I ordered the chicken Alfredo and it was so good. Both the chicken and sauce had great flavor. I would definitely eat here again.

The pizza was great, we just got a pepperoni. The salad was okay, I love a Greek salad but could've used more cucumbers, olives and chopped onion not the whole slice. The service was fast, only waited not even 10 minutes. It's definitely more of a pick up and take back home environment because it is very tiny inside. read more

I got a chicken parm sub with fries and an order of wings, mild with blue cheese. Nothing stellar about this place, kinda small but they have a couple tables for dine in. Food is average, the sub was good and the fries were good no complaints, the wings weren't that good. Having been to buffalo NY and getting wings at the Anchor bar I know what Buffalo wings are and these are about as good as dominoes wings or Pizza Hut wings are, they're baked and sauced. So I wouldn't get them again. If I was in Warrenton I could stop by maybe try the pizza read more

I have been here a few times because it is close to work. The pizza is decent. However, the inside of the restaurant is icky! I saw an ant crawling on the table once time while I was waiting for the food. I saw dirty tissues and crumbs on the floor, when it was only 1pm! I'm pretty sure they don't clean routinely. I would come back only because the pizza is decent. But not recommending other people to come. read more

Unless I'm insane I truly don't understand why this has any positive reviews. Only leaving two stars because it was affordable so I feel like I wasn't entirely scammed. Got a steak sub (at lunch time so it should have been busy enough for the cook to give a damn) the coldest unseasoned meat with a shred of cold cheese. Decided that must have been a fluke and tried their pizza another time which was inedible. Went in ANOTHER time months later to get a slice of pizza because Panera was closed and it was the only place conveniently located. Service was so bad I literally just walked out. There are so many better business to give money too in Warrenton. read more

Since this place opened - I've tried a couple of different menu items. So far I've had their version of an Italian Sub - and their take on a meat lovers pizza. Both were tasty and filling! Not really a sit down and eat in kind of place - there are 3-4 tables as I recall - if you really want to "eat in." #Goodfellas read more

See all

Good pizza and excellent wings. Our order came perfectly with contact free delivery and was faster than anticipated. Children's chicken nuggets and fries were hot and good. What's not to like. I recommended Goodfellas for your pizza fix in Warrenton. read more

I ordered from them when they opened as Goodfellas pizza, the previous owners had it under a different name but still a pizza place. I enjoyed the pizza from the previous owners but Goodfellas pizza didn't taste fresh and the toppings weren't good quality. The pizza was extremely greasy for a large extra cheese pizza. I have not been back since and get my pizza from Ciro's in Culpeper now read more

Their pizza is easily the best in Warrenton. Staff is always friendly for carryout too. Their cheesecake is also really thick and creamy New York style, delicious. read more

Pizza is very good I could've gave a 1-2 star but it's not like other pizza spots out here in Warrenton. When I had order my pizza tonight it was quick, hot, and fresh, when I opened my pizza I ran into a huge issues w...... IT WASNT CUT!!!!! parts here and there might show they attempted to cut the pizza but I had to tear my pizza just to get a slice. read more

Goodfellas - Pizza Near Me - Warrenton, Virginia

Very friendly when I called my order in so that was a good start. It takes me 20 minutes to get to town, when I told her on the phone that she said okay, we'll wait a few minutes to start your order. Walked in...the place is so clean compared to the previous pizza joint there. The pie was so tasty. Not gooey or mushy...crisp crust, you could taste the sauce, not over cheese, perfect balance of veggies, meat and cheese. I think we have found our new local pizza joint. read more

Goodfellas - Mushroom, black olive and ham 14" pie - Pizza Near Me - Warrenton, Virginia

