This place hits every time. I usually stop in for a penne vodka slice on lunch break. Consistently delicious and the guys there are chill. Sometimes I try a different slice when I go and everything is good read more

Pizza Boys - Penne Vodka Pizza Caesar salad pizza - Salad Near Me - Riverdale, New Jersey

Solid pizza! Service is always prompt, accurate, and relaxed. What I appreciate about Pizza Boys is that their food is always consistent, so you know exactly what you are getting. You cannot go wrong with any of the slices here. They are always well-made and delicious. That said, we have tried several of their offerings and have been happy every time. Staff are chill. Overall, recommended! read more

Walked in the place to pick up an order we'd called in. No one looked at me or said "Hello" or gave me the finger or anything. It was strange. I stood by the counter and no one looked at me. Finally one of the kids asked me if he could help me. Picked up my meatball parm and went home. Paid two extra dollars for garlic bread, and two extra dollars for extra cheese. I do not believe there was extra cheese, and for two dollars, I should have NO doubts there was extra cheese. There wasn't really even enough cheese on it for there to have been a regular parmesan sandwich. So that 13 dollar sandwich became a 17 dollar sandwich. I do not think that was a good deal. And I do not believe that it was served on garlic bread. I've had lots of garlic bread, and I can always tell it's garlic bread, mostly because it tastes like garlic. I actually forgot we ordered it on garlic bread until my last bite, which was all bread, and I noticed the distinct lack of garlic. Also missing were some meatballs. There were perhaps four or maybe five small meatballs on this 10 inch roll. It was very sparse. The sauce was good. Overall, not very impressed with this place. It was a poor first impression. I suggest training the people who work there to greet customers as soon as they walk in. Just have someone yell "Hello, we'll be right with you!". Or give a smile and a nod toward the counter. or SOMETHING. I know margins are slim at a restaurant, but maybe put an extra meatball in the sandwich, and some extra cheese on if you're going to charge two dollars for extra cheese. Don't think I'll be going back. read more

Pizza test: cold slice first. Yeah, I'm that guy. If a slice tastes good cold, I already know it's gonna be fire hot. And this one passed. Solid flavor, good structure, no sad, floppy regrets. Once I try it hot, I might have to upgrade this review because I can already tell it's heading there. Service was straight to the point. Pizza guy had me in and out, no small talk, no life story, just pizza. Some people want a full Broadway performance with their slice... I'm here for the food, not the monologue. Didn't explore past the showcase, but from the front everything looked clean, organized, and no red flags flying. Simple spot, doing what it's supposed to do. Cold today. Hot next time. Either way, it's already heating up. read more

Pizza Boys - Salad Near Me - Riverdale, New Jersey

Love Pizza Boys! Excellent Jersey pizza, great service and super friendly staff! Only downside is just 3 small tables. Still great to drop in for a few slices - many varieties made just need to be warmed up, or to go. Still have to try other menu items so far just different kinds of pizza but all really good. read more

See all

Excellent pizza as well as the apple salad (and the focaccia I had with it: amazing), the area needed a solid pizza place and this place is it! read more

Got a coupon in the mail for this place and saw that it was new so figured we would try it. We were SO impressed. We got the hot honey chicken panini and the hot honey pepperoni pie. Both were excellent. We ordered for delivery and the delivery was right on time and the driver was very nice. Will definitely be ordering from here again! Super unique menu and convenient location. read more

Pizza Boys - Hot honey chicken panini - Salad Near Me - Riverdale, New Jersey

See all

Pizza was just ok. People were raving about it. It wasn't horrible but then again it wasn't great

Very strange the first bite of the plain slice was actually very very good, but as I worked in the cheese was cheap the sauce was not to my liking the Sicilian slice that I got tasted like it was a day old read more

