So we did sit on the bar side, I believe Autumn was the server she was attentive, quick and easy to talk with! Food was true to the description on the menu and the taste was amazing.... Prices I thought were fair for the quality of the food! I will be back! read more

Save your money and go to Texas Roadhouse. For what they charge the steaks are just as good at TR My WAGYU burger, ordered medium, was brought and it was well done and just was not impressive for the $27 price tag. Threw some ketchup on it and still didn't eat it! The upside was the service. The waitress was very attentive and did a great job. Save your money and go to Texas Roadhouse. I'm not even kidding! read more

Indian Creek Steakhouse is a Caldwell institution. But temper your expectations on the quality front. My medium filet was overcooked. Had an inedible center chunk of lettuce taking over my Caesar salad. "Loaded" baked potato fell short on the toppings. Disappointing. On a positive note, loads of fun cowboy ambiance. read more

See all

My husband and I were celebrating our 25th wedding anniversary and wanted a nice steak and lobster dinner so we decided to go here and give it a try. So glad we did. The food was absolutely amazing. My husband had the 18 oz bone-in ribeye and I got the lobster tail. My husband loved his steak and my lobster was seriously THE BEST I have ever eaten. It was so good. Had a smoky flavor that I've never tasted with lobster before that was amazing. My only complaint is that we went on a Tuesday night when the farmers market was going so we had to park nearly five blocks away from the restaurant. The prices for the food seemed a bit excessive but after tasting it, I'd pay it again. Overall, we had a wonderful dinner and plan to make it our regular anniversary spot from now on. read more

Indian Creek Steakhouse - Lobster tail with loaded potato and grilled asparagus. - Steakhouses Near Me - Caldwell, Idaho

See all

I've only downgraded my 5 star review to 4 stars just purely due to price. I do understand food costs has risen all over, but I feel the increase was a bit too high. However, service was still top notch and the ambiance still gives you that old school cowboy steakhouse feel. It is a place I visit every time I'm in Idaho and I'll be back again just because the food is so dang good. read more

See all

This place is huge!!!! It has everything to dancing and dinning and a fun bar! The atmosphere is super fun! The service was very efficient friendly and super nice!! They have a cool quaint down stairs bar and dinning! Loved it! The bread was absolutely delicious and the ribeye steak was good. A cool place to bring friends out of town or family!! read more

See all

Food was decent, way over priced. Probably wouldn't come back for because of what I payed.

The food took forever to arrive at our table, and it was not good--mediocre at best. The same went for our drinks. The atmosphere was cool, with live music and dancing, which we enjoyed after dinner until we witnessed an angry-looking man carrying a knife. He was walking around clearly looking for someone specific. Apparently, Caldwell isn't the safest, so that was our cue to get out of there before something bad happened. I would not recommend this place for all of the above reasons. read more

Every thing was delish from the cheese curds the "swinging steaks" to the filet and the veggies. Waiter was nice and friendly, and the place was cute and clean ! read more

Indian Creek Steakhouse - Filet bacon wrapped with loaded potato and asparagus - Steakhouses Near Me - Caldwell, Idaho

See all

Went in here on Sunday midafternoon. They were not currently very busy yet, we waited around for everything. Most of our food was good, but I will say the BBQ sauce in the nachos was WAY too sweet and I would have loved a plate that didn't have all my food falling off of it.. I'm not sure with the prices and service if it's worth going back anymore. read more

Really under rated. Had a pitcher or two of beer. Ordered prime rib rare. Oh so good. Came with fried potatoes, salad , beans and fry bread. Wife had filet rare with baked potato, beans, salad and fry bread. So good. Server was great and always asked how it was. Love this place. read more

See all

This was a first and last time for Indian Creek Steakhouse. Im sure that at one point in time this was a solid go-to and fairly priced local gem which no longer exists. Granted I heard nothing but good things about this place. We showed up for our reservation on time and the place was busy. Within 10 minutes of being seated we had our drink order and food order placed. A chicken salad for my wife and a ribeye for myself. Fast forward about 45 minutes to an hour.....no food. We flagged down another server (who was very helpful and polite, a real sweetheart) who checked on our food which came out about 5 to 10 minutes after seeing some scrambling of the staff. My ribeye steak, baked potato, and beans were barely warm. So who knows how long this food sat around dying. Never have I sent food back and wanted to leave so quickly without eating anything. Needless to say I was craving a steak for dinner, but left the establishment behind along with my apetite. With a price tag of $48.99, I honestly expected quite a bit more from a "Steakhouse". When you attach those sort of prices you need to come with your "A" regardless how busy it was. read more

We have eaten here non-happy hour (7 days a week until 6pm) and honestly, would not do it again. Great food but very expensive. This review is purely based on happy hour...not regular dining! All well drinks, house wines, and domestic drafts are 1$ off on happy hour and they have a happy hour meal menu. We have tried all of the happy hour meals! Today we got burgers. They are amazing! Taste great, cooked how you want! Same with the steaks! Always cooked well and tase great! I'm not a huge fan of the nacho's because they come with bbq sauce, but they always just take it off for me. We typically sit up at the bar unless we have a group. Bar tenders are always nice and attentive. Drinks are made well and they are pretty good about special requests! Sitting at a table can be a bit more time consuming as the dining area her is massive! They do lots of live events and music! read more

