My wife and I had a late lunch after spending time at the beach. She had the Forbidden Chicken and I had the Classic Smash burger With a side of fries. Totally delicious! Fresh ingredients and relaxed atmosphere made for an enjoyable meal. Service was excellent. We will definitely visit for another meal when we are in Belmar again. Pete N. read more

For a quick reasonable meal, this hole in the wall does sandwiches right. Their forbidden chicken is an award winner.

This place was incredible when it first opened and has done nothing but get better year over year. It's undisputed. They create unique sandwiches with incredible attention to every detail as well as classics executed perfectly. It's hard to stray away from staples when picking however if you ever do you just end up with a new addiction. Absolutely delicious food. read more

Incredible sandwiches! Got the Caesar and the vodka parm sandwich and they were both amazing. So delish!!!!

A Flavor Explosion That'll Make You Question Your Loyalty to Other Sandwiches. I thought I knew what a good sandwich was--until I met Hoagito's. Now, every other sandwich feels like a sad, soggy imposter. The chicken sliders are so good, they will have you questioning your life choices--like why you didn't try this sooner. The staff? Friendly and efficient. The atmosphere? Casual and welcoming. The food? Life-changing. Hoagito's has set a new standard for what a sandwich should be. If you're in Belmar and haven't been to Hoagito's yet, what are you doing with your life? Get there. Your taste buds will thank you. read more

Hoagitos - Chicken Sliders - Sandwiches Near Me - Belmar, New Jersey

Our daughter had a competition in Neptune so we decided to come to Hoagitos for a second round. Food was a hit again. The Fried Mushroom Sammie was delicious, the Griddle Mac had a seasoned flavor, you could tell why it's called " griddle" and the fries were delicious! Crispy and seasoned well. The vodka sauce isn't spicy at all and Hubby loved the flavor!! read more

See all

Endless variety of delicious chicken sandwiches , you have to try more than one but they also do amazing Smashburgers. I tried atleast 13 of their sandwiches and everyone had its own twist on chicken. Some are made with a panko breaded chicken breast and some are a crispy battered chicken thigh. You can order order any sandwich with either one but no matter what the chicken is tender, and delicious. Here's what I tried : DUDE RANCH panko fried breast, bacon, arugula, tomato, onion, bab pickles, buttermilk ranch FORBIDDEN CHICKEN crispy thigh, sweet n spicy glaze, pickled daikon slaw, roasted garlic mayo SOUTHERN COMFORT panko fried breast, griddle mac, cabbage slaw, chili jam FINGER LICKER crispy thigh, honey butter, shredded lettuce. bab pickles, roasted garlic mayo NASHVILLE HOT crispy thigh, cheddar, cayenne dip, cabbage slaw, bab pickles, spicy mayo COLONEL MUSTARD crispy thigh, cheddar, arugula, tomato pickled onion, house honey mustard BUFFALO panko fried breast, buffalo sauce, american, shredded lettuce, bab pickles, house ranch CHIPOTLE panko fried breast, pepperjack, shredded lettuce, tomato, pickled onion,Fresno Chili, Chipotle mayo FRIED CHICKEN CAESAR * chicken cutlet, shredded lettuce, pickled onion, roasted tomato, house caesar, asiago, seeded semolina SPICY CHICKEN VODKA PARM chicken cutlet, fresh mozzarella, spicy vodka sauce, fresh basil, asiago, seeded semolina DOUBLE CLASSIC SMASH Beef smash patty, american, lettuce, red onion, bab pickles, spicy mayo Monthly Special- RICKY RICOTTA Chicken cutlet, thinly sliced soppressata, calabrian chili hot honey, arugula and herbs, whipped ricotta, shaved Asiago PORTOBELLO BURGER Crispy panko portobello mushroom, melty brie, pickled onion, arugula, herb mayo read more

See all

Just to get it out of the way, they really need to fix their door. It slams and it's apparently been happening for awhile because delivery food drivers carefully closed the door after them. We had our sandwiches to stay--a fried mushroom sandwich and the nashville hot chicken sandwich. The Nashville could have used a bit more heat. The fried mushroom was a bit heavy, with both mayo and Brie cheese. Maybe something tangier or extra pickled onions? But both were still good! read more

