I am disappointed to say that our recent experience ordering from The Hoagie Shop was not what we expected. We ordered Tuna hoagies and they were edible. The tuna flavor was very overbearing and the amount of mayo made the hoagie inedible for me. Luckily, my husband was able to eat it the next day. Stay with their regular subs and you should be fine! read more

I love The Hoagie Shop. A Butler institution. Some don't like their deli meat cut a little thick and wrapped around the cheese and shoved down on top of the lettuce and tomato, but that's what the Hoagie Shop is. Great meatballs, hot fresh fries and plenty of them. You have to try the Brisket. It's so good that sometimes I crave it at night! Very tender and cooked just right. Their horseradish sauce makes this sandwich a 10! And, I'm pretty sure the 2 Hoagie Shop locations are keeping a rubber band factory in business. Lol read more

The best ever! Has not changed in 65 years! So yummy! And a great price! Butler food at it's finest. read more

The smothered brisket sandwich was delicious . Just dot it with a little hotsauce takes over the top ! You can thank me later .

Is it possible to give a zero? It should be possible to give this place a zero. For whatever reason, getting a proper hoagie in Butler, PA has proven much more difficult than I would have thought. That is the exact type of food I thought would be easy to find in abundance here. I was ordering a Ham & Cheese hoagie from here and asked to add mayo. They told me that they don't do mayo, only miracle whip. What?!?! For that alone they should be stripped of the right to call themselves the "Hoagie" Shop. Even if the owner(s) is one of the very few on this planet of Earth who somehow prefer miracle whip over actual mayo, fine. To not even have mayo as an option though? It is one of the most common condiments that goes on sandwiches. Millions of time more popular than miracle whip. Literally millions. There certainly is over a million people a day (several million I would assume) adding mayo to their sandwiches and burger. How many in comparison are adding miracle whip? Now look, the mayo thing, bizarre as they may be for that, is not enough to earn them the only one star review. It's that after I got "no mayo", I asked for a tuna salad sandwich instead, "we dont have that". I pointed to the sign on the wall that clearly read "Tuna Salad". After no explanation from the two kids behind the counter I said "Okay, I'll do a chicken salad hoagie". If you are picking up on the pattern I bet you can guess the response that I got, "we don't have that", again with no explanation or additional help. Then came the coup de gras. When in response to the 3rd "we don't have" I asked which items they do have, the girl responded, I kid you not, "we got those items on the board" and pointed to the same sign that I had pointed at listing "Chicken Salad" and "Tuna Salad". It was like I was in an episode of Seinfeld or a prank video show. I simply, without a word, turned around and left. I attached a picture of the board below and highlighted chicken & tuna salad. I will add this one thing, the free bread box that is done at the other location is very cool. I do a Little Free Library and food pantry outside of my home. So I very much appreciate that they do that. read more

The Hoagie Shop - Wall Menu: it says chicken salad & tuna salad, but apparently those are not actually served. - Salad Near Me - Butler, Pennsylvania

Always fresh, delicious and fast. Their capocollo hoagie rocks with spice oil. It's my favorite. Great for a picnic before a kayak paddle.

For the first 33 years of my life, I'd always go with a regular no tomatoes but then i found the smothered steak and it's so delicious!! Also a big fan of the fried mushrooms! This place is great every time you go and the staff is friendly. There is sometimes a wait because they get very busy around lunch time but it's worth it! 10/10 would recommend! read more

Stop there on the way home from camping with my husband and a friend and his dog (we ate in the parking lot). Hoagie's were delicious served on homemade bread.. Cheese fries were good. Thick cut fries, average cheese sauce. Bane (the dog) said he liked everything. Only complaint, they need to give bigger napkins. read more

So, I was working in the area today and I saw a sandwich shop thinking "that's where I will have lunch." I saw food safety certificates on wall proudly displayed and the best sandwich for area. Well, I'm thinking "I'm in store for a great sandwich." Two young teenagers were running the store. One was glopping the industrial size of miracle whip in a Tupperware container: chattering. So, the sandwich was done but I can't have it till the fries were ready apparently... my 30 minute lunch was just ticking away... finally the moment I have been waiting for. I anxiously open wrapper of the sandwich, I see hoagie roll, a tomato slice (really only one and cut in half) lol lots of lettuce, and no onions even though she asked me. Also there was no dressing, no mustard no pickles and I asked for roast beef, but this wasn't deli meat like giant eagle, it looked like a piece of leather. So I wrapped up and brought home for daughter who said that was a mediocre sandwich. read more

I always enjoyed the Hoagie Shop on New Castle Road, and this one is closer to my work so I had to try it out. So far the hoagies I got were really good and made pretty quickly. I normally stick with the typical italian hoagie with the oil dressing, that has always been my favorite. The location is pretty small, but it is very clean, and the employees were always nice and talkative with me. I would recommend going just to try it out...either locations read more

Best hoagies in Butler PA. Love the steak & cheese hoagie with mushrooms peppers and onion

Same ole Same ole, Butler Hoagie shop, Can't tell one from another, Basic yes it has bread meat LTO, Did I mention basic.

I love the food I've been eating it since I was a kid. (I am 59) The thing is, the girls need to slow down and pay attention to what they are doing when making the sandwiches. example: Last week I had my son and grandsons in from Minnesota. They wanted a Philly steak sandwich. I don't think they make them here at The Hoagie Shop but what he got was a roast beef with some kind of cheese gravy. Not so good I guess he didn't like it. I also ordered three small steaks with LTM grilled onions mushrooms and provolone cheese. three small Grilled ham and cheese with everything. A large regular with everything, and a child's grilled chicken with cheese, a large order of fries and three orders of mushrooms. I got three cold grilled ham and cheese,(she forgot to grill the ham) I told her and she took my meat and cheese out and heated it for me. Okay but there was a problem. My ham hoagie tasted sour. I asked her if she put italian dressing on it she said no but maybe it was the spices. I. don't know what it was but it wasn't right. Also,two steaks without cheese, Three steaks without mushrooms and grilled onions, a grilled chicken with no cheese and, a large and a small french fry. I asked the girl why she was in such a hurry to make the food so fast that she did it wrong, and she said she has to get things done. When I reminded her that it was more important to get the order right than just get it out she just looked at me like I was insane. I told her to just slow down and please the customer. Yesterday. It was my mother's birthday. She wanted tuna hoagies from the hoagie shop. I had to feed six people and everything was fine except my Grilled Ham and Cheese with everything except spices. They never used to put spices on them just LTM onions relish oil and red pepper seeds. well of course my sandwich was wrong. They forgot the tomato. Not a big deal I had some on hand but, what if I ordered this for my lunch at work and got there and I didn't have my sandwich the way it was supposed to be I would be bummed and probably a little ticked. I hope the owner is reading this review I love your food please don't change it. Tell the help to be accurate. thank You, Joel Mann read more

Drusilla Sisson 4108 Cypress St. Butler, Pa 16001 724-332-1358 I have my high school diploma and I am extremely interested in working for the hoagie shop on New Castle Rd. or Bon Aire Pa I am willing to relocate to Florida or West. I know a Shirley Swory use to be from the one on New Castle Rd. Butler, Pa You can view my resume online through the Pennsylvania Career Link or Indeed. Thank You Drusilla Sisson read more