I wish there was a 4.5 option because for a simple NY slice of pizza late at night, this place is amazing! even though it took a little long to get our order ready, i think it helped crisp up the crust nicely so it was worth it. large portions too! -Plain cheese - solid slice. very good. -bacon chicken ranch - wow it was LOADED and heavy. delicious. -garlic knots - was not expecting this to be the star of the show but it was my favorite.. one of the best garlic knots i've had from diff pizza places. The chewy fluffy interior texture with the crispy bottom and seasoned well.. wow. Ask them to throw in some marinara on the side too. if in the area and craving some pizza, check it out! and get the garlic knots! read more

Great pizza! The huge slices are definitely worth the price paid. Staff friendly and pleasant. Can't wait to try some of their other entrees. read more

left the Bronx in the late 90's never had any pizza better than this.... best to me anywhere else I've had.... hated years back they had a fire and was out of commission for a while but came back just the same quality or even better... but I must say I only have regular cheese pizza no toppings... no need to order extra cheese it's excellent.... read more

It's been a long time since I had a slice of pizza this large and it was great! Crust was crunchy, oregano was tasty as well as the sauce, cheese and pepperoni. I also ordered tortellini soup and I could not believe the portions and again very tasty. The chicken parm was delicious and portions were very healthy! Food quality was a solid 4-4.5 but giving this a 5 star rating cause of the portions. Will be coming back read more

Three Boys From Italy has one of the finest Italian cuisine! The pizza is fantastic crispy crust, luscious sauce and fresh topping. Their pasta entrees are equally filling with a genuine taste and big enough size. This friendly atmosphere and the hospitality of the staff are performed and it is always perceived in a warm way. It is an excellent place to have a simple yet comfortable meal like a home-cooked Italian. read more

I've had better pizza than this in the Bronx the flop on their pizza is the worse I had to hold the slice from the back and body of the slice. Not to mention if you decide to eat in good luck because the tables were full of folks sitting and waiting on their take out orders than eating in. I had to stand by the table top by the window until someone's order was ready so they can get up and leave. read more

I've ordered from here several times. My favorite is the chicken parmigiana wedge. It's always fresh and delicious. Much better than from other pizza shops I've tried. read more

Nothing fancy, good neighborhood pizza joint. Had hero and pasta. Really good. Priced right. read more

Three Boys From Italy - Meatball parm hero. Vodka sauce pasta. - Pizza Near Me - Bronx, New York

This is the BEST PIZZA EVER IN ALL OF NEW YORK!!! You have all types of people come in from everywhere to this pizza place; people from the neighborhood, First Responders, and people from everywhere else who know that this is the only place where you can get a slice of heaven. I love that Three Boys From Italy is family owned. Dominic who is now running the family business makes you feel like you are part of the family when you come visit. This place knows how to make GREAT PIZZA. The way the cheese is oily (in a good way) and not dry really shows that they only use FRESH CHEESE. Dont be surprised by the fact that they do not leave out bottles of parm, you won't need it !!!! I cant wait to be back here. read more

Three Boys From Italy - BEST PIZZA EVER ! - Pizza Near Me - Bronx, New York

ordered my food on the phone and they didn't start it tilled i pulled up. workers were cool. i got a bbq pizza it was good. cheese pizza wasn't read more

They have Great food and amazing service! Always consistent. I've never been disappointed.

They use to be open late other than that it's still good but not as good as nicks on gun hill by the 5 train.

I normally dont review mediocre pizza, but I gotta ask how a place goes from insanely great to mediocre. Like, what's the thought process? This pizza sucks, man. It used to be top notch. read more

Best pizza in the Bronx. Meat & cheese calzones are great to. Really their whole menu is good

This place is always on the to do list when we come to New York! We haven't been since their building burned. Excellent pizza! We ordered a slice of the bbq chicken pizza, a slice of bacon pizza and the garlic knots with cheese. I think the bacon on the pizza may have been smoked. They filled the slice of pizza with a lot of bbq chicken. And the garlic knots were hit, full of garlic and cheese. I would suggest ordering it with a side of marinara. read more

