LOVE Natalie! Wonderful customer service! Love from the Coachella Valley!…read more Super attentive with great atmosphere.

The good: tasty wings, margaritas, apps The bad: pretty…read moretasteless fried fish and paninis The service could have been better (server forgot about my second drink) but she was doing her best, taking orders, bringing out food, busing tables, answering the phone

Got a veggie lovers pizza with added pineapple and replacing green peppers w jalapeños, added well…read moredone for another minute bake and it's truly delicious!! Almost too many items for the beautifully thin crust!!

Delicious, cheap slices for $3.50 and busy spot even though a lot of their items needed restocked…read moreand were unavailable. Loved eating in the outdoor space with picnic tables because inside was tiny.

I love getting Pizza here, It is always good especially since it's always hit and fresh with great…read moresides. It doesn't take long to wait if you get take out or order in since the staff is fast and efficient. The Outside has a nice view inside and outside. Overall it's a wonderful place to get pizza!

The service is always so friendly and the food is so tasty!! I would recommend this to anyone that…read morecomes into this small town in Meyersdale!

I had a Wonderful experience here! The Outside is nice and casual. The Inside is cozy. The Waitress…read moreI had was amazing. I had delicious appetizers like Cheese Sticks, some s Spinach Artichoke Dip, and Garlic Knots. My main Entrée Was so good! It's The Italian Oven Combo. I also had cheeze Pizza which was some of the best I ever Had! Overall I would absolutely go back!

I really do not know where to start with this one. I'll begin by stating I have grown up eating at…read moreItalian Oven. Back when your straw was a noodle. While I understand this is not exactly the same, we all know it basically is. So I had an idea of what we were in for. Or so I thought. We stopped in on a Saturday afternoon. At our arrival there were three other tables. The largest had four people. The atmosphere was very quiet at this time. Our waitress was very nice to us but still somehow seemed overwhelmed or busy. We ordered the Tuscan Brucshetta for an appetizer. What was brought to use was a hotdog/hoagie bun, toasted with tomatoes and balsamic on it. For lack of a better word, it was weird. One of the entrees was a calzone and I'm not even certain the dough even saw any heat. It was pale, soggy & just barely above raw. We didn't have a chance to ask the waitress to ask the kitchen to fire it again bc we didn't see her until she brought the bill and our to go pizza. Not even sure what to make of the pizza. Watery sauce and limp dough, again. We have said we might give this place another chance bc sometimes people have bad days. Not in a hurry for a rematch but will edit review if so. Plenty of parking. Handicap accessible. Plenty of room inside for wheelchairs, walkers, canes and scooters.

I would rename this The Beeth Oven after the fabulous Bill and Ted movie, because this was like…read morestepping back in time, but in a totally excellent way. The Most Triumphant dish? The Pizza Fries. These fried dough "egg rolls" contain pepperoni and cheese and are served with a most excellent red dipping sauce. They used to be called Pizza Fryes which was a take on the Historical Dude Founder's name. The Wedding Soup was also a favorite. It was loaded with meatballs and all the other goodness wedding soup has. I had a bowl because I knew it would be good. The pizza wasn't my favorite, but I was already kinda full from the other stuff too, so it didn't get a fair chance. I was kinda bummed they didn't use pasta as a straw. So much fun drinking that way. Love the extra carbs, but I can understand why they went with regular straws. They still serve soda pop in mason jars though. Be Excellent to Each Other! And enjoy your trip to The Italian Oven.

Delicious Italian Comfort Food…read more The food here is really good in this Family Style Italian Restaurant. I visited on a Friday night and was seated quickly. Entrees come with salad and fresh bread. I ordered the Stromboli Deluxe and my wife ordered the Chicken Marsala. Both dishes were delicious and the portions were large. This is very good Italian food and the prices are fair. The restaurant itself is a bit old, but it was clean. The restaurant's decor could really use a refresh, and the men's room needs an overhaul. This is a nice place to eat.

Same good pizza I've been eating for 40+years reasonably priced food with consistency What you…read moresee on website is what you get. Probably get take out one a month

Fabulous!! Loved everything we ate. Nice selection of beers…read more Salad and pizzas great.

I prefer not to give negative reviews, but I could not let this one go without comment. I think…read morethis may have been the worst pizza that I've ever had. While traveling with my kid, we picked up a simple thing: a pepperoni pizza from stairs. When we walked in, the staff were arguing with each other about who wrote down what, who put the wrong toppings on which pizza, etc.It seemed that the oldest person in the group, I'm assuming an owner? Manager? Was being the hardest on the younger staff, which was difficult to watch. We left after picking up our pizza, And drove out towards our campsite. On the way, we had a couple of slices, rather, we each had one slice. The dough was "bready" and soft, pepperoni and cheese on top we're hardly cooked (the cheese was melted, but barely). The sauce was sugary sweet. Even though we were very hungry, we simply could not eat this pizza and ended up throwing it away. It was a very disappointing experience.

Unless you have over an hour to kill waiting for a cold hot dog and hamburger, PICK A DIFFERENT…read moreRESTAURANT! Seriously, my friend and I ordered two orders of fries, a hot dog, a hamburger and two diet cokes at 12:08 today. We were told "30-40 minutes." People who ordered after us got their pizza and sides before we got our food, which was the first red flag. The lady at the table next to us said, "They are losing tickets; you better go check on your food." I did; I was told everything was fine. I asked for our drinks. They were grudgingly given. At 12:50 (42 minutes after ordering), my friend went to check on our food. She was told "It's gonna be another 20-25 minutes!" At 1:13 we finally got our food when I went to the window and asked AGAIN. Two bags were basically tossed at me. "It just came up," the waitress said. I call BS on that! Everything was cold! NEVER AGAIN

I must say I was very surprised that this place had such good pizza…read more Living in Chicago and working in large cities throughout our life's has surely made us aware of good and bad pizza. No offense to the MT Pleasant people born and a aided to only have had a limited pizza choice. I have heard so many people name Doughboys as the Pizza to beat. I have ordered dozens of pizzas and always said if this is s the standard I'm very very disappointed as have always had the best to choose from. I have found the local pizzas are have to much bread or a sauce that's to bitter or to sweet or just like pepperoni and cheese on a loaf of bread? Really poor choices of places and quality . Ok Here it is my review !New York Pizza is a true winner in comparing good and bad pizza. New York pizza has a perfect crust with its thickness and ingredients. The crust is solid and not mushy . The cheese is real and comes with enough cheese that does require a add on. The meats and vegetables are fresh and prepared properly. The sauce is not to Spicy by has just enough kick. Not sweet or to sour. The price is fair and I must say it's the best pizza I have found in the Mt Pleasant Area including Northern Fayette County. I'll rather drive a little distance and pick it up than continue to buy the pizza locally that is clearly only for a family snack or just clearly convenient . .

NY Pizza in Connellsville was "ok." If you have ever been to or lived in the NY/NJ area, you KNOW…read morewhat NY pizza really is all about. This is kinda close, but no winner. But - Connellsville isn't exactly New York, either, so there you go!