Excellent food and staff. always super polite if there is a mistake. Highly recommend to anyone…read morelooking for a good place to eat that is also convenient. Mal

So for the last few months I've been conducting my own personal search for the best buffalo chicken…read morepizza in Wayne and I think I found it ::insert fanfare!:: Ok so what's so good about it?? Unlike other spots in town Pizza One uses buffalo sauce as the base on the pizza, which is the only way go! Topped with mozz and buffalo chicken it's simple and so so good! Other places in town use a red sauce as their base which does not make sense to me. Another spot in town uses buff sauce but drowns their dough in it and that is just too much sauce, man. Pizza One has figured out the right sauce/cheese/chicken ratio. Their regular cheese pie is a winner too. They do a really nice thin but not too thin crust here which works for a plain pie but also is a nice base for loading up with the toppings too. I also have to talk about their garlic knots. Also the best that I've found in town (so far anyway..). They are big, fluffy and loaded with garlic. They are served w/ marinara but if you've got an extra buck I'd suggest you spring for the vodka sauce - it's sooooo good w/ the knots. No complaints re: service or wait times for pies. Pizza One is just a super solid spot in town to get food. Bonus -- if you order online they've always got some sort of deal going on - ie: a large cheese pie and 12 wings for $26 or 3 large pies for $42. We often order the pizza/wing combo (when I'm not insisting on ordering the aforementioned buffalo chicken pizza..) and when you compare to other spots you're saving at least $5 which is not nothin'.

Second go around wasn't as good as the first . The wings…read morewere just way to big and not crispy enough. Was kinda gross how big they are. We also had a mix up with the bartender serving us. Didn't order what we wanted but she made up for it by getting the right ones in and to us quickly. Still though off entire meal. We tried the xtra large pizza which was good. Not nearly enough toppings. It was too much for 3 people with apps. The Ceasar salad again was very bad. Shouldn't be on menu that's how not good it is. Overall love the place still and will be back.

Came here today with a friend, and we ordered the bar pie and the wings. Both were very good, and…read morethe waitresses were friendly, attentive, and provided excellent service. I also ordered the chicken sandwich, which was good, but I was disappointed that it didn't come with fries. Having to pay extra for fries with a sandwich feels a bit cheap. I also wasn't happy about the 4% surcharge for using a credit card. Those extra charges leave a bad impression and take away from an otherwise enjoyable meal. The food and service were solid, but my message to the owner is this: don't nickel-and-dime your customers. Including fries with a sandwich and avoiding credit card surcharges would go a long way toward creating a better overall experience.

Was fully packed on Wednesday eve, make reservations! We waited for 30mins to be seated…read more Relaxed rustic ambiance loved the atmosphere , we had Big Red Pizza, Pesto Chicken Pizza, roasted wings, focaccia bread. Everything was great, I like the chili oil in Big red. Nice place to hang out with friends and family. Will definitely come again!

Great family friendly spot. We were in and out on a Sunday…read morenight. Great beer list with some top notch local breweries. There was a typo on price and our server changed it right away on our check. Pizza good use a few more minutes in the oven but overall good flavor. Pastas served al dente. Our little one loved her pie from the kids menu. Will return especially after a costco run or after a movie in the area.

We ate here today after meeting with the folks at the Legacy Castle about our son's wedding. We…read morefound this delightful restaurant right here on Yelp after I googled "Best Italian restaurants near the Legacy Castle." I made reservations, which we didn't actually need, but I like to play it safe when going to a new place. The service was friendly and the food was delicious. I got the chicken piccata with a half Caesar salad and both were marvelous. My husband got the Rotini with Sunday Sauce (although in our house we call it Sunday Gravy, LOL) and it was yummy. Our son's fiancee got pasta amatriciana and said it was ALMOST as good as what she'd eaten in Rome, and our son got the sausage pizza fra diavolo and LOVED the thin crispy crust. Great food and service - thank you! Not sure why the posted review says we're from San Francisco; we're actually from Allentown, PA.

I went here a couple of times and don't really like any of their food items on the menu. I only…read morecame here for the occasional event, but I would never order food here if given the choice. The pizza is stale. The service is great though and the waiters are really nice and understanding. The ambiance is nice and the decor is lovely and pretty, the aesthetics are definitely there.

