OK folks - eating here twice in one week so yes I like this place. Ate here on 1/9/25 - Thursday for lunch. It was pleasantly busy - 8 tables full. Service was good but Sami from my early visit still stands out as a super star. We started with the meatball appetizer- very good and a large portion. Next, I ordered the Jersey Joe hoagie - everything about it was good except the Italian dressing that was drizzled on top - the dressing was sweet and not a good combo with Italian cold cuts - worse for me because I don't like sweet anything. Portion size was large so a good value. Other nit was the pickle - it was soft and not crisp - reminded me of Vlassic which again... not a fan of. Recommend they upgrade to Clausen. My wife had the gyro - same as what she got at our previous visit. It was excellent so they are consistent with the recipe. Net net - really like this place but I need to learn more about their recipes and flavor profiles to dial in on things I like versus the other options. read more

See all

Well the pizza was average and their bacon cheesy fries way over prized. The restaurant staff is lovely. The restaurant is very comfortable but I just felt dissatisfied with my meal. I don't think I'll return. read more

Fantastic pizza...one of the best I've had in the area by far. Great ambience in the restaurant...cozy atmosphere and nice TVs. Staff seemed friendly too. Would highly recommend...will be back for sure! read more

Stopped by for a quick bite on Sunday. WOW! Friendly greeting, quick and courteous service and recommendation of pizza rolls! So deilicious!!! I'll be back to try more! Excellent! read more

Well, I have tried pretty much every pizza place in the area and none of them blew my hair back until we tried Brooklyn Brothers. The inside of the restaurant seemed very nice and comfortable. Would be good for a date or a family outing. Getting a pizza was a little bit slow when I ordered in-house but if i order a head they usually have it ready by the time I get there. My only complaint is that they don't offer any specials or discounts, but their pizza is so good I guess they don't need to. read more

Haven't tried the pizza yet but it looked good. I opted for the meatball sub and a pear and Gorgonzola salad. The salad was very good and filling. The sub was good but the meatballs lacked flavor. I'll definitely try another sub for sure. That is based off the bread. Service was great and it was quiet and clean. read more

Great atmosphere, Pizza was excellent. Service was excellent Easily accessible Will definitely go back read more

Pizza/ salad combo was great. Service was great. I'll be back. Cool spot. :)....

One of the very best burgers and spaghetti in this area. Most importantly, the burger is tender, the steak is rich in flavor, and they provide a side salad. The service is very good too. read more

The pizza here is always incredible. Service is quick and friendly. Always greeted as I walk in. read more

Brooklyn Bros Pizzeria - A nice delicious small pepperoni pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Gainesville, Virginia

Stopped in on a random Saturday afternoon on my way to the airport because I was feeling some wings. For some reason they had college softball on every tv, nothing wrong with softball but other sports were available ‍ Staff was nice, waitress was good, knew the menu, didn't hover. The wings looked good. The sauce needed a little more bite, like some vinegar or something tangy but not terrible. The blue cheese had good chunks in it, so it was good. Overall not a bad experience, food was pricey but not outlandish for the area. I'd go back to try other items on the menu read more

Brooklyn Bros Pizzeria - Honey BBQ Wings & Blue Cheese Dressing - Pizza Near Me - Gainesville, Virginia

I was about to leave a new review about the consistently great food and service, and then saw 10 years ago I left a review with the same sentiments I still have today. Appreciate Brooklyn Bros. being a reliably great part of our community. Still love the pepperoni rolls and mushroom ravioli and always love the pizza and the welcome atmosphere. read more

Pizza had good flavor but bottom crust was overdone. Large cheese and pepperoni was over $22

Way too expensive! Nearly $70 for two small 12 inch pizzas plus tax, delivery charge, and tip. Pizza was good and delivery was fine (hence, 3 stars otherwise it'd be 2 or 1 star), but not worth the money. I won't be back. At these prices, they will be out of business in a year. read more

From the moment you enter this restaurant until the moment you leave you will have a great everything! I'm not sure why we didn't know of this place until recently but now that we found it, that's the only place where we get our pizzas from! People that work there are always kind and helpful. Pizza is always delicious and we are also addicted to their Alfredo and pesto pasta omg soooo good! Strongly recommend this place! read more