See all

I ate here back in December. I ordered a bottle of Huston Cab (I believe a 2016...rare...apparently they only have a few bottles). The menu price said it's C $95, but they actually changed me $125. When I brought it to the attention of the General Manager she reluctantly credited my CC....so she says. I didn't receive the credit...I called in January and again the GM said she will credit my Card. Well, as of today, I have not received the $30 credit ( the difference between the menu price and what I actually was charged. Couple other comments: 1. The General Manager (she works in the bar often). She's a liar and not customer friendly. 2. The bottle they think is so great isn't. After 10 years in the bottle, it hasn't aged well and really isn't worth the price. I'll never go back!!! read more

Took the family out for a spontaneous steak dinner Sunday night. The food was great but the highlight of the night was our server Jess. What a gem she is: kind, genuine, attentive and welcoming. There are many places to buy a steak in Treasure Valley--it's people like Jess that make you want to come back for the experience. So often today, customer service feels like a lost art. It was truly nice to see Indian Creek has some folks like Jess that understand hospitality. We'll be back and will be asking to spend our evening with her. The food was great too. Prime rib for the wife and I, cooked just the way we liked it. What a pleasant evening it was. Thanks Jess and Indian Creek! read more

Love the prime rib. We visit every family vacation. T-shirt shop is always hilarious to visit as well. read more

Indian Creek Steakhouse - Steakhouses Near Me - Caldwell, Idaho

I really enjoyed the food, the vibes and our server. Will definitely be back soon. I didn't a burger and fries both were perfect.

Indian Creek steakhouse is a great place to have a steak and if you like to have drinks and be entertained, they also have life band and dancing read more

Indian Creek Steakhouse has the potential to be a great spot, but it falls short in a few areas. It's more of a bar for middle-aged country folks than a true steakhouse experience. The space is massive--almost too big--and the lack of separation between the dining area and bar creates an awkward atmosphere. Before the live music starts, it's strangely quiet yet still loud because you can hear everyone's conversations. Once the music kicks in, it becomes almost impossible to have one of your own. The food was underwhelming for the price. I had a burger that cost $20 (with an upcharge for cheese), and it was so salty I could barely eat it. My husband ordered a steak, and his response was, "I could make this better at home for way less." To top it off, they never brought one of his sides. The best part of our experience was our server/bartender, who was really nice. Unfortunately, service was painfully slow--we waited a long time just to order, get our food, and finally receive the check. This place would be great if you're just looking to go out for drinks, but if you're here for the food and atmosphere, it's overpriced and poorly set up. With better food and a more defined separation between dining and the bar, it could be amazing. read more

Indian Creek Steakhouse - Drinks and stage view - Steakhouses Near Me - Caldwell, Idaho

Love the food!!! Best beef around and the wait staff was so friendly! We will be back....

Perfect char, melt-in-your-mouth tenderness, and grilled tastes that preach flavor louder than any sermon. This isn't just a steak-it's a spiritual experience on a plate. #HolyCow read more

Indian Creek Steakhouse - Steakhouses Near Me - Caldwell, Idaho

Place is great. The hostesses are good, food is good, We will be back. We love the atmosphere. read more

Used to be super good food and worth the money. No the money is a lot more and the food is a lot less and not the quality.

Came here on a Friday night at around 8pm and my girl friend and I sat at the bar. The bartender gave us our menu, water and a beer for my friend. Her and I looked at the menu, decided what we wanted and then we waited for him to come back. We saw him go to everyone but us. Finally I put the menu in the air and another bartender came up to us. Charly. She was new behind the bar and didn't know that we hadn't been helped yet. She apologized but it wasn't her fault at all. The male bartender seemed to purposely be avoiding us. The bar had us, another "table" of 5, and a couple others. The sitting area was semi busy, but he definitely had time to come to us and ask if we were ready to order. We ordered the appetizer sampler. The chicken tenders, green beans, and, one more thing. I can't remember. Also two fry breads. The appetizers were brought out on all separate plates and you could tell the fryer oil wasn't cleaned out in a bit. It was a really weird presentation. Usually when you order a sampler it is all on the same serving plate, but this wasn't. It just looked really weird. I heard the steaks here are good, but I probably wouldn't drive out here from SE boise. read more

Indian Creek Steakhouse - The appetizer sampler and fry bread. - Steakhouses Near Me - Caldwell, Idaho

Side regular salad was as expected. Nothing extraordinary but fresh and cold. Loaded potato had no bacon bits. No chives. And maybe a teaspoon of cheese , but to compensate. I guess, they topped it with two ice cream scoops of sour cream. Ew! She said they were out of chives then when I was finished with the plain potato, she brought me a little plastic container of those weird kinda fake crumbly bacon bits things. The $50 prime rib was pretty fatty. read more

Service and food are horrible! Don't waste your time or money on this place. You are better served to go to Taco Bell! read more

