I attended a luncheon where the menu consisted of pizza and breadsticks from Hunter Station. The pizza crust is very thick but they load on the toppings. We had a slice of supreme and a slice of pepperoni. There were so many layers of cheese and toppings that it was almost like a deep dish. Cons: With so many toppings the cheese was not completely melted. I will visit this pizza place again but I might ask them to keep my pie in the oven for a minute longer. I don't know how the staff are or what the restaurant is like since this was brought to the location of the luncheon. read more

this place should be busy for lunch. Pizza is hot fresh. Service was great. The young man and there was pretty much doing everything host server and cook. Did a great job. read more

Hunter Station - Got half pepperoni for SunShine and then pepperoni hamburger and jalapeños for me! - Pizza Near Me - Sellersburg, Indiana

See all

Last week we had our second experience with this restaurant/bar. The first was a carry out pizza - very good, but when the guys went to pick it up they handed over a $50 bill for a less than $20 order and the counter guy asked if they wanted any change! That has stuck in our minds. We ate in last Saturday. Pizza and meatball subs were good. Our server was Dayton and he was as accommodating as he could be. The only bad issues were that they were out of several things and vacated tables were not cleaned off the whole time we were there. Our bill for one create your own pizza, two beers, two waters and a meatball sub was $46 plus tax, totaling $49.20 plus tip. read more

Came in and waited to be seated per the sign at door. Place completely empty outside a few bar flies drinking at bar. We were sat in a booth in the main room and after 5-8 minutes waiter asked myself and my young teen to either sit at the bar or leave (which is an issue since minors shouldn't be sat at a bar where drinks are served from). So we had to leave because I guess a regular called in and reserved a section! No offer or free gift card for issue just leave! This place is absolutely awful! Do better read more

Fresh ingredients! Delicious pizza! Love the thin crust! Ordering online is easy and pick up is just as easy. We've also eaten inside and the environment is family friendly. read more

My mother took me there for dinner. We started out with the spinach artichoke dip. That was very good. then we ordered the biggest pie they had with the All Stars toppings. So good. And thank you for cutting it into squares. My mom got the brownie pie to-go. We had a small dip-n-dots for dessert. Service was excellent. That would be a great place for a small party. On Tuesday kids eat free. Also great talking to the owner Chris Fox. He is also running for Clark county council. I enjoyed the conversation. read more

See all

The food is decent, we had a pizza but there were a few large dough bubbles, maybe they should invest in one of those spiked rollers because this was the 2nd time we had a pizza like that from them. We also ordered a chicken bacon ranch sub. The bread was amazing, taste was good, I just wanted a little more chicken to hold up to the bread. We ordered door dash and the food arrived quickly. I would give them another shot. read more

Beer cheese and pretzel was okay. Pretzel was over the top good. Cheese was less than to be desired. All star pizza was good. Atmosphere was very loud. Great for families but the building itself makes the room very loud. read more

Hunter Station - All Star Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sellersburg, Indiana

See all

Food is good. We got a 16 inch pizza and it was great. I had gotten it carry out before which made me curious to go in person. The pizza did not disappoint. The service however needs to improve a bit. We had been finished eating for a solid 20 minutes (at least, if not longer) and our server never came back to give us a check. It was a Friday night and it was busy, so I completely understand having to wait a little, but our waiter just straight up disappeared on us. We ended up having to go up to bar to pay. Again, it was steadily busy, but throughout the whole service I felt like we were waiting longer than tables around us to order drinks, food, etc. Maybe it was just an off night? I'm not sure. If I come back I definitely won't be in a rush. Also note to people with sensory issues, this place can get LOUD. I think the guy playing music heightened it even more, but even when he wasn't going I felt more like I was at a college type bar. read more

After a long day of moving, along with a recent coupon purchase motivating our selection, we took in Hunter Station Pizza. Located just a couple miles from I-65 in Sellersburg it is located in a strip mall not too far from a good ice cream place, Chiller. The vibe is wide open semi-sports bar. Numerous big screen tv's with various sports in view. Looks like a recently added deck area was added, but not in use when we visited, but after a day of being wet from perspiration and water from the sky, indoors and cool was quite alright. I had a small margarita while waiting for the rest of our party, it hit the spot. We went with the cheese-sticks and were not disappointed, maybe the biggest outlay we have seen for those. The marinara was pretty standard, but it worked. We couldn't finish them all, these are poofier than what you would get at a Bearnos, and there ain't nothing wrong with that. Among us was ordered two calzones, which you can get up to three ingredients for no extra charge. I had sausage, pepperoni and black olive. The other one ordered was similar with mushroom. Also ordered was a pizza half sausage / half cheese. Warning; if ordering a calzone, phone a friend, they are massive. Neither of us were able to get through half. Loads of cheese and no skimping on ingredients. Hunter Station must have a pipeline to a cheese factory, as the cheese sticks, pizza, and the calzones were none too short. The pizza crust along with the calzones was cooked just right and has a medium thick consistency. We were quite happy with our selections. Our waiter was also very good and attentive. Hunter Station offers some very interesting dessert pizza's but after the amount of cheese inducted, we deferred. Great place, good food and good service. Was about half full of patron's when were there and seemed to be quite a bit of carry-out going on. Give them a try. read more

