UPDATE: Sad to hear they're permanently closed, this place was awesome the times I went to have dinner. They will definitely be missed in the neighborhood. If I could give Hunters Steakhouse 10 stars I would. The food here is absolutely amazing! I got one of the best burgers besides The Kettle Black (sorry they're still on my number 1 list) but Hunter's burgers are on point and you will not be disappointed. I love the classic decor, the wait staff was very friendly and welcoming. If you're looking for a restaurant with class and really good food Hunters Steakhouse is the place! read more

Went here for my mother in law's birthday dinner. The dining area is very well paneled and I love the look of the place. I had a special dish tonight, the seared Ahi Tuna with clams, mixed vegetable and saffron rice. It was exquisite and all the components perfectly complimented each other and the lemon sauce really gave a nice tang. Service was fantastic and I strongly recommend this restaurant whenever you are in Bay Ridge. read more

Hunters Steak & Ale House - Seared Ahi Tuna (special of the night) - Steakhouses Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I booked Hunters for New Years Eve. $150 with premium bar was the cost. The only good thing was the band who were fantastic but that's where it ends. We sat for over a half hour with nothing but water. When I asked for some bread I was told "we don't have any bread" When the appetizer came it was a shrimp cocktail but the shrimp looked like a limp cooked spaghetti. The main was ok. I'd never go back but I'd follow the band. read more

I was never really a fan, but this was it. Made a reservation is Sept for a party in Dec. A certain date and a certain room. watched them add it in the book. Talked to Steve and was assured everything would be taken care of. friends have been having their party here for years. The day of the part they call me with different reservations. Steve says, the room was taken, they booked it April. I will never give money to people like that. My friends can go there for their party next year and eat shoe leather steak. Every year the shoe leather gets smaller too. Better places, with better food for the money. read more

My sister and I came back recently for dinner and the service was nice. We got a table with a better lighting. This time I ordered a steak sandwich and it was a very big portion. I couldn't finish it, so I had leftovers for the next day. My sister ordered the surf and turf and her steak was quite good, however, her lobster was very fishy in spite of the use of lemon. She couldn't finish the surf part. I believe there is supposed to be valet parking. This is quite convenient to the subway. read more

Hunters Steak & Ale House - Steakhouses Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Food was okay. Not the best I've had but fair. The steak took forever to cook and was only medium but still came out cold, really tough, too chewy, and too unseasoned. The baked clams were too small and doughy. Overall though, some dishes were still ok and decent price so I would come again for restaurant week - UNTIL I always presented with the check with autogratutity 20% on party of 2. The service was barely adequate, long seating time even though plenty of tables were available and finally seated us at a table near the door even though other tables deeper in were available. The food took wayyy too long to arrive 20minutes per course and the check was brought to us without asking in the middle of our dessert that just arrived. Not professional. When asked about the autogratutity, they said it was noted in the menu but nowhere did it say it was mandatory tip for ALL regardless of party size or that it would be a whopping 20%. Service was not the best beginning or end, didn't feel comfy (so cramped) or welcoming. Would not come back again. Definitely ok food but felt very misled price wise and unwelcoming atitutude here. read more

Hunters Steak & Ale House - Steakhouses Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Tried this restaurant for the first time because of restaurant week and I'm glad I did. Came for lunch with my family and most of us tried the 10oz sirloin. Despite NOT being served on those sizzling hotplates with lots of oil and/or butter, the steak was surprisingly flavorful and tasty. We all enjoyed the steak and it was cooked the way we wanted it. I had to order a salmon filet to share with my toddler. Unfortunately, he wasn't in the mood for salmon but he enjoyed the julienned veggies. Also ordered the fish and chips, as well as yhe chicken fingers for the kids. They enjoyed them both. Service was great. Love that it seems to be family owned as they were training their teenage son how to be a waiter. Overall, I would definitely come back for some tasty but affordable steak. They have alot of other items on the menu as well including pasta, chicken, fish. read more

I didn't think it was possible for a steakhouse to make a bland steak, yet here we are.

