Horrible- two out of the four of us got sick! Pizza was…read morejust OK and every dish was truly horrible. Place was packed and only 3 people to attent to the whole crows. So much better food in the area. Don;t know how this place stays in business.

Hosts were great. Food was excellent. I had one of the best pieces of swordfish ever. The…read morerestaurant was very very loud. Service was a bit scattered but ended up as adequate. Bottom Line Was a great night out with family!

Here I am again giving it another chance. Ordered a cheese slice and it was just meh. No sauce just…read morea hint of red food coloring that gives the appearance of sauce topped with cheese. Again, had to add a ton of chili, oregano and garlic.

Food 4/5 Service 5/5…read moreOverall 9/10 I eat here often after work (just before they close) and staff is very agreeable and service is quick.

Was looking for a quick meal and ny style pizza. Service is fast and friendly with great prices…read more Easy to park in their own lot few tables inside few tables outside there is not service you order at the counter. My pizza was great and my pennz broccoli was even better than I expected.

We stopped here to grab some pizza late day - what an excellent choice for a gluten-free,…read morecauliflower-crust personal pizza! The service was friendly and prompt and the pizza crust had the exact right amount of crunch, yet was nice and thin. I recommend the margarita (I added onions). The basil and garlic it was prepared with took this to a next level of gourmet pizza. Yum!! Very casual atmosphere, great for kids. Outdoor seating in front. We will definitely be back! I foresee summer plans out east including this stop!

Party of five and no one was disappointed with the food, service or accommodations…read more Seating available outside, inside and at the bar. Servers are friendly and accommodating. The food was fab. Try the Cioppino filled with clams, mussels, shrimp, bass, calamari, cherry tomato broth, spicy calabrian salsa, grilled house ciabatta.

Stay away from Pellegrino's - they have gone downhill. Dinner check: $400 - including charging $2…read morefor bread! Called owner Pam to question the charge; left 3 messages with host - no response. Host confirmed she received messages. The answer is greed and "because I can". My $400 will be appreciated at Cappellette's - which is a far better restaurant!

Stopped into a great pizza place in Amagansett in the downtown area. You walk in and order right…read moreat the counter and can order by the slice or full pie. There is some room to sit inside and also some seats outside if you'd rather sit there. The cheese pizza had a delicious sauce and was very crisp and crunchy with a delicious crust. The white pizza had lemon zest on it which was very different but still great. We also tried the shallot pizza which was a bit spicy but that's something I love! This was a great experience and would definitely go back!

Pretty decent slice and one of the few places to grab a bite late. Loses stars because 1 I ordered…read moretwo slices of pepperoni and on two slices I got 2.5 pieces of pepperoni; and 2 they gave me one slice and there was a lot of confusion about getting my second one. What? This is the simplest business model there is. Gotta have that slice game on lock.

Context: I take photos for ubereats and doordash at over 300 restaurants on Long Island each year…read moreand have the perk of trying the food prepared for the photoshoot for free. So, I have been able to taste food at more restaurants than most. But I don't recommend more than a handful. Because the food at most is ok, but not great. Nothing I would drive 30 minutes to get. Slice of the Hamptons is an exception. I tried their fried chicken wings and the penne ala vodka. Both were shockingly tasty and memorable. The wings were the best I can remember having, ever. Extremely crunchy and thick crust with chicken underneath that had its own baked in flavor. You really have to try it. The penne ala vodka was so different from the typical bland sauced pasta I get elsewhere. Sauce was thick and creamy (was there cheese in there?) and surprisingly sweet. Each bite was a mouthful of flavors. This pizza place is hidden in a Dunkin Donuts building next to a gas station. I wish I didn't live over an hour away so I can try their other dishes.

Stopped for a slice on our way out east last year and found out that we shouldn't have. The pizza…read morewas mediocre and the place needed improvements across the board, from the wobbly table to the counterservice, so not surprised that it's closed now.

Five star review. really good, really fast, really good for kids. An easy quick dinner that is not…read moretoo expensive and can please everyone.

Love visiting Sag Pizza! The cocktails are great and the pizza choices are a fantastic creative…read moreItalian mix. Well cooked crust with brick oven char. The staff works so hard to get everyone seated and happy. Adorable pizza bar Italian vibe in beautiful Sag Harbor. In my opinion, Great after beach day stop!

Although I never write reviews I feel compelled to do so to warn others about such a terrible…read moreexperience. Food was mediocre. Most local NY pizzerias have better dishes. Buffalo wings and garlic bread was cold. Penne Ala vodka was essentially penne with marinara sauce and the chicken parm was very thick if you like that style. Service - 2/10. No dishes were ever cleared throughout the meal. You had to beg them to take dirty plates or bread baskets away. Had to reuse silverware. Soda was randomly provided in either a glass or plastic cup. The worst part is we wanted to order a side of pasta with butter. The waitress said she spoke with the owner and he said they won't do that and it will be $30. We asked how long it would and she said 2 minutes so we ordered it. After 20 minutes we told her please forget it and give us the check. She returned with the pasta in a to go dish and included it on the bill. We then asked her to speak with the owner. She came back and told us there was no owner or manager there so she couldn't remove the pasta from the bill. On the way out I saw a man who looked like a manager and he confirmed he was. Hence we were repeatedly lied to. When we got home and opened the buttered pasta we found unidentifiable red and white things in it. Obviously it was tampered with and clearly unsafe to eat. Overall this goes down as likely the worst dining experience of our lives. Poor food, unprofessional, terrible customer service, and possible food tampering in the kitchen. Please avoid!

Delicious Italian food with fantastic gluten-free pasta options!…read more We ordered takeout on a Thursday evening for a large party. Food was made fast and we had no issues picking it up! We ordered the large cheese pizza, which was perfectly doughy and cheesy. We also ordered gluten-free pasta with vodka sauce. Not sure what brand they use but it was the best gluten-free pasta I've ever had! Couldn't believe it wasn't regular pasta. And the sauce was rich and savory! Highly recommend!

Wow we saw the sign driving they won best bakery. So we decided to go the next morning. The place…read moreis adorable this review is only for the bakery in the back. We got amazing coffee and a very fresh almond crossaint that tasted like it was from Paris.

This place not only sucks it super sucks. Worst experience with the staff. No one there knows that…read morethey are doing. We were seated the. Told hald the things on the menu we wanted either were not there or they told us to go out back to the outhoise which was a bkery. Upon entry to the bakery we were told the place know for baguettes was out of baguettes! So i ordered a ham and cheese on sour dough. They told me no and only had prosciutto and cheese bouquets. I thought you were out of bougettes. They barely spoke english. Did not understand my order and was charged for something i did not ask for and because they didnt know how to operate the machine machines they told me they would trade the wrong order for two extra sandwiches, which is what I had ordered to begin with that they told me they were out of. Then after waiting 15 minutes, I was approached by a gentleman who came outside and said we can only give you one of the sandwiches. And that I would have to pay an additional $16 after paying $54 for two croissants. Seriously you can go kick rocks. You're serious with shit from the beginning and not only me, but the customers in front of me had issues and the customers behind me also had issues. I don't know if this place opened up yesterday but they need a serious course and how to treat customers and how to work your system once again this place is super sucks. They could shove their baguettes up there. You know what

It's ok. Got a cheese slice & roni slice to go. $9…read more Appreciated the use of cup & char roni, but the cheese had a weird texture and mouthfeel. It disintegrated without chewing. I couldn't figure it out. Crust was flavorless. Dough needs more salt. 6.8-7.2 on the barstool scale.

Great pizza, super nice staff! We had plain and the pepperoni pies and both were delicious. We will…read morebe coming back!