Love this place! Though the cookies and ice cream separately aren't to die for... when you combine with the warm cookie it's so yummy. The warm cookie makes it. Portions are pretty generous for $6 which most places IMO are not. Definitely stop here after dinner for a yummy treat. read more

I'm sorry I wasted my time trying to support this business. While the cookies smelled amazing, I stood at the front for 15 minutes without anyone acknowledging I was there. The girl at the front seemed irritated to have to do any work. She kept scratching her head and then disappearing to the back. **if you don't like customer service then don't work in customer service** This is a chain establishment and there are plenty other grateful small businesses around Athens to give your support to. read more

Insomnia Cookies fits the bill for a quick sweet bite. It only took about 30 seconds for the young man who took our order to make our ice cream cookie sandwich. Warm chocolate chip cookies with a decent sized scoop of ice cream; it was definitely big enough for two people to share! The only downside is the $6.50 price tag - ouch!!! read more

Insomnia Cookies - Food Delivery Services Near Me - Athens, Georgia

Awful service. Just terrible. The worker rolled his eyes at me and they continued to mess up our order. The line got so long and I felt like it was my fault but I literally had to remind them my order several times. Really unfortunate situation. read more

Cookies were good... BUT the cashier barley knew how to do the job and messed our order. And when we asked to fix it they it was to late and rolled their eyes at us. read more

Curbside pickup service is awesome during the pandemic but I was a little disappointed that my snickerdoodle cookie cake was not cooked throughly. The app made me order a hour and half in advance to ensure adequate time to prepare the cookie but it was stuck the cake board and really doughy. read more

Updated: Officially a 1 star at this point. I was willing to endure long wait times and inexperienced/fumbling employees but it's no longer worth the three block walk from my favorite Athens restaurant. Came in to a near-empty store tonight. One employee saw us come in and scurried for the back kitchen area. The other employee was scooping ice cream at the counter and could not be bothered to even look up, let alone greet us. Stood at the counter for 2 minutes in absolute silence, turned and walked out. Won't be back. read more

The flow of this place really almost deserves just three stars. They should have an in and an out door for how busy this place gets. That aside, this place serves warm cookies and milk (amongst other things like cookie and ice cream sandwiches, brownies, etc.) that really hit the spot when you are wanting just that with no frills. Two friends and I had some time to kill before an author event so walked close to a mile from the Avid bookshop location here and then close to a mile to our event at the Seney-Stovall Chapel. This is my second time here and I believe the first time I went with the Double Chocolate Chunk and I'm glad I split it with someone else because it was really rich. This time around I went with the snickerdoodle and that was delicious but I'm curious about some others on the menu if we ever make it back here. I brought back the Double Chocolate Mint for my husband and he said it was tasty. Things to note: * they do have a $3 minimum and just one cookie is under $2 so either have cash or commit to at least two cookies! read more

While visiting Athens, my family and I walked by this place and decided to buy some cookies for the ride home. We ordered the oatmeal raisin, the chocolate chip peanut butter and a brownie. While none of the items tasted bad, it was also nothing to write home about. Too bad for a place that specializes in cookies. read more

This place is always a game day first stop for me. Nothing like an amazing sandwich made up of two cookies and ice cream to keep you cheering the dawg to victory. GO DAWGS read more

See all

Pretty much what other people have said. Workers are extremely apathetic and just don't care. They will lie to you about what cookies they gave also because they're too lazy to correct themselves - make sure to open your box and check before leaving. read more

Easily a great dessert option or a quick snack to get through the day. Ordered a double chocolate chunk and chocolate chunk cookiewich with vanilla ice cream in the middle and it tasted oh so satisfying. Cookie was soft and creamy and the ice cream melted in the mouth. read more

Insomnia Cookies - Food Delivery Services Near Me - Athens, Georgia

See all

SOOOO GOOD i got a chocolate chip cookie and birthday cake ice cream and it was the best combo