Hunter's steakhouse is one of the older Bay Ridge staples, in a small cluster of steakhouses out near-ish the water. We had their $39.00 Restaurant Week Dinner Menu as well as some their regular dishes. Their regular dishes were quite creative, almost fusion. Take a look at my photos! Their dry age isn't too funky, which is bad if you like a strong flavor. That's the main reason for the 4 stars. I believe that people who seek out dry age steaks look for that flavor. The service was great. read more

Hunters Steak & Ale House - Mozzarella sticks, but in the style of spring rolls. - Steakhouses Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

My friends and I decided to try to place for restaurant week. It's a four course meal which includes, appetizer, salad, entree and dessert with tea or coffee for $39 which is not bad at all. I was the only one who picked salmon while the other picked steak. There is a wait in between each meal, so be aware. Like more then 12 min wait. My friends were starving !!! Dinner started at 6pm and we didn't leave until 8:15pm ish. read more

Hunters Steak & Ale House - Resturant week menu (salmon) - Steakhouses Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

The burger was both huge and delicious. The fries were hand cut and crispy (which seems to be something a lot of places can't quite manage). Not to mention that it was a happy hour special if you're seated at the bar as were the calamari and wings. read more

Hunters Steak & Ale House - Happy hour burger special - Steakhouses Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

We were a party of three for their $150 pp for New Year's Eve "special," which included an unlimited "premium" bar. We quickly learned that "premium" did not include all of the premium brands, but the waitress had no idea which. Finally, two of us ordered Maker's Mark bourbon, but as soon as they were brought over, at 9:00 p.m. at the beginning of the meal, the waitress said "that's the end of the Maker's Mark." They had no dry Rose' for the third drinker. After we sat there for an hour without a morsel to eat we asked for bread and were told "there's no bread -- nobody's getting bread." We ordered the shrimp cocktail appetizers -- the cocktail sauce was good, the shrimp were soft and floppy. The salads were minuscule, and the the Caesar salads had little or no dressing. The entrees were excellent. Desserts were good. Near midnight they came by with a couple of cheap noisemakers and hats, and there was a barely audible countdown to midnight by the band. The band was excellent. The night ended with champagne, in a plastic glass. This was a $150 New Years' Eve "special" done ON THE CHEAP. It's clear why they wanted full payment a week in advance. We shall not be returning, for any reason. read more

I haven't had a steak in a while so we decided to go here as it is in my favorite neighborhood in Brooklyn and got many good reviews. The place has a very nice ambiance and the service was good. The food was excellent but wow those prices. I don't blame the restaurant at all because they still need to make a buck. We will come back again and if you are in the area and want steak GO! read more

Hunters Steak & Ale House - Outside of the restaurant - Steakhouses Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Went there with my family for my daughter's 17th Birthday. Wanted to try a new place. Reviews were decent so I decided to try it. The place is clean and it has a nice ambience. The staff are nice as well. I mentioned to the waitress that it was my daughters birthday thinking like in other places they would acknowledge it and sing happy birthday- didn't happen. We ordered the wings- which had a decent flavor but the wings were very tough to chew; we ordered a chicken club sandwich- the chicken was raw...yes raw...the waitress apologized profusely and took it off our bill...we orders a steak sandwich which was edible, we ordered a burger-edible and we ordered the filet mignon with mashed potatoes- both of which had absolutely no flavor at all. Needless to say we will not be going back. read more

With our busy schedules this year we decided to do thanksgiving day out...hunters had a good deal so we thought why not? So glad we did! Wonderful service, delicious food and zero clean up! And still had leftovers for sandwiches the next day. Definitely coming back for steaks soon. read more

See all

Loved the food. The people are so welcoming. The salmon I had was amazing. They have live bangs and they are very entertaining. This is a spot to go to. Eg they had the band playing 60s music 1 day and other events the next. This is great. Also try not to drive. Hard to find parking around so might need to walk a few blocks. Walk or cab it. read more

See all

Thought its been a bit of a while since my last visit to the Hunters Steak and Ale House, I cannot say that I've ever had a bad meal here. Over the years, I've done brunches, lunches, dinners and special dining events that were all top drawer. There used to be a buffet brunch but that seems to have ended to move to a brunch menu which is still nice. There is a wonderful price fix dinner that changes in its options quite often and you get either a soup or salad, entree and dessert and coffee. During these times I've had either chicken francaise or petite filet mignon or some kind of shrimp dish if it was one of their shrimp specialty nights. While I am generally a beer drinker, when I am here I indulge in a glass or two of white or zinfandel since I like those two options more than a red wine. The waitstaff is curteous and friendly and checks back on the table often to make sure that you don't need anything. I like this especially after dining in places where you wonder where your waiter or waitress even went. I'd have to say that among my favorite seasonal themes here are the Octoberfest based on the cuisine they offer or the shrimp night since I just love shrimp. Oh yeah and there is a WiFi signal in the restaurant so you can do your Swarm and Yelp checkins while also letting all your friends on Facebook know your every move. Great place I look forward to going back. read more

