Had to stop in for a fresh hot cookie in the cold. The service was horrible so unfriendly and was like we were interrupting her and her friend in the back. But the cookie was good. Probably try another location. read more

Insomnia Cookies - Desserts Near Me - New York, New York

I placed an order to go and was in and out in five minutes on a Sunday afternoon. The person working at the counter was very friendly and made the transaction seamless. I ordered a brownie with ice cream on top and she was helpful in helping me figure out which brownie to get. I was the only customer in the shop at the time and it is pretty small but decent for grabbing an order to go. read more

Insomnia Cookies - Yum - Desserts Near Me - New York, New York

Very small location but they are quick and cookies are nice and warm. They always have a variety of flavors available. Macadamia is my favorite read more

This was my first time trying "Insomnia Cookies" & it was good. I tried their oatmeal raisin, candy apple & confetti. I think cookies taste best when warm & it just melts in your mouth. One of my cookies was a regular size, while the other was larger. I don't know if it depends on the cookie you get, but either way it was fine. It's a plus that they stay open late, so if you're out in the city & want something sweet, check them out! read more

Service was wonderful. I had ordered my batch of cookies for pick up the night before. Admittedly I should've gone in person and ordered on the spot because the employees had their patrons out really quick with their cookies. The cookies are chewy and soft in the center, but a little firm on the exterior. Depending on the flavor they can tend to be a little dry. It's clear that they're not the freshest and aren't warm (I'm assuming this is because the cookies you get for pick up are different from the ones you order on the spot). I got a free cookie through the cookiemagic subscription and it was warm and soft. Of course this is just a hypothesis, but I'd recommend just l ordering in person (yes even if you're shy). read more

Insomnia Cookies - Spring flavors 2022 (hibiscus berry and lemon poppy seed) - Desserts Near Me - New York, New York

great selection of cookies and especially my favorite Brownies. I first discovered Insomnia Cookies in Washington DC then saw they were here in Harlem. I highly recommend this Black Busines, you will not be disappointed. I promise. Although you might gain a pound or two read more

Insomnia Cookies - Me in Washington DC - Desserts Near Me - New York, New York

If you've never tried insomnia cookies... You absolutely must. They are really upping their game... I remember coming here and it was always just cookies, but now they have ice cream sandwiches where you can build and create your own, which is so nice. The only downside is that they add a lot of ice cream which of course is not a bad thing... It's just really messy. I came to this location and I ordered a classic chocolate chip cookie with cookies and cream ice cream. I had to eat the ice cream with a spoon because it was way too large to eat. The portion size is definitely worth the price though. For the month of June they are promoting these ice cream sandwiches so they are two dollars off making the total around six dollars and some change. They have such great flavors but if you've never been and don't know where to start the classic chocolate chip cookies and the M&M are my absolute favorite. If you're a chocolate lover they have a triple chocolate cookie which is also divine. Our cashiers were both very friendly. This location is very small but most insomnia cookies are so it doesn't bother me. read more

Insomnia Cookies - Desserts Near Me - New York, New York

I have visited the store in person and had no issue. The thing that really blew me away was the delivery service. Both options are good but sitting at home while fresh cookies are delivered just can't be beat. The cookies were warm, delicious and delivered without a hitch at an ungodly hour which will go undisclosed. The bigwich cookie sandwich was perfect and the whole order of cookies was great for sharing. I have no issue whatsoever with the delivery guy, as he was courteous and efficient! Now these cookies don't beat some other competitors but the highly accessible, affordable and delicious cookies are worth trying. read more

Insomnia Cookies - The six pack sampler, with 2 macadamia chunk cookies and a deluxe bigwich sandwich - Desserts Near Me - New York, New York

See all

the cookies SLAP, too good! lmao they're so yummy and soft, warm them up & it's the best cookie experience ever. plus they have so many options lol even the brownies... omggggg. read more

I've only recently started buying from insomnia. I've ordered twice from the location on 125th and once from their Penn Station location. Ironically, at both locations, I was met with the same poor, lack-luster, attitudes from employees. It seems like to have a white customer is a disturbance to the employees and they despise nothing more. I almost get the feeling that if my cookies could be thrown on the floor before being boxed it would bring these employees joy. I hate to think like this, but all 3 times I've gone to this store at both locations I was met with disdain and an attitude full of micro aggression; despite me being overtly friendly and kind to the staff. It's bad enough I'm not made to feel welcome in Harlem because I present as white, even though I'm actually Puerto Rican. I just can't idly stay silent anymore when treated like this at establishments I spend my hard earned money at. I think corporate for this company really needs to look into the employees they are hiring and train them customer service skills. I work in the medical field and if I treated one demographic more poorly for their skin color it would be HIGHLY unethical! My mother taught me to treat EVERYONE the same with dignity, respect and kindness. Do better! read more

The workers here are kind and the cookies are delicious and fresh. The selection is unfortunately a little bit limited (they run out of the special ones often) but if you're in it for the classics then this insomnia will do. read more

Very friendly service and cookies were warm and fresh even at 2am. Not to mention delicious.

