I've eaten at a lot of pizzerias, and I can honestly say Good Fellas Pizzeria has the best pizza I've ever had. The cheese and sauce taste incredibly authentic, and every bite is just perfect. Simple, fresh, and unforgettable! read more

Best in the Bronx! Riverdale's Five Stars Want fresh pizza this is the spot everything here is amazing

My bruschetta slice was decent, I must say. People...this pizza place caters to mostly college students meaning it's less expensive and slightly sub-par quality. But honestly, it's not bad! The folks who work here are cool, and the other customers I chatted up with were cool too... Standard spaciousness, and cleanliness. read more

Ice cold pizza! It' wasn't a great experience! I asked manager to come talk to me but no one showed up. The staff wasn't friendly at all. I should have ready all comments on yelp before I showed up there read more

I ordered and order from here for delivery all the time and have never had an issue. Therefore I can't say anything bad about this place. True it takes about 30 -45 minutes for delivery but it has to cook, I'm not expecting undercooked pizza. The one on Waldo avenue is awesome in my point of view. I haven't been to any other goodfellas except this one. I haven't had any issues with my pizza yet however if any issues come up I'll post my experience. read more

Food received not as ordered. Business offered $2 credit (half of one topping) on $36.95 pizza. Manager argumentative when I attempted to explain what happened so I gave up. In addition, Sicilian pizza WAY too much bread. Scrapped off topping and threw most out. With so many delicious Sicilian pizzas around, don't have to deal with this. read more

Ordered from this place for the first and last time. I can't even believe anyone took a look at this food and thought it was ok to give to people. Very disappointed. read more

See all

Ordered veggie pizza and I was sadly disappointed. Weirdly the cheese was on top of the vegetables and pizza was delivered in the rain with no cover so cold and alittle soggy. Very very disappointed and can't believe I wasted money for this. read more

See all

It's not easy being a pizza place in a city where pizza is King. I would not describe Goodfellas as the greatest pizza place in the city by any means, but everything I've ordered here has consistently been delicious and quick. Call me a Basic Betty, but I love the pepperoni pizza, generous on the cheese and pepperoni, with little crispy edges and reasonably priced. I love to drench mine in hot honey-- it's phenomenal. I still have the appetite of a 10-yr-old so we also usually order the chicken fingers. I doubt these are homemade, but they're exactly what you want in a chicken finger: super crunchy, fried tender chicken bites of heaven. With a solid honey mustard on the side, too. I'd love to see Goodfellas update their salads to be a bit more exciting and fresh (they have the standard pile of romaine lettuce with onions as their side salad). Still though, this is one of our go-to's in the neighborhood for a delicious, quick bite at a reasonable price. read more

They have one of the best pizzas in Riverdale and Bronx. I love their spinach and sausage pizza. The ingredients seems very fresh and high quality. They are super friendly and highly accommodating. We have been ordering for Goodfellas for past 3 years and they have maintained their quality. A+ and highly recommend!!! read more

The Literal Scourge of Humanity My other half and I went out for a romantic dinner on one of those cold winter Riverdale nights. After ordering what turned out to be the world's most anorexic pizza and an antipasto salad that induced organ failure from how sour it was--not to mention paying $.75 for DRESSING (a flagrant violation of our UN declared human rights)--we proceeded to ensconce ourselves at a table that hadn't been washed since the bicentennial. We wiped it down because God forbid the busboy lift a finger (he barked at us "We don't clean here!"), we choked down the slop before us. Wanting to ditch the calamity of a pizzeria and down the nearest bottle of Peptobismol we high tailed out of there--only to regrettably return because my wallet went missing. The "customer-focused" staff lashed out at us after we informed them of the predicament and gave us a pretty classy display of operatics to emphasize how they don't clean or have any watchful eye over the place. The CCTV camera was purely decorative as the cashier--who really should have been home studying for his SATs--shared zero remorse. He did nothing to resolve the issue as he said he didn't have access to security footage--I forgot this was Fort Knox. That's it for our review--back to stomach pumping. read more

They are overrated and the prices are high for no reason. I even gave specific directions in person, and they did not follow directions.

Pizza is pretty tasty and the slices are larger than the average slice. You have to ask for it well done or else you will receive a sloppy mess. Very overpriced but there's nothing you can do about it. read more

Not sure what's going on with the oven or the cook but my pizza was a cardboard with cheese. The bottom of the pizza was burned Crispy . Either the oven is too high or the cook is not paying attention . Note out of all the pizzerias in Riverdale I always choose to order from here unfortunately that will have to change if this keeps happening . read more

I ordered a calamari, side of fries and some garlic knots and all were disgusting. The calamari was just bad all the breadings had fallen off and they all stuck together due to the moistutre in the container and all the flour and it was just a disgusting mess. The fries tasted like they'd been sitting out on a counter for days and the garlic knots were all burnt and was hard as hell and also tasted old. Smh never again! read more