Went here for dinner last week with my boyfriend and we had a good time. The food and drinks were really good too. We got pasta, calamari and some wine. 9/10 8/2023 Giving them a 3 this time because as nice as the servers are and drinks are pretty good. Calamari has not been good and service can be a little slow depending on when you go. read more

Excellent food . Haven't been there in years but I remember it well. Great steak and the oysters amazing . We used to go as a family often for special occasions . They were very accommodating and helpful with my orders due to my special diet . (Food allergies). read more

As we make our way through each steakhouse in our area(lucky us they are all reknown for their food), we had finally made it to this place to try out. The moment you step inside is like being in an old steakhouse complete with pictures of families, New York, trinkets here and there, etc. There is something reminiscent and homey about being in a place like this that is not easily achieved. We started with red wine to set ourselves up for steak and appetizers. The calamari was very tender and fried well, only lacked a little salt, but this was made up for in the sauce. The portion size for this appetizer was huge and could easily feed at least 4 people. Steak. My wife went with a sirloin steak that was surprisingly good. It was more of the doorstopper shape, rather than your flat out piece. The ribeye I had was the winner by far thought. The compound butter rounded all of the tender charred meaty flavor. This steak felt more complete and was served at a perfect medium. The cheesecake we had for desert was underwhelming. Waxy, very mute flavor. It seemed like maybe it was an off night for this product, so I would maybe try it once more in the future. Thank you, will return soon. read more

See all

I came here for dinner and drinks . Classic steak house decor , friendly service . We had crab cakes , Caesar salad and both had burgers. They were very good and the fries were excellent . Very large menu . Would visiting again . read more

Hunters Steak & Ale House - Bacon cheeseburger with fries - Steakhouses Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Went to Hunter's for NYC Restaurant Week before it ended. Did their $39.00 Dinner Menu. You got four courses. The food was great. I had the fried calamari, caesar salad and the broiled salmon fillet. My dessert was a piece of cheesecake. The food came out fresh each time. Got to try a buffalo wing as well. I really enjoyed my meal. When I got home, I had the cheesecake. It was light and fluffy. We loved our waitress, Teresa. She was very friendly and checked up on us. Getting to Bay Ridge can be a trek but I can see myself going back to support due to the service alone. read more

Hunters Steak & Ale House - Broiled Salmon Fillet with mashed potatoes and spinach - Steakhouses Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Been here a few times so far, since I'm local. Never disappointed. The steak cannot be beat. The Filet was like slicing warm butter, soft tender, cooked perfectly. My Short ribs were fall off the bone perfect. Often has live music or karaoke on Friday nights starting 10pm. read more

See all

Since I've checked in here more times than any other single place, I guess I like it. The staff and bartenders are really nice here. The lunch menu is a real bargain. It might be one of the best bargains anywhere in NYC and Brooklyn..I'm serious. The owners are committed to the community but outsiders are always welcome. They treat everyone with respect here. Most recently I had the fish and chips, which is only about $14 for two nice pieces of fish along with an ample amount of fries. The burger is excellent too and is only $8 (on the lunch menu) and comes with fries. Plunk down some money on the Quick Draw machine...and boom, you might win it all back. If you haven't checked it out yet... try it... you'll be happy you did. read more

Hunters Steak & Ale House - Fish and chips lunch. - Steakhouses Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

The staff and the food was good. Wish the desert was better. Taste store bought. Maybe the food would be better if there wasn't a prefix menu. Would have been a better experience if the table wasn't so loud and obnoxious. Hopefully next time will be a better experience. The staff was really nice and attentive for such a big crowd. read more

Friendly service and nice atmosphere. Came here for some steak and really enjoyed it. Kids liked their cheeseburger and we appreciated the overall dinner. read more

Hunters Steak & Ale House - Filet Mignon and Surf And Turf - Steakhouses Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

My daughter and her fiancé chose Hunters for their engagement party. It was the best choice and we had a phenomenal time. We arrived early to set up and were offered help as we set up. The staff was absolutely wonderful. You could hear the guests say that "they never waited for a drink ". Our head waitress was constantly checking in to make sure everything was OK (and it always was). The food was absolutely delicious from the appetizers through the salad to the main course through the dessert. There was no difference in the quality of the food from a dinner for two or a party of 60. I would highly recommend Hunters for dinner, and now absolutely for a party!! read more