This insomnia cookies is super understaffed. I tried to enter the shop on a Saturday around 9pm. They were refusing customers and had to close for several minutes because they were overwhelmed with pick up and delivery orders. The employee working the register was clearly frustrated with the situation. When they did start taking orders, they were sold out of all the deluxe cookies so I ordered the regular chocolate chunk. The cookies weren't warm and were not the best quality. read more

Delicious! The cookies , the ice cream , the service. Literally no complaints ! Best cookies in town

Six pack came out hot and fresh. Hit the spot as I was craving something sweet at night. Place is open late and the staff are very friendly. read more

Insomnia Cookies - Sixpack - Desserts Near Me - New York, New York

See all

This location is super ghetto! Door is always locked after 7pm! Online orders only, they don't have all the "classic" cookies available online "peanut butter chip" for example, and seeing that the door is locked you can't even tell them to swap a cookie out for another one for the same price. read more

First time purchasing cookies in person. It was hard to decide but I made a delicious selection. I was looking forward to all of my choices. I was disappointed because I chose red velvet as one of my six cookies and when I got home I saw they gave me a chocolate mint cookie by mistake. yuck. I hate chocolate and mint together. All of the other cookies were correct and tasted amazing. read more

See all

My son bought me an assorted box of cookies and they were warm gooey and delicious. I sent my sister to the 125th store to get us some cookies and to my disappointment she came back with the cookies which were delicious but she stated that she would not be going back again because the girl serving her was soooo rude. It's a shame because we really loved the cookies; just lost a very good customer! read more

First time in New York, tried this spot cause it was still open and oh boy the ice cream is sooooo good. Worth every cent spent ! Service was good and it was a chill environment. Very Welcoming read more

I was very excited to learn that there is an Insomnia Cookies right in my neighborhood. Late-night desserts are always great in my book. *Maybe not so great for my waistline, but that is another problem for another day.* We ordered about a half dozen of cookies for delivery through Grubhub. The cookies and ice cream arrived within minutes (~25min), and the cookies were still pretty warm. I took one star away because there is a $2.99 delivery charge. Other than that charge, all was good in the hood. read more

Insomnia Cookies are some of the best cookies in NY. I used to love going to the one in Syracuse and this location has amazing cookies too. I came here late and they still had all the cookie options. The staff was patient with indecisive customers and they offered purchasing options that would save customers (me) money. I'm a sugar cookie and snickerdoodle girl but all the cookies taste good. read more

This place surprisingly always has my flavored cookies in stock. I know with Insomina it can be hit or miss with the selection. Cookies are always delivered to warm but the delivery window is weird. Sometimes they are quick and sometimes they take forever! Good cookies either way. read more

Delicious soft baked cookies! The aroma when you enter the shop is divine. They have tons of flavors and other sweet treats like ice cream. Definitely coming back to try the other flavors! read more

Insomnia Cookies - Desserts Near Me - New York, New York

See all

This insomnia cookie store sucks. Specifically whoever is doing delivery. They've messed up my order more than 3 times. I've had a couple of instances where I never even got my order. Terrible. read more

A snack should always but almost never is this satisfying!!! This is the only kind of dessert you could need and the only sweets worth the calories!! Do it!!! read more

We went in and the staff Nareai, Jamal and Bree Bree were super kind and friendly. They made us laugh after a long day and told us their favorite cookies. They recommend the peanut butter chip which was delicious. I would definitely recommend going to this location not just for the great cookies but amazing staff. Thank you so much ! read more

