Been here twice and each time the burgers were really good! Irish bar setting. Good bartenders. read more

Stopped in for brunch and was pleasantly surprised! The food was excellent. I had the Philly omelet, and it was absolutely delicious. Someone in our group ordered the avocado eggs Benedict and couldn't stop talking about how good it was. The burgers were cooked perfectly, too. I also tried the Peach Smash, and it was refreshing and full of flavor. The place has more of a sports bar vibe, but don't let that fool you--the food definitely exceeded expectations. The staff was friendly, and the service was great from start to finish. I'll definitely be back! read more

See all

My husband and I have eaten here about three times and every time we would order the same thing-- the Grumpy Jack's marinated burger. Today, we went to the bar to get our usuals, but we were served the regular cheeseburgers as opposed to the marinated burgers (which has a price difference). When we asked the runner who brought our food, she had to double-check with the bartender to make sure as if she didn't know the difference between each burger. We also asked for the burgers to be Medium, which they've always done right, but today it tasted like charcoal. Grossly overcooked. This was extremely disappointing considering how much we enjoyed their food, but shitty service ruins the entire experience. Never again. read more

Grumpy Jack's - Overcooked Cheeseburger* - Sports Bars Near Me - Port Jefferson, New York

Good food, good service, friendly casual atmosphere. A little loud, but it is a sports bar after all!

Went for dinner tonight, half way through I found a blond hair in my meal. I let my waitress know, who then called over the owner Trevor. He rudely asked me what the issue was, when I told him I found a blond hair, he asked is it yours or ours? Jokingly I said well I'm not blond so I'm guessing it's not mine. He came back a few minutes later and said, I see that you ate most of it but do you want something else anyway? I was not looking for a free meal, nor did I ask for one, I did eat three quarters of the meal. After paying the full bill I went to speak to Trevor. When I asked him if he had a minute he flat out told me no and tried to walk away. The way the situation was handled was horrible, and when I called him out on it, only then did he apologize. The hair in the food wasn't the issue, the way he spoke to me was. read more

Was planning on going to Hana Sushi next door which we had tried a few days ago but the food aroma from Grumpy Jack's was very inviting and we couldn't resist. Had a very nice dinner with my grumpy husband . He seemed to enjoy his wings and even chuckled at the choir group having dinner in the back which made for a very nice and happy atmosphere. He was also very punchy after two beers on tap. He had the Merman ‍ and the wave chaser. The Wave Chaser was his favorite since the Merman was a bit too bitter for his taste buds. Which is surprising considering his usual grumpy mood. Had a very nice waitress and offered an Aperol on the rocks instead of a Spritz. It was absolutely delicious and now I only want Aperol this way! I'm Mediterranean so it is now my favorite drink! The spritz part can go spritz itself. Hey owner your waitress deserves a raise! I don't know her name but young pretty with a blonde ponytail this evening shift on Tuesday at around 8:30 pm. Our bus boy and hostess were equally courteous. These kids work hard and doing a great job here! Now let's get to the yummy food - Had two appetizers and a main to share. The calamari platter was good and so were the buffalo wings not too spicy. I tried the chicken caprese and it was delectable without being too heavy and the sauce was nice to dip the calamari appetizer in. Nice and lemony !! We finished off the other an Irish coffee the mint on top of the cream was delicious - Super great service and great establishment to visit! read more

See all

If you want a comfy and cozy bar to go to for bar food, this is it. We went for a cute baby shower lunch in, they had a table upstairs and separate from everyone downstairs. Definitely cute and intimate. The drinks, was not what we were hoping for. A beer place for me. The coffee was extremely light but again, mind where you are going. The apps, all great. Mini tacos, mozzarella sticks, and popcorn chicken all great. I personally had the fried shrimp wrap with French fries and finished my plate. The dill pickles, amazing and we asked for more. Great place to go relax and for a casual dine in read more

Grumpy Jack's - Fried Shrimp Wrap - Sports Bars Near Me - Port Jefferson, New York

Burgers are amazing, thick and juicy and full of flavor. Service people are friendly and attentive. Ambience is a typical casual bar/ grill. Nice place for casual quick meal. read more

Best burger I ever ate!!! Huge chicken sandwich!! Excellent steak! Awesome appetizers! I recommend the wings and pretzels!! The service was superb and the atmosphere was amazing. I highly recommend you pay a visit! Oh and not pricey! read more

This little spot is one of our favorites. Great food and great service. You might have to wait for a table for a bit but I assure you it's well worth it. read more

When there with friends First time. Really enjoyed the burger. Great service. Nice atmosphere. Would recommend read more

The food and service was great! Will definitely go back! I've told a lot of my friends to here! read more

