Love their burgers…read more Great atmosphere aswell Great outdoor dining when the weather is nice

I've been there twice before, but boy howdy I'd forgotten how amazing their burgers were! Not sure…read morewhat it was called, but I had a double smash burger with grilled onions, fry sauce and double cheddar cheese. Asked for a side of house made raspberry jalapeno jelly. What a combo! Burger was cooked perfectly!!! Messy. And so worth it!!! My side was house chips. And do yourself a favor and ask for the red pepper aioli for dipping the chips in! Fantastic patio area too. I thought I was full, till I stepped into the Red Barn (on site) for ice cream. Also amazing!

Great hometown diner with the typical foods and drinks. Recommended to us by another (former)…read morelocal, we decided to go for dinner. Lots of seating and a very welcoming environment. We ordered at the counter and food was brought to our table. They brought fries for the kids meal instead of a fruit cup but quickly and graciously brought it out with a sincere apology. It was one of the best burgers I have had and all three types of fries were the perfect crispness and taste. Will definitely be recommending this anytime someone heads up to Show Low!

"Persnikkity's Food Offers a Lot: Hits the Hungry Spot"…read more Walking into Persnikkity in Show Low (which I have done many times from their old location to their new one), you immediately feel like you've stumbled onto something the town's been keeping to itself. The place has that lived-in charm where locals know each other's orders, and the staff treats you like you're part of the club from minute one. I've made the Asian chicken wrap and twisted beef Philly my reliable go-tos--they nail that balance of fresh and hearty that keeps pulling me back. The morning totchos are a brilliant mess of everything breakfast should be, the chicken and waffle hits that sweet-savory note without trying too hard, and even their bagel with salmon comes out like they actually care about it. The vanilla matcha bubble tea deserves its own mention because it tastes like someone put thought into it rather than just dumping powder into a cup. Service here makes the food taste even better--attentive without hovering, friendly without being fake. The vibe is casual enough that you can show up in whatever you're wearing, but the food quality makes it clear they're taking things seriously where it counts. It's the kind of spot where you find yourself coming back not just for one signature dish, but because the whole experience just works.​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​

Everything, and I mean everything, was good. This restaurant has a young, hip, sort of upscale…read morevibe, without being white cloth fancy. Excellent service staff. I had minestrone soup and their pitalian salad. Both were delicious! I was surprised that the beans and vegetables in the soup were cooked beautifully without being mushy in the broth. *Lovely broth without being excessively salty. I really enjoyed the soup. My partner had soup with sausage and meatballs in a cheese sauce. Out of this world! What a treat! Worth a visit is you are looking for a fun menu filled with light dishes and pizza options. If we lived here it would be a go to restaurant for sure.

Look, from all the high ratings and positive reviews came I, who unfortunately followed the…read morepopularity of this restaurant and turned up to be a bad dinner. I ordered the Spicy Meatball pizza, and while the dough was fresh, it was extremely salty and hard. The sauce and cheese were no better, being just as salty and very artificial. The "spicy meatballs" were just weird-tasting meatballs with a ton of chili flakes, not spicy meatballs. It was very cheap in quality but expensive in price. I do not recommend anyone who loves pizza to get this one. People always say the service is fast, but I had lazy service. What I mean is that you have to go up and do everything yourself except for the cooking. I almost was charged for an extra cheese pizza that I didn't order. It took about 30 minutes for this ~8 inch pizza, which wasn't that bad. But everything was just slow and there were some times where things were really busy. The restaurant itself was okay. Although it doesn't make up for the 3/10 meal, it was cushy but there were places that were pretty dirty. It's more interesting than actually good, but the booths were a little nice. Overall, I do not recommend this place. Take your business somewhere else, because I will most likely never come back to Pitalian. Sorry.

Sweet spot . We have been here many times. Food is delicious service is friendly and informative…read more Inviting and cozy inside and very cute on the deck. Always a great place to have a cold.drink and get a bite to eat. I would recommend MJ's Hideaway for a couple or even a party.

We stopped by MJ's after a round of golf at the Birdy Ranch and can't wait to to go back…read more Service was friendly, quick and responsive. Cold beers and delicious pizza.

Awesome soup and sandwich! The cannolis were the best I have ever had! Be sure to go her if you are…read moreever in Pinetop, AZ.

I can't say enough amazing things about this place. I tell everyone I talk to about their subs and…read morecannolis. With family living in Pinetop and us visiting multiple times a year, I honestly don't know how we didn't discover it sooner, but now it's a must every time we come up, without fail. I split the meatball sub with my husband, and I'm so glad I did because it was huge. Even my half had four HUGE meatballs, and they were hands down the best I've ever had. The sauce, the bread, my goodness, my mouth is watering just writing this review. I bought four cannolis to share, and while I'm glad I did, selfishly I could've eaten them all myself. Best cannolis EVER, don't try to tell me otherwise. The cupcakes were delicious, and the turkey sub was also so, so good. On top of everything, they even give you a bag of chips with each sub. The hours are limited, and you definitely need to get there early for the hot subs. If you go to Pinetop and don't try this place, you're crazy.

In a whim, we stopped and were very happy we did! The menu…read moreis thorough with lots of soups, salads, and sandwiches to choose from. Their dinner menu has a wonderful variety too. Service was fantastic! The atmosphere is quaint and cabin-y. As someone with Celiac, I very much appreciated their care in making my food safe (and delicious).

Very cute restaurant with beautiful garden outdoor seating. We arrived at noon and the parking lot…read morewas filling up very quickly. The service was super friendly. I ordered their grilled cheese with tomato bisque. Both were fenomenal, the bisque was on a spicy side. The lemonade is perfect as well. For dessert I got a slice of cherry pie, just yummy.

Food was good. Service was good. Big menu with a lot of choices. Waitress was friendly and smiledread more

Was excited to try this place with all the 5 star reviews…read more Unfortunately it fell short with us. The waffle was so tough I could hardly cut it with a knife. They used frozen blueberries which I don't like, hard to find the lemon curd, the amount was so small. Hubby had biscuits and gravy, the biscuit was hard and stale. Service was good, and food came out fast. Food was just mediocre. With so many choices for breakfast, probably won't be back.

Friendly service! Awesome menu. So many things looked great hard to only choose 1 sandwich…read more 100% I'll go back.

Simply the best! And not just for Lakeside or Pinetop-Lakeside or the mountain! Also fresh…read morecannoli, Italian Cream sodas, soups etc etc. I love this place

We had a good experience at this firehouse subs. Quick,…read morefriendly service. Good food made to order. Clean dining room. Fancy soda machine. Felt like it was a worthwhile stop!

Firehouse subs was reliable, the meat always delicious and the time it takes to get your order…read morepretty quick. It's nice to have something familiar and easy to order in Show Low when we are vacationing from the valley.

Food was great! Ordered the Patty Melt - it was almost more than I could eat. Service was…read moreexcellent!

This was a very nice find on our recent trip to the White Mountains. The menu had something for…read moreeveryone in our family that we all enjoyed. Samantha our server was very friendly, attentive and on point with recommendations. Their wings are unique in the sense they grill them and also do not sauce them but instead have a wide variety of rubs to choose from with sauces to dip on the side. I really enjoyed the flavor of the Moose's rub paired with their Cody's sauce, and this is coming from someone who's very particular with how I like my wings and rarely if ever now order them outside of my home since I typically will smoke my own. So those are something I would highly recommend. Overall we liked the casual vibe of the location along with the offerings and thus will make it a place to come back to on our next trip there.