Hoagie Shop

This place is a gem. The outside does not lend itself to what belies within. The food is eclectic…read moreand gourmet. The service is great and overall a pleasant surprise. This a five star restaurant wrapped in an unassuming diner package.

A must stop spot in Butler. Their menu is a variety of comfort food to dishes with flavors you…read morewouldn't expect to find. The cheeseburger soup was delicious. Heavy, but delicious. The portions are large and service and decor are great.

Inside

Duck pastrami Rueben yummmm

See all

The Space

Monroe Hotel

3.9(96 reviews)

2.1 mi

I understand this venue is historical and well-loved, but it is definitely toeing the line between…read morepreserved and fossilized. I came here with a large party for a recent family reunion, and everything was only just okay. Our standout impression was our server - she handled us all single-handedly and ensured we all had everything we needed. She was phenomenal. Unfortunately, the food is just fine and the interior isn't very interesting at all. Dirty, dingy, outdated. I ordered their French Sandwich, which was interesting. The dressing they used, which I asked on the side to dip my fries in, was the most exciting part. Tangy, garlicky, slightly spicy (not really) contrary to my uncle's spice tolerance. Everyone else's food looked passable, but nobody pointed out anything they particularly enjoyed. A warning, their large salads are HUGE - think the size of the salad bowl they give you at Olive Garden. The bread they give is plain, with butter in single-serve containers. Not much to write home about, am I missing something?

From service to food this place gives it all to you. Nice bar to meet people in. This place really…read morehas it all.

Full wings - Jumbo Wings

Cod sandwich

See all

Hot Sausage Sandwich with fries and a side of nacho cheese sauce to dip the fries into.

Rachel's Roadhouse

3.8(260 reviews)

1.7 mi

Stopped in with the family last weekend and WOW--instant new favorite. The food and service were…read moreabsolutely on point. If you go, do yourself a favor and order the smokehouse chicken. I'm still thinking about those horseradish mashed potatoes and that Bridge BBQ... I swear I almost licked the plate. Normally I'm the designated food photographer, but the hangry hit hard and everything disappeared before I even thought about my camera. Highly recommend. This place is definitely joining our family rotation.

Sat at the bar, and the bartender was polite and responsive…read more Ordered the Reuben, wings, and French onion soup. Unfortunately, the Reuben was the worst I've ever had. The bread was disappointing, and the overall sandwich was lacking in flavor and quality. The wings and soup were okay, but the Reuben was a major letdown.

Nice atmosphere

See all

Energized Dining

3.7(16 reviews)

2.0 mi

Excellent food - many menu offerings Service was great - the…read morewaitstaff was very attentive Ambiance is excellent. Owners did a wonderful remodeling job and it was so lovely and comfortable. Highly recommend.

We placed our order (take out) for a vegitable bowl and a salad at 11:00 AM. It is now 11:48 AM…read moreand we are still waiting.

See all

Vin & Joe's Inn

4.0(13 reviews)

2.7 mi

We had a group of 10 call in to come get drinks and apps on a Friday at 5. There was only one…read morebartender on a Friday night. After a half hour we all gave up and left.

Good food and good service . Always a chill ambiance when…read morein dinner . Just one con , be carefully when pulling out on Route 38 . Traffic can be a bit sketchy some times .

See all

The Brick House

2.9(47 reviews)

1.7 mi

We had a spontaneous family dinner there tonight. We all had to say the waiter / bartender was not…read morethe nicest to deal with. We had a larger party and we are a bit much at times, but still. Well the food has always been amazing so that's why we go there! Josh the Chef came out to bring our apps and was the most friendliest guy we ever met. He was professional and so kool ... and he knows what he is doing !!! Bang up job tonight Josh your skills surpass everyone and your Customer service was spot on !!! You got 10 out of 5 star reviews from us all !! Thank you !! You made our night perfect

Absolutely terrible. Walked in and asked for a beer on tap. He said, sure, but the beer isn't cold…read more He then point down to a moldy mini fridge and said that they had some cold drinks in there. Literally saw mold on the bottom of the fridge! Crappy bartender and would never recommend this place to anyone. Don't go

General Tso chicken

See all

11th Frame Bar and Grille

2.9(9 reviews)

0.8 mi

For years the service has been horrible and people have continued to visit for their mediocre food…read more Tonight for a bowling dinner we were asked to place our order 3 hours ahead of time. Waited 4 hours and 45 minutes for chicken tenders and fries. Honestly they should be embarrassed by not only their unorganized business practices but also by their help.