Goodfellas Pizza Pasta - This is the disgusting calmari they sent to me - Pizza Near Me - Bronx, New York

Authentic reasonably priced Italian food. The fettuccini Alfredo is delicious! The staff is quite friendly read more

Sometimes the BF and I stop in here for a slice on our walk down the stairs to get to the 1 train. I can't complain...although the plain slice being equal to a subway fare rule of thumb doesn't apply here. A plain slice is $3. Every once in a while I'll order a white personal pie for delivery. The white pizza is alright - nothing special...and the delivery guys are always in a big hurry. Tonight the guy almost forgot to give me my drink. I think I prefer eating takeout here vs. delivery. read more

we used to order from here all the time and I had no complaints. This time I ordered my regular pie, and firstly noticed it was smaller than usual. Secondly the price was higher. Thirdly, I always ask for extra sauce. I tried this pizza and it was NOTHING like before. When I called, I was told "well what do you want us to do???" I'm HELLO take it back, give me a refund! This pie sucks! He proceeds to ask "did you try the pizza?" Yes MF of course I tried it, that's how I know it blows. (Said it more lady like, tho) He said he could give us a dollar off NEXT time. Are you joking? What am I supposed to do with a pie I paid for that I will not eat because admittedly you said you had a diff cook in and this is far from your reg tasty pizza? The unprofessional attitude was unbelievable. How unfortunate I used to order from here all the time and now never again. Why even ask if we took a bite? Do they intend on reselling it??? What is this!? What good would it do me to try to screw you over one eaten slice then ask for my money back when I've never done that before? After getting pissed off and arguing they finally agreed to give the refund and they did take the pie back-and checked it lol I did not know they were this stingy. Disappointed. read more

Pretty standard slice, prices are great! More cheese on a plain slice than usual so I wish I could give it 3.5 stars. Clean and cozy sitting area read more

Ordered delivery on a Wednesday night. Called and placed my order. Sicilian pie half meat explosion half cheese. The pizza was delivered within 30-45 minutes (free over $10 I believe) and was VERY hot. The delivery guy was nice and walked up all 5 flights to my door. The pizza was very heavy. I was stuffed after 2 slices. I felt the meat explosion was a little salty for my liking but my boyfriend loved it. Definitely would order pizza from here again! Good service and decent pricing. read more

Goodfellas Pizza Pasta - Sicilian pizza half meat explosion half cheese $24 plus tip - Pizza Near Me - Bronx, New York

Goodfellas Pizza is one notch up from any other corner pizzeria, but demand Manhattan prices. They made 3 mistakes with 3 different orders and when you call up and bring it to their attention you get attitude from them, they are very stingy with their Cheese & Peperoni Pizza, be prepared for a lot of crust. I only live 1 block away and still had to wait an hour for delivery at 3pm when placing the order. read more

Horrible delivery service. Had a miscommunication with one of the delivery guys and he called to resolve it and we explained to him what happened with the change. He hung up, and then continued to call me 5+ times and left a voicemail. I didn't see these calls because I was busy and then he proceeded to text my personal cell with a rude and degrading text message. After this service from the delivery man I will not support Goodfellas Pizza. This was uncalled for and very unprofessional on his part, mind you, it was a discrepancy of $8.00. read more

Goodfellas Pizza Pasta - text message from delivery guy, RUDE and DISRESPECTFUL on all levels, also very unprofessional. - Pizza Near Me - Bronx, New York

Favorite spot for specialty pizza in the Bronx!!! Must try lasagna slice, chicken bacon ranch slice, or the chicken bruschetta slice

Update: September.19th,2017 Yet ANOTHER dinner success. Thank you guys so much. Amazingly garlic knots, and pizza. Fast Delivery. Me and kids are satiated once again. Quick delivery. Took less than an hour to arrive after delivered. Food was still hot. Nice delivery man. Reasonably priced. Fresh food. Would definitely order again. Thank you for me and my kids dinner!!! read more

Goodfellas Pizza Pasta - I added some parm cheese and oregano. But fresh and hot. Thank you!!! - Pizza Near Me - Bronx, New York

Warning to women: if you stop in for food you might get a side of harassment with your order. Couldn't eat in peace without eyes on me the entire time. It was creepy and uncomfortable. And the pizza isn't even worth the trouble. Save yourself the hassle. read more

This place is near a college, so the food is fine for students. Don't expect anything gourmet. Hours are convenient. Prices are okay.