The menu was a bit confusing with all the weird names like "finger steak" (we're Yankees). There were a lot of choices for appetizers which was good, our waitress was nice and the place is very clean, but you should not enter in the karaoke contest there is some good singers in that. read more

Indian Creek Steakhouse - Old timey cowboy (girl) place. - Steakhouses Near Me - Caldwell, Idaho

To pricey for not great food, service could have been better. Probably won't eat here again

Food is always great from my experience and I haven't had bad service yet. We ate here most recently on a Saturday night and it wasn't terribly crowded but busy. The food prices though have just become to unreasonably high. Unfortunately I won't be coming back to eat here unless it's decided for me due to a meet up with family or friends but even then I'll try and persuade a different restaurant just due to the menu pricing being so high. Sorry ICS. read more

Food was alright, . The vibe was cute and very spacious. And our server was nice, but honestly I'd say just go to Outback with more options and better tasting food. read more

Such a great experience last night! It was mine and my husband's first time here. My husband and I enjoyed the steakhouse! We ordered some wings that were delicious! Probably the best wings I've had. They also had some really good nachos. Service was great! We were taken care of almost every 5 minutes! She was awesome! We were sitting near the pool table where it got loud which I didn't mind. There were a few drunk people by the bar that were being obnoxiously loud. Again not judging, it is a bar type place! Other than that, food and ambiance were great. Definitely will be back again (: read more

So- we discovered that there is a better time to come and get local steaks/drinks. It's any weeknight that isn't in the middle of the Christmas season. We went back on a Tuesday and everything was fast, friendly, cooked correctly and tasted fantastic. Get the fried pickles (always ask for extra ranch), get the fillet and get the loaded mashed potatoes. read more

I've tried an Indian creek steakhouse several times, and it seems like it just keeps getting worse. Overpriced, service is terrible and I can get a much better steak for less money around the corner from here. I'm done trying. I won't be back. read more

Let me start by saying that their happy hour deals are hard to beat, an 8 oz sirloin and two sides for $12.99 is unheard of! They have happy hour from 2-6 daily! There are a few different food options on their happy hour menu and drinks are $1 off. This space is huge! They have an area with pool tables and a mechanical bull, an area with a dance floor and live music, and then they have what they call their "tavern" which is much more laid back and offers a quiet romantic environment. We were seated in the tavern and loved it! The decor was awesome and we felt very secluded from the rest of the restaurant. The steak was incredible. It had such good flavor and was so tender. I got a side of loaded mashed potatoes and a side salad. We also got an order of fried pickles to share. They tasted very fresh and definitely homemade, we loved them. I will definitely be back for another happy hour! read more

See all

We sat by the back door and every time someone came in or out we got an arctic wind across the table. The guy behind me kept bumping into me ( I sat down long before he arrived). Took forever to get our food. My steak was cold. They ran out of bread. After asking for bread the waitress brought bread when I almost done with my dinner. Worst dinner ever. The noise was deafening. Kids yelling and hitting billiard balls over to our table. Will never go back. It was our 47th wedding anniversary. Texas Roadhouse is way better and way cheaper!!! Also the Rocky Mountain oysters were very small, overcooked and tasted like chicken gizzards. I have had much better. read more

I ordered my steak medium well, so the "chef" delivered a rare steak to me just to teach me a lesson. That happened twice, so I learned my lesson. Good service, nasty kitchen help. read more

While the food and service was good, I thought that $35.00 was a little steep for 8 shrimp, however what cheesed me off was getting charged $2.00 for sour cream on my baked potato and then being charged another $2.00 for having asparagus instead of beans, without being told of the up charge. read more

My husband and I go here for the live music. The food is mediocre. The service is hit or miss. It's a great hang out for sure but I would not go here if I was looking for great food. If you love live music and a cool western vibe venue with a decent size dance floor, definitely check it out. If you are looking for great food try another restaurant. read more

Absolutely love this place. It's our go to steakhouse. Steaks are cooked over applewood grills and delicious. The servers and the bartenders are our reason for coming back on regular basis. For me and my family the western atmosphere is what an Idaho steakhouse should be. read more

We were saddened by our experience today. We have always enjoyed our meals and time at ICS for the past 15 years. Today, not so much. Prices have gone through the roof. We were there at 4pm and had expected to order a burger for a late lunch, but those are now off the menu. My husband ordered a steak salad and I had the shrimp and fettuccine. The salad was a bagged mix with 3 cherry tomatoes and two cucumber slices that appeared to have been frozen at one point. The steak was ordered well and it was. The fettuccine was so loaded up with cheese and butter it was a glob. The shrimp was over cooked. We waited over 45 minutes for our meals while there were very few people there. Both our meals appeared to have been forgotten under a heater before coming to our table as my pasta had a hardened film on top and my husband's steak didn't appear fresh off the grill either. The waiter was training new staff, which isn't a problem, but if he's the trainer and forgetting our meals under a heater before lamp, that's not the best for their future. We spent $103 for a steak salad, shrimp fettuccine, two ciders, and 20% tip. We probably won't be back for a while. I hope they will get back to their old ways of great service and food. Today was a 3 out of 10. read more