First time at this place on 6/7/22. Went in about 9pm and service was friendly and responsive. Good…read moreselection of beers on tap, and nice covered patio. Ordered wings (jumbo) - reasonable price given market and inflation. Got the dry rub "Cranch" (combo of Cajun and ranch) - it was neither. Good crispy wing, but absolutely no flavor. For a bar food staple, I was hoping for better. Will need to stop back and try something else.

Overview of bar seating, draft system and liquor shelves.

March featured St. Patty's cocktails! Spring cocktail menu arrives April 1st, 2022.

See all

Snack-N-Pack

2.7(43 reviews)

2.0 mi

I have ordered several times from this place the food has always been really good but they are very…read moreinconsistent. Sometimes I order I get sides sometimes they don't give sides. Last time I ordered on doordash I was upcharged by $2.23 for special instruction and didn't receive either side for 2 meals. Doordash won't refund either. I'd rate 2.5 out of 5.

First time i went here, the burger,and fries were excellent! The second time, i went down for…read morebreakfast. Took a while to get my food, but the staff was very pleasant (they were busy when i went in), and very apologetic for the slow service. Today, i went there for lunch, and the lady that waited on me was just a tad foul mouthed, but again, the service was great. I will go back again, as much as possible

Soggy... chicken, onion and peppers not chopped up small, instead huge pieces that fall out before I could get a bite...

See all

Shellys Main Street Grille

3.4(8 reviews)

1.8 mi

Smh. Just ate their rendition of an Omelette. Not happy with it. We had the meat lovers. What a…read morejoke. First of all the omelette was paper thin. When I say thin...I mean THIN! The meat portion was down right a joke. It was probably less than half of a fist full. That's being generous. At least give us what we paid for. I will NEVER eat there again. Ever! Plus no eating utensils. Pissed!

This was the worst experience I have ever had from a 5star reviewed place. It was a long wait to…read moreget a bad meal if I could give negative stars I would

Jersey Mike's Subs

3.9(11 reviews)

1.1 mi

No. 8, great!. Excellent sandwich. Didn't care for Jersey…read moreMikes until I discovered this.

Love this place! I was greeted upon arrival and my subs were started quickly. Bread was perfect,…read moreand the turkey and provolone was finished to my request. The Jersey Shore sandwich was finished Mike's way and my husband said it was very good. I'll be back!!

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

3 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Tamny D.

8 months ago

U don' t give enough time to put in my time to every time I try . Even time I try to use in. Every time I go to flight ....... Sooooo I need more time for enter read more

Larry R.

12 years ago

My favorite place to eat, steak hoagie is the best of all. Been going there since 1965 I still drive from erie pa just to get a hoagie.

Blake H.

13 years ago

Great food and fries! Very, fulfilling!

Hoagie Shop - newamerican - Updated September 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of Butler, Pennsylvania Restaurants near Hoagie Shop

BEST of Butler, Pennsylvania Things to Do near Hoagie Shop

BEST of Butler, Pennsylvania Desserts near Hoagie Shop

BEST of Butler, Pennsylvania Cocktail Bars near Hoagie Shop

BEST of Butler, Pennsylvania Coffee near Hoagie Shop

BEST of Butler, Pennsylvania Parking near Hoagie Shop

BEST of Butler, Pennsylvania Wineries near Hoagie Shop

BEST of Butler, Pennsylvania Brunch near Hoagie Shop

BEST of Butler, Pennsylvania Breakfast near Hoagie Shop

BEST of Butler, Pennsylvania Shopping near Hoagie Shop

Best of Butler

Things to do in Butler

Browse Brands

Brands by name

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed Hoagie Shop also viewed

The Hoagie Shop

3.9

(15 reviews)

This place is amazing and just like what I remember from the 90's when I used to go frequently…read more The hoagie rolls are really good and I forgot how great their fries are.

I am disappointed to say that our recent experience ordering from The Hoagie Shop was not what we…read moreexpected. We ordered Tuna hoagies and they were edible. The tuna flavor was very overbearing and the amount of mayo made the hoagie inedible for me. Luckily, my husband was able to eat it the next day. Stay with their regular subs and you should be fine!

Bob's Sub & Sandwich Shop

3.6

(104 reviews)

Bobs Subs is currently and was one of the best subs you can get. I went to SRU in the early 2000s…read moreand this place is awesome. The Super Junior was always my go to. The seating is somewhat limited, but these subs are great to either eat in or take one out.

Every summer when I return to the area, Bob's has been a favorite. I would have agreed that they…read moreare the best--that is until my recent visit. I ordered two sandwiches both of which were inedible. The bread they are using is so dense and bland. I called to discuss the matter and was told that they had lost their bread supplier and that the manager was out but would get back to me the next day. That was nearly three weeks ago. Like everything else, the prices have gone up. Unfortunately, the quality has gone down. $27.00 for two dreadful sandwiches. I will not be back.