I came here with my daughters on my their birthday to enjoy a good meal. The waitress was nice-ish I mean she did help me clean up the ranch that she spilled when she was taking the plates from our table, besides that we didn't see her much. We got the bill I gave the waitress my cc and I put my money for my tip on the table and left a tip on the card too since I didn't have a lot of cash. Now mind you the tip on the credit card was only $4.12 and it rounded my bill up to $82.00 even and like I said I left cash as well. When my credit card payment went through I was charged with $92.00 payment the waitress changed my $4.12 tip on cc to $14.12 that is illegal and I'm very upset about this. I guess my cash and card payment weren't good enough? I disputed this payment with my cc company for the $10 the waitress stole from me. She should be fired. No I don't know her name because she didn't tell us but I didn't think to ask because I didn't think my waitress would steal from me. read more

There's no such thing as attention to detail at this place, apparently- listen to the negative reviews if you're ordering online. I paid for two extra toppings on my Mediterranean pizza- sausage and banana peppers. I received neither. I paid for Honey BBQ wings- got hot wings instead. Every single item arrived cold- the order time kept getting pushed back. Utterly disappointing experience and I will make sure to not repeat the mistake of ordering from here again. read more

Brooklyn Brothers has a great menu with a host of delicious pizza flavors to choose from. The variety is pretty broad, and the quality of their pies is quite high. The crust is crispy and acts as the perfect compliment to the fillings. The prices are actually rather low in comparison to the higher quality of the pies. They also have some none pizza options if you're not interested in pizza (hamburgers, salads, soups). The setting is warm and cozy, and the staff are very friendly and engaging. Even going so far as to remember your favorite dishes if you make this one of your regular places. read more

1st, hands down best slice in Gainesville area!!! 2nd the customer service is phenomenal and the owner is one those people who would give the shirt off his back, you can tell he's a real one. Definitely the place to go to get a pie!! read more

I can't believe I haven't written a review of this place before. We got the sausage n peppers sub. Unbelievable. They told us they get the sausage from NY n I believe them (I'm from NYC). The meatball sub, mouth drop actually told my husband to get his hands off of my sub, Chicken Philly sub - my husband said it was the best he ever had. And my son ordered the calzone, sausage, meatball n ricotta for a snack later. Love, love this place. Everyone is always so helpful. Thank you. Looking forward to our next visit. Highly Recommend! read more

Dined in at 3pm on Wednesday. Pretty good food. A little higher prices than other pizza type restaurants. We ordered breaded zucchini sticks $8.99; antipasti salad $14.99; two lunch specials: 1 slice of pizza, small caesar salad and a drink $10.95. The pizza wasn't hot, just warm. We will probably go back again. read more

See all

One of the best pizza spots in Gainesville! The crust is superb, sauce is flavorful and altogether, everything is awesome! I just wish they delivered. read more

We always have take-out orders. I believe you will always be satisfied with your order. Their pizza is delicious and their crust is very tasty. Makes me think they must put sugar in their pizza dough. They have very good grilled chicken garden salads. Also, the first time I ordered the spaghetti and meat balls I was surprised by the excellent taste of the spaghetti, the sauce, and the meat balls. All their food has an excellent taste and flavor and their portions are generous. read more

See all

Great service, ambiance is 'neighborhood pizzeria' but the food we have ordered has all been delicious! The ravioli was outstanding! I will go back again and again for the ravioli alone!! read more

**3.5 stars** Went back to Brooklyn Brothers last Saturday evening for dinner with my family. We were celebrating my Sister-in-Law's birthday. My brother, his wife, two daughters, my Mom, and I went for dinner. I've never eaten in here - only gotten pizza to go. We were seated immediately - we were greeted by some cheerful folks. We ordered Mussels and Calamari as appetizers. My Mom and I ordered the Linguini with Clams, my brother and Sister-in-Law both ordered the Stromboli, and my nieces ordered the Spaghetti and Meatballs and pizza, respectively. The Mussels were good - but nothing outstanding, the Calamari was fried and very tender - very good. The Linguini with Clams was just average - I added some Black Pepper and some Parmesan cheese - but it was nothing to rave about. Both my brother ans Sister-in-Law raved about how good their Stromboli was. The service was attentive and good. I will come back and try some other things on the menu! read more

I have ordered from this restaurant for many years. I love the food but online ordering is the reason I am breaking up with them. Tonight I placed an order for Veal Parmesan. I requested fettuccini Alfredo as my pasta instead of the usual red sauce pasta. Someone called and wanted to confirm. I said I want the veal parmesan with the red sauce and fettuccini Alfredo as the pasta. He argued with me, he said that is a whole different order. I finally lost it, not my finest moment. I will never order from here again. I am surprised a simple order is so hard to comprehend The owner called and apologized. I told him I appreciated him reaching out. I have to admit, it would be hard to break up with their Greek pizza read more

Very nice restaurant if you are looking for Italian food. Great pizza selection. Lots of choices and plenty of appetizers. Server was nice and friendly. Plenty of parking. Restrooms were clean. I have a calzone which was amazing. My wife had a hero which she enjoyed. Wish they had Manicotti though. read more

Solid pizza and amazing wings. Ordered from there several times and they are consistent on food quality. Highly recommend!