First of all bartender Mike was extremely accommodating. He was friendly and allowed us to sit in the dining area even though it was officially closed. We had the sliced steak sandwich which was awesome. We were able to get home made coleslaw instead of fries. It was superb. The late evening ambiance was complementary contributing to a warm and intimate experience. This place is a gem and worthy of a revisit.. read more

We went in for lunch mid week. It was quiet but that's what we were looking for. Our server was very attentive, food came out really quick. We just ordered a few appetizers ...Probably some of the best chicken fingers I've ever had. The broccoli cheddar bites were on the special menu and they were so good. The perogies weren't my favorite (they were just hard) but that's ok because everything else made up for it. Especially my margarita. We will definitely be back read more

Grumpy Jack's - Started lunch with a margarita - Sports Bars Near Me - Port Jefferson, New York

Went a few weeks back. The food was good. It was crowded but we were served pretty quickly. We will have to stop back in again soon.

Food was good and atmosphere was good. Wait time was long but it was worth it. I would definitely go back.

We came here to celebrate my stepdaughter's birthday. We also invited her friendly neighbor to come along. The place is a double-storey house look alike and we were seated at a big booth downstairs. It's a big restaurant. It could occupy big and small groups--the perfect place for brunch, lunch and dinner. We had a friendly and energetic waiter and since we were too occupied with conversation, I forgot to ask for his name. He did a great job. We had the grumpy sampler to start. It was good. Then my stepdaughter ordered a chicken quesadilla. I had a grumpy omelet, and Hubby had a cowboy burger. My grumpy omelet was a bit dry but tasted good. The potato that was served with it was finely seasoned. I tried the quesadilla, not bad! I'm glad my stepdaughter enjoyed her birthday meal. We had a great time and no one was grumpy! Everybody's happy! read more

See all

Very local spot with great ambiance. Food si good. The wings and burgers are great. I also love the pasta pasta too! This place is always a good spot to come for drinks and hang out with friends read more

Dark ,depressing place Awful fish and chips (hope I won't get sick) Won't recommend Don't know how is other food but my first impression was not great read more

We stopped in before seeing A Christmas Carol at Theater Three. We were seated with a group of 5 upstairs. Very comfortable. Service from start to finish was excellent. Everyone was very friendly. I had a marinated burger. It was a bit more done than I asked for but it was still juicy. Great tasting burger. The other plates were the Rasta Pasta, very tasty. A chicken dish with eggplant my mom loved it. Buffalo Popcorn Chicken was tasty. A grilled chicken salad - very nice salad. We were all very happy. Service was great, food was good and they served us fast with out feeling rushed at all. We will be back again. read more

See all

Strait away Greatly packed Saturday Evening for dinner,Went in ,place was humming ,,said there's a wait,,then texted us when table was ready, Food was Best Black and Bleu Burger,Others were in obvious Food Friends Heaven,Must Go here read more

Grumpy Jack's - Really is an ode to Mom,her license plate was Grumpy 3, - Sports Bars Near Me - Port Jefferson, New York

Not a horrible local dive bar restaurant, some of the food that came out looked pretty good. My "Buffalo" wings were not great, kind of oily with Chile pepper flakes. Their own recipe I guess, nothing worth seeking out. If you're hungover, live in the area & want a really dark bar, this is your place. It's probably lit up more in the night than the day time, the sunlight just doesn't get in there. read more

Grumpy Jack's - Wings - Sports Bars Near Me - Port Jefferson, New York

The food here was great. I got a burger and was cooked just right. Had a lotta flavor. One of the better burgers I've had in a very long time. Service was quick, speedy and friendly. Definitely recommended can't wait to go back. It was a nice sitting area bar field to it. read more

I have been here several times with my family when I am out on LI. I always enjoy the vegetable tower. My family likes to order ahi tuna, reuben sandwiches and burgers. Nice selection of beers and always good service! read more

Thanks for being open late on a Monday night. We had left a funeral home and were starving. The menu is huge with something for everyone to eat. We started with appetizers. Fried clams, fried calamari, steamed clams, mozzarella sticks and the pretzel is GIGANTIC. Most of our entrees were delicious. The steak that my son had was good, as was my Reuben and my brothers burger too! We shared a chocolate peanut butter pie, brownie sundae and chocolate chip cookie sundae. Yum! read more

Stopped in to Grumpy Jacks the other day while I was working in Port Jeff for lunch with some colleagues, and I was pleasantly surprised. The exterior looks like it would be a beat up run down watering hole, but then you go inside and the interior looks pretty nice. We got a table and checked the menu, and it had a really good selection of food, lots of sandwhiches and wraps/ drinks. I got the Grilled Chicken Greek Wrap, colleague got the Buttermilk Chx Sandwhich. He liked his, I thought my wrap was really good too. The place had 1 waitress who was running the dining room like a champ, and we had great service even if she was overloaded! Nice Sports bar to chill with your friends with good eats! read more

