We had a wonderful experience at Gerardo's Pizzeria! Audrey was our server, and she was incredibly friendly, attentive, and made us feel truly welcome throughout our visit. Everything we ordered was absolutely delicious. The pizzas were great and full of flavor! We tried both types of pizza dough , the classic and the sourdough, and both were absolutely outstanding. The tiramisu was the perfect ending to the meal! It tasted homemade and was one of the best we've ever had. You can really tell there's a great team behind this restaurant. The atmosphere is warm, the service is excellent, and every detail makes you want to come back. We'll definitely be visiting again the next time we're in town. Highly recommended! read more

Gerardo's Pizzeria - Italian Near Me - Sedona, Arizona

See all

Owners there! Owners cooking! I was alone and welcomed like a guest at home. Home made pasta was excellent. Pizza delicious- smoky and cheesy without being too much. More traditional ingredients vs the clique hippy style place up the road (which I also like). I bet it's incredible on their patio. The dining room was busy and clean, well kept. Beautiful handmade ovens. read more

This place has ruined me in the best way possible!! I will be dreaming of the delicious food here and am beyond excited for the next time I get to eat here. I am salivating as I type. We started with their Italian Salad, ordered the Ortolana Pizza and their Bolognese Special. When I bit into their Bolognese Pasta, I got schooled as to what Bolognese really tastes like. For the Ortolana Pizza, we added the honey chillin sauce to it and also requested for it to be made with their sourdough. Highly recommend both add one. Honestly the best pizza & pasta I've ever had. Since the dinner was beyond, we decided to get their tirimisu dessert, we were surprised at how large the serving was, absolute delicious, not too sweet. Just perfect. Presentation was phenomenal. Staff was so friendly & you could tell the chefs take such pride in their work!! Every seat is a great seat at this restaurant. We sat at the bar & it felt like we were able to really feel the soul of the restaurant right in front of the pizza oven!! Great place. Chef's kiss!! Xoxo read more

See all

Let's say I know pizza. I'm not saying I'm a pizza snob or I get saucey over bad pizza but I come from a place where a-pizza is our pride and joy. Geraldo's is a must try if you are in Sedona! They take pride in their ingredients all the down to the soil that grows the wheat for the flour. House-made mozzarella, sausage dough, lemoncello etc.. This father and son duo pour their heart and soul into tasty creations while feeding off of each other's expertise. I truly enjoy coming in to see what they have to offer. They make you feel like family read more

See all

WOW! This was fantastic and exceeded our expectations. We were looking a pizza place with outdoor dining for dinner so we could bring our dog. Our dog sometimes is reactive to other dogs so we wanted a spot where the tables were pretty spread out. When we arrived, we were promptly seated and the outdoor patio was actually way nicer than we expected. All the heaters were on and it was actually very cozy with the string lights as well. There was a line for inside seating and were surprised not more people opted to sit outside. Our server was great and shared the daily specials with us. We tried the wine and both the Riesling and Moscato were lovely. We shared the Carnivore pizza (12 inches), rigatoni bolognese (special of the day), and a bruschetta (special of the day). The bruschetta was super tasty with prosciutto and arugula. 3 good size pieces as well. The pizza was unsurprisingly fantastic - great char from the wood fire and tasty toppings and crust. The standout was the pasta though. The homemade rigatoni had a nice chew and absorbed the sauce very nicely. For dessert, we shared the creme brulee and it was tasty as well. The moon shaped cookie was cute but very hard to break apart. The table next to us got the brioche bread with strawberries and cream (special of the day) and it looked REALLY good. Kinda wish we ordered that instead, haha! Amazing food, great service, and cute relaxing ambiance. Best meal during our visit to Sedona! read more

See all

Great wood fired pizza, locally owned, and fresh ingredient sourced! Our waitress Maria provided excellent service and our pizzas were delicious. You can customize the type of pizza dough you would like such as traditional, sourdough, or black ink dough. We also got the cannoli trio and pistachio tiramisu desserts to take home. They tasted awesome, however the tiramisu did melt a bit, so you may want to get that option for dine-in only. The ambiance for the indoor seating was nice and none of the tables were too close together. Additionally, they have outdoor patio seating that is dog friendly. For parking, there is an attached parking lot. If you are in Sedona, this is a good casual restaurant to check out! read more

See all

Some of the best pizza I have had state side outside of Italy. Who would know it's in Sedona. Definitely worth the stop when in Sedona.