Interesting and simple business model. Happy with my brownie and ice cream. Had to wait for over 5 min for it, but was rewarded with extra free cookies. It was good. One of those that you enjoyed eating but felt guilty afterwards. Interesting to see that they run out of some of the cookie flavors. It's definitely a popular joint. read more

Insomnia Cookies - Brownie with a scoop of vanilla. - Food Delivery Services Near Me - Athens, Georgia

Disclaimer: review from a non-undergrad's (but UGA alum's) POV, so if you're visiting Athens - here you go. A fellow UGA alum and friend of mine had a hankering for Insomnia cookies two nights in a row during a weekend visit to the Classic City. They have an awesome business model - sell warm cookies by the single, dozen, etc., for cheap, at all hours of the day. Deliver to on-campus and near-campus location. Offer some ice cream and milk to upsell and sweeten the deal. Easy and simple, right? Seriously! If you're a big-time cookie (or ice cream snob), you probably won't walk away impressed or flabbergasted by Insomnia, but I guarantee your late-night and/or alcohol- or stress-fueled cookie craving will be met, and at a very fair price per cookie, in my humble opinion. Choose from approximately 6 "regular" cookies choices, such as the classics of Chocolate Chip, Peanut Butter, or Snickerdoodle. For a slight upcharge, there are some "special" options such as S'Mores, Rocky Road, and the like. Cookies are pulled from a warmer and placed in a bag, so warmth and freshness are pretty much locked-in at the "just from the oven put cooled enough to eat without melted chocolate burning your tongue" temperature. I can't vouch for the ice cream, but it looks pretty run-of-the-mill and is probably best left alone or sandwiched between two strong cookie flavors. Man - seriously - DELIVERY of WARM COOKIES until 3 AM?! Where was this concept when I was at UGA? Oh well...good to know they'll deliver to me when I'm partying downtown with my alum friends! :) Parking is obviously a pain, but let's be honest, if you're needing cookies and it's late at night, you shouldn't be driving...or if you're coming from campus and need a break, you're probably walking. Service is quick and the line moves efficiently; space inside is standing room only if your want to eat your cookies in-store. read more

Great Cookies, Poor Hospitality I love the cookies they serve (my favorite is the Double Chocolate Mint), and I love the option to mix it with ice cream. But the past (and only) 2 times I have gone, the people there haven't been exactly welcoming. Today's trip involved the two workers, great, but they also had a friend there that they were just hanging out with, gossiping with, and goofing off with the whole time they were helping us. On top of that, I have two very young and impressionable kids, and they were with me, whilst the workers and their friend were yelling and using obscene words the whole time we were there. I couldn't wait to leave. The first time I was there was better, but the workers would rather be avoiding the customers then, and spent most of the time in the bathroom than out tending to their post at the counter. read more

I've purchased cookies here numerous times and have had excellent service and products. However, went in tonight and a very rude clerk immediately, and with a condescending tone thought that my friend was only using the bathroom (not a game day) and decided to address me (waiting at the table) with a negative and very rude tone. The sign is posted which is more than sufficient for potential "wrong doers." I resent that type of treatment as I go out of my way to support local businesses. This is my first post and I am signing up because of how disheartening his tone and what I deem as a prejudice demeanor were toward my friend and I. He tries to rectify the situation with a 50% discount. However, he needs immediate customer service and cultural sensitivities retraining or find a new job. To the owners: watch who you leave unsupervised. You have a fantastic business that can only be tarnished by misrepresentation. read more

I deeply love everything about Insomnia, many a time I have ordered for delivery and had it come faster than I expected, one time I got an extra cookie, and THE BEST THING is if you get the Insomnia app sometimes they have awesome little deals like 3 for $3 for 2 free chocolate chip cookies and it's so great and I've NEVER had a less than 10/10 cookie. You guys are amazing. I've heard the ice cream is good as well. Vegans beware, the vegan cookie may be hard. read more

