OddFellows Ice Cream

259

284

691

12 days ago

Odd Fellows has a great variety of traditional and non traditional ice cream flavors from mango sticky rice to cookies and cream. The staff is nice and will let you try the flavors before ordering, which I recommend doing. There's a small seating area as well if you want to stay in and eat. read more

OddFellows Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

OddFellows Ice Cream - Ice cream selection - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Marisa M.

417

652

2346

2 months ago

Best hard ice cream I have had in a while. Prices a little steep but worth it. Two scoops and a topping cost ~10. Long line, that takes a while. There are a couple of tables inside and out, inside was hot and stuffy didn't have AC on. This place has mochi topping! Yay my favorite. Lots of flavors were sold out by the time we got there but I got the strawberry jam and smores peanut-butter. Such unique flavor combos done right. The strawberry jam has oozing jam and was way beyond basic strawberry ice cream. So good. The smores peanut butter was a nice pairing and it was a little more of a subdued flavor but still very good. Would def come back! read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 1

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Kobi P.

0

10

7

8 days ago

The ice cream was tasty and the server was really nice and there was some really special flavors the place was really good and the prices where good so I recommend that you go there and try some really good ice cream read more

OddFellows Ice Cream - Macha Matcha Strawberry - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Alisa J.

243

2039

7107

2 months ago

Blueberry blondie flavor was good. They have a pretty good selection of vegan flavors Didn't think it was amazing but it was enjoyable ice cream. Not crowded which was nice on a week day night. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Victoria L.

336

138

118

5 months ago

Always passed by this place, always curious, but never actually went inside. It was a false spring day during winter, and happy hour during a work day. To my surprise, the flavors were completely unexpected. Reminds me of my favorite ice cream store on the west coast. Weird flavors like miso ginger. Which actually tastes like miso. Few min before actual happy hour guy gave me the discount, which is double scoop for $7. I got passionfruit apricot pistachio and cookie jar. Delicious! And not too sweet. They have pints for $11-12 which I will get in the future. This might be my favorite ice cream place so far. read more

OddFellows Ice Cream - Passionfruit Apricot Pistachio, Cookie Jar - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Sarah Y.

182

185

530

4 months ago

We got the matcha strawberry flavor which was very solid. The strawberry in the matcha ice cream really added to it! There is some seating in the restaurant and pretty quiet place. Would recommend! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 1

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Au G.

0

5

12

5 days ago

Service is good and friendly staff. If you are looking for local ice cream make sure to stop by!

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Cole D.

494

1571

2953

11 months ago

Fun place to try. Very nice service who was chatty and kind. Very generous taste testers. I got the cookie and mint and also the chocolate PB cheesecake. The cookies and mint was MINT. It was so tasty. The cheesecake was ok. Some of the PB globs tasted like gelatin. Yuck. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 1

Stephanie R.

199

324

674

8 months ago

Unique and delicious flavors to choose from. Large variety whether you like chocolate, fruity flavors, etc. nice amount of space to sit down and eat inside. read more

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Tito T.

0

5

4

2 months ago

Delicious ice cream and great customer service from sweet employees. Highly recommended. I will be back. read more

OddFellows Ice Cream - Vegan Coconut Pandan - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

OddFellows Ice Cream - Even the freaky clowns adore ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Debbie S.

336

285

880

1 year ago

Excellent! Not too sweet and nice and creamy. Loved the brooklyn blackout and banana Banoffee read more

Helpful 5

Thanks 1

Love this 3

Oh no 0

Ryan C.

4

92

272

1 year ago

Hits the spot! They always have a few vegan options. They do let you try flavors and there's some tables inside. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 1

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Carina H.

29

388

1014

2 years ago

I've passed by OddFellows a few times before but didn't realize it was an ice cream shop. When I searched this place up, I saw the variety of unique flavors and had to go back to try it out. I didn't associate the neon monkey logo with ice cream, but I absolutely love the decor inside and out. It reminds me of a retro toy store. There's seating for maybe 3-4 small groups. I got a scoop of Brooklyn Blackout ice cream with peanuts and cherry syrup in a toasted brioche bun. The wait wasn't too long. I really liked the ice cream but found the brioche bun to be a little dry and/or stale, considering the price point. I really liked the ice cream flavor though. Well, it was a fun order to try! read more

OddFellows Ice Cream - Brooklyn Blackout ice cream, peanuts, cherry syrup, brioche bun - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Mia T.

16

299

8 months ago

Variety of unique ice cream flavors with a cool retro vibe. I'm usually in the mood for fruity flavors and they had plenty of options to choose from. Being New York, it was expensive for a scoop but you do receive a good amount of ice cream for the price. A must stop if you're in the area! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Dana A.

136

220

644

2 years ago

I work in the area and have seen this place numerous times. It's a nice small shop with different icecream flavors. The cookie jar was recommended by the staff and I must say it did not disappoint. It had all the fixing that you can think of: cookie dough, sprinkles, cookie pieces and mixed together perfectly. read more

OddFellows Ice Cream - Cookie Jar - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Helpful 6

Thanks 2

Love this 3

Oh no 0

Ava W.