Their service is terrible here. The guy in the front clearly doesn't want to work at Lucci's and…read moreseems bothered to handle anything at all. 1st time: Placed an order over the phone on Sunday evening. Guy seemed overwhelmed and reluctantly took my order. I showed up 30 min later and no one had any record of my order. I recognized the guy's voice and told him he took my order. He was pissed and got into a shouting match with me with 3 other customers around. He eventually apologized and offered a free side of meatballs and spaghetti (don't order that btw, super underwhelming). 2nd time: Wife placed an order for a pie with half pepperoni on their website. Came back with the order and the pie had full toppings. Small nit but annoying. 3rd time: I called at 6pm on a Thursday. No one picked up. Opted to place order on their website and got the same item as last time. Showed up at and the same miserable guy asked for my name and order... and then said he didn't have any order. I told him I placed an order on the website... and he said "You should have called." with an awful (only a mother can love) grin. I showed him my email confirming 6:20pm pickup time and he said he had no order... before pulling a pie with my name on it. I asked if it had half pepperoni and it didn't. Full toppings AGAIN. Clearly, their website is not equipped to actually take half toppings orders. Pizza is OK but not worth the headache or poor service here.

So when I want a slice of pizza late night "lately" this has been my go to spot. They close at…read moremidnight except for Friday and Saturday which is at 2am. I love a slice of pizza that has the crunchy bottom and the pepperoni is charred and cupped. Their white slice is good too. If you want that crunch but not too crunchy come here for a late night slice. They have pastas and sandwiches but never had it. Maybe one day. Pros: - Quick and friendly service - Crunch bottom pizza slices for those who love eating it this way - Opens late on the weekends until 2am - Want coffee?? Dunkin is next door but they close a lot earlier than here Cons: - Limited seating area - Small parking lot but late night there's always a spot Come check them out for a late night slice!

We moved back to Jersey a year ago and could not find great pizza. We have finally found it!!!…read more Have been here twice already in a week. The smell of the wood fire as you walk in is amazing. And if you've forgotten a beverage - there's a liquor store across the parking lot!!! Mike is great to speak with as he preps the dough and everyone who comes in is a regular!

We stopped here one afternoon, the owner had just come out of the hospital but came in to work…read moremaking pizza. The pizza came out in only a few minutes, very good and would highly recommend going here. Great place try it out, talking to the owner he was very friendly and accommodating.

The cheese slices definitely stood out! I was eating here and pretty much everyone came in after…read moreordered the cheese slices. My eggplant panini was okay.

I love their cheese slice! This is definitely my favorite slice in the area. I've had their vodka…read morechicken, bacon &chicken and plain Slice. I liked their chicken& bacon slice but nothing beats a good plain cheese slice. It's crispy and perfect thickness!

Bar pie extra sauce well done absolutely delicious no flop on that Crust. Harley recommended…read morelooking forward to going back. They also have some other things that look absolutely delicious.

Solid pizza! Service is always prompt, accurate, and relaxed. What I appreciate about Pizza Boys is…read morethat their food is always consistent, so you know exactly what you are getting. You cannot go wrong with any of the slices here. They are always well-made and delicious. That said, we have tried several of their offerings and have been happy every time. Staff are chill. Overall, recommended!

Hand down, best pizza experience/food I have ever experience so far. The service was amazing and so…read morewas the food. I think the gentleman who served us was named Dave/David? Not too sure, but he was friendly and did a great job making the food as well. I have been here multiple times, and each time feels like the first time I've ever had their food because its that good. Overall, the quality of service and food are definitely worth five stars. I highly recommend checking this place out. FYI Its personal pies, so you cant get sliced or the regular pies that you order elsewhere. Portions are reasonable.

Great place with amazing pizza. Wish they still ran the storefront instead of just a road showread more

Neil's is the BEST of the BEST!!! Amazing food AND amazing customer service…read more Been faithful customers for months now & not had one bad experience. they're always so accommodating, prompt & eager to help! It's so fresh and delicious. Today my mom and son went for pizza and got stuck inside due to an unexpected thunderstorm & an employee walked them to their car with an umbrella- just above and beyond, truly! They've even offered to cut up my toddler's pizza into little bites whenever we go. just love them! no bad things to stay!

Easily one of the better pizza spots in Wayne, tucked into a convenient strip mall across from the…read morehigh school and near a Whole Foods. It's the kind of place where you can grab the kid from school, order a solid pie and knock out your grocery shopping in the same trip -- a small luxury that feels surprisingly efficient for townies. An excellent white pie which pairs even better with spinach if you're feeling like a filling meal.