Best hard ice cream I have had in a while. Prices a little steep but worth it. Two scoops and a topping cost ~10. Long line, that takes a while. There are a couple of tables inside and out, inside was hot and stuffy didn't have AC on. This place has mochi topping! Yay my favorite. Lots of flavors were sold out by the time we got there but I got the strawberry jam and smores peanut-butter. Such unique flavor combos done right. The strawberry jam has oozing jam and was way beyond basic strawberry ice cream. So good. The smores peanut butter was a nice pairing and it was a little more of a subdued flavor but still very good. Would def come back! read more

OddFellows Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

Always passed by this place, always curious, but never actually went inside. It was a false spring day during winter, and happy hour during a work day. To my surprise, the flavors were completely unexpected. Reminds me of my favorite ice cream store on the west coast. Weird flavors like miso ginger. Which actually tastes like miso. Few min before actual happy hour guy gave me the discount, which is double scoop for $7. I got passionfruit apricot pistachio and cookie jar. Delicious! And not too sweet. They have pints for $11-12 which I will get in the future. This might be my favorite ice cream place so far. read more

OddFellows Ice Cream - Passionfruit Apricot Pistachio, Cookie Jar - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

Blueberry blondie flavor was good. They have a pretty good selection of vegan flavors Didn't think it was amazing but it was enjoyable ice cream. Not crowded which was nice on a week day night. read more

OddFellows Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

Delicious ice cream and great customer service from sweet employees. Highly recommended. I will be back. read more

OddFellows Ice Cream - Vegan Coconut Pandan - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

See all

We got the matcha strawberry flavor which was very solid. The strawberry in the matcha ice cream really added to it! There is some seating in the restaurant and pretty quiet place. Would recommend! read more

OddFellows Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

Fun place to try. Very nice service who was chatty and kind. Very generous taste testers. I got the cookie and mint and also the chocolate PB cheesecake. The cookies and mint was MINT. It was so tasty. The cheesecake was ok. Some of the PB globs tasted like gelatin. Yuck. read more

OddFellows Ice Cream - Cookies and mint, Chocolate Peanut Butter Cheesecake - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

Unique and delicious flavors to choose from. Large variety whether you like chocolate, fruity flavors, etc. nice amount of space to sit down and eat inside. read more

See all

Excellent! Not too sweet and nice and creamy. Loved the brooklyn blackout and banana Banoffee read more

OddFellows Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

Hits the spot! They always have a few vegan options. They do let you try flavors and there's some tables inside. read more

OddFellows Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

I've passed by OddFellows a few times before but didn't realize it was an ice cream shop. When I searched this place up, I saw the variety of unique flavors and had to go back to try it out. I didn't associate the neon monkey logo with ice cream, but I absolutely love the decor inside and out. It reminds me of a retro toy store. There's seating for maybe 3-4 small groups. I got a scoop of Brooklyn Blackout ice cream with peanuts and cherry syrup in a toasted brioche bun. The wait wasn't too long. I really liked the ice cream but found the brioche bun to be a little dry and/or stale, considering the price point. I really liked the ice cream flavor though. Well, it was a fun order to try! read more

OddFellows Ice Cream - Brooklyn Blackout ice cream, peanuts, cherry syrup, brioche bun - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

Variety of unique ice cream flavors with a cool retro vibe. I'm usually in the mood for fruity flavors and they had plenty of options to choose from. Being New York, it was expensive for a scoop but you do receive a good amount of ice cream for the price. A must stop if you're in the area! read more

Are you kidding me?? This is the CUTEST ice cream palor I've been to in a while! Retro themed but still with a fresh vibe! So many interesting flavors to try yet we could only get one for our first visit! We opted to go with the mango sticky rice flavor and it was quite good. It tastes like a sweeter version of what I would expect an ice cream dish of that flavor would be. My partner brought up a neat suggestion that maybe they could add bits of sticky rice on top to sell the flavor as well! Either way it was delicious!!! We are looking forward to trying the pistachio sea salt flavor during our next visit! Thank you again to the patient staff who took our order and let us sift through the menu! there's so many unique flavors to check out so maybe research before you go! We hope to try them all during our next visits! read more

See all

Poor customer service practice to have private events and not have any way for other customers to tell if you're open (ie not answering your phones after we called 4x, nothing posted online, nothing on instagram or social media). Really unfortunate to waste a trip here for nothing read more

I work in the area and have seen this place numerous times. It's a nice small shop with different icecream flavors. The cookie jar was recommended by the staff and I must say it did not disappoint. It had all the fixing that you can think of: cookie dough, sprinkles, cookie pieces and mixed together perfectly. read more

OddFellows Ice Cream - Cookie Jar - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Returned to try some of the fresh ice cream and was not disappointed. Chocolate chunk in a s'mores cone was absolutely phenomenal, and the employees were super friendly when my coworker and I visited. Need to return ASAP!! read more

See all

First time trying OddFellows and I'm a fan! Their ice cream isn't as "gummy" and thick as other ice cream shops that I prefer, but I still enjoyed the texture! Got the coffee crunch and sea salt pistachio. The coffee crunch didn't have much of a "crunch" component but was rather mixed with some chocolate bits. What stood out to me was that this flavor tasted like actual coffee, rather than coffee ice cream, which I really appreciated. I wanted more after every bite! The pistachio had a more subtle nutty taste and the sea salt salinity aspect was more of an aftertaste, which I thought was also interesting. This location was pretty spacious and with good lighting. As soon as you walk in, you're greeted by their fresh waffle cone aroma. Staff weren't super friendly but polite. Would definitely come back to check out their other flavors. read more