74

143

166

2 years ago

Are you kidding me?? This is the CUTEST ice cream palor I've been to in a while! Retro themed but still with a fresh vibe! So many interesting flavors to try yet we could only get one for our first visit! We opted to go with the mango sticky rice flavor and it was quite good. It tastes like a sweeter version of what I would expect an ice cream dish of that flavor would be. My partner brought up a neat suggestion that maybe they could add bits of sticky rice on top to sell the flavor as well! Either way it was delicious!!! We are looking forward to trying the pistachio sea salt flavor during our next visit! Thank you again to the patient staff who took our order and let us sift through the menu! there's so many unique flavors to check out so maybe research before you go! We hope to try them all during our next visits! read more

OddFellows Ice Cream - Mango Sticky Rice Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Matt F.

7

125

300

1 year ago

Poor customer service practice to have private events and not have any way for other customers to tell if you're open (ie not answering your phones after we called 4x, nothing posted online, nothing on instagram or social media). Really unfortunate to waste a trip here for nothing read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Gab G.

Elite 26 All-Star

288

3977

15875

2 years ago

Returned to try some of the fresh ice cream and was not disappointed. Chocolate chunk in a s'mores cone was absolutely phenomenal, and the employees were super friendly when my coworker and I visited. Need to return ASAP!! read more

OddFellows Ice Cream - Sonic collab - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

OddFellows Ice Cream - Chocolate Chunk in s'mores cone!!!! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Nicole N.

Elite 26 All-Star

241

1150

4101

2 years ago

First time trying OddFellows and I'm a fan! Their ice cream isn't as "gummy" and thick as other ice cream shops that I prefer, but I still enjoyed the texture! Got the coffee crunch and sea salt pistachio. The coffee crunch didn't have much of a "crunch" component but was rather mixed with some chocolate bits. What stood out to me was that this flavor tasted like actual coffee, rather than coffee ice cream, which I really appreciated. I wanted more after every bite! The pistachio had a more subtle nutty taste and the sea salt salinity aspect was more of an aftertaste, which I thought was also interesting. This location was pretty spacious and with good lighting. As soon as you walk in, you're greeted by their fresh waffle cone aroma. Staff weren't super friendly but polite. Would definitely come back to check out their other flavors. read more

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Lisa H.

4

165

130

1 year ago

I'm shocked at how good this place is. Truly "odd" because of their amazing selection of UNIQUE flavors. I got the miso peanut butter and blackberry cheesecake biscuit. Both were amazing. - Good service nice people who let me eat samples. - Ambiance is a cute, small little scoop shop with some seating. It is very retro and old school looking. read more

Helpful 2

Thanks 1

Love this 1

Oh no 1

Shubha A.

262

198

565

1 year ago

the ice cream itself is give it a 7/10 but the waffle cone was really hard and not good at all & is about a $2 upcharge! the lady who took our order wasn't the most enthusiastic but she let us try a couple of flavors before placing our order which was nice. i really liked the brooklyn blackout but if you're not a chocolate person I recommend the cookie butter flavor - would come back for the ice cream but definitely wouldn't get the cone again read more

OddFellows Ice Cream - brooklyn blackout flavor - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Ty H.

198

808

480

11 months ago

I had the chocolate cheesecake peanut butter ice cream. It was actually really really good. I was very surprised. Very fresh and very tasty. The small cup was big enough for two people. A little pricey and $8.50 but it is New York City. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 1

Love this 1

Oh no 1

Sandy Y.

51

642

1799

2 years ago

Unique flavors and plenty of options to taste & choose from. As soon as you enter, you can tell it's gonna be weird and quirky (in a good way). This shop tests the limits with their flavor and texture combinations but I am not mad about it. I tasted a bunch before I decided on the limited edition pandan flavor (with chocolate covered sunflower seeds). In the vanilla base, it had a subtle pandan flavor and the chocolate covered sunflowers gave it such a nice, sweet, nutty crunch. Got on a classic sugar cone but their specialty cones did intrigue me (similar to emack & bolio's) - maybe next time. read more

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Cathy K.

202

514

1034

3 years ago

Go try the special Sonic flavors now!!! Green pandan with coconut was so good had to buy a tub to go. I've been a follower of OddFellows since 2018 even before their cute storefronts. Was mourning the loss of Ample Hills which sat empty for a few months but now my sorrows are gone! Lol. Super convenient location off 14th and 8th. Loved all the limited edition Sonic flavors and had a hard time narrowing down to a double scoop. A few tables and a long bench to sit on. Just a warning, there a bunch of high schools nearby so when I ordered huge groups of teens just took over the whole place and all the tables and then only ordered 1 cone...I feel kind of sorry for the staff, they were very professional despite it all. Definitely recommended read more

OddFellows Ice Cream - Outside - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

OddFellows Ice Cream - Strawberry fields and pandan - both Sonic flavor, limited time - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Ally R.

18

433

540

3 years ago

OddFellows has a nice variety of flavors! Today I tried the vegan coconut mango sticky rice flavor. I was hesitant but it was actually really delicious! The base was coconutty with a mango purée swirl and little chewy mochi pieces. I'd definitely get it again! Beckett was super friendly and let us try samples and answered our questions. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Kunyan X.

205

182

369

3 years ago

What a surprise to stumble into OddFellows return to Manhattan! This location is quite spacious with a few tables to dine in. So much more flavors here including the return of their "odd flavors". Staff are friendly and quick to serve. Got the triple to try a few new flavors and they're just as good as their usual ones. The ice cream is always nice and creamy. Welcome back to Manhattan! read more

OddFellows Ice Cream - Sonic flavor, Mango Cheesecake, Passionfruit Apricot Pistachio - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

Helpful 2

Thanks 1

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Craig S.

