The new location for Henriksen's Fish House is fantastic. The ability to buy fresh or frozen fish…read morethat's caught nearby in the bay is worth the drive up to Ellison Bay. I brought a giant cooler with me so I could load up with frozen whitefish before heading home to the Milwaukee area. The amount I bought won't last me until the next time I'm in Door County, which is sad, but knowing that I can stop at Henriksen's again the next time I'm here makes me happy.

Great fresh white fish. I also bought premise patties, they were wonderful. Great place to pick…read moreup fresh white fish.

This is a special place as there are few places in Wisconsin to buy fresh lake fish. Fresh Lake…read moreMichigan whitefish and lake trout filets can be purchased here! Smoked fish spread and smoked white fish was excellent too. Would highly recommend if you love fresh water not frozen locally caught fish

Tucked away down a side road in a residential area, we only found out about this place from a…read morebrochure of the area. Knowing how much hubs likes smoked fish, I directed him here. There is plenty of parking, and we were the only customers at the time of our visit. As soon as you open the door, you get slapped in the face with the smell of fish (of course!). I wasn't expecting the wide variety of offerings, though! Saltwater and freshwater fish, as well as scallops. If you're a little queasy about such things, there is a table about 20 feet from the door where they process the day's catch, so you may want to look away or have someone else do your shopping for you. The shopping area is small, about 6 by 15 feet, maybe? A counter with fresh fish and scallops on display and two freezers with frozen goodies. Prices were reasonable; we picked up some smoked salmon and went to a little park nearby to snack. Now that we know it's here, we have another place to go besides our old stand-by in Gill's Rock! 34/2022

The food was top tits the drinks were rad. The 60 lobster was worth it. Pasta was so good the…read morechocolate cake hard on service was good waitress was nice the vibe was collected

Had outdoor dining on the patio. We ordered the walleye sandwich with chips, a Caesar salad, and…read morethe soup special of chicken poblano. All the food items were excellent and the service outstanding. Dined here many times over the years and always a good experience.

We visited this Sister Bay eatery a few weeks back and had an enjoyable time. Normally this is a…read morehot spot for patio and open-aired seating, but it was late in the season with chilly weather, so the restaurant was buttoned up. It imagine it's extra delightful in the summer months. Giving all of the boathouse vibes for sure. You'll find allllll the seafood options on this menu, and definitely on the pricier side. From salmon and lobster mac, to ahi tuna, whitefish and shrimp. Oh and if you're a meat eater instead, fear not because there are plenty of good options there too. I went with the blackened catfish, topped with avo lime sauce and a side of veggies. Was it tasty? Yes. Was it worthy of $27? Probably not. Everyone else was pleased with their meals, our server was so sweet, and the overall atmosphere was great. Would certainly return next time we're in town to try other menu items.

Nice casual spot on the water. We had burgers which were wonderful. Laid back place with good food…read more Service very friendly.

Best Tuscan Garlick smoked salmon on the planet! You rock. Your lobster cold water was excellent…read morefor New Year's Eve. Great staff to help ring you up. Tip them like I did!

I love the food and selection there. But the last 2 things I bought…read more We're not very good. The fish sticks good size dry and stringy not Flicky at all Scallops were dry, no sweetness to it, actually no flavor. I'm not giving a bad review. I just want you to know. I've always had a great experience there. These were the breaded ones. I think next time I'm going to get fresh. Baby octopus is wonderful. I would have given that a five It could be just the Batch that they made

Wonderful dining experience! The meal was outstanding, the ambiance was excellent and the service…read morewas great. I had the Cast Iron Chicken and my wife had sesame encrusted Salmon ? Portion size was very nice reasobly oriced and perfectly seasoned. Best meal I have had in DC in recent memory. Would definitely recommend and will definitely plan on going back!

We dined last evening and everything about our experience was exceptional. Everyone in our party…read moreenjoyed our apps and entrees. We ordered the fish dip, avocado tartare, and smoked salmon Rangoon along with white fish platter and chicken and grits. What I want to note is the owners went above and beyond to make our dining experience exceptional. They truly went out of their way to take care of us. We will be back and highly recommend!

First night in Door County for the year and decided we needed to see the water. We had a lovely…read moretable near a window. Sun going down, but the shades were easily lowered and we were still able to see the water as we ate. Prince Edward oysters were wonderful, along with fried calamari to start. Caesar salad and wedge salad nicely dressed; just the perfect amount of dressing. Very large salads. Lollipop lamb small plate cooked to perfection. And who doesn't love bolognese?!? This was an excellent version. I'll be enjoying the leftovers.

Wow, so glad we went! From the delicious food, through the great service, all accompanied by a…read morespectacular sunset, it was an awesome evening. Ben was our server and was impeccable. He had great suggestions and paced our courses well. We started with the wedge salad which was way better than the traditional wedge salad of bygone days. Everything was so fresh and the bacon was delicious. Baby lamb chops were cooked perfectly. And the sauce was yummy. Shrimp and grits were good. Halibut with lemon risotto was great too. We split everything so we'd get to taste it all. And we topped off the meal with a slice of their carrot cake. Moist cake with excellent cream cheese frosting elevated by a caramel swirl and birthday message!

They've started a round-up policy to avoid giving out exact change. This is just the beginning of…read morewoke/communism/socialism/dictatorship. When I demanded exact change, they had to get a manager involved, who was offended by my insistance. The cashier and manager had difficulty figuring the exact change. I like their store, but won't do business with automatons.

I am a troll from Lansing. I was surprised to see such a variety of offerings and at very good…read moreprices compared to where I live. I wished there was a market like that where I live. I beats the chain stores such as Meijer's, Kroger, and Walmart. Way to go Elmer's!

A fantastic experience! My husband and I had a wonderful time going to Pelletier's fish boil!…read moreGetting to see the process of the potatoes, onion, corn and Lake Michigan native fish go into the pot with a fun history was a unique and fun experience. Everyone enjoyed their time on the patio seeing the boil itself before going in to enjoy the outcome. My husband immediately said that it was the best fish he'd ever had, and was shocked that it needed no extra seasonings or sauces. The salt that was used and the cooking process itself brought out incredible flavors in the fish and sides. The owner takes so much pride in his work and is excellent interacting with his guests! There is a lot of indoor/outdoor seating but you should call to make a reservation and get your name on the list! You have to get there about 45 minutes early before "the show" to get your ticket, which is no issue. There is also an option to choose from over a dozen other entrees if you're not interested in seafood (I saw a vegetarian option too), as well as a kids menu. The non-alcoholic beverages are included in the ticket but there is an option to purchase local and big name beers as well. The cherry pie at the end is the chef's kiss! It was such a perfect addition to our trip, even people who brought toddlers had a fun time with their kids. We'll come back to this fish boil every time we visit Door County!

I've been waiting years to finally get a reservation for the fish boil here and it finally…read morehappened! I should have opted for the smaller portion because the regular portion was more than I could consume! It was over a pound of fish! The master boiler has been doing this for over 40 years so it must be a great place to work! That says a lot for a business these days. Dining options are indoors or outdoors, and we opted for outdoors the bread was a little disappointing as it was just sliced bread and not rolls. It includes a soft drink, which is a nice touch and of course, the cherry pie. It would be nice if there was seasoning on the table is a little bland.

Friendly, helpful staff Comfy furniture & tables…read moreAdorable book store plus Delicious gf bakery! Amazing latte

A totally fun store with the best granola around! Homemade scones, fresh coffee and more. Its…read morecute as can be in an old Church building. Gardens surround the building. The staff is friendly and helpful. A definite stop on my Door County itinerary!