Hoagitos - Fried Mushroom - Sandwiches Near Me - Belmar, New Jersey

See all

My boyfriend discovered this restaurant and he really wanted me to get there one day. So we happened to be down the shore for the day on a day they were open. We stooped in after a day on the beach. I ordered a buffalo chicken sandwich. It was SO good! read more

See all

Amazing flavor, one of the best Mac and cheese around and perfectly crisp chicken. Will be back.

I am on that hot chicken spell at the moment. They all look delicious and I just want these things to hurt me good. That sounded a bit weird. But you know when the heat is hot but at the same time good. Yeah that. I had the Nashville hot chicken and it was hot, not too hot just enough. I'd order again or maybe a hotter one of they have it. Not much else to say, it's chicken. read more

I've been to this location several times and each time I've experienced pure racism. Employees working inside are rude and don't really care for their customers. Food is good but not worth loosing your integrity over it. Safe to say I will not be going back to Hoagitos ever again. read more

short story- NO better value, or taste treat at this very friendly price point in the area. I've been multiple times, ordered all over the menu... no duds, no yawns... everything a taste treat salvo that has you immediately looking at the menu, thinking about your next visit. Most recently the Ruben, March special. Hush the fuss... other spots are the Ruben king... no they're not. This is legit the best Ruben in the area.. and that I've ever had. Just go. read more

The best chicken sandwich. I'm not even kidding. They have a fun vibe about them on Instagram. Friendly staff and so happy they are so close to me now. read more

Hoagitos - The finger licker - Sandwiches Near Me - Belmar, New Jersey

Got the Griddle Mac & Cheese and it was sooo delicious!!! Crispy with each bite and amazing seasoning! Kind workers too :) read more

Hoagitos - Got the Griddle Mac & Cheese and it was sooo delicious!!! Crispy with each bite and amazing seasoning! Kind workers too :) - Sandwiches Near Me - Belmar, New Jersey

The sandwiches were not good. The chicken cheese steak was too salty. The other sandwich we ordered was not what it was described as. A piece of chicken cutlet on bread and nothing else. I called to let them know that it was not what I ordered. The man that answered the phone said he checked with his cook and that he made it correctly. He was Rude. It was our first time there. We went out of our way to try it and definitely will not go back. read more

Sandwiches were great! Had the double smash and it was delicious. We also ordered the chicken Caesar. Chicken was fresh and crispy the sandwich itself was really big. Could only eat half. Griddle Mac had the best flavor too. They also have chicken nuggets that are freshly made and these were soo good!! I love that the chicken for the sandwich and nuggets were freshly made and not your typical processed food that is thrown in a fryer. read more

The food wasnt cooked fully and when I got into the car to open up my food it had the letters C.U.M. on it. Obviously that means cum but why is this even written on the box with the uncooked food that I payed for is beyond me. This is the first time this has happened at the establishment for me so I'm a little confused and almost pissed off considering the fact I'm writing my first food review. read more

Hoagitos - Sandwiches Near Me - Belmar, New Jersey

I saw the post of Ricky Ricotta sandwich that they had but it was only a may monthly special. We ordered the dude ranch, fubar fries, and finger licker. The fubar fries tasted great but were super salty; fries had tons of salt &with sauce on top it made it more heavy. My bf got the regular fries; it was also salty. He said the finger licker was 9/10. I checked in through yelp and got the 30% off and showed it to the staff but he said its only for online but doesnt say that on the coupon. We had alrdy given him our order and didn't want for him to delete everything he input into the tablet so we didn't get to use the 30% off. read more

See all

Holy cow - I've never had such good sandwiches ever. I am not exaggerating. My bf said this place was good, but I didn't think it was this good!!! Ordered the Meatball Sandwich and the Finger Licker. I'm not a huge fan of meatballs but this was out of this world. The sauce it was tossed in was amazing. The garlic taste was exceptional. The Finger Licker had a nice honey touch to it. Both were amazing. Will absolutely be back to order these two again and try others. If you're in the area - DO NOT PASS THIS PLACE UP. It's is heaven on earth. My new shore spot for sure! 20/10 read more