A great casual family restaurant with old world red checkered tablecloth feel , serving delicious Italian dishes meat and pasta and the best NY Pizza in Sedona , actually equivalent to NYC pizza . Good for dinner any season, large outdoor patio gor large parties. The Service is alway excellent! read more

We were seated immediately as walk ups, I like that this place is further away from the crowded downtown area. Decor is simple and server was friendly. The food was unbelievable. The bolognese was the best I've ever had in my life! Pizza was solid and I'm glad I added the hot honey. Salad dressing was wonderful. Tiramisu was huge. read more

See all

Easily my best meal in the Sedona area. Highly, highly recommend making a meal stop here. Visiting from Chicago (and very Italian) I had high expectations and they were surpassed. The ingredients are fresh and high quality. I've visited many Neapolitan places in Italy and in Chicago and this is easily top 5 in the mix. Service was kind and attentive, they have some unique ovens explained as part of your dining experience. We started with the calamari which was good - lightly breaded like in Italy. We went straight for the pizzas which were excellent. I enjoyed that they had classics on their menu - like Salssicia and capprriciosa that we greatly enjoyed. Excellent. Highly recommend. Grazie mille per l'eccellente esperienza culinaria e il cibo meraviglioso! Alla prossima! read more

See all

Hubby and I came here while visiting Sedona in October. We were seated rally quickly, and our server came over shortly after and made suggestions. I tried the Carnivora uncut. The bread made the pizza even more delicious than it already was! Sooo good! We also ordered the tiramisu, which was pretty good too. 5 stars!! read more

See all

I came here with a group of girls after a long hike in Sedona and let me just say -- I will think about this place forever. It was so good! We sat outside on the patio and the weather was so beautiful in the evening. Our waitress was so kind while she explained the specials and waited for us to think. We got four pizzas. The best one was the mortadella and pesto!!! I want that everyday of my life!! My least favorite was the spicy burrata. Margarita was just like any other. The prosciutto and fig was not what I wanted. It was fine. The crème brûlée was super delicious and the tiramisu could be skipped. Wish I tried the cannoli. read more

See all

Highly recommend the squid ink dough! Very unique and delicious. We've never seen squid ink being used in pizza before. This place is so far our favorite in Sedona. Good service and tasty food, will def come back! read more

See all

As someone who always enjoys but never seeks out pizza I'm here to say that Gerardo's is a place to seek out. Every pizza lover should be wowed by the pizza offerings but even those who'd generally choose otherwise will be won over here. I was headed someplace else and arrived to find that place closed. Yelp directed me to Gerardo's, which I'd not have otherwise chosen as it's off-the-street-behind-another-building setting wouldn't draw me in. Then you park and go inside and hmmm... this place looks like the real deal: Without going into excruciating detail, know that Gerardo's has the "slow food" seal of approval and that their web site talks of their dough like this: "our dough doesn't just rise--it rests, breathes, and transforms over 72 hours. We treat it like a baby: with patience, consistency, and care". I haven't had pizza like this since my trip to Naples. I sat at the small bar from which I could watch pizzas being placed into the artful oven and observe servers carefully measuring ample wine pours. I was charmed and thrilled to have gotten any seat at all (reservations aren't accepted and the place gets packed). I had some good meals in Sedona but my meal here was the best. read more

Gerardo's Pizzeria - Vesuvio ($22) - Mozarella, EVOO, Burrata, Calabrian Chile. (Perfection) - Italian Near Me - Sedona, Arizona

See all

Best experience! We had an opportunity to speak with the owner and learn more background of the charming, mouth watering and top notch pizzeria. We sat on the patio and enjoyed a caprese salad, the house Caesar salad, prosciutto and fig le pizze, and the inferno dolce thick Sicilian pizza. Those looking for a dog friendly location you can bring your fur babies and eat on the patio. A must stop when in Sedona! read more

See all

Food was not good and the preparation was pretty bad. Didn't taste good and was poorly made.

We were recommended this spot as the best pizza in Sedona. The restaurant is smaller so make sure you have a reservation. We did not have one and waited 30 minutes which wasn't too bad as you can get a drink while you wait. It is a cute restaurant with good service. The pizza was good. The pesto side sauce was delicious. Was it the best pizza in Sedona? I'm not sure about that. But it was good. They had a pecan caramel tiramisu which I would say was the best dessert we've had in Sedona. read more

Gerardo's Pizzeria - Italian Near Me - Sedona, Arizona

See all

Recommended to us from Blaine. We were looking for good Italian with pasta on our mind upon arrival but ended up with margaritas, calamari, salad, pizza, and tiramisu. We learned pasta is only an occasional special as they are primarily focused on premium pizzas. We enjoyed the outdoor seating, service, and our meal. Thanks Blaine for the recommendation! read more

Gerardo's Pizzeria - Thick crust pizza - Italian Near Me - Sedona, Arizona

See all

Okay so the food was pretty good but for a family with picky eaters some of the options just weren't meant for us. The waitresses took a while to refill drinks but the food came out quickly. read more