0

4

0

9 months ago

Service was great ice cream was even better. Everybody was so nice and helpful and helped us decide what flavors we should get.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Liang Z.

42

196

140

2 years ago

Generous portion. Tasty. Good vibe. Limited seating. Ordered the coffee and it was delectable. They are franchising.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 1

Lisa G.

1

2

1

2 years ago

Amazing flavor profiles!! Must do if you're in the area. Great spot for a walk and a refreshing treat. Staff helpful and kind! read more

OddFellows Ice Cream - Ice cream flavor selection to go - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Rich H.

Elite 24

14

102

135

2 years ago

Just got back from the new 8th Avenue location I got the coffee sticky bun which was really good!! I really enjoyed the sticky bun chunks!!. When I walked in I immediately got a welcoming vibe no awkwardness at all!. The ice cream itself wasn't all that expensive in my opinion anyway!. Looking forward to coming back!! read more

OddFellows Ice Cream - The front entrance way!! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

OddFellows Ice Cream - Coffee sticky bun!! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

OddFellows Ice Cream - Window by the front entrance!! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 1

Rose A.

0

1

0

8 months ago

came all the way from connecticut and didn't even get to try the ice cream, we were turned away at the door and given nasty looks and told there was a private party, yet there was nothing online to note they would be closing 3 hours early. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Chris S.

108

193

237

3 years ago

I think this place should be a 3.5 but I'll settle on giving it a 3. The ice cream is good, no complaints there. Biggest issue I had was the price. $7 for a single scoop of ice cream on a cone is too expensive. Can't say I really got my money's worth. I prefer 16 Handles which is nearby. Healthier and the toppings can't be beat. Still, this isn't a bad spot. I wouldn't be against coming back. It's a great looking store by the way. Plenty of interesting flavor to choose from. Free samples are available if you ask. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Donay Q.

36

57

8

2 years ago

Ice cream did not have much flavor. Both the chocolate and black cherry Could have been richer in taste,

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Brad R.

7

4

0

2 years ago

I went tonight to get some ice cream and I walked in literally right behind a couple, and the guy waved me off and rudely said "we are closed " as if in walked in at 10:05 expecting service. It was 959, I probably would've been out the door at 10. employee was so rude. not even a "sorry, I can't serve you" read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 1

Love this 0

Oh no 2

Bobby B.

0

4

0

2 years ago

The Ice Cream was o.k. The sugar-cone was a Costco special. The service was obnoxious. $9.00 for a single scoop had me reeling.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Mason S.

0

240

0

3 years ago

Mango Cheesecake hit the spot even if it was just 1 scoop.....$6.40 for the scoop but I didn't mind it because the ice cream tasted good. I like the name and look of this ice cream shop and will return again. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

More info about OddFellows Ice Cream

141 8th Ave
New York, NY 10011
Chelsea
Directions
(631) 825-2342
Call Now
Order Takeout or Delivery
Start Order
Visit Website
http://oddfellowsnyc.com

Full menu

Hours

What time does OddFellows Ice Cream open?

OddFellows Ice Cream opens at 1:00 PM on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, Saturday and Sunday.

What time does OddFellows Ice Cream close?

OddFellows Ice Cream closes at 11:00 PM on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, Saturday and Sunday.

Mon-Sun 1:00 PM - 11:00 PM

Payment methods

Does OddFellows Ice Cream take Bitcoin?

No, OddFellows Ice Cream does not take Bitcoin.

Does OddFellows Ice Cream take credit cards?

Yes, OddFellows Ice Cream takes credit cards.

Food & Alcohol

Does OddFellows Ice Cream have catering options?

Yes, OddFellows Ice Cream does have catering options.

Does OddFellows Ice Cream have a drive thru?

No, OddFellows Ice Cream does not have a drive thru.

Outdoor Amenities

Does OddFellows Ice Cream have bike parking?

No, OddFellows Ice Cream does not have bike parking.

Does OddFellows Ice Cream have parking?

Yes, OddFellows Ice Cream has parking options.

Other Amenities

Is OddFellows Ice Cream wheelchair accessible?

Yes, OddFellows Ice Cream is wheelchair accessible.

Does OddFellows Ice Cream have free WiFi?

No, OddFellows Ice Cream does not have free WiFi.

From the Business

Specialties

We are a small-batch ice cream company with a compulsive creativity problem. Since opening our first shop in Brooklyn in 2013, we have concocted more than 500 wacky and weird flavors alongside reimagined and improved classics. Our ice cream is like driving 31 in a 25, honking the horn the entire time.

More Info

Health Score

You might also consider

Van Leeuwen Ice Cream - Chelsea

(26 reviews)

0.1 mi

Mango Sticky Rice is AMAZING! With the heat lately I had to try this and also they have a great…read moretasting Shirley Temple Float. We enjoyed our afternoon snack while sitting outside on the bench to relax a bit. The place was packed but the line went by very fast and friendly service!

Van Leeuwen is a very popular ice cream chain in New York. This location in Chelsea is off the main…read morestreet and felt very nice and quiet. The workers on Friday night (Jan 30th) were great! They were very helpful and friendly, patiently helping our whole group. The flavors were great, with the Coffee flavor being my favorite! Overall, Van Leeuwen in Chelsea is a great spot for ice cream!