Hoagitos - Meatball Sandwich and Finger Licker - Sandwiches Near Me - Belmar, New Jersey

I never do reviews, but after this interaction I decided I had to. I waited over 30 minutes for my food and when asked how much longer, I was told that my order wasn't even being made yet. After wasting my time I decided to get a refund, in which I was told they don't do refunds. I ended up leaving out of frustration with no food and no money back, definitely would not recommend. read more

Pretty good, should come with fries at no extra charge though ‍ Great service, cute small place for a quick bite plenty of parking, will give it another try read more

Hoagitos - Crispy Forbidden Chicken (Travel Channel Featured) - Sandwiches Near Me - Belmar, New Jersey

Holy moly. I just moved into the Belmar area & I've been eyeing this place on DoorDash. I've lost my love of chicken over the years-except for when it's a properly done fried chicken sandwich. This place slapsss. It took me like 10 minutes to decide which sandwich I wanted to try first, they all have their own special flavor profile so it was hard to choose. I went with the Finger Lickin sandwich, & requested purple slaw & pickled onions on it as well. I also got the griddle Mac and cheese. The Mac comes looking like a pancake pillow- and it was so incredibly good. Sweet, creamy, well seasoned- hints of onion & almost like maple syrup- ugh heaven. The sandwich was perfection. Crispy, crunchy breading & juicy, tasty chicken thigh. Delicious toppings, a huge fan of the pickles & slaw, & the sauce was the finishing touch. Ordered through DD & it was here in less than 25 minutes. I can't wait to try the rest & get my husband hooked on this place too. read more

Great service, quick delivery! As always, amazing & tasty food! The Finger Licker Sandwich & Fresh Cut Fries are always a great option. read more

Hoagitos - Finger Licker & Fresh Cut Fries - Sandwiches Near Me - Belmar, New Jersey

This place never misses.the buffalo Sammy is a home run. Fries, cookie, etc are the best.

This place is phenomenal. The kale Caesar with Panko chicken and the risotto balls are delicious. Highly reco read more

See all

Oh boy what a lunch. I've been following Hoagitos on Instagram for several months. I've always wanted to stop in but never have. Today I checked and realized they're 10 min from where I was. I wandered in to a smaller restaurant with a handful of tables. The menu was written on the wall in chalk. There were sliders and some chicken sandwiches listed. I asked the guy at the register what I should have. He asked me a few questions about my tastes, if I liked spicy food etc. he recommended the forbidden chicken sandwich. This sandwich is a boneless chicken thigh, deep fried. Dipped in a sweet and spicy sauce and I think it had some cabbage slaw on it. I made it a combo w fries and a drink. I was told to sit and they would serve me. About 5 min later my little bit of heaven arrived. What amazing crunch and flavor this sandwich had, my nose was running from the spice but then the sweet was stopping it. The fries came in a huge portion with a some chipotle Mayo. The fries were salty but that's how I like them. The whole meal was really good. I'm looking forward to trying their other sandwiches. read more

Hoagitos - Customers exploring the goods. - Sandwiches Near Me - Belmar, New Jersey

See all

I try NOT to eat this type of food .. but if you're going to be bad.. BE BAD Here! The fried chicken sandwich ,,especially the spicy hot one is crisp,temp hot, flavor hot and totally bomb ! I love the brioche it's sits on and slaws are out of this world The Nashville is my favorite So when you want to break rules.. do it right...here! read more

Everything was go good and fresh! Some items had more flavor than others, but overall it was wonderful and we would definitely go back! The portions are pretty large as well (even the sliders are bigger than traditional sliders). And the ranch dressing tasted homemade. So colorful and really just can't say enough about how fresh and well prepared everything was! read more

