The Hoagie Shop

Stopped in with the family last weekend and WOW--instant new favorite. The food and service were…read moreabsolutely on point. If you go, do yourself a favor and order the smokehouse chicken. I'm still thinking about those horseradish mashed potatoes and that Bridge BBQ... I swear I almost licked the plate. Normally I'm the designated food photographer, but the hangry hit hard and everything disappeared before I even thought about my camera. Highly recommend. This place is definitely joining our family rotation.

Sat at the bar, and the bartender was polite and responsive…read more Ordered the Reuben, wings, and French onion soup. Unfortunately, the Reuben was the worst I've ever had. The bread was disappointing, and the overall sandwich was lacking in flavor and quality. The wings and soup were okay, but the Reuben was a major letdown.

Nice atmosphere

See all

Michael's Restaurant

3.7(14 reviews)

6.2 mi

Michael's is right off the road, convenient to exiting & accessing the highway. It is homecooked…read morefood. The one pancake was almost as big as the plate! The sausages looked handmade. I got decaf, which was ok, but another customer said that the regular was excellent. It has a small-ish dining room, 12 tables. It's a little run-down, but clean. Jerri, the waitress, is efficient and pleasant. For a full breakfast, less than 10 bucks, you can't go wrong. PS Ugh. The ladies room needs significant improvement. Pretty bad. And sticky. Ew.

Food still good but service is the Pits!!!! New owners are…read moreclueless when it comes to service. Wife & I will be taking a very long break and hope that telling a customer that there is no time to wipe down a table is unacceptable especially by one of the owners!

Front Door

See all

Chop Shop

4.7(314 reviews)

1.4 mi

This place is a gem. The outside does not lend itself to what belies within. The food is eclectic…read moreand gourmet. The service is great and overall a pleasant surprise. This a five star restaurant wrapped in an unassuming diner package.

A must stop spot in Butler. Their menu is a variety of comfort food to dishes with flavors you…read morewouldn't expect to find. The cheeseburger soup was delicious. Heavy, but delicious. The portions are large and service and decor are great.

Inside

Duck pastrami Rueben yummmm

See all

The Space

Diamond Joe’s Pizza

4.5(2 reviews)

1.7 mi

Extra cheese with mushrooms. Unbelievably delicious. Crust was crisped to perfection.read more

Not bad. We had this pizza, Patty and I, last evening it was pretty good but the crust was not as…read moregood as Villa Grande crust according to my taste buds. Patty thought it had too much sauce. I thought the cheese was too chewy. I know I'm splitting hairs here but that's what I do. Years ago I loved Sirena's pizza at Bon Aire shopping center I would get it every Friday for my Four boys and myself. Now I see the Sirena's pizza in Kittanning is still open so I am going there next to try it out. So I would rate this diamond Joe's an 8 out of ten. It's mostly about the crust people.

See all

Deconstructed Chicken Philly Cheesesteak.

Villa Grande Restaurant

3.9(101 reviews)

1.7 mi

I came to Villa Grande looking for local eats that had amazing flavor and they did not disappoint!…read moreI ordered three different pasta entrees, the bruschetta, and the french onion soup. Every single item was made fresh and tasted absolutely amazing! I would recommend this restaurant to anyone looking for a good meal!

We were traveling across the country and stumbled onto this exceptional Italian restaurant. Our…read moredinner was delicious and the service was excellent. Everything down to the bread was first rate. We eat a lot of Italian food in NY and CA and will definitely return to this wonderful place if we are ever again in this area.

Wedding Soup

Linguini with white clam sauce

See all

Olive and Rye

4.3(3 reviews)

1.6 mi

Found this breakfast and lunch spot when I was fiending for caffeine. I was a little thrown off…read morethat it was immediately adjacent to another coffee cafe with a similar menu, not sure what's up with that. Both offer sandwiches, soups, salads, and coffee/tea drinks, this spot also has crepes. I came here because it seemed like the faster option of the two. I grabbed a few drinks to go, they were okay. I was a little surprised that their lattes seem to come with oat milk by default? Thankfully they were able to accommodate me with another option. At the register they had a separate paper menu with additional options that aren't online. My drink was just okay, but they seem to be more known for their food, specifically their sandwiches. I intended to grab something small but the pastry case was empty even though it was still pretty early. The space was a little on the sterile side with a brown and gray color scheme and florescent lighting but I did like the flowers used as decor in the space, and apparently their tables are custom made by a local carpenter!