See all

I grew up in the area and have been going here since I was a kid (until I moved). This is in no way close to what Dominic (original owner) used to churn out. The pizza doesn't pack that old school chutzpah and hence, I was disappointed at the product they churned out. The Italian flavor, Italian charm, and Italian charisma have left the room. There were three hispanic men (nice but not the OGs) churning out these mediocre pies and a then charging $21 for 8 medium (and mediocre) slices. The large pie is around 16-18 inches I believe but it ultimately lacks the size and flavor definition of its predecessors. When a good establishment changes hand, it is customary to let people in on the fact that their is new management at the helm. The Italians who used to own this place and churn out quality product most likely went on to bigger and better things (real estate development etc) so the new boys on here are not the one we need to be seeking to fulfill our craving for 90's NYC $1.00 slice pizza. They need to change the name of this pizza joint from Three boys from Italy to Three boys from Guadalajara. I mean that with the utmost respect. There are better pizza joints in the area. read more

Three Boys From Italy - Not it. - Pizza Near Me - Bronx, New York

I am not giving any rating but have to, but I want all to know this is not the original owner. He was forced to retire due to injury. I should know since I am family. And whomever has mentioned Dominic in a review, the eldest of the three boys, had passed a few years ago. He was a wonderful man and his families pizzeria is still going strong in New Jersey on the border of Rockland County. And if you want to see Tony, the brother you know most, you will see him there sometimes. So again, good luck to these owners, but you are not the Original Three Boys. read more

Best pizza ever omg I don't even know where to start with this review but I'm so in love with this pizza ever time I come to the Bronx I gotta have a slice if you want real NY pizza then this is definitely the place to come and the prices are very reasonable too! I promise you that you won't be disappointed read more

See all

Came here out of desperation - not much else around. Wasn't expecting the world, but man was I surprised. One of the best plain slices I've had. Their specialty slices are a bit steep: $4.50 for a white slice (AYFKM?!) but the plain slices follow the subway fare rule of thumb...$2.75...and for that $2.75 you get a pretty substantial pizza slab! People complaining that a plain slice is a ripoff? Go eat your shitty dollar pizza and go away. read more

Three Boys From Italy - Plain slice. - Pizza Near Me - Bronx, New York

Big slices, but below average on what you expect from a NY slice. It was undercooked, not crispy and the cheese wasn't the best. read more

This is literally the worst pizza in New York State. The workers are rude. They upset but not once did The worker that I spoke to was disgustingly rude. Need to do much better read more

See all

I've lived in the area for 3 years and have only stopped in three times; every time I'm reminded why. Pizza's are too expensive, the wait is too long, and after all of that the food tastes bland. I ordered a personal "margharita" pizza and waited about 30 minutes which would've been fine if it was what I ordered but what I ended up getting was a regular cheese pizza the only difference is the cheese was in spots rather than all around. No basil, no flavor, nothing. I hate writing bad reviews, it makes me feel like such a karen but hopefully this is taken as constructive criticism. I'm honestly so upset, if it wasn't a far walk I'd go back and order something else or get a refund but unfortunately here we are. read more

Three Boys From Italy - "Margherita" pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bronx, New York

Pizza pretty good, but the price on the slices gonna $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$

This right here to me is one of those pizzerias from back in the days that you would never see again they've been in the neighborhood since 1968 and even with a fire they are still there family owned I've been going to this pizzeria since 1982 and I am still loyal going here love the fact that they are family owned and there pizza is delicious there is nothing better than to get that first slice at 10:15 in the morning after they open read more

Three Boys From Italy - Iconic sign before the fire - Pizza Near Me - Bronx, New York

See all

Service is awesome pizza is very tasteful don't need other ingredients. Always fast I will give a A + to this pizzeria.

This restaurant serves very fresh and very tasty food. I assume they use all natural and organic ingredients. The fettuccine alfredo, chicken parmigiana, pizza are to die for. Granted, they have the typical drinks like soda and Snapple but bring your own drink and you are set. read more

Great pizza slice, size is good and the quality of the ingredients comes through on taking a bite and tasting that sweet slice. The reason its 4 stars and not 5 is the prices, plus they charge tax on top of their own store prices, its to expensive, a slice of pizza is $3:50, thats outrageously high. All pizza follows the bus fare rule, but not this place, its sad because I was such a loyal customer and would eat their weekly, but now its once a month if I can afford a pie for the family. $4 for one topping added to each pie, meaning if you want a large extra cheese and pepperoni pizza which is what I would get for the family, it comes out to $25 plus tax, and thats with no drinks either, no soda, nothing. Here's the menu prices as of Nov 2020... read more

See all

I'm giving them three stars. The inside is revamped it looks nice and the pizza is good but I'm a New Yorker I'm not giving you more than three stars just for a cheese slice. Your really not doing pizza well if a slice ain't at least 3 stars so hopefully when I go back and get something else besides cheese they won't be a disappointment. Definitely going let you know. read more

Three Boys From Italy - Pizza Near Me - Bronx, New York

See all

A bit of the beaten path from our usual pizza spots, but we'll worth it every time! Big slices at good prices.