This rating is specifically for the 125th street location tonight. 1 star for delicious cookies + 1 star for following covid regulations. HOWEVER- staff needs customer service training. I came in very friendly and said how delicious it smells in there and said hello. I was ignored as staff talked amongst each other. My husband asked what a specific cookie flavor was as it looked good and she seemed bothered to respond. Everything was just abrupt. This was Not my first time having bad service. I once ordered for delivery. The delivery arrived earlier than scheduled which I appreciated but I was in the middle of bathing my newborn child and didn't answer the phone right away. The delivery person sent me a text saying to cancel my order "cuz I'm not coming back" and then "I'll take longer next time". Thumbs up to insomnias great recipes, thumbs down to their hiring practices. read more

Insomnia Cookies - Desserts Near Me - New York, New York

the food is really good, but the delivery service is horrible i'd definitely recommend you go in person rather than ordering online

Not what they're cracked up to be. Just sorta meh. I guess the appeal is the 2 am delivery ‍ and generally the person would have a discerning palate LOL I was with an expectant mom, so we weren't tipsy read more

Went there with cash & the lady at the front claimed that the cash register was broken & that they only receive card that kinda sucked

I love Insomnia Cookies. I don't like that they made one in Harlem because now it's so hard to resist with them being just a few blocks from me. Last week I sampled the birthday cake ice cream and thought it was good so I came back recently and actually bought a pint of it and it was so good. All of the cookies are great warm and they sell milk. The lady behind the counter was very nice and this location is easily accessible. read more

Delicious and soft fresh cookies. Nothing out of the ordinary here. My favorite place for cookies especially on a late night munchies run.

Store manager Jennifer at 17 W125th was remarkably HOSTILE and cancelled our order and hung up on me when I simply called to inquire about the status of an order 1 hour and 10 mins after it had been placed...and five minutes after the scheduled delivery time. To back-up, 55 mins after the order was placed I called customer service to inquire about the status of delivery and was told that it would arrive at 930p. At 930p the order had still not arrived. At 935p I called the store directly to inquire about delivery. Jennifer - who later identified herself as the store manager - began berating me as soon as I provided the name associated with the order. She said "you just called ten minutes ago, we told you 930, it's only 935, it's only five minutes late, why are you calling again?!" Her tone was remarkably rude and hostile. She would not let me speak and continuously cut me off. I asked why she was being so hostile in response to an order inquiry and this made her IRATE. You'd think I insulted her mother. She said "I'm canceling the order" and hung up. I called back at 937p and asked her why she had cancelled the order and why she'd hung up on me. I informed her that my children were now crying because the cookie order had been for them. She continued to cut me off throughout the conversation and said I should call Customer Service if I wanted to make a complaint, which I did. DO NOT ORDER FROM THIS LOCATION IF YOU EXPECT TO BE TREATED RESPECTFULLY. read more

Lord... these cookies were so good I'd cry. If you are in the area you need to try Insomnia Cookies. I had late night cravings so I walked a couple blocks away from my apartment and visited this location. They didn't have many options to choose from, so I had a sugar cookie and an m&m cookie with Chocolate milk. My husband had a brownie and a deluxe chocolate chip cookie. Everything was warm when handed to us, it was delicious, and I could even feel the sugar melting in my mouth. I wish I had something like this back home. Warm cookies until 3 AM, delivered to you? Sounds like a dream come true if you ask me! read more

The messy well prepared cookies are great for a snack, and are just simply delicious and amazing. PS: I was looking at others reviews and I thought maybe it's just luck some get it better and some don't. read more

This is the second time this has happened to me. I ordered over 2 hours ago through seamless I keep getting a message saying they are going to be here in 30 minute! I called Insomnia Cookies customer service and the lady I talked on the phone hung up. I wasn't using bad language or anything. Don't bother with this one. Better luck ordering from one of the other locations if you ever want to get a cookie lol read more

Couldn't even get cookies bc they were "busy."(mind you no one is there) Worker was so rude, yelled at me that they weren't accepting customers. Never coming back here. read more

The cookie was very good. I ordered a birthday cookie for my daughter and she loved it. It was the mini one, so it was small. Only two people can eat that one. read more

I live 4 blocks away, and delivery took almost 2.5 hours. I called at the hour mark and found they were out of vanilla and needed me to pick another flavor, but no one had called to ask this. I ordered through Insomnia itself, but have heard ordering through Uber Eats or Grubhub is faster. read more

DO NOT ORDER FROM HERE. I ordered from their website and I live a few blocks away. After an hour with no update to the tracking site, I called them with no response. No contact, no update nothing.... but they already took my money. After another half an hour, I received a text that my order was delivered. NOTHING WAS DELIVERED anywhere to my address. NOTHING. and they refuse to communicate with me to tell me what happed to my order or to give me a refund. read more