Glass Nickel Pizza Co. Menasha-Neenah

Locally owned & operated

25 years in business

I have been walking the city of Neenah a long time now looking for those who need help in the city…read more Under the bridges and in the parks I find a lot of wrappers from Great Harvest Bread Co. They are one of the kindest establishments in the city and are responsible for helping those in need the most. I asked the managers of the business if I could write some poetry on the public sidewalk in front of the bakery. I hope that comes to pass soon! Until then I will keep passing out this bread and giving a 2.00 bill in the tip jar for the best smells in town. Jimmy Johns has NUTHIN' on Great Harvest Bread Co. Keep up the good work!

This is my favorite spot for soup and a sandwich. The Classic Club on Honey Wheat is so delicious…read moreand they have a choice of several soups.

See all

Chicago's House of Hoagies

4.5(26 reviews)

1.8 mi

Incredible find. Super friendly owner from Chicago. Lots of options and great descriptions of all…read morethe sandwiches. Was craving a solid sandwich and this hit the spot. Fresh fries with a tangy sauce was great too. I got the three meats on my all dressed sub and it was packed with flavor and overloaded with toppings. Would definitely stop by again! Was very clean and had a good dining area that I was able to work in for a bit as well.

Chicago House of Hoagies 1089 Racine Rd - Menasha I…read moreexperienced the 131st Street Hoagie. My husband had the Altgeld Garden Hoagie - see picture. Very messy as a true hoagie should be. Very delicious! Big portions. High quality ingredients. Staff friendly, willing to accommodate my special requests. My bun was toasted and his was not (as ordered). I think toasted is less messy and tastier. Added Northside fries and a slice of chocolate cake. Total under $40. Will be back!! Great meal made to order. After eating we agreed next time we are wanting a sandwich or any burger place we would eat Chicago House of Hoagies instead - much healthier and more filling. I ate half of mine saving the rest for later, he ate all of his and is very full. He said "If I am going to break my keto & have carbs - this sandwich is worth it!"

Dinning area!

Altgeld Garden Hoagie! Same as 131st but not toasted

See all

Greene's Pour House

3.7(175 reviews)

Pretty good bar and pub! Food is heavy, but that's to be expected for a bar! Their Bloody Mary bar…read moreon Saturdays is a great deal and very tasty!

We have been here a handful (exactly 5 times) and sometimes are definitely better than others…read more This time was a good fail. We ordered and the bartender was kind and friendly and pretty quick. The food was not great. Pickle chips w/o pickles they were super sucky, pickles are to thin and they are so over cooked! The Cuban was also meh. I ate a 1/4 and left it behind. The onion rings were really good but everything was on the verge of overcooked/burnt. The ambience and decor are fine though and had the look of a fun hometown Wisconsin bar

See all

Beer options

The Old Grog

4.2(54 reviews)

Excellent wings. Got the breaded Option. Juicy with a very…read moretasty sauce. The fries are fine, beer was cold

The chicken wings are the best I've ever had. I go there at least twice a month. Even the steak…read moresandwich and hamburgers are excellent not to mention the chicken dinners on Sunday.

Broasted chicken special

See all

Zuppas Market Cafe and Catering

4.0(62 reviews)

2.8 mi

Interesting variety of food choices. Accomodating to large groups. Foodie Haven. Drinkable wines…read moretoo!

Food and Sevice are Amazing!! Staff were welcoming and friendly. The food was fresh and prepared…read moreperfectly. Will be spending my next lunch out with friends there again.

Zuppas Market Cafe and Catering - Sweet Jesus this might be the worst soup I have ever tried. It smelled like simmering corpse when I heated it on the stove.

Sweet Jesus this might be the worst soup I have ever tried. It smelled like simmering corpse when I heated it on the stove.

