Unfortunately, the first few bites were absolutely awful. The bacon was as tough as a dog's rawhide treat -- it was really bad. That said, after taking the bacon off, the burger itself was much better. The French fries were excellent, the staff was super friendly and nice, and the location is great. I had higher hopes for this place because I'm a big burger lover, but the bacon really let the whole meal down. read more

Hearthly Burger - Burger - Burgers Near Me - Shrewsbury, New Jersey

See all

SHREWSBURY: Hearthly Burger is a delicious and casual spot serving up better burgers made from the best ingredients, and their Shrewsbury location welcomes leashed and friendly pups on the outdoor patio! In addition to burgers, their menu features chicken, seafood, vegetarian, and vegan options, so there is something for everyone. The Beyond Burger, vegan chocolate shake, and classic fries are all excellent! The outdoor seating area is cute, comfortable, and surrounded by greenery, perfect for relaxing with your pup and enjoying a great meal. read more

Hearthly Burger - Burgers Near Me - Shrewsbury, New Jersey

New burger spot right near the Sea Bright Beach! Great seating and delicious, varied menu options - there's something for everyone! We opted for the sauces on the side, and in turn, had a more generous portion of sauces. The burgers are smashed style, but a single patty is pretty filling. I enjoyed my Endless Summer burger - the combination of the super crunchy fried onions, fresh thinly sliced coleslaw, and their delicious dill pickles with the barbecue sauce was perfection! The Truffle Fries were also well seasoned and savory - it is typically served with the aioli atop but we opted to have it on the side. read more

See all

It was pretty good... Glad there are some organic places to eat out quickly instead of the usual crappy food places. We sat outside, the people were nice /service good, the food was tasty. Would try again. read more

Hearthly (not a typo) Burger is in a storefront in The Grove West on Broad St (Route 35 S) in Shrewsbury. A rather small store, with seating for 20 or so. Forgetting my guidelines of getting an unknown sauce on the side and not ordering extra cheese, led to the rather quick delivery of a delightfully messy double cheeseburger slightly overhanging the bun, dripping with two American Cheese slices ($2.50 for the extra slice!) and "OG sauce". The sauce was explained as a mix of three ingredients one of which was Sriracha. The "pasture-raised beef" pieces were large (do I need to start measuring diameters?), perfectly cooked (the medium-well with little to no pink that is fairly standard in the gourmet burger fare) and much resembled my favorite Smashburger in appearance with a slight char edge. At first I instinctively thought to add salt, but didn't see any in the building and by the time we got to the middle of the burger, I found well-adequate amounts of it. Drinks: non traditional "Organic Fountain Soda by Tractor" The Kola Cola Lite was possibly not carbonated; the Cherry Cream definitely was. They kindly list # calories / 12 oz; charged for a large soda but was given a small cup for $3.95 On the menu (a nice trifold white on orange handout): 7 burgers, plus Seafood (Surf Burger or Bites, each Mahi Mahi ), Vegetarian (veggie burger or Grilled Cheese), Vegan, Chicken (6 choices), Salads, Fries (Hand Cut | Cheese Fries | Truffe), Add-ons, Speciality Sauces (choice of ten), Shakes, Kids Menu (4 choices) and Lemonade and two iced tea choices plus the note at the bottom of Beef, "Any of our burgers can be made vegan or vegetarian" Nits: -No refills on the sweet tea ; -the napkins were the standard issue you get at Wawa or Taco Bell, happily with a good supply on the table, but if you have a messy burger like I did , you wish they had bigger napkins or even a roll of towels like some places do (or... maybe normal people don't order extra cheese and OG sauce...) -straws thin, but at least plastic Pricing of my items: Cheeseburger 11.95, 2nd patty $5.95, x cheese $2.50 soda $3.95 Contact for them: @hearthlyburger; hearthlyburger.com read more

Hearthly Burger - the Cheeseburger - Double with OG Sauce and one slice extra cheese - Burgers Near Me - Shrewsbury, New Jersey

This place fell off. The burger non of the options I checked were put on. And the fries tasted like the oil was very all along with the chicken bits. I think they were purchased by PE feeling like the quality went way down and the price went up even more. read more