See all

This is one of the best chicken sandwich spots I've ever had. The forbidden chicken is to die for! The sweetness of the sauce complimented the chicken thigh so well. We also got the dude ranch sandwich -- it was basically a chicken cutlet BLT sandwich but made with love. I would definitely recommend the chicken sandwiches here so be sure to take advantage of that. As for the sides, i would skip it in the future and maybe try the hand cut fries. We had gotten the risotto balls and the mac and cheese. The risotto balls were underwhelming. It didn't give me a wow factor that made me feel better on splurging $7 on 3 balls. Not worth it, skip it. For the mac and cheese, it was delicious but nothing i would go out of my way with. If you are craving it then go for it but honestly the star of the show would be the delectable forbidden chicken. read more

See all

Went here last night with a friend. I got the forbidden chicken sandwich. It was delicious, probably one of the best I've had in awhile. Definitely gotta come back to try more of the food here. read more

Hoagitos - Forbidden Chicken (Travel Channel Featured) - Sandwiches Near Me - Belmar, New Jersey

Super good! Clean, kind service, fresh food! We will definitely be coming back here when we're in town.

Wow what an amazing find. My friends who are local brought us to this joint on a Saturday for sandwiches and I was skeptical. Com'on like sandwich near the beach on a beautiful sunny Saturday morning!?!? Where's my drink and funnel cake and fires. Boy was I wrong. The price point was amazing. I got the Nashville hot chicken sandwich off of the special menu for $7. The chicken was crispy, plentiful, and slaw was flavorful with light vinegar. 100% better than chick fil a, shake shack, and pop eye combined. We got a bunch of sea salt chocolate chips cookies as well but they went down so fast I couldn't get a picture. They set up bunch of seats outside for guests to pick up and chill. read more

Hoagitos - Nashville hot chicken. Would you just look at that crunchy cut of chicken. Best decision ever. - Sandwiches Near Me - Belmar, New Jersey

See all

Good chicken sandwich. But I'll never be back. I went there last night quarter after seven and they were closed on a Saturday. Ridiculous read more

Everything we had was awesome all food was cook to order fresh ingredients friendly staff every time I come to Belmar I have to stop in. The pics def say a thousand words!!! read more

See all

Looking for a quick but fresh spot for your after beach craving. Look no further than Hoagitos. I have been here twice in as many weeks and both times the sandwich and fries were amazing. My first trip was the Forbidden Chicken and the last trip was the Nashville Hot Chicken ( pictured). Both have plenty of meat and toppings and packed with flavor. The fresh cut fries with the seasoned mayo/ ketchup sauce were fantastic! read more

Hoagitos - Nashville Hot Chicken and Fries - Sandwiches Near Me - Belmar, New Jersey

Hoagitos is one of those spots that I had bookmarked for a little while. They serve awesome sandwiches and make them fresh to order. The blackened chicken sandwich was the monthly or weekly special so I had to try that. They didn't have one of the ingredients but it was still good. Their sandwiches are smaller but are full of flavor. I would say order 2 if you want to leave full. The turkey sandwich also did the trick. The sopressata was a nice take on an italian sub. My favorite were the southern comfort and forbidden chicken. The fried chicken was tender and had a nice crust on the outside. I can't keep track what ingredients are on each sandwich but it worked. It is a cool place and I would come back in a heartbeat. read more

See all

This place was so good. We got a buffalo fried chicken sandwich and shared it w fries it was totally on point. It's kinda in the cut and u don't see it but once u find It's plaza it's next to a bunch of other really cool spots too. Can't go wrong good food and was quick to make! read more

Chicken sandwiches are made to perfection and the smash burgers are delicious! Not to mention the fries are amazing as well. Here on a work trip and we made the time to stop by twice while we had the chance. read more

Southern comfort is my favorite thing in the menu. It comes with fried chicken, grilled Mac, cabbage and chili jam, what more can you ask for? It's the perfect size; not to big and not so small where you question why did I pay for much for such a small item. This is my go to sandwich when I'm craving one. read more

Hoagitos - Sandwiches Near Me - Belmar, New Jersey