See all

Sammy's Pizza In Neenah

4.5(27 reviews)

0.3 mi

Amazing pizza a little pricey but worth it. 1 large pizza fed 5 people in the house so that's not…read morebad at all

Before coming up to Appleton, I looked at all the pizza places in the area and the pictures of…read moretheir pizza. Sammy looked most like Chicago pizza that I like. I was not disappointed. I came in for the lunch special. There are maybe four or five booths and I would say about the same for tables. They also have seats at the counter like a diner. The gentleman who waited on me was pleasant and helpful. I ordered the lunch special which is between 11 AM and 1 PM. It is a 9 inch pizza with one topping for $7.25. He brought it out to me with my can of soda. It did not disappoint. I watched the people coming in and out. It seem to be a steady stream also it seem to be like Cheers where everyone knows everyone. They all seem to have a personal connection with the owner. What an unassuming place to come and get great pizza. Would you believe I left having met a new friend. When I come back to Neena we're going to get together again.

Get this shit....they give you an ice cream sandwich after your meal. Respect!

Cheese garlic bread.

See all

14" sausage pizza

Lawlss Coffee

4.2(26 reviews)

Great local coffee shop and roasters, with a good balance of flavored lattes and more third-wave…read morestyle options, like pour overs and speciality roasts. Loved the cold brew, americano, and the seasonal banana latte! Also got a bag of the house blend to go!

Customer service is absolutely horrible in this place. The barista had a disgusting attitude filled…read morewith sarcasm.

See all

Latte

Mihm's Charcoal Grill

4.3(161 reviews)

0.5 mi

Mihm's has been a staple in the Fox Valley for decades. I believe it is under new ownership. This…read morereview is not only for the food they serve but for the sense of community they foster. When an EF-3 tornado devastated Menasha this July 2026, Mihm's was one of the first establishments to offer food to the tornado victims and volunteers. It may be a small eatery, but it has a lot of heart. Deserving more than 5 stars. Ambiance has no frills but welcoming. Service was consistent, asking about your food or drink. BTW, I had a mushroom Swiss burger which was juicy and very much tasted off the grill.

First timer for trying this butter burger joint. The atmosphere was nice and whatever music they…read morewere streaming was great. It can be a little loud there when it's busy, but that's all part of the vibe. Service was great, they tag team the tables so multiple servers checked on us. Definitely going to go back and have a beer with my burger next time! Oh and definitely get a double patty, I got a single and my friends double with bacon looked fire

The tables.

Cheeseburger

See all

The Front.

ICU Bar & Grill

4.3(52 reviews)

1.6 mi

Hands down best Wings I've ever had. Great food. Great prices. Always consistent! Appetizers are…read morealways tasty and you can smell your burger while it's being cooked.

Good food Good service Great value for the dollar, worth the stop for a good bite. Quite clean…read more Enjoy your stop!

See all

Luigi's Pizza & Pasta

3.3(45 reviews)

0.1 mi

We had a great experience here and Joe took fantastic care of us. Our kids came with and they were…read morealso treated well, which isn't always the case. We're excited to try the fish fry! Good pizza, fresh salads and AMAZING gelato (pictured).

We ordered a large thim crust pizza with green pepper, sausage, mushrooms. It was pretty good. I…read morethink the sausage was a little spicy, so I just picked them off. Do you have other sausage like mild or even sweet would be good? All in all it was good and also delivered in a timely manner. Thank you! Pam

Gelato with strawberries

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

8 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Cassy B.

0

1

0

4 years ago

The most highly unprofessional place of employment I have ever came across in the fox cities. When issues occur the issues are swept under the rug or there's zero communication. For example, when a female employee made a racial slur, she was only relocated to the Appleton store. She views her employees as children and insists they be babysat, instead of empowering her employees especially by setting an example. Favoritism seems to be a subject at the store, unless you are a female employee, or related to her in some way shape or form, these employees get away with the most, leaving other employees feeling like they have no purpose or undervalued. Jobs are created to fit the needs of the female employees but she insists the men need to follow her every need instead of attempting to adjust to every male employees needs. Most employees won't know they did wrong because of the lack of communication, professional criticism and correction, until the owner talks about you, in front of you, without addressing you, about the subject by the owner and another employee, again leaving employees feeling belittled and undervalued. What one employee can get away with isn't the same when it comes to those on her favorite list, leaving employees feeling like their jobs aren't secure. For example, an employee on her favorite list can be up to 4 hours late, and this is overlooked, while another employee is 15 minutes late, their shift is then covered, they're automatically put on suspension, then the owner chooses to not communicate, answer phone calls, return phone calls, leaving this employee feeling their job is lost while they did not quit, nor was there proper policy and procedure followed nor was the employee terminated. All employees are paid on a favoritism scale as well, pay is not equal within the work place all of which violates labor laws. read more

Sean L.