Matcha strawberry and banana bread pudding

Signage

See all

Outside of the store

Gelateria Gentile

This gelateria I…read morecan't believe it took me so long to discover it. Located in New York, small quiet spot, you can't wait inside, it a take out thing, I don't care! Their gelato is delicious and so rich! I was so happy!

Tiny, clean desert place. No bathrooms for customers…read more Staff are accommodating. Don't be afraid to try to sample the gelatos. Sample them all until you choose the flavor you like. There are different types of cold treats: gelatos and more slushie like consistency frozen confections that are served in a cup. My vegan friend appreciated that he could choose from multiple vegan flavors, not just be limited to the one and only offering, which is what most places usually have. Melon flavor was incredible. Tasted like frozen melon was crushed with ice and chopped into an ice/smoothie blend. Super refreshing. Very sweet, though. All flavors are very sweet, so a small portion can be shared and you will feel satisfied. I personally enjoyed their in-house special flavor of gelato: honey cream with crushed almonds, pistachios, and hazelnuts. That was bombastic! Love how nutty the consistency was. I love nuts, so this almost reminded me of a chunky peanut butter situation: just more fine grained and smooth, with gelato being the base. Highly recommend trying this flavor! Focacia was okay. A bit too dry and bland for my liking, but still decent. My favorite item was the pistachio bombolone which is officially now my favorite dessert. This was magnificent! The yeasty dough was so light and airy--perfectly light and balanced. The filling of pistachio cream was very delicate and not sweet at all, which was such a nice surprise. I do not like saccharine dessert. The fresh raspberry jam was a perfect balance to the pistachio cream. I never like jams in my desserts, but this was a perfect complement. Woooow, what a treat! Can't wait to return for it and to try more of their other flavors--hazelnut & chocolate, coconut, white chocolate, tiramisu. You could taste the superb quality of the ingredients. Highly recommend.

Vegan/Non dairy options: Bergamotto (orange) and Fondente (dark chocolate)

Gelato Flavors

See all

Grace Street

Locally owned & operated

Locally sourced ingredients

Need a spot that's buzzing with energy and gewd desserts? Grab a table and some deliciousness here!…read moreThe shave ice portions are ginormous and very flavorful. 3 orders were a great medley of flavors, but my party of 5 was too stuffed from Kbbq to finish it all. :( the staff go the extra mile with making sure the area isn't sticky and making sure everyone has what they need. Will be back to try the other desserts!!

Grace Street is one of the best places to get shaved ice cream in NYC. I cannot explain it, but the…read moretexture and flakiness of shaved ice cream (called shaved snow at Grace Street) is absolutely delightful in your mouth. Every time I visit NYC, I have to come here and get it. While the price is about 20$, it's absolutely worth it and they pile it high. It's meant to be shared, so make sure you come with your friends! Service is fast- they use a pager system to tell you when your order is ready to pick it up. While it's a little cold inside, it is extremely clean despite them serving lots of desserts everyday - there is someone who cleans all of the tables thoroughly. Cannot recommend more!

See all

Sunset Lemonade ($5.50)

Aubi & Ramsa

I ended up here after dinner with some friends, and I'm so glad we stopped by…read more The space is on the smaller side, which gives it a cozy, intimate vibe. It would be perfect for a date night or catching up with a small group of friends. They had a great selection of flavors, but I went with the Tennessee Crème Brûlée. It was sooo good--rich, creamy, and definitely worth trying. My only complaint is that I wish the serving was a little bigger, but I get it... there's alcohol in it. We ended up staying much longer than we planned, just talking and enjoying the atmosphere. It was the perfect way to end the night, and I'll definitely be back.

This is a really fun little spot in NYC. The alcohol-infused ice cream is actually good, not too…read morestrong. just a nice twist on regular ice cream. It's a cute place to stop by after dinner or if you just want something different for dessert. I tried a couple flavors and liked them more than I expected. Would definitely go back to try others.

Left to right: Strawberry & Rosé, Tangerine Mimosa, Jack & Chocolate.

Kentucky Creme Brulee

See all

Chocolate and Amaretto

Insomnia Cookies

small establishments but I've noticed most insomnia locations are small . We got a 6 pack and they…read morejust came out the oven. We were in heaven. My favorite is oatmeal cookies

Insomnia Cookies used to be my go to for a nice, fresh, hot baked chocolate chip cookie. Recently,…read moreI went here and felt like the cookies are getting pricier but yet smaller. The service was great, but I am disappointed that Insomnia Cookies are shrinking. I really like having a cookie every once in a while as a late night snack; however, I must admit I will probably think twice since my cookie will be gone in two full bites. Not to mention, if you don't scan your rewards account in the store, you cannot claim your points after your purchase.

See all

Sundaes and Cones

Amazing Ice Cream Shop on East 10th Street off 3rd Avenue…read more Awesome selection of ice cream and gelato in traditional and unique flavors, many Asian, like lavender, ginger, etc. They have a frequent visitor membership rewards and bet there are many, like myself, who take advantage given frequent visits year round. The service is always great. Sometimes the Moms and Dads visiting their kids at NYU clog up the front with a LOT of questions, but usually very quick for a large waffle cone with 2 scoops. If dining at other venues in the area, skip desert and stop here for a special treat!

