This is a special place as there are few places in Wisconsin to buy fresh lake fish. Fresh Lake…read moreMichigan whitefish and lake trout filets can be purchased here! Smoked fish spread and smoked white fish was excellent too. Would highly recommend if you love fresh water not frozen locally caught fish

Tucked away down a side road in a residential area, we only found out about this place from a…read morebrochure of the area. Knowing how much hubs likes smoked fish, I directed him here. There is plenty of parking, and we were the only customers at the time of our visit. As soon as you open the door, you get slapped in the face with the smell of fish (of course!). I wasn't expecting the wide variety of offerings, though! Saltwater and freshwater fish, as well as scallops. If you're a little queasy about such things, there is a table about 20 feet from the door where they process the day's catch, so you may want to look away or have someone else do your shopping for you. The shopping area is small, about 6 by 15 feet, maybe? A counter with fresh fish and scallops on display and two freezers with frozen goodies. Prices were reasonable; we picked up some smoked salmon and went to a little park nearby to snack. Now that we know it's here, we have another place to go besides our old stand-by in Gill's Rock! 34/2022

It was an absolutely wonderful experience, from sitting at the bar for a little while waiting for…read moreour reservation because we showed up way early and having the brussels sprouts that were amazing. Our bartender was wonderful, and then we receded in the most perfect table which overlooked the water. I had an amazing Connecticut lobster roll in my husband had the Seabass and both were perfect. The restaurant is very beautiful inside. Also, just a great spot.

Sooo... I really wanted to love this place…read more We made a day trip to Door County and had a long list of restaurants to choose from. After reading countless reviews, we picked this one as our #1 dinner choice because it seemed to have great vibes and a beautiful outdoor garden overlooking Lake Michigan. The setting absolutely lived up to the hype, and that alone earns it a star. We arrived a little early for our reservation and decided to grab a drink at the bar. My mom simply asked if they had any watermelon or pineapple seltzers, and instead of answering, the bartender just handed her a drink menu and walked away. It was a small interaction, but it came across as dismissive, so we decided not to order drinks. We were seated shortly after in a wonderful spot in the garden. We had our dog with us, and it was the perfect outdoor setting for her to relax while we enjoyed dinner. Our server was pleasant, but she didn't seem very attentive or able to read the table. We started with the Brussels sprouts, which were delicious and probably the highlight of the meal. We know this restaurant is especially known for its whitefish and lobster boil. After tasting our meals, my mother said she wished she had ordered the whitefish since we'd heard such amazing things about it. Unfortunately, when it became obvious that we weren't enjoying our food, our server never asked if something was wrong or if we'd like to try something else. The crab Rangoon dip was just okay. The lobster bisque was completely flavorless--the worst lobster bisque I've ever had, and I order it whenever it's on a menu. The sage butter gnocchi was equally bland and lacked any real flavor. My mom ordered the ribeye, and she said it tasted more like a sirloin and was totally overcooked. It lacked the rich flavor you'd expect from a ribeye and had quite a bit of fat. She only ate a few bites before giving most of it to the dog. The vegetables (I believe asparagus or broccolini) weren't good, and the au gratin potatoes were equally disappointing. The only real win was my son's chicken tenders. He's an extremely picky eater, and he genuinely enjoyed them. What disappointed us most was how the situation was handled. When our server checked back, she asked how everything was, and we replied, "It's alright." Later, when she saw that our plates were still mostly full and asked if we wanted boxes, we said no. That would have been the perfect opportunity to ask if something was wrong or if there was anything they could do. Instead, the conversation ended there and the check was placed on the table. At that point, we just wanted to leave. Between the underwhelming service, the bland food, and the high prices, the experience simply wasn't worth it. We left feeling incredibly disappointed, annoyed and hungry. It's unfortunate because the location and atmosphere are beautiful, and we truly wanted this restaurant to be a highlight of our trip. Sadly, if we make it back to Baileys Harbor, we won't be returning.

We love this place! It's great to sit outside and watch the boats while eating delicious food…read more Tried the whitefish chowder and the wedge salad this time and both were super. Key lime pie for dessert... Our server was great...Sydney I think. She was very professional and friendly. And patient, especially as other tables were requesting separate checks. Nothing phased her!

Great, friendly service! Briana spoiled us! Seated on patio…read moreand was a picture perfect day! We enjoyed the perch basket. Nicely breaded and very tasty! A nice portion. Enjoy!

Best Tuscan Garlick smoked salmon on the planet! You rock. Your lobster cold water was excellent…read morefor New Year's Eve. Great staff to help ring you up. Tip them like I did!

I love the food and selection there. But the last 2 things I bought…read more We're not very good. The fish sticks good size dry and stringy not Flicky at all Scallops were dry, no sweetness to it, actually no flavor. I'm not giving a bad review. I just want you to know. I've always had a great experience there. These were the breaded ones. I think next time I'm going to get fresh. Baby octopus is wonderful. I would have given that a five It could be just the Batch that they made

Wonderful dining experience! The meal was outstanding, the ambiance was excellent and the service…read morewas great. I had the Cast Iron Chicken and my wife had sesame encrusted Salmon ? Portion size was very nice reasobly oriced and perfectly seasoned. Best meal I have had in DC in recent memory. Would definitely recommend and will definitely plan on going back!

We all absolutely everything. Such a pretty spot too. Fish and chips, fish dip, salad with very…read morefresh tomatoes and cherry champagne vinaigrette, blt hot dog, etc. Friendly staff too. Everything felt very homemade.

The food was excellent. We had whitefish, lamb and steak. The service was first class. The…read morewaitstaff was knowledgeable and attentive. The facility is smart, cozy and clean. We rate the ambiance a 5 out of 5.

The food was amazing, had the ribeye. Our server ben was the best thing you could ever want from a…read moreserver. Patient, funny, respectful, friendly. No notes. Outdoor seating was lovely!

They've started a round-up policy to avoid giving out exact change. This is just the beginning of…read morewoke/communism/socialism/dictatorship. When I demanded exact change, they had to get a manager involved, who was offended by my insistance. The cashier and manager had difficulty figuring the exact change. I like their store, but won't do business with automatons.

I am a troll from Lansing. I was surprised to see such a variety of offerings and at very good…read moreprices compared to where I live. I wished there was a market like that where I live. I beats the chain stores such as Meijer's, Kroger, and Walmart. Way to go Elmer's!

The fish was very good, caught the same day. It was very cool to see the process and the…read morepresentation.

This place has been on our list to visit for their traditional and popular fish boil (an evening…read moreevent), but instead we dropped in here for a Sunday lunch for our first visit. The spacious restaurant was not very busy. Our server was busy though as she covered several tables including several of their popular patio tables. I ordered their fish-n-chips plate lunch for $15. Wife ordered their lake perch plate lunch for $22 but requested the perch grilled instead of fried. She actually wanted the whitefish plate lunch but they were out of whitefish at the time. Both plates came with buttered rye bread and that was a nice, and relatively unique, accompaniment to the fish and fries. Our server first brought out a plate of fried perch but quickly realized the error and promptly brought out the correct grilled perch plate. The grilled perch didn't look grilled, and may have been baked or even microwaved. It was in ok range for her, but I probably enjoyed my conventional cod fish-n-chips more than she did her perch.