This is a new little cafe that is perfect for a lunch. They have a great tuna salad that you can…read moreget on greens or on bread. The chicken salad is very good too. My go-to spot anytime I am in Butler.

Tuna salad

Chicken salad

See all

Natili North

3.7(34 reviews)

1.3 mi

Food was excellent. Had the spaghetti and hot sausage and a glass of milk. Son had a white pizza…read more Fantastic. But what was exceptional was the server, Day. She was by far the best we have had in a very long while. We will be back soon.

Their pizza tastes like store bought frozen pizza, no lie. Me personally I'd go eat dominos and I…read moredon't even like dominos. My brother got hired on there and worked a week and got fired because he made too much money. What a joke.

See all

Tropical Smoothie Cafe

2.8(6 reviews)

2.5 mi

Extremely slow. ordered online and even got there almost 10 minutes past my pickup time. Half of my…read moreorder was still not done and when i went to just let them know i was there they just looked at me like i was supposed to come behind the counter and make the smoothie myself. They moved around seeming like they had no idea what they were doing and just kept looking at me apologizing instead of actually just making the smoothie. Might need new employees who actually know what to do and don't just look at you confused ‍

The smoothie was terrible!! All I wanted was strawberries and bananas and tasted something too…read moresweet and non fruit like in it. I could not drink it. Also had a peanut butter banana smoothie with protein that was unsinkable!! Way too sweet and terrible. Would not ever go there again for a too expensive, too sweet smoothie!!

Protein breakfast: Peanut Paradise™, Mixed Berry Greek Yogurt Bowl & Sausage Egg & Cheese Dilla'.

See all

Chia Oatmeal Tropic Bowl.

Energized Dining

3.7(16 reviews)

3.0 mi

Excellent food - many menu offerings Service was great - the…read morewaitstaff was very attentive Ambiance is excellent. Owners did a wonderful remodeling job and it was so lovely and comfortable. Highly recommend.

We placed our order (take out) for a vegitable bowl and a salad at 11:00 AM. It is now 11:48 AM…read moreand we are still waiting.

See all

Compadres Mexican Restaurant Butler

3.7(53 reviews)

1.0 mi

Nice surprise. Really comfortable feeling when I saw the interior. Even better when our server was…read morequickly at our table to inquire as to drinks, returning shortly to take my order. I was the last one in our group of seven to arrive, probably twenty minutes or more, and the others seemed well taken care of. Decided on the Chicken Big Fajita Burrito. Would order again. Good salsa and chips. Hope I have an opportunity to be up this way again.

Usually everything I get from this restaurant is awesome. I have no complaints recently though. I…read moregot one of the chicken tacos or actually three of them and I wouldn't recommend that to anybody. They tasted great. They just don't stay together and were as greasy as John Travolta's hair in Grease.

Entrance

See all

Free chips and fresh salsa time!

The Hoagie Shop - salad - Updated September 2026

People who viewed The Hoagie Shop also viewed

Hoagie Shop

4.1

(23 reviews)

Great hoagie or subs if thats what you like to call them made fresh and fast. And reasonable…read moreprices.

Typical great service and food! Have been ordering for years. Glad this one wasn't over spiced w…read morepepper flakes! Really hit the spot!

Upper Crust Shop

4.4

(8 reviews)

Small, family-owned diner that caters to Butler county courthouse workers and visitors as it's…read moreconveniently located a short walk away. No frills, takeaway-style spot with efficient and courteous service. The menu is exactly what you'd expect for lunch ranging from the usuals like soups, salads, and sandwiches. All executed well and really good. Affordable prices.

Upper Crust's chicken salad is to die for--beautifully prepared chicken breast with just enough…read moremayo to hold it together and accented with green grapes and slices almonds.