This ice cream shop has been around forever - 2000's maybe & is just slightly off the busy area of…read moreSt. Mark's but deserves the attention! Don't remember what I had the previous 20+ years I went there after a group dinner. This time I was influenced & specifically took a bus over for their corn ice cream. It's STILL the summer of corn. Prices are now average - good for a scoop $7.50 & the portion is good compared to other craft ice cream shops in LES. The corn flavor was good. Medium flavor with that corn sweetness. The quality of the ice cream was excellent, medium creamy & very smooth with the teeniest bit of corn blended. Sampled the hazelnut which was great also - like a thick gelato. Would like to try the lychee next time. They have probably 20 different flavors, displayed well. The staff is patient & very nice. The space is very big for a business in the East Village with mostly a waiting area. 4-5 seats are up front & they set up a few plastic chairs on the side. On a 90°F day, the shop was filled with customers & groups. A stantion at the door with directions for 2 lines would help manage things better.

Scoop of mint chocolate chip ice cream in a cup with a cone. Ice cream freshness ftw

Exterior

See all

Green Tea Rose, Black Sesame

Amorino Gelato

Solid gelato what can I say the sorbetti and gelati worked very well together…read more Short line and great location!

The workers are friendly and the service was good. The place is cozy and was a nice spot to chill…read moreat especially during the cold weather. The Affogato al cioccolato was very rich and sweet. The chocolate was more on the thicker side. I definitely recommend it if you are a fan of chocolate. The ice cream here is very smooth and creamy.

2 flavors

Small waffle cone

See all

Anita Gelato

Don't be deterred by the line outside the store and around the block. Its there for a reason. They…read morehave the best gelato in town. The line moves quickly and you are greeted with an array of flavors. Sample a few and take your pick. We got the hazelnut and coffee flavor combination and loved it. The staff is helpful and efficient - make a stop here! They have some seating area and the crowd moves through pretty fast.

I've been all over Italy, Venice, Florence, Portofino, Tuscany and all the outlying villages and…read morehaven't enjoyed gelato there as much as I have here. Maybe they put an American twist on traditional gelato but whatever the case it's now become my go to for ice cream gelato in New York City yes it's pricey but it's value is there My queen Victoria ( the sample queen) tasted over 8 flavors and had a hard time selecting. in the end the cup of 4 flavors served her well especially the raspberry crunch, and the mango. Go ! If she said it's good... it's great!

Chocolate pistachio and mint

Small Gelato (pistachio + strawberry)

See all

The scooped gelato.

Van Leeuwen Ice Cream

Why was my 1 scoop $10?! It was so mid. But I was hot. Actually quite upset I decided to still pay…read morefor it. The ice cream was worth maybe $5 but 10 bucks felt cruel and unusual. Service was good, and I felt bad for the girl scooping bc there were so many indecisive people (including myself) so I really appreciated her attentiveness.

Such amazing ice cream! So many vegan options! Service was quick and efficient and the storefront…read morehad cute seating where we could lookout the window while we enjoyed our yummy ice cream!

Vegan strawberry cheescake

Passion Fruit Berry Pop

Earl grey tea

See all

Anita Gelato

Fantastic gelato near Times Square broadway district. Perfect for after a show!…read more We sampled a lot of the flavors and they were all very good but the three best for us were strawberry, chocolate, and pistachio. They taste like they use real flavoring and not artificial flavors. Some of the white chocolate flavors are a bit overly sweet for me but that's how real white chocolate is to me as well so all the flavors are pretty spot on.

This review is for the Anita Gelato located in the Theater District (there is more than one)…read more There are many flavors to pick from. The way the containers are sold is what they call a regular, medium and large. We did see cones as well, but we were offered prices for the contaibners, so we went with that. You can have one or two flavors in the regular, up to three flavors in the medium and up to four flavors in the large container. Or, you can have just one flavor - up to you. Note to keep in mind: Gelato melts fairly quickly, so if you select flavors like chocolate, mango, and strawberry mascarpone and ricotta in the same container, you are going to have a gastro-nightmare in your mouth! Therefore, I recommend you select flavors that have similar ingredients or are complimentary in some way. As an example, we got the dark chocolate, the hazelnut mousse and chocolate crunch, and the stracciatella. Our favorite was the dark chocolate (plain). The hazelnut mousse was too grainy and sweet for our liking. The stracciatella was nice, but lacked depth of flavor to the gelato overall. Staff will let you try samples on a small spoon if you are undecided. The line can be long (out onto the side walk) to get in, and there are very few tables. So, when you make your order unless you are there on a "down time" be prepared to walk and eat your gelato (another reason to keep in mind the flavors in case of drips on your clothes)! The scoop is served standing up in the container. After the adjacent theaters let out, the line is long. We got a regular size container and with the tax and tip it was just a little over $11. The regular size container is suited to one person. The medium can potentially serve two people if you share "nicely" with each other! They also sell yogurt and coffee drinks. We were in town just for a few days, so we only tried three flavors, but if we were back in the area again, we would try some of the fruit-flavors they sell. Enjoy!

Dairy-free heaven: Dark Chocolate, and Chocolate Cookie (both rich, both intense, both dairy-free)

Inside decor

Large cup - 4 flavors

See all

Caffe Paradiso

4.4

(216 reviews)

1.4 mi

Got the brown butter latte (surprise) and was better than I had initially thought. Has a slight…read moreaftertaste, but it's also brown butter, so I'm not surprised. Not sure if it was worth the wait though. Service was good, noticed that many others had an unpleasant experience, but the lady who took my order was kind and did not scam me! Overall it's not really worth the hype to watch a man pour coffee from a machine. Yes, it's a place to buy a nice cup of coffee, but only if there's little to no line.

