Good selection of bagels. Got the "Hobo" breakfast sandwich on Egg Bagel. Fantastic…read more Would definitely recommend / return Nice prompt service even on a busy morning. 5/5

Moments after I placed my order, I noticed the flat bagel sandwiches and started second-guessing my…read morechoice. When I heard another customer order one, that sealed it--I decided to change mine. I asked the woman who took my order if I could switch; she hesitated, likely because my bagel was already toasted, but then quickly agreed and handled it. It felt a bit awkward for a moment, but customer-service-wise it was the right move. This is a legendary bagel shop and worth a stop if you're nearby. The bacon, egg, and cheese I ordered was a bit dry--being toasted without a smear made it come off a little crusty. Next time I'd definitely get a smear, or maybe not have it toasted at all. The highlight, surprisingly, was the heavy-duty sweatshirt I bought as a souvenir--honestly felt even heavier than Carhartt. Tip: Go for the flat bagel version and don't skip the smear.

Goldberg great breakfast place, foods good and fast but the problem is it takes so long. There is…read morealways a line out the door, but overall it's fine. Good ambiance.

I like Goldberg's but the lines are unbearable. Call ahead always. The young man who works the…read morecashier at the East Hampton location is the best. Overall good food but not worth the wait if you don't call ahead.

Looking for a good pizza that won't break the bank out in Bridgehampton then this should be your go…read moreto place. The pizza was hot out of the oven -- cheesy, crisp and delicious. And don't let their name fool you as there is way more than pizza and bagels being served up. There was a huge variety of items that the locals clearly know and love. While waiting for our pizza, we watched people stream in for their favorites including Chinese and Mexican dishes.

Meh they are ok the bagels aren't bad it's just they don't give you enough cream cheese like if I…read morewanted to eat toasted bread with barley anything on it I would of just got it plain. I like my bagels to be full and creamy with cream cheese. Best part is I asked for extra

The new location for the iconic East End bagel kingdom is just superb. Not only does it have…read moreamazing bagels and fare, you can get pizza and ice cream from concession partners in the same space! There's plenty of indoor and outdoor tables and parking is not a problem. There is also A rash of Tesla Supercharger in the parking lot with a lone Chargepoint charger. Now I can enjoy my bagel sandwich while I charge me EVs. It's pretty convenient.

Recently frequented the new Goldberg's in Water Mill, the owner (Rob) approached me unsolicited and…read morecouldn't be a better business owner. Love the expanded selections, sandwiches, pizza, ice cream etc. Food is also really fresh. Great job!

I paid $6.50 per bagel for 3 bagels with lox spread. There was next to nothing on the bagel --…read morebarely a schmear! This is consumer fraud.

Died and went to lox bagel heaven. Given great bagels are commonplace on the East Coast, maybe I am…read morea little biased (and living on a very underrepresented bagel coast) but a hot everything bagel straight out of the oven was pure bliss. Great crust, warm and fluffy on the inside, nothing more I could have asked for (also why have we never put coarse salt on our everything bagels in CA?!). Yes, it's not the cleanest (hopefully just looking) place. Yes, it takes forever for the bagel to be ready. 10/10 I would return.

Overpriced and mid bagels. Kind of to be expected but still. The breakfast sandwich saved it the…read moremeh bagels. Takes forever on the weekends but probably best bagels in the area.

I would give this place 5 stars if my order was right but I wanted the lox bagel with the smoked…read moresalmon, onions and capers but when I ordered the lady who was helping me looked at me crazy. She gave me the bagel with a lox cream cheese. I thought maybe this was just all they had until my friend came out with the bagel I asked for! Both bagels were good but the layered lox is objectively better. The service isn't the best but they know how to get the line down quickly

Always fresh and delicious. Quick lines. Miss their pizza. Excellent staff and always free space…read moreto park. A most welcome addition to the Hamptons.

Burnt scramble eggs on a doughy bagel. Over priced and over rated . Mexican music blaring in…read morebackground . Housr fly insects everywhere - Attention Sag Harbor Health Department and Chamber of Commerce!!! . Had same experience once at a dump in South America . This is prestigious Sag Harbor?

To start, rosemary salt bagel for the win! Honestly all the bagels were delicious. Cinnamon Raisin,…read moreJalapeño Cheddar, Everything. All of them were really good. We didn't get any of the breakfast sandwiches, but next time we will get them as they sounded so good!

Fun local breakfast spot on the island with friendly service and good coffee. Bagels are up to…read morestandard and service is quick

Great little coffee, bagel, and lunch spot in North Fork-specifically, Cutchogue…read more My friends are North Fork residences and hosted us for a long and lovely weekend; Black Sheep is their prefered bagel spot in the area, so we ordered breakfast pickup for five of us. The order included a handful of the *must-try* breakfast bagels, tofu bagel, and a gluten-free bagel for moi. Topped it off with OJ and iced coffee.

Consistently fantastic. Breakfast sandwiches and lunch wraps are always top shelf! Highly recommend.read more

We got an amazing delivery today from The Big Brunch Box! They make custom brunch boxes with…read morebagels, lox, cream cheese, salads, desserts, etc. The food was so yummy and the packaging was so detailed and pretty! We highly recommend The Big Brunch Box! It's great for gifts or for yourself. 5 stars!