Hunters Steak & Ale House - My daughter and her fiancé's engagement party - Steakhouses Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Had dinner on Sunday was very disappointing loud party going on. the wait staff was very much in a rush. They were very pushy about getting the entrée order, even before we had drinks and an appetizer. The fried calamari tasted like it was from a bag, the clams were no better,( blows). Waitress came over about three times for the entrée order. Bus boy came over to remove the plates even before we finished, I didn't see anyone else getting the rush. The food was nothing to brag about, once upon a time it was good now it blows. Not going back the only is if they pay us, very disappointed.Who ever is buying the steaks should buy less fatty meats. Going back to Atlas on Coney Island, it's has more CLASS & food taste Better read more

I picked up a porterhouse with spinach and sweet potato for pickup. The food was amazing the steak was cooked perfect and the sides were great. I've had steak all over nyc and bay ridge. I highly recommend this place for a solid steak. The overall atmosphere of the place is very nice as well read more

I was there Saturday with seven friends and ordered a New York sirloin steak. The steak costs $41. It was so tough I could have used a electric tool to cut it. It was the worst steak I ever had. Another in my party had the same steak and sent it back. I didn't do that. The meals the rest of my party was good. read more

Ah where to begin. Well this is the first indoor dining in about five months. Now I've never been here before so I took a chance and sometimes chances payoff! Hunter's Steak and Ale House is a bay ridge Brooklyn gem. One of those places that's "been here forever" and you'll see why. Order a ribeye and taste what can only be described as years of culinary mastery served on a plate. The steak cooked perfectly to order and there vegetables...OMG, just the best mixed veg julienne you've ever had and spinach that's divine,I didn't do any starch because I'm avoiding carbs. Also the most friendly wait staff I've seen in years, yes that is a big compliment to Valerie who took care of us tonight. So if your looking for great food, ambiance for a date or to celebrate with friends or any occasion than Hunter's Steak and Ale House is the place! read more

See all

We celebrated my son's communion here recently and it was great. The service and food were excellent! The owner was very easy to work with and accommodating. Highly recommend! read more

I asked co-workers how is hunters steak and ale restaurant. they all said it's great. I went there today and ordered food was 5/10. I ordered the braised salmon with sautéed spinach and my dish was very very bland. Fish was not cooked enough spinach was the best pa meal. Then ordered rib eye steak . the steak it's true to its size.. but very bland, no seasoning French fries and baked potato not cooked throughLyncy read more

This place has amazing steak and lamb chops, very reasonably priced- would definitely go again! Great service, great food! read more

Hunters Steak & Ale House - Steakhouses Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Great food, such attentive service. We moved tables and I forgot my purse. 15 mins later the bus boy brought it right to me. Any other place someone might have taken it. Our waitress Theresa was so sweet, you can tell she's great at her job. Overall very happy with our first indoor dining experience in months! The Tiramisu was so tender. Thank you guys for everything. read more

We had Dinner at Hunters Steakhouse in Bayridge and to my surprise my T-Bone steak was NOT to my liking. The steak was Tough!!! I, showed the nice attentive waitress how I, tried to cut into the steak. We did get a discount on the bill. As we were leaving, a older man was standing in the doorway, we believe he worked there and saw us leaving Intentionally blocked the exit. I, had to say excuse me for him to move to the side. Maybe he thought we didn't Pay the Bill and was stopping us from leaving. It was RULE!!! We spend a decent amount of money and left the Nice Waitress a nice Tip and didn't deserve to be treated like that!!! Not Nice!!! Now I, have to go to a real Steakhouse where I, never had a problem with a Steak and treated like a person and Thanked for Coming!!! That's RUTH CHRIS!!! read more

Great variety of american food but all of October is a fantastic Octoberfest. A special menu for 3 courses of lunch & dinner. Start with a flavorful salad with a strawberry vinaigrette, then select one of 5 German entrees and finish off with an Apple strudel. Great service to. read more

Food is delicious but three times I went there I got hair inside my food! I don't know why it keeps happening to me. But other then that lovely place. read more

Like this place so much. Tried it during Restarurant week. Taste good. Staff are friendly

Paid a visit here as they were a participant in Restaurant Week. The food & service were good, and the portions were suitable. My only issue is the indoor dining is a bit cramped. The table for two is a bit small and the layout of the tables is too tight, even excluding COVID considerations. read more