Found this place a while ago on Yelp and today was finally the day to pay a visit. They are located right in front of The Grove at Shrewsbury. The food was good. The fact that you can substitute any beef patty with the vegan option is fantastic. Because you get to try different versions. I just wish their spicy burger was actually spicy. This was unfortunately was as spicy as ketchup The service was good and super quick and the ambiance was like any other quick sit down burger joint. Nice and clean. We also got truffle fries which were very truffly. I'd give a go again! read more

See all

This place is amazing!!! The food is delicious and is actually made with good healthy ingredients for burgers and fries. They have incredible gluten free options and use a separate frier for celiacs. I got the burger with the lettuce boat, truffle fries, and my dad got the fire burger. This is our go to spot when we want a good burger but we don't want bad ingredients. They also just started using algae oil which made the fries taste delish and is good for the gut. You'd never know this place used the cleanest freshest ingredients. On top of the amazing clean food the place has great vibes. Comfortable booths and reggae music playing! Very clean and enjoyable to hang out in. The staff is so kind and very knowledgeable of the menu. Check it out! read more

Hearthly Burger - Cheeseburger - Burgers Near Me - Shrewsbury, New Jersey

Solid cheeseburger. I visit this place very rarely and should probably change that. If you're having a burger craving, make it here. read more

See all

AMBIENCE: This was my first time walking into a Hearthly Burger. The decor was very nature positive with strains of Ivy and bright colors covering the inside walls STAFF: The staff were friendly while being interactive. Additionally, the delivery speed of the food was swift and still hot upon delivery to my table. FOOD: Now rolling into the food. I ordered a double cheeseburger with a side of fries and a drink. The fries were mediocre. They were pleasantly seasoned with salt, but they were limp and soggy, signifying they were underdone. My burger was decent; it had a savory taste to it combined with the sauce they laid on top of the chopped lettuce. It wasn't overly greasy which sometimes can happen with burgers which is good on their part. But overall, the portion sizes were way too small. A double cheeseburger in accordance with their menu marketed prices should be a beefier sandwich for someone who is looking for a filling bite to eat. However, to my surprise I received a small hamburger. RECOMMENDATIONS: Personally, I just didn't enjoy the restaurant. The food was very midline at best and nothing stood out to me while I was eating my meal. Secondly the pricing for the food was extremely high and didn't match the quality that was being put out by the kitchen. In total my order came out to $30 for a lunch with medium/smaller portion sizes. CONCLUDING REMARKS: I think if the pricing is going to be that high on a burger fries order I believe that the quality of food should be improved. read more

Hearthly Burger - Double Cheeseburger with Fries - Burgers Near Me - Shrewsbury, New Jersey

See all

Friendly service, and options for everyone. I ordered a truffle burger and substituted a beyond burger. My partner got the spicy burger and we shared an order of truffle fries. The truffle burger was truffley and both burgers were very oily and the contents squished through while eating. The spicy burger was not spicy at all. I usually love truffle fries but wasn't a fan of this one, the aioli overpowered everything. read more

Hearthly Burger - Truffle burger and truffle fries - Burgers Near Me - Shrewsbury, New Jersey

Not cheap, but decent price/quality ratio. Clean flavors, you can taste the quality. Lots of choices for those who go beyond burgers. Sides are very good. read more

My girlfriend and I chose to try Hearthly Burger, located at 520 Broad Street, Shrewsbury, NJ, because we eat 100% organic and rarely eat meat, so we thought this would be a good place to try a burger. While our food was being prepared, the cook -- wearing the same gloves used for food handling -- began spraying a chemical degreaser approximately six inches below the food prep table. We could clearly see the mist drifting near the food. Because of the visible chemical spray near active food preparation, and due to my serious gluten allergy, we politely asked that the food be remade. The response from staff made us feel as though we were the problem for raising the concern. The employee appeared upset and threw the food into the garbage, and no explanation, apology, or reassurance was offered. From our perspective, chemical degreasers and food preparation should never occur at the same time. After I clarified that this was a food safety issue, a second employee stepped in and properly remade the food, which I appreciated. The food itself was poor to fair. Despite this being a to-go order, we still tipped 18%, yet the overall experience reflected very poor customer service. If a food safety officer had been present, this would likely have been a very bad day for the restaurant. Am I overreacting..Zero Would I return? Never. Will I share this experience with friends? Yes. read more