Why 5 stars? * First, it's delicious! My pepperoni Stromboli was fresh, hot, and the mozzarella strung out an arm-length when pulling it apart. The marinara was on the side and was also fresh and delicious. It was a good room temp. Not hot. Not cold. Just right. I could taste the ricotta and it was a good balance. Any more it, would be overpowering. The taste of Parmesan was perfect. We also ordered a small pepperoni pizza. We already ate a large pepperoni from here before and this small one was just as flavorful and aesthetically pleasing. I got onions rings and bone-in wings. I was told the wings were perfect. (That's coming from my daughter who can be picky about her wings). She said they were not over sauced. Her words. She liked the onion rings and I'm surprised because when I see this type, I already know I wish I didn't get them. They're like the little frozen ones with the cut up onions inside. It's good she liked them but I could do without them. * Second, this place is within walking distance of my house. Less than a mile. I could walk and eat there or drive to pick up just as quick. (When I say eat there, note there's no seating, but there are neighboring businesses with seating that might not mind your 30 min guest appearance). *Third. As far as Warrenton, (town of), pizza, this is the best there is. I wish I could re-do ALL of my Yelp pizza reviews. Goodfellas is the best pizza in Warrenton and they don't even have a brick oven. * Forth, note that sauces are at an extra cost. Adding toppings, extra cost. *And finally This is the first time I've used Grubhub, delivery. Though the process is simple and my order was quick and hot upon arrival, it cost me an extra $10. Yikes. But that's not Goodfella's issue. Just reminds me to get up and go get it myself. *Glad Goodfellas is in town. A great addition to Warrenton! read more

See all

I honestly think this is the best pizza in Warrenton. Definitely not the best appetizers. Every time I've gotten their mozzarella sticks. They were fried so long that there was absolutely no cheese in them because they exploded. But if you want pizza, hands-down, this place over any other place in Warrenton, they have the best sauce, the best toppings everything. read more

Argue with customer!! Do not have food ready and act like u do not know where you placed the order.

Where are the toppings? Ordered a medium cheese with fresh mozzarella, salami and mushrooms on the entire pizza. Saw a few mushrooms on one slice, a small sprinkling of salami appeared on maybe two (out of 6) slices, and there was no fresh mozzarella to be found anywhere. Warrenton has MUCH better to offer! read more

Tried out Goodfellas for the first time. Called in an order for an extra large all meat pizza and fried ravioli. Order was ready in 20 minutes when I arrived. Pizza was traditional crust but Goodfellas also has some other styles. The raviolis we're a nice addition, they come with a marinara sauce. I will definitely consider getting carryout from goodfellas when I'm in the area. read more

Typical conveyor belt pizza. You can literally see the marks on the bottom of the pizza. This is ok if you're trying to feed kids, but if you want something real deal, go elsewhere read more

Wanted to try a local over a chain and glad we did. Got a large pizza and some wings. The sauce list is CRAZY so we had to try a few. Would definitely go back! read more

Got a medium cheese pizza and jalapeño poppers for pick up. The staff was incredibly nice and friendly, and the place was clean. The pizza was good, nothing to write home about. The jalapeño poppers were on point and it seemed pretty reasonably priced to me. read more

Food is good, BUT NO EATING UTENSILS. For the prices, they could at least include a plastic fork.

Great variety. Love the calzones and cannoli, food is always hot and fresh, friendly staff. Great job guys

DONT RECOMMENDED THIS RESTAURANT!!!! Bad management. We placed the order and they misplaced the wing order. We called and ask if they have the delivery service and they say they do but they can't sent the delivery guy to replace my wing order and asked us to go pick up the order from the store instead. What kind of business is it ??? We have to abandoned our pizza and leave it cold and go get the replacement wing?? We paid over $50 for the cold pizza and poor management?? Poor management!! Shame on the restaurant owner that could not find a better manager or even the team to work ! read more

They close on Sunday but will still take your order online. However, you will never get it. Their phone number just rings no answer. No messages, no directions. A lousy operation and I'll never order from them again. read more

We ordered the Sicilian pizza with pepperoni & cheese pan pizza. They were the absolute best pizza I've had in a long time, certainly the best in this area. read more

The pizza is absolutely delicious. The crust and sauce to topping ratio is perfect. This is our new go to pizza place.

Don't bother paying for extra sauces, they won't bring them. Ordered boneless wings got bone in, no sauce. Margarita pizza used to be good, now no basil and looks thrown together. When this place opened it was amazing but the quality has definitely fall-in off. We kept supporting them because we love their mozzeralla sticks and boneless wings but they didn't even give me the boneless wings I ordered tonight. read more