Just tried to eat at Grumpy Jacks.Arrived at 610 told 15 minute wait decided to wait. Sat at a high top near bar waiting for a table and after 20 minutes was offered to stay and eat at that table or keep waiting.Too loud and uncomfortable to eat by bar so we figured wait 5-10 more minutes.Two empty tables for 5-6 and one came so I get that.Other empty still and maybe since we have eaten there many times offer a drink or get appetizers going if we wanted (not expecting on the house at all ) just common courtesy. Left after the 10 minutes after only being told it will be any minute for the last 15minutes.Business must be good hope so anyway. read more

Bartenders are possibly the best in the area. Service is fantastic and most menu items are exceptional for a bar. That being said, the grumpy sampler is a bad choice, probably the only thing in the menu worth missing. Straight out of a freezer box. read more

Wife and I dropped in for dinner after a long day at work. Seated in 5 mins despite the place being packed. I ordered a burger with waffle fries and she had the fish and chips. Both delicious choices. Service was good and well attended by the staff. Decor ok. Bright enough to see the decorations. Lastly, noise level was a bit loud but it also has a sports bar as part of the restaurant, so you have to take that into account. Yes, we will be back. read more

I like this place. They have wing Tuesday's and you will not be disappointed. The bar is nice , not a lot of tables but good enough. I usually get a seat by the fireplace. Most of the time I can choose my own table (usually 2 in my party). The wait staff are very kind and the bartender makes a good drink. read more

Grumpy Jack's - Menu - Sports Bars Near Me - Port Jefferson, New York

See all

Great burgers n beer, best soups. Good bar n great for large groups. A good local vibe with their own parking lot read more

Patrician salad was fantastic . Onion rings were bomb, the French onion was legit. Loved this place.

Got a to-go order. The chicken cutlet with mozzarella was good, and was still hot by the time I came home. Fries were decent, can't speak to the service but I imagine that it's alright. read more

Staff is great, food is even better! Not your typical bar food. You can't go wrong with anything in the menu but The wings are phenomenal! read more

We had the best time tonight TJ and the staff was awesome Food was great as always Thank you again for great time read more

I'm really surprised this place gets as many negative reviews as it does. Back when I lived in the neighborhood, I used to go here all the time, but since I moved I haven't been here in years. We happened to be nearby today so we stopped by for nostalgia's sake and it was just like old times. Friendly, neighborhood atmosphere. Especially at night and on the weekends there's an "everybody knows your name" vibe among regulars. It can get QUITE loud and crowded on nights and weekends but during the day it's quiet and enjoyable. Today was a lazy Sunday and not many people in the bar or restaurant, yet it did take a while for the food to come out. My fish and chips were excellent, I got the waffle fries (some of the best around) and hubby got the Cajun burger, which today was a little overdone. There seems to be a consensus among recent yelpers that the burgers come out overdone. This had never been a problem for us in the past... maybe new cooks? My menu recommendations are the French onion soup, the chicken wings, the Shepard's pie, The fish and chips and (my absolute favorite!) the grumpy jack wrap which is steak, mozzarella and jalapeño ranch in a wrap. This is a must-try... unfortunately we went during lent so I'll just have to come back! They also have a good selection of beers both draught and bottle, one disappointment was they no longer have the Wells banana bread on tap. At least they had it bottled, but it's not the same. I'd really recommend Grumpy's to anyone. Tasty American pub fare in a welcoming atmosphere and right by the Port Jeff station (if you're waiting for a train). Good times. read more

See all

Hoagie's are mid, waffle fries slap tho, thanks for finishing the pairs with me samara. Also why tf is taras closed smh

I REALLY dislike Grumpy's. I've been here several times and it has never been a memorable experience (in a good way at least). The food isn't good -- unless you like baskets of fried junk food... think chicken tenders and fries -- and their specials aren't anything special at all. I've ordered from both the standard menu and the daily specials, and each and every time I've been disappointed and have felt instant regret after my meal. I guess if you want wings, beer and to watch a sporting event it might be ok, but I wouldn't go here for lunch or dinner ever again Also what irks me in this day and age is when an establishment doesn't have wheelchair access. That's a thumbs down in my book read more

Food was really good, nice fresh seafood, authentic warm vibe lots of wood and local flavors. Standout was Jade our waitress. Soul of service, all smiles super sweet never rattled great demeanor and knew the menu. Super understanding of allergies and sensitivities; thanks for a super night. read more

Great hidden gem in port Jeff! Service was great! I'm a celiac and Jade was outstanding! Checked and double checked to ensure a delightful, celiac-safe and delicious dining experience! If you haven't tried it give it a go!!!! read more