Trust me... Caffe Paradiso is viral for a reason, and the hype is VERY real! Their Salty Brown…read moreButter & Oat Latte is easily one of the best lattes I've ever had. It was 100% worth standing in line in the humid weather, and I'd do it all over again! The drink was perfectly salty, incredibly creamy, and I could actually taste those delicious brown butter notes. Of course, it's not the strongest coffee-wise, which is something I usually prefer in my everyday coffee, but as a treat it's absolutely perfect!

It was busy, so after paying, you get a cute ticket--hand it to the barista for the viral latte!

Salted brown butter oat latte on tap

See all

Salted Brown Butter & Oat Latte

Ess-a-Bagel

Amazing bagels! It was a quick line and easy to order. You actually have time to think about your…read moreorder before getting to the front. We ended up getting a few bagel sandwiches (a BEC and a lox sando), but next time I'd just do a classic bagel and smear. Lots of bagel and cream cheese options! Only a handful of seating options but most people were grab-and-go. Fun vibe overall.

Vibe/ambiance: classic grab and go bagel spot Service:…read morestandard Items ordered: scallion cream cheese sesame bagel: there was no wow factor to the bagel, but this was a standard bagel and does the job. the bagel texture needs a little more bit and fragrance

Plain Bagel w Chocolate Chip Cream Cheese

See all

Signature favorite (lox, tomato, capers and lettuce) with less cream cheese) on pumpernickel

Hamburger America

If you're looking for a perfect, no-nonsense smash burger, this is the place. It's exactly what a…read moreburger should be. They don't rely on a laundry list of fancy toppings to hide behind; it's just the basics, executed flawlessly. I really appreciated that they keep it simple, giving you the choice of onion or no onion, letting the quality of the beef and the perfect sear speak for itself. Logistically, it's first-come, first-served seating where you're given a number. It wasn't too busy when I stopped by, so the process was seamless and quick. It's hard to imagine how they could make this any better without fundamentally changing what a smash burger is supposed to be. If you appreciate the classics done right, this is an absolute must-visit in NYC.

Went to Hamburger America on a weekend in the early afternoon. It's located at the corner of West…read moreHouston Street/Sixth Ave, between SoHo and the West Village. It was busy but not overcrowded, and we found a table outside. When you arrive, you order at the counter inside, receive a number, and then find a seat while your meal is prepared fresh. A server brings your food to your table once it is ready, it only took about 5-7 minutes for our food to arrive. I ordered the "All the Way" burger, their classic smash burger with mustard, diced onions, dill pickles, and cheese, along with fries and a gluten-free bun. The total came to about $17, including tax and tip. The burger was delicious. Smash burgers are my favorite, and this one was cooked perfectly with crispy edges while still moist. I also really appreciate that they offer a gluten-free bun. The burger and fries were a satisfying portion without feeling overly heavy. This is a casual spot, but it consistently delivers delicious food at a reasonable price. If you are looking for a classic smash burger in the neighborhood, I would recommend. I will certainly be back!

Lunch Counter and kitchen

Double George Motz's Fried Onion Burger.

See all

Fried Onion Double Cheeseburger

Crispy Heaven Bakery

High quality French bakery/brunch spot!! They won nyc's best baguette in 2024. Only downside is…read morethat their sandwiches are kinda pricey I def need to come back to try their pancakes and Turkish eggs. - Grass fed short rib 1/2 baguette sandwich: 11/10, the baguette was crispy on the outside and chewy on the inside, and the meat was so tender and flavorful w/ the caramelized onions. The soup was insanely flavorful too and not too salty (which I was scared about) - 16 m. aged serrano ham 1/2 baguette sandwich w/ Gouda cheese: 7/10, not as good as the short rib baguette sandwich, but still yummy

Really good bread here! Scrambled eggs were nice and fluffy. My only criticism is the short amount…read moreof time we had at our table. We had made a reservation for 9.30 am and they asked us to leave at 10.05 am because they had another reservation waiting. Kind of weird to only give 30mins to sit down, look at the menu, order and eat your food. I had just finished my last bite and the plates were taken away and we were given the cheque. The waitress was friendly, just wish we weren't rushed out.

Latte and bread pudding

See all

Beet salad

Parla

10/10 Mafaldine Alla Vodka - This pasta is insanely delicious and so creamy. My mouth is watering…read morejust thinking about it. I absolutely love the pasta it comes with too. The shape is unique, which makes it even better. My only complaint is... why doesn't it come with any protein? Cost - $22.87

{Overall: 4; Food: 4} Ambiance: 4; Service: 4…read more Parla is a great Italian restaurant on the Upper West Side very close to the American Museum of Natural History. The menu is focused on Italian American comfort food, with an emphasis on pizza and pasta. *Mafaldine Alla Vodka: Really good. The pasta was cooked perfectly, with plenty of rich vodka sauce. The chili flakes added a nice little kick. *Angry Roni: A really satisfying pizza with lots of melty cheese and toppings. Service was very friendly and attentive throughout the meal. The ambiance is also nice. There is bar seating, communal tables, and a windowed area at the front of the restaurant that feels like a sunroom.