0

1

0

8 years ago

The pizza was great, I really liked the fresh mushrooms. I also got some fried jalapeno poppers to go with it. It was hard deciding what I wanted the menu was so big. I got it all delivered for lunch and the lady who brought it was super friendly. read more

Kevin D.

0

2

0

8 years ago

I work on the road a lot. So having a place that delivers is great. I have ate here a lot and all the food was great. Prices are great. Delivery is fast and the drivers are friendly. Love this place read more

Kasandra S.

0

1

0

9 years ago

Awesome experience! Ordered late after a long day at work fed the crew and everyone was very satisfied with the food great customer service on time delivery perfect food! read more

Jessica C.

0

2

0

6 years ago

I've never had their pizza before, it was amazing. I will definitely be a returning customer! Best I've he ad in a long time.

Curtis B.

0

1

0

7 years ago

Order from work all the time. Food is hot and delicious. Delivery is always quick. Same results when I order from

Micah R.

0

1

0

8 years ago

Great food, friendly service and fast delivery. Super recommended.

Misty C.

0

1

0

8 years ago

Best pizza place iv ever been to and had in my life

Glass Nickel Pizza Co. Menasha-Neenah - pizza - Updated September 2026

People who viewed Glass Nickel Pizza Co. Menasha-Neenah also viewed

Pagoni's Pizza

4.1

(54 reviews)

Best darn wings around. I love them so much, my wife even…read moresurprised me with them for my birthday dinner. I was VERY happy and hungry

The ambiance was nice the woman at the counter was very friendly and accommodating…read more I had a calzone which was fine but nothing to write about. My friend had the buffet that looked dried out and lukewarm when I arrived at noon. We stayed an hour, there were maybe five other patrons, and no one else ate from the buffet. Zero fresh food was replaced, it just became drier, colder and nastier.

Pizza King

3.5

(10 reviews)

The food was delicious, but the service was horrendous. I do not know who this young male is, he is…read morearound 5'6 with reddish curly hair. He was extremely disrespectful to my teenage daughter. They go to school together, my daughter informed me he has been known for harassing multiple teenager at Appleton North. As much as I would love to give a high rating, I cannot.

The pizza is truly one of the best in the valley! Wonderful to call in your order & have it made…read morefresh and ready to go!

Sal's Pizza

3.4

(111 reviews)

Yay! Just stopped at Sal's, my old stomping ground pizzeria…read morefrom party nights in Appleton. Awesome slices and great service, nothing has changed. Tried the new lasagna pizza, awesome... My wife got the chicken, bacon, ranch slice and said it was the best she ever had! That is saying something, since she is quite picky about her favorite type of pizza everyone... Take note Sal's rocks. Always has. Ooooooooh yeahhhhhh!

Margarita pizza, but no basil! Veggie pizza all tasted like cardboard. The Cannolis was not…read moreedible.

Stucs Pizza

3.9

(176 reviews)

Their pizza is delicious. I typically ask for light sauce on mine because they are generous with…read moretheir sauce on the pizzas and calzone. The dining area is always clean and we've always had good service. I appreciate that they keep it simple.

Ordered Stucs from Grubhub/DoorDash? through Yelp…read more The experience doing that was about 2-stars, because the delivery time was off and the driver did not view or was unable to view my directions. One of the options was for the driver to text when dropping off the pizza in the hotel lobby. He did not, so the concierge had to call my cell phone. Not a big deal, but also not seamless. Because of this, the pizza was lukewarm. Again, not ideal, but we had a microwave in the room. That said, the pizza was delicious. We got a regular pan type 3-meat pizza and we loved it. There was just the right meat to cheese ratio, where you could taste all ingredients and not feel overwhelmed by one element over another. That can be a huge challenge with these meat pizzas. I would come back, but definitely will not use the Yelp app to order delivery. I think we want to try the deep dish next, since I am a self-proclaimed expert on the topic. With the delivery issues, I would have rated 3-stars or less, but I know that the experience was not Stucs-related.