Went to Pizza boys for some pizza, eggplant wrap, cheesy garlic knots and a ham and cheese calzone. The plain cheese pizza was just meh. It tasted like the kind you would get from seaside. I never really liked shore pizza, but if that's your thing then this place is for you. The eggplant wrap was ok. I felt like it needed more balsamic. The garlic knots weren't that bad. Maybe the best thing I ate for this dinner. The calzone was so-so. It needed more taste (maybe more salt). The place is just ok. Not the best but not the worst. I did an online order and it was on time, the people were super nice and welcoming. It is small inside and there aren't a lot of places to sit, but that is typical of most pizzerias. read more

Found this place last month after nearby go to changed owners. Right off the bat was impressed w sicilian pie! Then regular pie, then ordered eggplant rollatini one week and was out of this world! Ordered w side salad. The order was 3 huge pieces. Ordered tonight and was very disappointed. This time i ordered w pasta on the SIDE. the young girls taking orders do not listen, had to repeat order and address several times and still got the order wrong! What came was very small pieces on TOP of too much pasta without any sauce to boot! Hopefully was just because very busy, if not i give up on Jersey pizza places, not same as when i lived on Nyc read more

Another great experience! Tried a new salad and wasn't disappointed, everything was great! read more

See all

Finally, after my go to pizza place closed up I was lost, but now I'm back enjoying pizza again I only eat the pizza but the family loves the chicken parm with vodka sauce sandwich read more

I ordered two cheesesteak sandwich was a large sandwich. Very nice delicious steak unbelievable. Great service very nice people.

I stopped into Pizza Boys and tried their Hot Honey Chicken Panini. It was awesome!! Just the right amount of spice. Not to hot and not to mild. The pizzas at the counter looked fresh and delicious so when I come back I definitely want to try some of their slices. The staff was very friendly as well so that's always a plus. I highly recommend coming here!! read more

Stopped in today for a quick lunch had spinach egg drop soup it was delicious. Hot and very tasty. I can't wait to try the pizza it all looked delicious read more

Stopped here for a couple slices for lunch while I was working in the area. Didn't know I was about to have some of the best slices of pizza I've ever had in my life. Pizza Boys is the answer. read more

I didn't know about Pizza Boys until I saw it on DoorDash. I get the idea it's fairly new. Ordered a steak and cheese pressed sandwich, calamari and eggplant parm entree with spaghetti. The calamari is one of the best in the area. Lightly breaded with flour, not over cooked and not overly salted. Could use a bigger side of sauce but was really excellent. The steak sandwich was a wrap which was filled with meat, onions, mushroom and cheese. Would order it again. Eggplant parm, which I order from every restaurant that offers it, was also one of the best in the area. The side of spaghetti was a little on the small side and it really could use more sauce, as it was pretty dry. Minor complaint. They use nice plastic containers and delivered using a bag! I love that. I am tired of dealing with these bulky boxes to recycle after getting Italian food. It's also hard to pick up a box if you have a bad back or bad knee. The bag is so much easier. Will be a regular customer and I hope they do well. read more

Incredible pizza, with an incredibly kind staff. Enough said. For sure a new go-to spot when in town.

best pizza sinec i moved to riverdale nj over 10 yrs ago 20/10. nice crisp thin crust.

Pizza made just the way I like it. Thin well done not burnt. Perfect. Close by pizzeria for delivery eat in or pick up.

Went there for the first time. Pizza was oblong and flimsy and sausage was spicey. It's to bad always wanted to try them.

Fairly new spot. We've gotten food here now 4 times now (twice this week). It's seriously SO good. Everything is fresh. The pies are unbelievable. Great salads and entrees. And the delivery guys are SO nice. This is our new pizza place for sure!!!! read more

I've been going here weekly and making a point to order a different pie every time, always a great experience great pies and great people.

We decided to try this place and damn, simply amazing!!!! We ordered a Sicilian pie and it had to be one of the best pies we've had in a while. Light, crispy and truly really fresh ingredients. Can't wait to order again. Highly recommend!!! read more