See all

Pura Vida Miami

(212 reviews)

0.7 mi

Pablo was so attentive and food was amazing!! Thank you!! Salmon bowl was fantasic ans bites were…read morea treat!!

Amazing food and outstanding service! Everything we ordered was absolutely delicious--10/10. The…read moreservice was fast, friendly, and attentive. Special thanks to Pablo for being so kind and making our experience even better. I'll definitely be back!

Handcrafted coffee with latte art and a hazelnut crunch acai bowl, served in a warm and welcoming all day café atmosphere.

Fresh and healthy table spread featuring vibrant salads, nutritious bowls and wraps, all-day breakfast favorites, superfood s...

See all

The Perfect Egg Sandwich with pasture-raised eggs, avocado, tomato, arugula and mozzarella - the ultimate healthy breakfast on-the-go

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

4 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Edwin L.

0

11

0

1 year ago

The ice cream here was amazing! I was pleasantly surprised by the wide variety of flavors, and I personally loved the cookies and cream -- it was so good. The waffle cones were also delicious and added the perfect touch to my treat. The service was friendly and welcoming, and the atmosphere was super instagram-worthy. Definitely a spot i'd recommend for anyone looking to satisfy their sweet tooth! read more

Ronnie J.

0

3

0

2 years ago

Big OddFellows fan, I love their unique but still delicious flavors. The honey rosemary is a favorite of mine, but I will say miss their olive oil ice cream. The staff were friendly and eager to recommend their favorites and let me sample different flavors. read more

Chris D.

0

4

0

3 years ago

Some of the best ice cream I've ever had, you have to try the Wild Berry Crumble if they have it. Super friendly people behind the counter and fun atmosphere inside. read more

Justin C.

0

5

0

1 year ago

Some of the best ice cream you can find in New York and the decor is amazing. Love coming here, the people are the best.

OddFellows Ice Cream - icecream - Updated August 2026

People who viewed OddFellows Ice Cream also viewed

Van Leeuwen

4.4

(159 reviews)

Sweet tooth? Craving? Or just simply love icecream with multiple toppings...definitely visit this…read moreshop. There's many chain locations around New York. However this particular location was perfect! Serving many delicious mix match icecream flavors whether a cup or waffle cone. Small seating area. Nice friendly attentive staff with smiles on their faces. They're eager and happy to help with any questions! Take out home pint size options. Walk in fast service. With Mobile pay options. Metal or plastic tasting spoon options. $$ There's also vegan icecream options.

Knicks in Five! Van Leeuwen offered $3 scoops (usually $7.95)…read more Stopped in to sample some flavors and ordered a scoop of Brown Sugar Cookie Dough Brownie. Yum! Great quality, but they tend to give small scoops for that price tag.

Gelatoville

(26 reviews)

We were here when they opened and now returned - some things get better with time and this place…read moreabsolutely did From the team member on 8th avenue to the staff behind the counter - service (even when dealing with a large Friday night crowd) was excellent The choices have increased, including awesome vegan choices (passion fruit one was excellent) and from the regular gelato the mix of Dubai chocolate with The cookie crumble made it the right "self-care" treat for completing a very stressful week Totally worth the trip and yes we have tried several other gelato shoos around union square and flower district/west 25+ but the texture and quality of the gelato here was perfect - not over creamy and not over sugarized We are definitely come back!

Stopped by Gelatoville for a sweet treat, and it definitely delivered!…read more The gelato was rich, creamy, and full of flavor. They were happy to offer samples, which made choosing a little easier, and the staff were super friendly throughout. Simple, delicious, and absolutely worth a stop if you're in the area. I'd definitely come back!

Gelateria Gentile

(113 reviews)

This gelateria I…read morecan't believe it took me so long to discover it. Located in New York, small quiet spot, you can't wait inside, it a take out thing, I don't care! Their gelato is delicious and so rich! I was so happy!

Tiny, clean desert place. No bathrooms for customers…read more Staff are accommodating. Don't be afraid to try to sample the gelatos. Sample them all until you choose the flavor you like. There are different types of cold treats: gelatos and more slushie like consistency frozen confections that are served in a cup. My vegan friend appreciated that he could choose from multiple vegan flavors, not just be limited to the one and only offering, which is what most places usually have. Melon flavor was incredible. Tasted like frozen melon was crushed with ice and chopped into an ice/smoothie blend. Super refreshing. Very sweet, though. All flavors are very sweet, so a small portion can be shared and you will feel satisfied. I personally enjoyed their in-house special flavor of gelato: honey cream with crushed almonds, pistachios, and hazelnuts. That was bombastic! Love how nutty the consistency was. I love nuts, so this almost reminded me of a chunky peanut butter situation: just more fine grained and smooth, with gelato being the base. Highly recommend trying this flavor! Focacia was okay. A bit too dry and bland for my liking, but still decent. My favorite item was the pistachio bombolone which is officially now my favorite dessert. This was magnificent! The yeasty dough was so light and airy--perfectly light and balanced. The filling of pistachio cream was very delicate and not sweet at all, which was such a nice surprise. I do not like saccharine dessert. The fresh raspberry jam was a perfect balance to the pistachio cream. I never like jams in my desserts, but this was a perfect complement. Woooow, what a treat! Can't wait to return for it and to try more of their other flavors--hazelnut & chocolate, coconut, white chocolate, tiramisu. You could taste the superb quality of the ingredients. Highly recommend.