Do NOT order from here. We placed an order and we're charged $122.26 via Apple Pay, the receipt from the business, which is take out or delivery only, is for $96.75. We called and were told that it's because we ordered online. That is a surcharge of $25.51 or a little over 26%. Flipping ridiculous! Needless to say we will not be going back. read more

Brooklyn Bros Pizzeria - the receipt for the pizza - Pizza Near Me - Gainesville, Virginia

Pizza had Great flavor good service Delivery was spot on very nice young man Just moved to the area happy with Brooklyn Bros pizza read more

Happy mistake of Parms. Received dinners instead of sandwiches but came out on top. Salad, parm on top of spaghetti ! So full and bringing the rest home for dinner. Nice home atmosphere. Lots of room and tables. Tvs on sports and great 70's music. Sweet server! He was attentive and did not make us wait. Great food! read more

YUMMY & FAST!!! We've ordered delivery for the first time today and they didn't disappoint!!! The Supreme Pizza was delicious!!! The crust was not that thick and the toppings was just right, sauce not that salty at all! The honey bbq wings were crispy and good! This is now our fave pizza place!! read more

Brooklyn Bros Pizzeria - Supreme Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Gainesville, Virginia

See all

There was a group of about ten of us for lunch on a Friday and the place wasn't very busy, but the service was very slow.

I am so tired of Warrenton's pizza situation. Boring with no flavor. Every pizza place out there. I told my son today, while driving home from Centreville, that we'd stop by and get some to go. I walked in that door and the fresh pizza smell hit me right in the face. When you walk in and smell pizza at a pizza joint thats a good thing! Think about that next time you walk into your local pizza making place. What does it smell like? We got a simple large pepperoni and it was delicious. The guy that took my order was very nice. I think he said he worked there for 7 years and he loved the smell too. The pizza was good when we got home. I'm sure it's out of sight to sit there and eat it while its hot. I'm going to come back and try the veggie sub. The cost was like $16 and change!! Most pappa John and such places average out to be more expensive and have no flavor whatsoever. I'm glad we thought to come here. Its not too far out from us really.. its worth it. read more

See all

Customer service is rude. Online ordering is hit or miss. And when you call to ask for an update- you are treated as if you are intruding into their day. This used to be my go to spot but I will wait until service improves before I order from here again. read more

Awesome food. Great service. The delivery people are very nice as well! Always recommend this place and love eating their homemade pizza.

Great Service!!!! Wonder food, pizza and bruschetta was authentic and certainly on point. I would highly recommend this pizzeria

Very Good, I never rate Great.. because I am in search of. These folks have never let me down. Few mishaps, but overall excellent, reliable good food. THANK YOU BROOKLYN BROS GAINESVILLE VA. read more

I've been coming to Brooklyn Brothers pizza for more than a year. I've never been disappointed with the food, the friendly service or the value for the price. I've had their Italian wedding soup, chicken noodle soup, garden and Cesar salads, their gyro, their cheesesteak, their pasta and their pizza. It's New York classic Italian in Gainesville. The staff and owner take pride in delivering a consistent experience every time. If you're looking for a quality pizza or Italian food at a reasonable price, check out Brooklyn Brothers. Good for solo meals, dates or the family - with classic arcade games in the back for the kids. Brooklyn Brothers is a gem in Gainesville / Haymarket. Take the time to check them out. read more

When I called to place my order, the person on the other end immediately placed me on hold. After a six-minute hold, I finally was able to place my order. They said it'd be ready in 15 to 20 minutes. I gave them at least 30 minutes because I ordered a gluten-free pizza and I understand that a lot of companies don't make a lot of these, and it could take a little extra preparation. When I went into the facility, they weren't busy, but the guy at the front told me to "hold on" after I said I was there to pick up my pizza. Meanwhile, he messed with a delivery bag that went nowhere, as I stood at the counter waiting. In the end, I spent $15 and some odd cents for an average-sized gluten-free pizza and I'll have to place it back in the oven because it is very undercooked. Doubt I'll give them a try again. Poor customer service and they obviously don't take their time into preparing the food. read more

Brooklyn Bros Pizzeria - Undercooked Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Gainesville, Virginia