OddFellows Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

I'm shocked at how good this place is. Truly "odd" because of their amazing selection of UNIQUE flavors. I got the miso peanut butter and blackberry cheesecake biscuit. Both were amazing. - Good service nice people who let me eat samples. - Ambiance is a cute, small little scoop shop with some seating. It is very retro and old school looking. read more

the ice cream itself is give it a 7/10 but the waffle cone was really hard and not good at all & is about a $2 upcharge! the lady who took our order wasn't the most enthusiastic but she let us try a couple of flavors before placing our order which was nice. i really liked the brooklyn blackout but if you're not a chocolate person I recommend the cookie butter flavor - would come back for the ice cream but definitely wouldn't get the cone again read more

OddFellows Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

See all

I had the chocolate cheesecake peanut butter ice cream. It was actually really really good. I was very surprised. Very fresh and very tasty. The small cup was big enough for two people. A little pricey and $8.50 but it is New York City. read more

Unique flavors and plenty of options to taste & choose from. As soon as you enter, you can tell it's gonna be weird and quirky (in a good way). This shop tests the limits with their flavor and texture combinations but I am not mad about it. I tasted a bunch before I decided on the limited edition pandan flavor (with chocolate covered sunflower seeds). In the vanilla base, it had a subtle pandan flavor and the chocolate covered sunflowers gave it such a nice, sweet, nutty crunch. Got on a classic sugar cone but their specialty cones did intrigue me (similar to emack & bolio's) - maybe next time. read more

OddFellows Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

Go try the special Sonic flavors now!!! Green pandan with coconut was so good had to buy a tub to go. I've been a follower of OddFellows since 2018 even before their cute storefronts. Was mourning the loss of Ample Hills which sat empty for a few months but now my sorrows are gone! Lol. Super convenient location off 14th and 8th. Loved all the limited edition Sonic flavors and had a hard time narrowing down to a double scoop. A few tables and a long bench to sit on. Just a warning, there a bunch of high schools nearby so when I ordered huge groups of teens just took over the whole place and all the tables and then only ordered 1 cone...I feel kind of sorry for the staff, they were very professional despite it all. Definitely recommended read more

OddFellows Ice Cream - Outside - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

See all

OddFellows has a nice variety of flavors! Today I tried the vegan coconut mango sticky rice flavor. I was hesitant but it was actually really delicious! The base was coconutty with a mango purée swirl and little chewy mochi pieces. I'd definitely get it again! Beckett was super friendly and let us try samples and answered our questions. read more

OddFellows Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

What a surprise to stumble into OddFellows return to Manhattan! This location is quite spacious with a few tables to dine in. So much more flavors here including the return of their "odd flavors". Staff are friendly and quick to serve. Got the triple to try a few new flavors and they're just as good as their usual ones. The ice cream is always nice and creamy. Welcome back to Manhattan! read more

OddFellows Ice Cream - Sonic flavor, Mango Cheesecake, Passionfruit Apricot Pistachio - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

Service was great ice cream was even better. Everybody was so nice and helpful and helped us decide what flavors we should get.

Generous portion. Tasty. Good vibe. Limited seating. Ordered the coffee and it was delectable. They are franchising.

Amazing flavor profiles!! Must do if you're in the area. Great spot for a walk and a refreshing treat. Staff helpful and kind! read more

OddFellows Ice Cream - Ice cream flavor selection to go - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

came all the way from connecticut and didn't even get to try the ice cream, we were turned away at the door and given nasty looks and told there was a private party, yet there was nothing online to note they would be closing 3 hours early. read more

Just got back from the new 8th Avenue location I got the coffee sticky bun which was really good!! I really enjoyed the sticky bun chunks!!. When I walked in I immediately got a welcoming vibe no awkwardness at all!. The ice cream itself wasn't all that expensive in my opinion anyway!. Looking forward to coming back!! read more

See all

I think this place should be a 3.5 but I'll settle on giving it a 3. The ice cream is good, no complaints there. Biggest issue I had was the price. $7 for a single scoop of ice cream on a cone is too expensive. Can't say I really got my money's worth. I prefer 16 Handles which is nearby. Healthier and the toppings can't be beat. Still, this isn't a bad spot. I wouldn't be against coming back. It's a great looking store by the way. Plenty of interesting flavor to choose from. Free samples are available if you ask. read more

OddFellows Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

Ice cream did not have much flavor. Both the chocolate and black cherry Could have been richer in taste,

I went tonight to get some ice cream and I walked in literally right behind a couple, and the guy waved me off and rudely said "we are closed " as if in walked in at 10:05 expecting service. It was 959, I probably would've been out the door at 10. employee was so rude. not even a "sorry, I can't serve you" read more

The Ice Cream was o.k. The sugar-cone was a Costco special. The service was obnoxious. $9.00 for a single scoop had me reeling.

Mango Cheesecake hit the spot even if it was just 1 scoop.....$6.40 for the scoop but I didn't mind it because the ice cream tasted good. I like the name and look of this ice cream shop and will return again. read more