Cookies are really good. A little pricey especially fir a college town but good. Location was a little difficult to get to due to road construction read more

I can not even give this place one star! I went there today for the very first time. The cashier was extremely nasty in appearance and ATTITUDE!!! I work in public safety In Athens and we have received these cookies at the police department. I decided to get some for my family this afternoon and was met with a cashier who appeared to be inconvenienced! I was the only customer in the store and asked about a selection that was out of stock at the time. I asked what was close to the flavor and was met with the most vile and disrespectful response. I placed an order and then thought better of it, because the cashier seemed to have a bad attitude and I was not taking any chance for my order to be tampered with...the black, slim female or male needs to be employed somewhere, where customer service is NOT A REQUIREMENT!!! I will be calling the management ASAP!!! read more

My boyfriend and I were refused service because we didn't have a mask to wear. We happened to not have any with us at the moment. Whenever we asked if they had one we could use they told us no. If you require masks you should have them to hand out at all times! We then asked if we could just go ahead and order and wait outside and they said no. They said we could order online and then come back in store WITHOUT a mask on to pick them up. This makes no sense. We will not be returning. read more

Delivery takes at least two hours or you never get your order. I was stuck on hold for ages just to be told I can get a refund because my order isn't coming anymore. read more

DO NOT ORDER!!! i ordered a box of cookies at 8:45 pm on a thursday night. the tracking did not work so I called around 10 for an update and was on hold for so long with no answer. called again at 11 and was told they would fully refund our order and it would be delivered within 30-45 minutes and would send email confirmation. after hearing nothing, at 12:45 am i called again and they said they would only offer us a 50% refund and had too many orders and would most likely not be able to deliver ours tonight although we placed the order 4 HOURS AGO. i am furious because several other people were waiting for this order with me and insomnia has horrible customer service and no remorse for such a huge disappointment. how can they be unable to fill our order tonight when we ordered hours in advance from their 1 am closing time??? read more

A visit to my daughter at UGA was not complete without a stop at Insomnia Cookies. She usually gets them delivered to her dorm, but we were out an about that day and stopped in at the store. These have got to be the best chocolate chip (chunk!) cookies ever! We ordered a dozen and started munching right there on the sidewalk to capture that warm, fresh from the oven, gooeyness. They are to die for! I plan on sending her a gift from their online ordering system for her to enjoy while she's in the throes of her final exams. :) read more

Why even offer delivery if your tracker doesn't work and the food is going to be over THREE hours late? And then I spent 45 minutes on hold trying to get in contact and no one ever picked up. Wtf... read more

Came here for a date night dessert trip with my wife, and the cookies were good. Listening to the staff members curse in the back room while talking about their after hours trysts, and making fun of my wife and I, were not as good. Cursing and making fun of customers is a sure fire way to make sure your one time customers stay just that. I will not be returning. read more

They would rather not do business than take a credit card for my purchase, this is 2016. I choose not to make a dollar because it costs me a few cents, while actually it is much cheaper than handling cash. Completely rude approach for your customers who are in the digital world. Oh well, I need to avoid what is being served here anyway. read more

We came by after being told we just HAD to get insomnia cookies. When we stopped by they were closed for restocking but someone said it'd only be about 15 more minutes so we waited. The guy inside was very nice when he took our order. We got a snickerdoodle (which was by far the best in my opinion), oatmeal raisin, double chocolate chunk and peanut butter. The cookies were pretty good but nothing worth seeking out by any means. read more

Gotta love a warm, soft and chewy cookie. I stopped by here while visiting with some friends at UGA. I tried their white chocolate macadamia and snickerdoodle cookie. My pet peave is when I order something with nuts but it ends up tasting stale. So I was relieved when this wasn't the case here. My friend ordered their brownie a la mode. Their brownie is on the earthy side if that makes sense. I wasn't a fan of their vanilla ice cream though as flavors didn't balance well with the brownie. If I could choose a different vanilla ice cream I feel that I would have enjoyed it more. I really liked that their cookies weren't overly sweet. read more