Tbh, Good fellas is one of my favorite pizza spots ever, everything I've tried whether it's the pasta or sandwiches, apps, etc have all been delicious!! + their customer service & delivery timing are always on point. read more

Go here for pizza all the time and love it! Usually get white pizza or chicken bacon ranch. Both are delicious! Servers are very friendly. Love the pasta too! Only giving them a 4 because I have ordered delivery from here a few times and it usually takes at least 45 minutes and I only live down the road. Still I definitely recommend but you will get food faster by going inside and ordering. read more

Is anyone watching the store?? I received a delivery of 3 slices tonight. Each was overcooked but more significantly, parts of each slice were burned! Is that the care that this restaurant shows when putting its food into a pizza box? Do they look at what they serve customers?? I have had good experiences with Goodfellas but this lack of care is inexplicable and unacceptable. Whoever was responsible should be fired. read more

We ordered a large pie with pepperoni, tomato, garlic, and extra cheese. Fast and nice delivery person. The pizza was fresh and messy (expected with extra cheese and tomato) and unequivocally exceeded our expectations - utterly delicious. Their generosity with the garlic made it that much better. We also ordered a caesar salad with breaded chicken. It's surprisingly easy to mess up a caesar salad, but that was not the case today. The dressing did not overwhelm, and the chicken was well done. All and all - we fully intend to repeat this order in the near future. Today's order deserves five stars. read more

Called in today for my girls bday and asked the owner if he can do me a "special order" I wanted a large pepperoni pie but the pepperoni had to spell out happy bday! And he did just that! My gf is the hardest person to ever make happy, but this guy outdid himself and made my girl happy! Not the mention the pizzas outstanding great flavor! Super cheesy and good sauce! I will deff come back! And dude if you read this! Thank you a million times! Making my lady happy made me a happy customer! Cheers! read more

Goodfellas Pizza Pasta - This dude made my gf the happiest gf ever lol! He spelled out happy b day and added a smiley face! You guys rock! - Pizza Near Me - Bronx, New York

My go to pizza place in Riverdale! $17.78 gets you a large EXTRA pie and 4 sides of ranch. Delicious!

Visited here after volunteering at an event. Was the closest pizza spot I could find. Slices we're about $4.50 and up. A bit too pricey for mediocre pizza. I ordered a margarita slice and the veggie slice. I enjoyed the veggie slice but the quality didn't match the price. If I'm in the area I might consider again.....possibly read more

WOW! I just took a giant bite of my Chicken Parmigiana hero which is piping hot and my mouth is doing a happy dance! This hero is HUGE and is stuffed with moist, tender chicken cutlet, a wonderfully tangy/a bit spicy tomato sauce with just the right amount of mozzarella. It arrived piping hot and the delivery guy was wearing a mask and was very friendly. He told me "It's hot, be careful" and he wasn't lying! It's been several years since I've been to Goodfellas (I normally order from Pizza Chef) but, there was a special on the Slice app so I only paid $8 for the Chicken Parmigiana hero so I figured I'd give it a shot and I'm glad I did. Also order 2 slices which look great but I told them not to bother heating them up since I planned to freeze them to enjoy later. All in all, my mouth is still doing a happy dance and I'm so full that there's no way I am going to be able to finish my hero tonight! Great food, fast, hot delivery, delivery guy wearing a mask, I'd like to say there's a negative since I never trust 100% positive reviews but honestly, on a scale of 1 - 10, I'd give them a solid 9.0. Highly recommend! read more

The pizza is good here. If you order nothing else, order the pizza. They have the specials of the day, but I've never tried them...because their pizza is THAT good!! read more

Go here for lunch every time I'm working in the area. Pizza is good and the lasagna is great. Staff is really freindly read more

Goodfellas Pizza Pasta - Lasagna for lunch...mmmmm - Pizza Near Me - Bronx, New York

A pizza place in the Bronx called Goodfellas -- NO WAY! :-) Goodfellas is good stuff, and they always have decent discounts going on. I've never eaten there (it's a small place with a few seats inside), but the delivery comes quickly and is hot upon arrival. Thumbs up for another quality pizza place in my neck of the woods. PS: Goodfellas is across the street from An Beal Bocht (see my review), which is one of my favorite bars. So if you come up here for one, it would be easy to visit the other. read more

Absolutely terrible. Delivery guy dropped our pizza pie on the dirty COVID-19 ground outside of our door and ran off. The box was partially open leaving our pizza compromised. The box was not taped up or tied up. The delivery person could have had bio contact with the food. We ordered from Grubhub and did not request contact free delivery. Via GH policy, contact free delivery is at the customer's request only. The pizza and other food could have been handed over to us with zero touch or contact. Instead, our food was thrown directly on the dirty ground. We spent $73 for this crap. When we called to speak with someone at Goodfellas, they lied about Grubhub's policy. Shortly thereafter, he started yelling at me at top of his lungs when I told him that it was unsafe to not only drop our food on the dirty floor but to leave the box unsecured, untaped and unsafe for transporting. He also responded very nastily with, "am I supposed to tape up every box?" YES! Tape up or tie EVERY SINGLE ONE. Doing so keeps your customers safe. But these people don't care about returning customers. Despicable behavior. Will NEVER order from Goodfellas (Waldo Ave) again. read more

Best pizza in the Bronx! Quick delivery! Got a large pie with a few toppings. We like our pizza well done and it was perfect! Thanks guys!!!! read more

Food is fantastic. Order is always correct. My go to take out in the neighborhood. The sauce is amazing.