Very easy to order. I sat outside. My order was brought out to me. I ordered the Beyond Burger. It came with vegan cheese, onion slices, tomato, their sauce, one 3 large lettuce leaves. The presentation was lovely. The burger, sauce, etc., was very delicious. I would definitely order from here again, the next time I'm in the area. (I should have taken a picture. Next time, I will.) read more

The best burger I have ever had. The price was reasonable, and the place was spotless. Service above and beyond. Highly highly recommend. NO SEED OILS !!The organic milkshakes were off the charts. read more

Amazing !!! Great vibe !!food is delicious zero seed oils!! the burgers are organic. It's incredible. Wish there were more places like this. Very friendly atmosphere. Well Done !!! read more

Me and my friend love this place so much we come almost every day after school and the workers are so polite and sweet especially the girl with brown hair and the boy with brown curly hair. I totally recommend this place. It's family friendly and has plenty of options it's also healthy. read more

WOW! The Burgers here are AMAZING! Everything here is organic and the beef is grass fed. You can tell the burgers here are high quality. I had the Mushroom Shroom Burger, and it was so delicious! The burger was so juicy. Even the bun was fresh and melted in my mouth along with the burger. The hand cut fries were very good, but wish they were served hot. I was shocked when the girl at the register said the truffle fries were $12 and a small milkshake is $10! You can end up spending $40-$50 just for a burger, truffle fries, and a shake here which is overpriced. The 5 stars is because everything was so delicious! I recommend Hearthly Burger in Shrewsbury! read more

Hearthly Burger - Maple Shroom Burger DELICIOUS!!! - Burgers Near Me - Shrewsbury, New Jersey

Best burger. Excellent taste. Each time I am around the area I try to go. Very good crafted burger. Fries are excellent too.

(I actually went to the one in Sea Bright) There are good burgers. There are great burgers. And every once in a while, there are excellent burgers. This was truly excellent, a mouthwatering journey of awesomeness. Burger was exactly how I wanted it, juicy and perfectly seasoned. Fries were also bangin! read more

I tried the Sea Bright location with my grandson. Up stairs-did not see any handicap access but maybe in back. He wasn't hungry but had a kids vanilla shake. He didn't like it-I tasted it and it was bland. I had a regular cheeseburger, fries, and a small bottle of Diet Coke. they were fine-nothing special. What shocked me was the price. $31 for that. Outrageous. Will not go back if given a choice. read more

The place is practically outside and my favorite part of it is the outdoor vegetable garden in the middle where you can eat your food. Almost feels like I am on a little farm. I love it! It also looks like they use some of the things they grow to cook which is bonus points from me. They have gluten free options and interesting burger options like the kimchi buttermilk chicken (a favorite), mahi mahi burger and more. I also like their vegan milkshakes and chicken tenders. Fun fact about the chicken tenders - they taste great the next day even when eaten cold. It's a favorite pit stop of mine when I am in the area and definitely worth a try. read more

See all

I try not to have burgers often ( cholesterol killer) but when I do I simply love these burgers The place is a bit more than an upscale McDonald's. There is No wait service ( although they will bring your order after you order at the cash register) They use the highest quality beef I think from Nieman ranch co. The flavor is outstanding. The fries are just ok The soft drinks are all made with pure sugars no corn syrups I do find it expensive for a burger place , still I grin and bear it read more

When it comes to burgers, I am pretty basic. I will typically go for a greasy burger at hole in the wall over a trendy burger spot but there's no denying that Hearthly Burger makes a solid burger. The concept is simple. You order at the counter and they bring your food to you. I ordered the double cheeseburger which came with 2 patties, American cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion and OG sauce. My fiance ordered the cauliflower fries tossed in buffalo sauce. The burgers are made from grass fed beef and all of the ingredients are extremely fresh. We were part of a group of 6 and opted to eat outside since the restaurant is pretty small and most of the tables were occupied. The food and service were great. I'd like to try their fries and milkshakes on my next visit. I don't see myself coming back super often as I find a $17 burger to be too expensive, especially if it doesn't come with fries or a drink but for a tasty burger, you can't go wrong here. read more