My Heroes Sub Shop

3.9

(28 reviews)

We've been meaning to try this place for a while, and finally made it out today. The restaurant…read moreitself is very small, with a handful of tables to eat in. I got a ham & cheese sub. The sub was kind of underwhelming. The bread was great, but the rest of the sub was just okay. They also need bigger plates as mine barely fit and lettuce kept falling out. The steak fries were great, however. All in all, an ok experience but probably not one that I'll repeat.

I've been getting subs here since I was a kid and have never been disappointed. They are…read moreconsistently delicious, no matter which one you order. The service is great and they're quick! Highly recommend stopping here. They also have amazing party trays!

Penn Street Pizza

3.5

(16 reviews)

Seating, there were 2 tables and 4 chairs at each table, But you were not allowed to even sit while…read morewaiting for your order. We sat on the front steps while waiting for our food. They can take your money but also inconvenience you. We will not be coming back. I do not recommend going there if you intend to go out to eat. They charge a $10.00 delivery fee no matter what. This was recommended by the hotel we were staying at, that they told us you can sit in and eat. Its not. Our hotel does not have seating in the room.

We tried to order lunch on several different Fridays from my office. Despite everything saying…read morethey would be open at 11 am, they never answered. We called a day ahead of time (Thursday at 4 pm) to ask if they would be open for lunch the following day. We were told they would be open at 11:00 am. So at 11 am we called to place a rather LARGE order... no answer and the answering machine said they didn't open until 4 pm. We give up. We'll give someone else our business.

Upper Crust Shop

4.4

(8 reviews)

Small, family-owned diner that caters to Butler county courthouse workers and visitors as it's…read moreconveniently located a short walk away. No frills, takeaway-style spot with efficient and courteous service. The menu is exactly what you'd expect for lunch ranging from the usuals like soups, salads, and sandwiches. All executed well and really good. Affordable prices.

Upper Crust's chicken salad is to die for--beautifully prepared chicken breast with just enough…read moremayo to hold it together and accented with green grapes and slices almonds.

Lindys Lunch

4.1

(19 reviews)

This place is the bomb! You want French fries to blow you away? These will. I get mine with chili…read moresauce- oh man! Crispy, spicy, hot! Husband gets cheese on his as well as the sauce. Jealous! I need to try the burgers... can't drag myself away from the dogs. Drive from Pittsburgh to get this. Service is good and everybody smiles. Don't be too late for May's Donuts next door! Go ahead and splurge

Excellent menu, great food, inexpensive and personal were all very nice. Will return again and…read moreagain! Thank you for everything!

Burger Hut 2

3.0

(28 reviews)

Not a "hut" but a Diner! Seat yourself in any one of the 12 booths, or sit at the cool counter…read more Got there before lunch rush, but did the customers start coming in. Our waitress, the only waitress-was pretty cool and took our order. We both got burgers of course, and to our Suprise? Delicious! Homemade patties cooked to perfection. Decent prices, but add ons, ie- Let, tom, etc- start adding up- sides don't come w the burger without an upcharge Great place to eat a good Burger!

I stopped into Burger Hut 2 expecting a quick, easy visit since there was no one else inside. An…read moreelderly man politely asked the cook if he could make a simple request for his hot dogs. Instead of responding professionally, the cook snapped at him and said, "You're talking to me? Don't ever yell back here again?" -- even though he wasn't yelling at all. After that, she completely ignored him for the rest of the time. Watching an elderly customer be spoken to that way was upsetting and uncomfortable. Regardless of how busy or slow it is, there's no excuse for treating customers with that level of disrespect. Unfortunately, because of this interaction, I won't be returning.

Freedom Farms Carry-Out Kitchen

4.4

(62 reviews)

Delicious! A great atmosphere and delicious food. We had fried pickles, a Reuben, and the spicy…read moreItalian. They were all fantastic. The bread was great, the sandwiches were flavorful and the fries were really good.

You can't beat a farm to fork restaurant. I love this place. The food, price, staff and vibe. It…read morenever disappoints! Also their house ranch is SO good.

Fifth Avenue Taphouse

3.8

(32 reviews)

Food is fanfuckintastic, the owner is constantly walking around talking to people. We go there…read moreweekly and ne er had a bad experience

Great breakfasts here. Anything you want. Pancakes are the best. Sausage gravy too. Service top…read morenotch.

Brown's Country Kitchen

3.7

(115 reviews)