Insomnia Cookies - Food Delivery Services Near Me - Athens, Georgia

The delivery service is honestly THE worst I've ever dealt with. On THREE different occasions my order has been been delayed 2 plus hours. 1 order we never even received then was offered 50% of what I paid as a refund. Y'all seriously need to do some revamping and analyzing to figure why your delivery times are so far off. Planned 2 parties and after the first abysmal flip I chalked it up to just coincidence. Nope! Scheduled a cookie cake an hour ahead to be there at 9. Tell me why at midnight I had still not received my cake! That's inexcusable! Get your act together. Customer service is a nightmare and offer you half your total back when they've totally fucked up. Never again. read more

I tried to do something nice and get cookies for a friend. The order would not let me track it on the app, was then over 2 hours late (which was at that point 1am, when originally scheduled to be delivered at 10:45pm) , and was delivered to the wrong address!! I specifically requested the order be handed off to the recipient and it was not and still said "delivered". I even called and was understanding that they had a backed up night with only one driver but I really feel as though they should've had a better system going in order to provide customers with what they paid for. read more

I have been to several other Insomnia Cookies in New York and they were always absolutely fantastic. We drove 30 minutes out of the way to go to the one in Athens, GA. I am a Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup fan. When we got there, the clerk (who was not very friendly) said they did not have any. He said "we only have what's in the display box". Very disappointing. I got a double chocolate chunk cookie and it was hard and tasted a little burned. My family got different cookies. My wife's was pretty good but nowhere near as good as other times I have visited. Maybe they were just having a bad day, but it was by far the most disappointing visit ever to Insomnia Cookies. read more

Heard about this place and decided to stop by after dinner to satisfy my sweet tooth since I heard they close at 3am. We arrived there close to 10pm and they had quite a few customers in there. The person that was working behind the counter was friendly as we ordered even tho they where low on cookies and told us a fresh batch was coming out the oven. 5mins later or so we got our cookies. I have to say it was worth the wait, the cookies where soft but not to chewy, it had a nice crunch crisp too it that wasn't over the top. I highly recommend stopping by and grabbing a variety of cookies, their white chocolate macadamia , the snicker doodle and chocolate chip cookies are some of my favorites. read more

Just your run of the mill cookie shop, nothing to write home about. They deliver late though, which is a plus. The staff is really nice, the cookies are mediocre. read more

Happened upon this place while visiting Athens. Delish! Especially the peanut butter cup chocolate chip cookie. I ordered ice cream too. Omg! So good. read more

Really good cookies the delivery is not the best but the cookies are delicious the employees are also nice!

Every time I get a delivery ... a pint of ice cream is what $8??? They only fill it up half way. Stupid.

My husband and I stopped by at 8:00pm, on New Year's Day, to get dessert for our 20th anniversary. Downtown Athens was quite busy. The employee greeted us by telling us they were only doing pick-up orders. I told her it was our first time in the store. She said we had to use the QR code outside to place our order, and she was the only employee, so it would take awhile. I will not be back. This establishment lost my business before I even tried it. Rude employees are reflection of poor management. In my opinion, if you only have ONE employee scheduled, a manager should be working. Ridiculous. read more

Waited over three hours for cookies we never got. Called them 4 times and every time they just told us a different time to expect the cookies. The tracker doesn't work but maybe that's because they never sent the cookies out. Last time I called they said they had delivered them to the wrong house a little earlier and I guess I had to call for them to tell me that. They proceeded to ask me if I accidentally got someone else's order who they apparently screwed up too. read more

The cookies are good but they are expensive for what you get. That said, 3 employees were there. No other customers in the store. 2 on cell phones. The third one was the only one that was actually working. The cell phone guys looked stoned. Not really a good look for a business. I'm sure there are better options in Athens. read more