely awesome. She was very helpful and patient with me because I was super nervous and quite clueless on this whole process. She explained everything to me from cut, clarity and color to shapes. Let me just say that Donna made this whole experience so perfect. Sometimes with purchases like this you look back and feel like you could have done better or that the person who helped you wasn't very helpful or seemed pushy. That is not the case at all here the entire staff was great and made this experience really easy and smooth. I will definately go back to purchase wedding bands there. Really great place. Thank you again Donna! read more

Great service and fantastic selection. It's great to walk into a store and not be "sold" on something, is even better. All the other stores I went into today were more interested in trying to force me to buy what they had instead of helping me find what I wanted. Goldmine's staff all took the time to try to help me find what I actually wanted. read more

I am so in love with my engagement ring & the entire staff is wonderful! My fiance can't say enough great things about them and how helpful they were during the buying process. They weren't pushy and really helped him through it all with ease. Gerald was a delight & showed me how to care for my ring and offered his assistance with recommending vendors if we choose to stay local. I can't wait to go back and get our wedding bands from them! We are now forever customers. I can't say enough wonderful things, go and see for yourself! read more

I knew that Gerald Peters was the place to go when I was ready to propose to my girlfriend. Anna and Gerald guided me through choosing the perfect setting and made sure that the final product came out exactly how I wanted it to. I picked up the ring on a Thursday night and couldn't even wait to pop the question, within a half hour my new fiancee was wearing her beautiful new ring. We are looking forward to going back to the store and picking out our bands. Thank you Gerald Peters for making this moment so specia! read more

I have dealt with this company for years. They are honest and very knowledgeable. They are more interested in developing long-term relationships with customers than in making immediate sales. read more

Just had the best shopping experience in a very long time at the Gerald Peters jewelry store in the Staten Island Mall! Having to buy many gifts at one time can be a very daunting experience. Working with Sandra, a lovely, knowledgeable, and patient sales associate made this an easy and pleasurable task. Not only did she find the perfect gifts but made some wonderful suggestions for additional items to complement them! She was so helpful that I know I will be back to this store again before the holiday season comes to a close! Thank you, Sandra! read more

Make sure to see Rick at Gerald Peters. His level of personal service and support is outstanding. Gerald Peters makes sure to treat you the way an expensive watch buyer expects to be treated. I've purchased a few Rolex's from Rick after visiting a few other Authorized Dealers that were rude and very impersonal. I highly recommend this store If you're considering purchasing a beautiful watch from people who care about your experience before and after the sale. read more

Would not buy a watch at any other store. I have purchased all of my watches at this store and can safely say that if your looking for an incredible selection and the best buyers experience see Richard. Every time your here it feels like your family and they make the entire shopping experience easy. I personally recommend them to all my friends and family as well. This is the place to go, don't hesitate. read more

My first review! The service in Gerald Peters today was so amazing that it motivated me to actually leave a review. Donna and Jerry were outstanding. I had a such terrible experience today at different jewelry store, not in the mall. I couldn't believe the lack of attention, care, and respect that I ended up walked out. I had to go to the mall to return a few things. I've been to Gerald Peters a few times before and everyone had been helpful. I figured I would go to them for a second opinion. Donna helped me right away. She listened to what happened to me earlier and said, We can help. She went to the back, and promptly returned. She confirmed that they could. Donna was fast, helpful, and polite. She brought me to the register and Jerry came out and shook my hand, looked me in eyes and said glad we can help. The whole experience was so freaking polite, respectful, efficient, and simple. Easy location, the lighting is amazing, displays are clean no finger prints or scratches. Friendly, knowledgeable staff. Most importantly, trustworthy! read more

GREAT jewelry store. Friendly staff. Knowledgeable. They get back to you in a timely manner. Ricky helped me pick out my engagement ring last September. I worked with him in a previous store years ago, so I know what he was all about. This guy is world-class. He knows his stuff. Anything about rings, or jewelry in general, he'll give you the answers. Ricky is the man! Highly recommended!!! read more

Forgot about my Anniversary was tomorrow so I rushed to the Mall to see that Gerald Peters moved upstairs across from Apple. Beautiful store. Julie patiently helped me pick out a bracelet. Here's my wife's text hours after receiving it. "Love, love, LOVE my bracelet!!! Thanks soooo much! What a surprise!!! xxx". Thanks Gerald Peters read more

First class jewelers! Dealing with Pete made my watch buying experience a great one. It was seamless. They are the most down to earth professionals and treat you with upmost respect. They will go the extra mile to make sure you are a satisfied customer. They have a huge selection of inventory and their prices are great. They have become my go to jeweler. read more

greeted by big guy infront with a smile and proceeded to be helped by saleswoman Cathy she was very friendly and helped me choose the right gift for my girl thx so much very professional and nice read more

I recently starting working in Staten Island and being from New Jersey I saw the billboards for GP quite often. Looking at how long they have been in the business and with their new location opening I figured to check them out for a purchase on an engagement ring. On my first visit I met Angela who walked me through the types of stones and settings and really helped me understand the ins and outs of diamond purchasing. After a few visits and research I noticed that GP's pricing was very competitive and the level of service was impeccable. Not once did I feel like I was just being sold to but that Angela really cared and wanted to make this experience memorable. The employees here are really like family and I even had the pleasure to meet others like Ricki and Gerald who really couldn't wait to hear my ideas around the proposal. In all with their help I created an amazing ring and my fiancé cannot stop staring at its beauty. Thank you Gerald Peters for making this first time experience super stress free and memorable! Sam R. read more

No matter what you need for any special occasion in your life, Gerald Peters Goldmine has a wide selection. The staff always help you find the perfect gift from watches, to rings, to Pandora charms, to Alex and Ani bracelets. Worth a visit ! read more

Today my husband and I went to pick out a wedding band for my 50th birthday. I went in to just take a look at what I really wanted because I was looking for something plain as I was replacing a band lost years ago. We were just shopping around and Anna came over to help. I am very picky about a ring being extremely comfortable as I am not big on wearing jewelry anymore. Every ring is more beautiful than the next and very nice quality so it wasn't an easy task. Anna was so patient and as I was trying to pick between two rings she grabbed one more and that was the ring for me. I love it and happy I took my time picking it out. Thank you Anna for being patient and finding the right one for me!! read more

Excellent service at Goldmine. Fantastic selection of engagement rings and wedding bands. The staff is extremely knowledgeable and can answer any of your questions without pressuring you to purchase anything. I recently met with Richard who taught me so much about engagement rings and diamonds when I previously knew nothing at all. My boyfriend knows now to go straight to him when he's finally ready! read more

Been two months since I've gotten engaged and I can't tell you how much I love my ring! I received so many compliments! Gerald Peters have the most wonderful jewelry and the staff are very nice people, not pushy at all. I recommend Gerald Peters for all your jewelry needs! read more

I can honestly say without any shed of doubt that in all my years as a customer, I have never been treated this well . This is the true meaning of customer service I have ever seen . I was given the utmost attention the minute my mother and I walked through the door . A difficult buy decision was made easy and I was given help and advice every step along the way until I picked the best ring for my future bride . While my ring was being made and the diamond set , I was called numerous times to update me on its progress. My salesperson even sent me pictures of the ring (by a professional photographer). I was told the only thing left was the engraving , my pickup date was confirmed and I came in . From start to finish it was flawless. Mr wubnig I want to say thank you for making a nerveracking process easy . Gerald Peter's has earned my future business , I wont go any where else period . read more