Primo has been popular takeout spot among my friends and recently it has become my family's Friday night pizza spot. The pizza is always fresh and the sauce holds its own against other pizza places in the area. The real standout surprised me - the empanadas. I was a little skeptical about ordering empanadas from a pizza place but a friend recently raved to me about them. I decided to give them a try and ordered two of the spinach + feta and one ham + cheese. The dough was pillowy soft and contained the perfect amount of filling. Quick tip: they are not listed on the online menu and are inside a case next to the register. This is mostly a takeout spot but there is a fair amount of indoor seating. The parking lot is fairly small and is shared with a pool hall and Wayne Steakhouse. Staff is friendly and happy to help. Highly recommended ordering from Primo if you are in the Wayne/Pompton Lakes area. Plain Pie: 4/5 Spinach Empanada: 5/5 Ham and Cheese empanada: 5/5 read more

Primo Pizza - Empanadas - Pizza Near Me - Wayne, New Jersey

See all

Walked into this empty spot and soon realized why that was the case. The owner appears to be hostile and not welcoming at all ! Had their chicken parm slice which was pretty good but the Sicilian slice was tasteless! The tables were sticky! A nope for me! read more

See all

Food is amazing. The Service is a amazing and i would recommend them. The ambiance is so good. read more

Family of 4 had different slices each. All were tasty. Good crust, nice sauce. My kids liked the amount of cheese. Garlic knots delicious - very garlicky. Friendly employees. Good stop! read more

This place has become our go to pizza place over the last few years. Of course there are a million pizza places in this area, but Primo is the only one that has been consistent every time. The restaurant itself is pretty bare-bones and not super aesthetically pleasing but it doesn't even matter because the food is always so good. Service is always fast. Even on a busy Friday night, food is always ready within an hour. Will always continue to come back here. read more

We order from Primo once or twice a week. Consistent, delicious, and always accommodating. We've also catered several of our large parties from them and always get complimented on the food. Price is good, portions are great. The red sauce (gravy) is on par with most of the Italian restaurants in the area. We get the Tortellini Alfredo with chicken cutlet all the time and it always hits the spot. And if you order their garlic knots, which are awesome, you might get an extra one or two. No guarantees of course but we have been lucky a few times. read more

Always delicious and a nice crew working there. Tried many things on the menu and it's always fresh and tasty.

Easily the best pizza in the area. And their food is incredible too - love their sandwiches, salads, and dinners. They also do great trays for catering. Not your average pizza place and has good prices. Great service and the owner is a fantastic guy who treats his customers right. Been going there for 15+ years. The staff is friendly. read more

I've eaten here a few times and for the most part the pizzas are ok. Ordered a margarita pizza and was disappointed. Looked like all they did was add tomatoes on top of a plain pizza. read more

Primo Pizza - Margarita pizza - Pizza Near Me - Wayne, New Jersey

Regular place ...almost weekly we order food for pick up or delivery! I have not always provided a review, but wanted to share how consistently good they are. Fresh, tasty and timely! They have your food ready for pick up and deliver in a timely manner when ordered. More than just a pizza place... sandwiches, wings and much more! My entire family enjoys the food and my order today was great. Also wanted to share each and every time I visit, the team is ready, pleasant and helpful. Thanks for being a neighborhood location I welcome to frequent often. Check them out! read more

Our go-to spot for pizza in our area. The pizza is always consistent and they have the best chicken Vodka parm sandwich in the area. Even during busy times, we never have to wait long for our food. read more

Grilled chicken wrap was delicious. Will try the salad later on for dinner . The curly fries were soggy ! Will order again read more

If I could give zero stars I would. Was in there today.. waiting to pick up my togo order (which was ready). I guess another customer walked in who the owner knew and he went right ahead and grabbed his food and rang him up. I was literally shocked. He is beyond rude and I will never give PRIMO another dollar and will be sure to tell everyone I know in town to do the same. This isn't the first time I have had a bad experience with the owner, but it will definitely be the last. So many other better Pizza spots- do not give this asshole any of your business! The pizza also sucked- which made this so much better. read more

Regular place ...almost weekly we order food for pick up or delivery! I have not always provided a review, but wanted Tis share how consistently good they are. Fresh, tasty and timely! They have your food ready for pick up and deliver in a timely manner when ordered. More than just a pizza place... sandwiches, wings and much more! My entire family enjoys the food and my latest pie with different toppings --simply wonderful! Also wanted to share each and every time I visit, the team is ready, pleasant and helpful. Thanks for being a neighborhood location I welcome to frequent often! read more