What a wonderful experience! The pizza is the best I've had in the USA and the wines are selected to enhance the meal. The owners take their pizza seriously and you can tell by the taste and ingredients! Please, please, please do not miss this restaurant if you anywhere near Sedona after 4 pm Wednesday thru Sunday! You'll be missing a gem. read more

Wow! What a wonderful gem in Sedona! A family-run business with a warm atmosphere and awesome food! Due to the high-quality food, the wait was a little long, but darn well worth it! The owner sat us and chatted with us a bit about the restaurant history and his family. We had the Cardini salad with homemade parm crisps (awesome!) and calamari to start. We followed that with a Margherita pizza and the Mortadella & Pistachio pizza (with Black dough!). Pretty dang good! Thanks for a great experience Gerardo's! read more

Gerardo's Pizzeria - Margherita pizza and the Mortadella & Pistachio pizza with Black dough (Spanish Cuttlefish ink) - Italian Near Me - Sedona, Arizona

The food is fantastic. My husband had linguine with shrimp. The dish was beautiful. The shrimp was tender and perfectly cooked. Amazing! I had a pizza made in the Woodford oven. It had Italian ham, mushrooms and artichoke hearts. It was cooked to perfection and tasted fantastic. We sat at the bar and watched the kitchen staff cook. It was orchestrated efficiently. Our server ,Maria was very attentive and pleasant. Overall, best restaurant in Sedona so far. We have been in this beautiful town 4-5 times in the last couple years. You have to try Geraldos!! We will be back. read more

5 Stars. Fantastic restaurant. One of the Owner's, Gerardo, greeted us as we were sat and pointed out a special Pizza that was a "Sun Devil Special" because I was wearing my ASU quarter zip. He told us all about how their family was a pioneer of the Slow Food movement in Italy and that they brought that same philosophy here to their restaurant in Sedona. His wife, Guadalupe was our server and was amazing - they made sure to give great recommendations and took great care of us. I would 10/10 go back to this restaurant next time we are in Sedona. It is more of a local known spot and I will be sure to tell everyone about this place who visits. read more

Gerardo's Pizzeria - Pizza + Bolognese pasta special. - Italian Near Me - Sedona, Arizona

A Must-Visit for Pizza Lovers in Sedona! We had an amazing dining experience here with their flavorful wood-fired pizzas! We ordered three: pepperoni (for the kids), Margherita, and the Mortadella Pistachio pizza. Each one was absolutely delicious. The crust was light, flaky, and packed with flavor--a perfect base for their creative toppings. The wine selection complemented the meal wonderfully, and the overall vibe of the place was warm and inviting. While we couldn't enjoy the patio due to the chilly December evenings, the indoor ambiance was lively and cozy. It can get a bit loud, but we appreciated that since we were dining with young kids (ages 3 and 5) who could be their lively selves without worry. Service was attentive and friendly, rounding out a great experience. We'll definitely recommend this spot to our friends and look forward to coming back the next time we're in Sedona! read more

See all

amazing pizza. regenerative agriculture flour, fresh tasting ingredients, each of our three pies was delightful. and the tiramisu was decadent. definitely stop by here in sedona! daughter even said it was perfection, 10/10 read more

See all

My family ate here last night. The staff has true pride in what they do. The service and pizza was excellent. Welcoming and authentic. Would recommend to anyone stopping by in town. read more

I literally crave this crust even though I am mostly gluten-free. They have 12 regenerative farms in the US where they get their flour and it is magical to my gut. I've never seen Pizza like this that is literally nourishing. Easily as good as Italy and done with such love. They even make their own cheese. True connoisseurs will appreciate this heartfelt family business. read more

Must go to restaurant in Sedona!! Absolutely loved the Burrata pizza! I have been here twice and can't wait to go back! We started with the Insalata Della Casa. This was refreshing and love the dressing. We got two pizzas. The with pizza sauce was the Salsiccia and the without pizza sauce the Burrata. The Salsiccia was perfect with the sausage and onions. The Burrata pizza was the best pizza! The Burrata was the perfect combination to the prosciutto, arugula,and balsamic glaze. The crust was made perfectly. Sadly they do not take reservations, so go check in and then go around the area while waiting for the table. They have indoor and outdoor seating options. This pizzeria is definitely worth the wait! read more

See all

Best Italian spot in town and also has plenty of family vibe and attention. It's not glamorous but definitely good. I choose this over my other choices in town. Service is good and it's nice being waited on instead of just ordering at a counter. read more