Delicious food, high quality ingredients, friendly service, served fast in a pleasant space. Ragin chicken sandwich, fries, burgers all great. Check out their new location with ocean views. read more

I walk and some young good looking man with the smooth skills of a marketing professional sells the hell out of this burger -- locally sourced, butcher is basically in the back and they're killing the cow as we speaks I mean he was good-- instantly I told him he was a good public speaker. I wasn't expecting something a little worse than 5Guys hopefully better than Wendy's but ready for nasty McDonalds fake meat. I ordered the truffle fries , the fried chicken and the mushroom burger. OH MY F******* G-d was it mind blowing delicious. I mean.. the flavor if the meat, the seasoning, the sauces they all got together made sweet, passionate raw love to my tongue like Ariana Grande my taste "I want it, I got it." Now. the fried we're homemade and the cheese and truffle -- in hyperventilating as remember sticking each fry into my mouth. Finally the chicken-- the batter they put on the chicken was scrumptious and dipped alongside several different sauces I can't remember-- it reminded me of being bakc in the Dominican Republic sipping mama juana in the sun looking at the beautiful people in the beach-- that's how i Felt eating all this food Unfortunately my office is in Trenton so I dont anticipate in coming back to this area any time soon but I want to return to eat this food read more

Update: so happy Heartly has kept up its high quality of food been back a number of times and the food is consistently delicious love the burger and kimchi chicken if you're lucky enough to get the mahi burger go for it the quality here rivals the top restaurants in NYC don't leave without having their milkshake. What a gem!! Please come to north jersey!! read more

Mahi burger is really good, but expensive! We had 2 Mahi sandwiches and an order of cauliflower poppers and it was $52!!! I'd give 3.5 stars because if the price but the food was really good. Not a good value but enjoyable non the less. read more

Hearthly Burger - Register area - Burgers Near Me - Shrewsbury, New Jersey

We came here for the mahi mahi burgers. We have been here many times. They are amazing . We get them on a gluten-free buns. I would highly recommend read more

This was one of the best burgers I've ever had! SO DELICIOUS. Happened to find this place randomly while visiting a nearby wedding venue, and was so happy I stopped in. The staff was kind and friendly. I only wish it wasn't two hours away from city haha read more

Wow I am really impressed with the food here. They have the best French fries around. IMO better than Five Guys or Shake Shack. We had them with the truffle Mayo and they tasted like a more expensive favorite from a high end steak house. I had a fried chicken sandwich/burger with pickles, lettuce, tomato and their spicy aoli but it was mild. It was actually too big for me to finish but i wanted to! My better half had a grilled chicken burger and claimed that it was superior. Best part was not feeling that gross heavy or overly full "my stomach feels like cement" vibe that I get after eating at other fast food places. Great staff and table service (after you order at the cashier). Cute outdoor seating area with nice plantings. Highly recommended. Will be back soon! read more

Hearthly Burger - Fried Chicken Burger with fries - Burgers Near Me - Shrewsbury, New Jersey

Looking for something healthy, tasty, fun and easy to keep trying? Go to hearthy Burger, I have had both a cheese burger and a Fried chicken sandwich, both were outstanding. Service was great, the store is nice and clean. Great Place I fully recomend! read more

$50 for one double cheeseburger with bacon, small fries and a small soda?? Way over priced. The polo club in NYC charged that for their burgers. No thank you!! read more

Had the fried chicken burger - it was a bit messy and bland but the worst thing about it is that halfway into it-tasted uncooked. Could not finish it - at these prices ($16 for a sandwich). It better be damn near perfection. read more