Pierri Pizza

4.4

(34 reviews)

Great pizza cooked in a Faulds oven old school. Supper thin full of flavor. This is a must try if…read moreyou're a pizza snob.

Well, I have lived in Appleton for six years. Why didn't I find this place before?! Cracker thin…read morecrust and just the right amount of toppings. The only improvement would be better napkins. I will be back again and again.

Sammy's Pizza In Neenah

4.5

(27 reviews)

Amazing pizza a little pricey but worth it. 1 large pizza fed 5 people in the house so that's not…read morebad at all

Before coming up to Appleton, I looked at all the pizza places in the area and the pictures of…read moretheir pizza. Sammy looked most like Chicago pizza that I like. I was not disappointed. I came in for the lunch special. There are maybe four or five booths and I would say about the same for tables. They also have seats at the counter like a diner. The gentleman who waited on me was pleasant and helpful. I ordered the lunch special which is between 11 AM and 1 PM. It is a 9 inch pizza with one topping for $7.25. He brought it out to me with my can of soda. It did not disappoint. I watched the people coming in and out. It seem to be a steady stream also it seem to be like Cheers where everyone knows everyone. They all seem to have a personal connection with the owner. What an unassuming place to come and get great pizza. Would you believe I left having met a new friend. When I come back to Neena we're going to get together again.

Glass Nickel Pizza Co. Appleton

3.4

(129 reviews)

I'm so happy I finally tried this place! I had the mac daddy pizza, and unlike every other mac &…read morecheese pizza I've had, it was an alfredo sauce base instead of cheese sauce.. and it WORKED! It was way better this way. The cheese curds were delicious too, and the cinna nugs were one of the best desserts I've ever had.

Went in to pick up a pizza and noticed a special: $4 cheesy bread with a pizza purchase. I asked if…read moreI could add it to my order, and the guy flatly said no. I wasn't asking for anything crazy, just to add a $4 item that was advertised in store (it wasn't even listed on their website, so I didn't know about it beforehand). No offer to help, no coupon, nothing, just a hard no, delivered like I'd asked for something unreasonable. On top of that, the total came to over $40 for one large and one small pizza, which already felt steep. Combined with the unhelpful service, it just wasn't worth it.

Broken Tree Pizza

4.4

(135 reviews)

A fantastic spot in downtown Neenah for a great wood fire pizza. The Haley's Comet (added…read moremushrooms) has great flavor combinations. The chicken, bacon, artichokes and onions all play well together. Adding the mushrooms brought a nice umami/earthy flavor to already solid flavor profile. My only small criticism, the pizza could've used another 20-30 seconds. It would've given more crisp to the middle of the pie, and a touch more char would've been . I would recommend swinging in and giving Broken Tree Pizza a try, I will when back in the area.

I rarely give 5 stars. This place rates it. An unassuming little place in downtown Neenah Wisconsin…read moredelivers some of the best pizza I've ever had. Wood fired, with a delicious thin crust. Comes in one size only, 12". I had a "That's Life": house red sauce base, house blend cheese, calabrese salami, Italian seasoning, finished with arugula, balsamic glaze and shredded parmesan. My wife ordered a "Hailey's Comet": creamy garlic sauce base, house blend cheese, chicken, bacon, spinach, artichoke. Both were delicious *chef's kiss*! They have a nice selection of local craft beers. The place is neat, clean, and unassuming. The kitchen is right there, you can watch the wood burn in the oven. Great little place, service was quick and efficient.

Chef Fresh Pizza

3.3

(15 reviews)

Chef Fresh Pizza as now in 2026 the famous Wanzurskies potato salad its not the same even a little…read more In 1989 we went to Wanzurskies for all our party needs and when they were closing the owner said they gave special recipe to Chef Fresh Pizza, in2002 Chef Fresh did a great job on perfection it was great through 2016 wedding event ! In 2018 for graduation noticed the potato salad is not the same. Now in 2026 its not the same at all and the service is not the same either not good. I guess all good thing must come to an end.

I haven't been wowed in a long time, but you inspired me to write a review! My vote for best pizza…read morein the Valley hands down! The Works pizza & cheesy garlic bread was absolutely phenomenal!

Cranky Pat's Pizza

3.7

(146 reviews)