See all

We tried carryout for our first time. Carry out order online went smooth and was ready on time. Everything we ordered was great, will definitely be back. read more

Found this little gem on a whim! Called to make a pickup order and had a wonderful experience with the guy I spoke to and the food was amazing! I highly recommend giving this place a try! read more

Went here for the first time a few weeks ago with a group. Hadn't planned on eating but ending up having a pizza and cheese sticks. Really enjoyed the pizza, and we definitely go back. The cheese sticks were overdone and dry. I'm sure they would have made it right, but I don't say anything. The bartender was our server and he was absolutely amazing. If you haven't tried it yet, you definitely. read more

This may be my new favorite pizza place. We've had the Chicken Bacon Ranch, the Carnivore, The Hot Brown, and the Cheese Bread. All were excellent. And service was fast. read more

This place is just what we needed! While I'm sure others might disagree because Sellersburg has so many different t pizza places, but none of them compare to here! This food was excellent! Food was ready on time, the staff was very nice and and welcoming. The sauce was actually in the order! It was amazing! You can taste the quality of ingredients on the pizza! Give them a try! read more

See all

So this is a nice pizza joint. We were seated immediately on a Saturday around 7:30pm. The service was a little slow, it probably took 15 minutes for someone to come to us, no biggie. Our waitress was bussing tables, instead of focusing on customers. The pizza was fantastic. We would definitely go back. If they would direct their servers to focus on customers that would make them a 5/5 read more

I'm torn about this review. I usually don't leave bad reviews because I believe in supporting local businesses. However, this place was nominated to be featured on ABR, so I had high expectations. It was mediocre at best. The soda and tap beer were flat. No big deal. I get it. Sometimes things happen. But, the pizza tasted no different than Papa John's and went through me faster than Little Caesar's. At least with those I know what I'm getting. I don't think they make the sauce or crust in house. A place like this should even if it's just to stand out. All in all, I might go back but order not pizza. I hope the ABR profile helps. Given the choice, I'd probably drive the extra way for Mazerella's. read more

Gonna give my honest review. I bought three pizza's from this place at different times. Two were carry out, and not any better than a frozen pizza at grocery store. No cheese pull and not a lot of toppings on them. Not worth $20 dollars for sure. One pizza I had was was eat in, excellent and it tasted fresh and had a cheese pull. Very, slow service and a no care attitude! read more

Our first time trying the pizza here. We selected the All-Star with a thin crust. It was delicious! We are new to the area so called another pizza place first. After waiting for 20 minutes beyond our delivery time we called and asked about our pizza. We were told that they didn't have enough drivers so we would have to wait until a driver returned. What were they doing with our pizza for what could be 40 our so minutes late--keeping it warm under a heat lamp. Great. If we had been told that there were short on delivery drivers we could have come and picked our pizza up. Poor management. We cancelled. Then called Hunter Station. We won't be going back to the other pizza place--Hunter Station Pizza has our business now. Great staff and great service by the way. A + all the way around. read more

Food is really good when you get it. Most of the time we cannot get a menu or after we have the menu, we cannot order. Drinks are refilled when we ask the server if we can get her to stop when she walks by. I normally do not leave these types of reviews but there are only 2 servers there that do a good job. read more

Pizza and sandwiches are great and beer is cold. Great pretzels and cheese. I'm not a beer cheese fan so I always ask for regular cheese. However, I did try the beer cheese and it's not bad. As any restaurant, the service depends on the server and the kitchen. So, I've had great and terrible service but enjoy the relaxed ambiance, bordering on sports bar vibe, location, and will continue to return. read more

First time having Hunter Station Pizza and it was really good! I picked up two pizzas. Had the pizza with everything and it was piled high with great tasting toppings. Due to the heavy load, I would suggest having it cooked extra done to make certain toppings get hot and the crust gets crispy. My favorite pizza was the veggie. It had an abundance of veggie toppings and you could taste all the ingredients. Loved the cheese they used to top their pizzas. I will be back next month to dine in. read more

Hunter Station - 14 in Big Bubba - Pizza Near Me - Sellersburg, Indiana

See all

Placed a carry out order. 2 pizzas, breadsticks & a salad. Pizzas were sooo good. Toppings were very flavorful, salad was enough for 2 people to share. Breadsticks lacked flavor. Hubby picked up the pizza. Said service was top notch, very attentive staff. Pizza was still warm and yummy the 15 min trip home. First time trying this place. Didn't disappoint. Will definitely order again. read more

Good pizza but not impressed with much else! Service was sub par! Atmosphere is good!