Freedom Farms Carry-Out Kitchen

4.4

(61 reviews)

You can't beat a farm to fork restaurant. I love this place. The food, price, staff and vibe. It…read morenever disappoints! Also their house ranch is SO good.

Great lunch spot with grist house beers available....pretty much enough said. Had the buffalo…read morechicken wrap. Clearly using quality chicken with a nice crunch and traditional sauce. Bonus is a full grist house tap room and great indoor and outdoor seating. The service on both the food and tap room was friendly and quick. The set up is kind of like a food hall but with one food option. Order food, get a buzzer, have a beer, then pick up your food when buzzed (no pun intended). Anyway, this is a great option for fresh quality sandwiches and fresh quality beer. Plus you can walk 25 yards to the freedom farm market for seasonal goods and fantastic local provisions. Jump in the car on a beautiful Saturday and take a drive to Butler and freedom farms. There's also plenty of other country market, food and fun in the surrounding area.

Bowser's

4.0

(193 reviews)

Food was really good. Service was excellent Not crowded…read more So many things on the menu to try!

Neighborhood restaurant, close by, and good food! At supper there is always a big crowd! So many…read moremenu items to choose from. The Joe Namath burger is excellent! I wonder if he has ever had one? The buns are just right. Not real thick to take away from the burgers. The fries and onion rings are the best around. Wait staff is always attentive and willing to go the extra mile for requests. Frank has been there forever and always has great suggestions if you can't decide. He is "Bowser's " mascot! The roast beef , fries and gravy are second to none! If you haven't tried the steak salads be forewarned they are HUGE! Some unique items using brisket. Yes there is the best brisket you will find nowhere. AND you can see where the smoking of the brisket and pork happens as you walk in the door!

Penn Street Pizza

3.5

(16 reviews)

i literally LOVE this place. I always get it when I come visit my mom. I get takeout and although…read moreit takes about an hour/hour to a half, the food explains why. It's so delicious. This is the best wedgie that ive ever had. Everything is also very reasonably priced!!

Seating, there were 2 tables and 4 chairs at each table, But you were not allowed to even sit while…read morewaiting for your order. We sat on the front steps while waiting for our food. They can take your money but also inconvenience you. We will not be coming back. I do not recommend going there if you intend to go out to eat. They charge a $10.00 delivery fee no matter what. This was recommended by the hotel we were staying at, that they told us you can sit in and eat. Its not. Our hotel does not have seating in the room.

Philly Originals

3.9

(85 reviews)

I stopped in for lunch with my wife on a Saturday. We were surprised to find that the place was…read moreempty with all of the shoppers walking around outside, but we were not disappointed with our lunch. We each ordered a junior cheesesteak - which is plenty big for an adult in my opinion. I added a bunch of toppings, and my wife went kind of plain jane with just green peppers and cheese. Both were served quickly and (very) hot on a tasty roll. My one negative comment is that the sandwich was a little greasy and messy, but that's like complaining that your beer is too cold. Anyway, the place was reasonably clean, the guys working the counter were nice, and we enjoyed our meal. I'll be back again.

Stopped by for lunch when I was in Beaver. Really enjoyed the meatball sub and French fries. Split…read morethe meal with my husband, was more than enough to share. Fast service was very appreciated. Cute outdoor seating.

Butler Hot Dog Shoppe

3.5

(43 reviews)

Swung by to get a Butler classic hotdog. The doggie deal is $7 comes with two dogs fries and a…read moredrink. It was exactly what I needed. Store bought dogs with store bought chili and cheese. I wish they had put more chili on I wanted it dripping off. The fries are basic store bought fries with salt and pepper added they hit the spot. Ate at a picnic table outside. So good!

I recently moved to the area and saw this posted on FB Exploring Butler so I stopped in (and so…read moreglad I did)!!! The staff were patient and extremely helpful; after giving my order, we chatted while my hot dog and onion rings were prepared. The staff explained the onion rings were made with real onions and homemade coating! YUM! and the chili on the hot dog was very tasty. If you order a large onion rings, I hope you have a large appetite! huge portion! I highly recommend you stop in! and on Mondays, hot dogs are only $1!!!!!!

Soup-Herb Sproutz

4.2

(65 reviews)