UPDATE: Stopped in cause we were down the block at TJs and I was wanting chicken (I try my hardest to stick to organic). Glad we did! LOVE how cautious they are with Covid laws, they don't let anyone inside everyone was masked and gloved. The young guy working at the front was super sweet, checked on us a few times to make sure everything was OK, they have some great seating outside Adirondack chairs and picnic tables to choose from, surrounded by lots of flowers so you can enjoy a little nature. What can I say the chicken is amazing, I didn't get anything else, just chicken with pickles and lettuce, no bun..and a hemp drink.. its still $$$ but so good, juicy, nice sized.. I will be back! Sorry guys this is a NO from us as we feel completely ripped off. First, the burgers were so small for the price. I would like my child at least to feel full for a $12 burger and $4 fries. The super thin burger did not satisfy a teen, so it definitely won't satisfy a grown man.. needless to say the hubs and boy weren't happy. Everyone ate all the fries not because we like cold, mushy fries but because we were hungry! In fact, we were, stopping and getting shakes at Sonic on the way home kinda hungry. I, LOVED my chicken sandwich those two stars are for the chicken alone. I am a organic whore :-) so you had me at 'Organic'. I felt it was juicy, certainly big enough for me (probably four times the thickness of the burgers....so if you eat here, go for the chicken. The worst thing, and what really forced the hubs hand in saying 'never again' to this place was the PATHETIC excuse of a grilled cheese sandwich.. I mean really guys, HOW can you screw this one up so bad?!?! First of all.. where in your eva lovin mind do you get off charging $8 for a hamburger bun and a SINGLE slice of american cheese?!?! I was livid when I looked over and saw what my Daughter was eating for dinner, I had to do a double take.. like wait, what are you eating, didn't you order an $8 grilled cheese? Cause for $8, you better get some emmental or gruyere on fresh baked sourdough, grilled in Kerry Gold butter, maybe even throw in a slice of tomato, if you really like your customers.... but it is NOT a bun and a slice of cheese squashed on the grill in hamburger grease..look at the photo, this is taking advantage of people who are keeping you in business!! Good chicken can't make up for the rest of the very pricey meal so although I loved the chicken, I might end up divorced if I come back for more, cause there is one thing the hubs hates more than bad food and that is bad food with a high price tag!! read more

See all

I got the cheeseburger, truffle fries, cauliflower bites, and regular fries to share and let me tell you... everything was AMAZING. The OG sauce was phenomenal, and my friend who's vegan got the beyond burger and said it was incredible. I also love that they serve olipop. Will be returning ! read more

This review is for customer service and how they prepare their food. I called them and the girl answered the phone, "Hello?" And I paused and asked, "Is this a business?" And she laughed and said, "Yes". How do you answer the phone like that? And she never apologized or anything. I asked if they fry their fries and she had to ask someone in the background who said yes they do deep fry. A healthy restaurant should not be deep frying their fries and still call themselves healthy. There are air fryers that can "fry" food with no oil and it would be a healthier option. read more

I'm astonished that I forgot to review this place. My wife loved it when she went with her friends so I was eager to try it for myself. On 8/4, a close friend reached out to me that he was in the area and wanted to meet for lunch. I took the opportunity to have him meet me at Hearthly. It's kind of hidden, you cannot see it from Rt. 35. It's off Patterson but tucked between a clothing store and Billabong. It's all organic if that's your thing. I had the single cheeseburger and fries. My buddy had the Fire burger single. I loved the fries, they're thin cut but soft the way I like them. I imagine you can get them crispy but I loved them the way they came out. The burger is tasty, well topped with fresh ingredients. The OG sauce is delicious. You order at the counter and they bring it to your table. The young lady who took my order said they usually cook it medium, but it was well done. It was still very good. My friend really enjoyed his as well. They also have a tank of fresh lemon water!! That is perfect for me because I really don't drink soda. I like that they anticipate people like me. I took a star off because the burger is kind of Smash Burger like, the burger could have been a little larger. The fries were abundant though. I'm going back to try the chicken sandwich because I'm eager for someone to wow me with a properly cooked and superior quality sandwich. Stay tuned. read more

This places is by far the tastiest sandwiches I've ever had with unrivaled quality. 10/10 recommend the food here, everything being all organic and locally sourced. It's pricey, but that's expected when food is quality! read more

It was so good!! Amazing burgers, all around it was delicious, such friendly service. Definitely going back!