15/10. Our first time visiting Gerardo's and it was phenomenal! Our server Eric was kind, professional, tentative, and knowledgeable about the menu. He had a great attitude and delivered wonderful service. Our food and drinks were delicious! We ordered the Coccoli to start, the Diavola pizza, Carnivora pizza and Sedona pizza. All were an explosion of flavor and quality ingredients. To drink we had the limoncello spritz and G's Italian margarita. To end the night we had the cannoli trio and crème brûlée. Everything was fantastic! The restaurant is lovely with generational family pictures on the walls. Seating was plentiful and spaced out nicely. Overall this a wonderful restaurant and worth the visit! We will be back! read more

See all

Our family visited Sedona during winter vacation; we came at 6PM and Gerardo's was packed. Waited for 40 min to be seated at the patio, but this place worth the wait. The pizzas were absolutely tasty; their almond cookies and cream brulee were also amazing. The service was top notch. My kiddo was curious about their pizza oven; the owner & staff were kindly showing her up close. It was very memorable dinner for her. read more

Gerardo's Pizzeria - Cream brulee - Italian Near Me - Sedona, Arizona

This place is a gem! Wonderful pizzas cooked in a Woodfire oven. You can have it served without being cut and cut it with a knife and fork just like they do in Italy. They had some delicious bottled Italian sodas as well! The staff is top-notch too! read more

This is our third time at Gerardo's. We live in California and love to come to Sedona as often as we can. We discovered Gerardo's on Yelp a few years ago and it's one of our first stops when we come to visit. This is the best pizza we've ever had. I had the burrata and prosciutto, hubby had the margarita and added sausage. Both were delicious! Also had a salad that was crisp and fresh. Service was great, all staff were pleasant and attentive. We sat out on the patio, where the atmosphere was peaceful and very comfortable. We will definitely return on our next visit! read more

The restaurant is cute and we met a few locals that knew the owners that raved about the history, the family passion, and the food. We were seated rather quickly. The service was the only mishap as we had a much older waitress that was seemingly tired, snappy in demeanor and really unhelpful. We'd ask questions about recommendations and she'd answer very abruptly and with annoyance. We didn't let that ruin the great food- I will say the margherita pizza and the calzone were exceptional ! We'd try again and hopefully have different service. :) read more

See all

Andrea was our server she explained the options on specials and we went with one of their pizzas. Over all the pizza is amazing home made and the ingredients explain its self. Over all it's a must place to have pizza thank you read more

The order: Buriata pizza & Salsiccia Insalata Della Casa, salad The good: both pizzas are outstanding. If you get a pizza here, you'll experience that their dough is outstanding. It's fluffy, but still substantial and has a good chew. My jaw was not tired from eating this. The buriata pizza was one of the best I've ever had. The bad: I wished they had some sort of reservation system read more

See all

Everything from the appetizer to dessert was delicious definitely a requirement to come to this gem! Just forget to take a picture of the appetizer read more

Gerardo's Pizzeria - Dessert special for the night. Olive cake with raspberries. - Italian Near Me - Sedona, Arizona

See all

Had a quick trip to Sedona and gave this place a try. Very mom and pop feel and relatively busy. It appears to be a favorite among locals. We started with the focaccia, which in hindsight turned out to be too much bread for the evening. Seasoned well and had a nice crunch. I ordered the Quattro stagioni and my boyfriend the A.c Milan. The A.C Milan was delightful. Had lots of layers of flavor. Sweet meets savory and very complimentary. The dough in this restaurant is exceptional. However, my pizza was lack luster. They have these place mats that describe the restaurants conception and origin and spotlight ingredients, so naturally, I was excited tot et their sauce. My pizza was sorely lacking sauce. It was quite the disappointment and I even have to ask my server for Marinara. It's not the same as the pizza sauce but it did definitely help the dryness. Their prosciutto was a little thick cut for my liking. Other than that very good. Super casual setting and looks like they have a nice patio. The prices are a little exorbitant for my taste. I don't normally gravitate towards pizzas, but spending 27$ for 12 inch that was lack luster (in my opinion) was a hard pill to swallow. read more

See all

Not sure where to start. Sooo good. Even though this is a pizzeria the true Italian heritage here enticed me to order the on special pasta. I was so grateful for that decision. The salad was an exceptional classic Cesar with added anchovies. ALL quality ingredients and I highly recommend it. But the special was even better. I had the very basic Rigatoni Bolognese Meat Sauce with homemade pasta. You must have superb chef skills to enable something this basic taste this incredible. Kudos to you! Worth every penny. read more

What a find! Food was so fresh and so good! My wife and I split a Della La Casa salad and the Sedona pizza. The salad was solid, but that pizza....loved it! It had fresh mushrooms and it had a cherry jam that I've never had on a pizza before...but it was one of the best pizzas we've had in a very long time. The staff was also super friendly and welcoming. Truly enjoyed this visit! read more