Excellent pizza excellent service ambiance is just a regular pizza parlor nothing fancy

Everytime I crave pizza this is my go to spot. Everyone is friendly the pricing isn't bad and the pizza is amazing...I also love there pepperoni roll, calzone and the zepoli. You get great new york pizza from this place. read more

The pizza just doesn't taste as good as it use to a few years ago . And it's so expensive now.

The absolute best. My first stop when I travel back home to The Bronx. I have been going there for 50 years. Even after they re-opened after the fire, nothing changed. Still great pizza, the best Sicilian anywhere. Now I'm hungry. Mike Mac read more

I thought the pizza here was just okay, although above average for a giant slice place. First off, this place rubs me the wrong way because they have too many rules. There's no bathroom, you pay for ice, 2 ways are prohibited...I mean I know these things can be issues in the Bronx, but you don't need to put up so many signs about them. The place is one big open space, with like 3 4-person tables and everything else behind a counter. The staff was friendly enough, and the tile work around the walls was nice looking for the Bronx, but of course all this means nothing. What does mean something is the pizza. I thought the crust, cheese, and sauce here were all thoroughly mediocre. The sauce didn't stand out and there wasn't that much to begin with; the cheese was okay quality but there was too much of it. The crust was a typical giant slice crust: doughy and completely unremarkable. As a whole, it wasn't terrible for some reason but nothing remarkable what so ever. Just because the slices are huge doesn't make it great pizza. This is pretty good for the area all things considered, but I'm not sure why this place has as good a rep as it does. I'd skip this one unless you're in the immediate area looking for a cheap meal, and even then there was a burger place on the corner that looked pretty good. read more

Best hood pizza + always a fun place to stop and its open till 3 + the old guy in the back is always there, even you think hes not, WAIT- he will pop out just for a second or two. At first gimpse- this slice may seem a bit cheesy, but alas- it is actually an acceptable sauce to cheese ratio- one of the first times i have been fooled. Get the red drink out of the fountain- it completes the three (tree) boys experience. If going on a Bronx pizza tour- It is compulsory to stop here- It is unique in its location- all of the other good Bronx Pizza spots are located in Italian strongholds-- this one has survived the transition and continues to prosper. I know people that come down from Portchester just to copp one of these slices. read more

There back!!! Super happy to see these guys back up and running! Pizza is still as good as it was before. The place is set up the same way it was before. My only issue is that I brought 3 slices, 2 with pepperoni & a regular which I thought would come out to $10.75 but when I went to pay the lady she said $11.70!!! There's Tax Now! They never taxed before, and if they did it was already included in all prices already! I love this pizza but I'm not loving this new tax thing! read more

See all

Wow, yelp did it again! On a late night ride through the Bronx I looked for open restaurants and found out that this place is open till 3 AM. Came in for a pizza got a personal pizza it's huge! Absolutely delicious crust and fresh ingredients. Fantastic thank you very much! read more

Local pizza shop in the Bronx. Been going since grade school and it was a hole in the wall with the best slices of pizza. However , since they reopened from fire , it lost a little of its flavor and the prices ha e gone up . Still decent slice and one of favs. read more

If only they were open 24 hours a day! I'd have pizza for breakfast! They have a good variety of pizza, calzone, and other New York pizza standards. My only ding is that they make me leave the house to get some of the best pizza in NYC because they don't offer home delivery and many of their subpar competitors do. Oh well...I probably need the exercise! read more

My neighborhood go-to, the pizza is a bit over priced compared to my childhood pizzerias. But they are fast and the pizza is great. I'm a cheese person, so they are not shy on it.. makes up for the price. One of the best pizza shops in the Bronx! read more