My go-to pizza spot in the area. I have only gotten pizza from primos, and it's so delicious, well balanced, and when you ask for it, well done, perfectly crispy. I'm simple and get a plain cheese pie every time. read more

Omg this place is def a hidden gem. Stumbled upon this restaurant one Saturday night and fell in love!! They have awesome pizza, fettuccini alfredo and awesome spaghetti and meatballs. We have ordered from them frequently over the last month and quality is always consistent. Check them out!! read more

Come on in and enjoy excellent pizza say hello to Cesar and have him recommend a nice dish for you. I have been coming here for years and the food has not disappointed me. read more

At first this place look any other pizza joint but it's not! Their food is awesome! From salads to subs to pizza and pasta! Everything that I have tried has been delicious even the gelato ice cream. This place will not disappoint you. Go by yourself or bring the whole family. read more

Primo Pizza - a plate of food on a table - Pizza Near Me - Wayne, New Jersey

We ordered a plain pie and it was incredibly greasy! My plate and hands were covered in grease. Yes, I know pizzas will be a bit greasy but this was unfortunately on another level. The flavor was simply so so. It did its job of keeping us full for the rest of the evening. The customer service was good and prices were fair. Not sure that I'll be back. read more

I recently ordered catering from Primo for the first time and had a fantastic experience. They were patient with my multiple calls, organized with my order and everything came out hot and on time. The food was delicious! Honestly some of the of the best penne vodka I've ever had, my guests were so excited to take left overs home with them. The trays went a long way and were reasonably priced. They even gave us extra bread and garlic knots which was a nice surprise. I just found my new go-to for Italian take out and I'm looking forward to returning. read more

I've never had their pizza, so I can't vouch for that.., it their eggplant dishes are excellent. The eggplant parm is a little different, in that it's cut up into smaller pieces, but it's topped with lots of cheese and the sauce is good. I love that they offer rigatoni as a pasta side option. I never see that. I usually order through the Slice app but I've called them to ask them something and they've always been friendly. read more

Prosciutto & mozarella panini was super good! Great portion along with the fries. Will be ordering again.

Ordered delivery. Got a pepperoni pie - too oily and thin. Sausage roll was decent but not the best. Cheesesteak sandwich was great.

I always get my pizza from here and it's always delicious but today was craving linguine with white clam sauce. The portion was huge! It was probably the best white clam sauce I've ever had. My picky 6 year old even loved it! Highly recommend, everything I've ordered from here has been delicious. read more

I've been going to this place since 4th grade and now I am 22 years old and about to graduate college. Yes the place has gone through lots of changes but all for the better of the customers and Resturants. Anytime I want pizza I can count on them to deliver in a reasonable amount of time and always will make what ever you ask for. The employees are wonderful. Especially the owner Ceaser who will go out of his way up help you and gives you very accurate times for pick up. Also if you get there and don't see a pizza slice you want he will most likely make a whole pie just for you and give you as many slices as you please. Prices are extremely fair and I would recommend to anyone who wants great pizza to head to primo! read more

We ordered from here while on vacation. The person that took our order was very accommodating as we inquired about the free 2 liter with the purchase of a large pizza. He took our order and promised 45 min. delivery. It was around 40 minutes later when we got a call from the front desk of the hotel that our pizza arrived and we remembered we forgot to ask for plates. To our surprise they had us covered and delivered plates with the pizza this might be usual for them but in Chicago if you don't ask for plates and utensils you most likely won't get them. We ordered the following: A large sausage and cheese pizza - 16 inches Two personal pizzas one with just cheese and the other cheese and sausage 12 inches A order of garlic knots Everything tasted good but New York/New Jersey style pizza is just too thin for this Chicagoan I didn't know to fold the pizza and felt as if I might chip a tooth with every bite lol Note to self fold pizza before eating read more

My husband and I order from this place basically 3+ days a week (maybe more because I'm too lazy to cook). We just ordered a pizza with extra cheese, basil, and sauce. It was super awesome. Best in a long time. They always have great pizza, but this time was superb. The cheese was full of flavor. We order from all the local places to try them out but always come back to them. The salads, dinner entrees, and even the darn burgers are great. Gelato is a nice perk too. read more