Gelateria Gentile - Nolita

4.1

(73 reviews)

After dinner we decided to try something different and stopped into Gelateria Gentile - Nolita for…read moredessert. We have been making a point lately of hitting dedicated dessert spots rather than just ordering something off the restaurant menu, and this place reminded us exactly why. I went with the Crema Antica, a vanilla cream with just a slight hint of lime. It was really good. That little citrus note against the cream was subtle but it worked perfectly. Wifey enjoyed hers just as much and we both walked out happy. The vibe in there was relaxed and the staff was cool. No pretension, just good energy. The gelato itself sits somewhere between traditional gelato and ice cream, a little of both, and it landed just right. We heard the flavors rotate pretty regularly which honestly makes it worth going back just to see what is new. If we lived any closer to this place we would be in serious trouble. The kind of trouble where you tell yourself once a week and somehow end up there three times. Highly recommend making a stop if you are in the area, especially after a good meal. Skip the restaurant dessert menu and come here instead. You will not regret it.

I normally love Gentile. I genuinely think it is one of the best authentic gelato spots in the…read morecity. That being said, the staff at this location were horrific. They were so unfriendly to the point where I felt like I was annoying them to place my order. They really ruined the experience of stopping for gelato. I live in the area, and it's safe to say that I won't be returning. I'll just have to stop by other locations when I'm nearby.

Aubi & Ramsa

4.5

(138 reviews)

I was strolling around the city and stumbled upon this location and my friend and I decided we had…read moreto try it. The decor was beautiful and the place was clean. The server was really nice and attentive. We decided to get the Tennessee Crème Brûlée. It was absolutely delicious. And the alcohol content was there. We could taste it. It was an awesome experience. I will definitely visit again.

On our trip to NYC this week, my daughter introduced us to our first taste or ADULT ice cream. We…read moretried a couple different flavors and truly enjoyed the brief break from the outdoor activity .. Spent about 30 mins here and all three of us agreed that the experience was delightful and that we would return another time!!

il laboratorio del gelato

4.2

(1.5k reviews)

Gelato, sorbet?? This is the place. One can sample many of the flavors that may tickle your…read moretastebuds before deciding.... The scoopers behind the tubs are so sweet but it is the gelato..I have very discriminating taste buds.. I rarely order outside of my favorite 3 but when I do, you know it is damn tasty.. Thank you for the real deal in the USA.. I pay in cash!!!!

Overall rating: 4.4…read more I've heard they have grape flavor but they didn't have any when I was there. It was good, it was expensive. Can't say the staff was that nice when I was deciding what to get but I went around 8pm so I think they were just counting down their shift. I don't even remember what I got, good flavors

Gelatoville

4.5

(95 reviews)

Gelato is delicious. Service is friendly and fast. It's a great and convenient location, and there…read moreis a good amount of seating available inside and outside. I'd sit outside the shop and have gelato during summer, it's good ambiance. I also like that they're open late to hit that late night sweets craving! I like their pistachio and hazelnut flavors the most but have tried many, including dark chocolate (vegan), caramel cookie, Kinder bueno etc. They have a huge variety of flavors and some of them include nice chunky cookie or chocolate pieces. Portions are very generous for the price.

Gelatoville was good, but nothing to rave about. Average…read moregelato spot with very mid to low service. The inside was beautiful and they were newly finishing a remodel when we came in. Unfortunately, there was nothing praise worthy of this spot. The flavors were typical flavors. Would I navigate back just for this place? Absolutely not Yelpers. Here's to originality Yelpers, it sets us apart! Xx

Aubi & Ramsa

4.6

(158 reviews)

I ended up here after dinner with some friends, and I'm so glad we stopped by…read more The space is on the smaller side, which gives it a cozy, intimate vibe. It would be perfect for a date night or catching up with a small group of friends. They had a great selection of flavors, but I went with the Tennessee Crème Brûlée. It was sooo good--rich, creamy, and definitely worth trying. My only complaint is that I wish the serving was a little bigger, but I get it... there's alcohol in it. We ended up staying much longer than we planned, just talking and enjoying the atmosphere. It was the perfect way to end the night, and I'll definitely be back.

This is a really fun little spot in NYC. The alcohol-infused ice cream is actually good, not too…read morestrong. just a nice twist on regular ice cream. It's a cute place to stop by after dinner or if you just want something different for dessert. I tried a couple flavors and liked them more than I expected. Would definitely go back to try others.

I CE NY

4.0

(591 reviews)

•$

One of the original Thai rolled ice cream places I NYC. Got a delicious matcha ice cream here and…read moreit was fun to watch it being rolled around. According to maps it seems this place no longer exists.

Never really had rolled ice cream before so definitely wanted to check it out. It definitely tastes…read morelike normal ice cream, just a different form. They give you a lot! Quantity is not a question. I believe its only one quantity but a cup has 7-8 rolled ice cream pieces. Then you get all those toppings. I had a tough time finishing it, definitely could feed 2-3 people if you considered sharing. They have a bunch of pre-made flavors...all of which I only liked some things about. For example, I got the Matcha Mania which has matched ice cream, oreo pieces, red bean, mochi, and condensed milk drizzle. Sounds like a boba shop dream but I personally didn't think the red bean and Oreos meshed well with the rest. Return? probably not Recommend? Sure if you're in the area already..but you might want to try to create your own (not sure if they allow it)

Figo Il Gelato Italiano

4.6

(121 reviews)