They are clearly not ready for opening. We waited 30 minutes for someone to wait on us before walking out. It was their second day opening and I was giving them grace but cmon. At least greet us and give us some drinks. Half the dining room walked out with us. Other people that came in after us at least got drinks. People before us were still waiting too. This was at 4:15pm. Maybe we'll give them another chance but so far their reputation isn't looking too good. read more

Been wanting to try this place for a while now. I had high hopes. Place looks very nice. Pizza was good, not great. But unfortunately the killer was the service. Could get the girl to ever come back to the table. Finally had to carry my empty cups to the bar to get my own refills. Left feeling very disappointed. Not sure if I'll give it another try or not. read more

We've been trying to find a great pizza for 6 years, since we moved to So. IN. I was really happy with food, we got the Hawaiian Thin Crust. The crust was crisp but not fragile. The sauce was excellent and a great distribution of toppings. Our only complaint is we ordered a salad to split and it came out with the pizza instead of before the pizza. The ambiance was nice. It's like a sports bar. Overall thumbs up!!! read more

The bartender was ok. The food was decent. Had the wings. Recommend to request well done. Sauces are hot and tasty so make sure you ask about heat level. Overall just a friendly and chill place. read more

Picked up an All Star pizza to go! The order was right, service was good, people were friendly, and we were in and out in just a few minutes. Will certainly go again and eat in the establishment for it looked like a great place to hang out! read more

We ordered the Hot Brown pizza and some cheese sticks for takeout. Everything was very good and hot. We'll be back. I recommend checking it out. read more

Stopped for lunch. Pizza price is high. Ordered ham and cheese calzone with unsweetened tea. Waiter provided refill on tea. Refills are not free and cos $3 each. Good food, nice environment but cost too much read more

Way overpriced for the quality of the food. It was like cafeteria pizza. Don't go. It was $70 for a salad, breadsticks, 2 soft drinks and pizza.. go to Mazzarellas read more

A one star only because a zero is not available. Horrible experience! Order placed and double checked by manager and still made incorrectly! Order placed by my brother, who was already there So it would be ready when I arrived.No offer to remake it when I pointed out it was wrong. Server offered to bring me some raw pepperoni to place on pizza. Server walked around restaurant twirling his hair with his hand. Gross! When asked upon paying bill, how hard would it have been to remake my pizza correctly? Server said 'I don't make the pizza's. To which I replied, but you placed the order and manager checked it. Server said 'You weren't here when the order was placed!' Very smarmy and snarky! Manager was called over. Manager claimed he was her Star Server! He stood behind her smirking the entire time. Manager claimed she would refund money back to account. That hasn't happened yet. Never was there an apology for his attitude or disrespect! Never! She kept saying he was her 'Star Server' ! I'd hate to think what a lesser server would be like. Defined not worth the drive to come out and eat there. read more

The pizza is pretty good. I wouldn't say it's anything special per se, but we enjoyed it. The crust is a little too thick for my preference, but other than that, a pretty decent pie. The salad was mediocre...the lettuce didn't taste that fresh. The mango habenero wings were very tasty. It's obvious they are still "getting it together" service wise. It was confusing when we got there because the "open" sign was turned off, there were no handles on the front door, and there was a "we're closed" sign on the side door. But when we pulled the door it opened, and there were people inside eating. Our waiter didn't even greet us, just asked how many and sat us down. He had no personality and just didn't seem like he wanted to be there. Definitely needs better training. We will probably try again sometime just because it's such a convenient location for us. Hopefully the service improves! read more

Pizza was delicious, and plenty of options. And I enjoyed the beer cheese and pretzel sticks. Service isn't the quickest, and it's always a little too warm in the building, but the biggest issue is in the past few times I've been there to pick up carry out, the front area has a lingering smell of vomit. Not overwhelming, but it's there. Almost like it was cleaned up with a mop, and that same mop still gets used to clean the floor. Combine the smell with the warm temp, and it's why I've never eaten in and will only get carry out. Four-star food but three-star setup. read more

Super good pizza. Sellersburg really needed a pizza place like this. It tasted Great!!! Will order again.