Primo Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Wayne, New Jersey

Never again. After ordering the same thing weekly for 5 months now. They still messed up my wife's order of Disco fries. Its the only things she eats from there. Instead of fries cheese and gravy they gave her and oversize portion of just waffle fries. No attention to detail with the chicken fingers either. All stuck together, some orders 5 strips some orders 3 now its just gross. Details & Communication need attention. Stop staring at the big screen and double check orders. I regret ordering 3 pies on fathers day too & only because V&J didn't have a delivery guy yet. I wish them luck. By the way we had V&J pizza the other night I walked in right before they closed, he so nicely put the last slice of a meat pie in the oven and a side of warm red sauce and let me tell you it was banging. read more

After reading the two reviews written here, I was hesitant to bring my family for lunch to Primo's. It was close to a place we were visiting, and the kids were hungry, so we gave it a shot. The pizza by the slice options were limited, but enough for satisfy the kids. My wife and I ordered sandwiches, and the staff was more than accommodating with a few changes we requested. The sandwiches were made quickly, and they were very tasty! The bread particularly tasted very fresh and had a nice soft texture to it. The best part was dessert. While the options were limited, I LOVED what I chose, which was a three layer chocolate mouse type dessert. Just amazing. So I would not judge this place based on the other two reviews. Their food is good, and they are definitely worth a shot if you are in the area. The only area of improvement: whole wheat rolls for the subs. read more

Best take out we have had in this area! Have tried them a couple times and the food is consistently amazing, I'm obsessed with the chicken sandwich with vodka sauce and fresh mozzarella it's such a large portion i can't finish it in one sitting. The pizzas are great too and the dinners. They are quick with delivery and the food is always HOT when we get it. read more

My coworkers and I occasionally get delivery from here, since its probably the closest pizza joint to us. Not the greatest food, but I don't think it's deserving of one star. Are you really expecting high quality, authentic fare from a strip mall pizzeria? This is fast food version of Italian, like most other pizzerias folks. Doesn't make it right, but let's be fair. We like to get the spinach rolls - big, nice and crispy with lots of spinach and cheese, but admittedly on the greasy side. Pizza here is nothing to get excited over, but its not terrible. Some of my coworkers get the salads too, and nobody's complained. read more

I always get my pizza from here and I buy their pizza dough also. The pizza is always excellent and the dough is the best around. I definitely recommend this place. read more

"oh yeah" grandma pizza with extra pepperoni & extra sauce. bangin' delicious! read more

Primo Pizza - Grandma Pizza (Xpepp & Xsauce) - Pizza Near Me - Wayne, New Jersey

This rating would be a lot higher if I didn't have this one issue. 2 days ago I had bought a Large Pie half with BBQ Chicken, Broccoli, and Ranch on top and the other half French Fry. The total had come out to $18. Today I go and I got a small pie. This time when I go to pick it up, the cashier says it's "$20". I question it and bring up the price before and they lower it to $17.59. This i do not understand at all. How is a small pie with the same stuff on it almost more expensive than a Large pie of similar kind. Are you telling me that I could have gotten the large pie for a dollar more? This honestly got me upset and it takes a lot to get me upset and make reviews about places. I would like an explanation for this outrageous price jump and if it was a mistake on the cashiers fault Id like to get some type of money or something back. Everyone makes mistakes and it's fine but I'd like to get something to make up for this. If this issue is explained and fixed I will adjust my rating to 5 because the pizza is great and people there are truly nice. read more

It's the best pizza in this area.. actually, everything is good from there! The subs, the dinners, the appetizers all delicious!

Pizza is pretty good. Their special sub with chicken cutlet and vodka sauce is Delish!

THE BEST PIZZA IN WAYNE,NEW JERSEY. The attention of its staff, always helping the client politely and helpful. Given the opportunity, come and try, not based on the comments of some people liars. Always, each based from their point of view. Try and draw their own conclusion read more

This has been my favorite pizza place for pick up and delivery, though tonight ordered for delivery and they never showed up! At least a phone call would have been nice. Well the pizza showed up 45 minutes late...after some heating up it was good read more

The pizza is OK at best but be careful the guy with the bald head and goatee (owner I think) is very cheap and overcharged us. The pizza we got was half specialty, we thought they would average the price of $14 and $16.50 to $15.25, but instead they charged us 17.25 by adding a $2 delivery charge even though we picked it up IN THE STORE. He refused to change it by claiming that it was still cheaper than Frank's pizza. I told him I would be writing a poor review if he didn't change they DO NOT value customer service. Beware: DO NOT GO. I am never going again. read more

I've been to probably 20 pizza places since I moved to new Jersey... Very impressed with quality and flavors... Good prices...taking my family back... read more