We have ordered takeout here a few times and the food is always good. The broiled seafood platter is a favorite. I ordered mussels to serve at a gathering, they were delicious. Raynah was extremely helpful and attentive to my needs, really went above and beyond. Definitely recommend their tasty food for dinner or guests. read more

I would order take out from here at least one a week food is amazing can't deny that and I would often stop at the store but on one particular day I spent over $300 for a dinner I was making it was an assortment of fresh seafood. I had asked for horseradish to go with the fresh oysters initially. after he ran my card and took the payment the 1st time i noticed I didn't get the horseradish so the employee looked at me and said $2.00 plus tax and credit card fee. I clearly didn't have cash just my debit card so he proceeded to then ring me up for the smallest container of horseradish and then taxed me again twice on the purchase ! In addition to that when he charged me for a everything he forgot to charge me for the oyster which I pointed out the amount didn't seem to add up it seemed to cheap so he checked and he realized he didn't so he then ran my card a 3rd time with both tax fees. I was beyond words I just spent well over $300 and you couldn't say it's okay no worries doesn't that usually come along with fresh oysters lemons and cocktail sauce.... I would come here all the time but after that experience I'm not even sure anymore. Something as small as that turns away loyal customers because after it's all said and done you should have included the condiments with the purchase. read more

The best place to get seafood on the island!!! Never steer you wrong... the recommendation are " off da hook" . They will ask what you need the seafood for and then ask you if you would like suggestions of how to prepare it. They will give you samples if you are not sure about anything. It's a local homie feel. The prices are great!! read more

Island Fish - the front of the restaurant - Seafood Markets Near Me - Farmingville, New York

The service at this place is amazing! I loved the mango slushie, I just got some salmon and baked clams! First time here and I loved everything about it. Definitely coming back read more

Came here on Sunday, small and clean, a lot of customers came and go, they should leave a good review for them! Busy now and I am waiting for my half shell oysters Updating my review: Changing stars 5 to 3 Reason: super slow in services.... Open oysters take forever to wait Update again: Back to 4 stars Reason: food are delicious! Worth to wait read more

See all

What a hidden gem! I stop here all the time to get my seafood fix. Their prices are very fair and the fish is always fresh. The atmosphere is homey, they have a few small tables if you want to dine in but I usually take my food to go. The staff is always very friendly and you always get served with a smile whenever coming in here. The menu is huge here. They have frozen fish, or hot plates, sandwiches, wraps, a very wide selection. Their lobster bisque is pure gold. I could eat that stuff everyday and never get sick of it. Definitely try it if you come here. read more

See all

What's a girl to do when having family over the house for a gathering with no intention to cook? You guessed it, catering it is! This was my first time ordering catering from this place. My dad loves seafood so that was the theme of the night.Service was top notch when ordering the food to receiving the food. The food is where is goes downhill. I ordered individual lobster bakes which everyone in my family enjoyed. I also ordered paella,Hawaiian chicken, stuffed mushrooms, and baked clams which were all mehhhh.I honestly was embarrassed that I served this food at my family gathering . It looked good but it sure was not the case.I'm such a foodie and pride myself in sharing great meals with my family, and this was a disaster! Definitely not my best decision. I will absolutely never ever place an order for catering here ever again. read more

It is a very small place with only one table, so I purchased take out. I bought the shrimp scampi that had 9 large shrimps and linguine. It was really flavorful. I was only able to eat 1/2 of it the first night and finished the other 1/2 the next night and it reheated well. I I was given a sample of cold shrimp with dill that so amazing. I purchased 1/2 pound and then went back the next day for two more pounds. read more

Let me first describe Island Fish. It is a working class take-out fish place with a substantial menu and 4 tables for folks who want to eat in. It is not pretending to be a fancy restaurant. I went there today for the first time. I got the best fish and chips I have ever had. I rejected the offer of tarter sauce and got offered malt vinegar (which to my taste is a whole lot better). The batter was thin and crisp; the fries were big fat steak bore no oil. I brought home a scallop and bacon cake, something I have never heard of before. I'll eat it tomorrow. Island Fish has an inventive chef who also seems to be a practical businessman. The Michelin folks may not come soon, but on the basis of my one visit I'm giving the place all the stars you have to offer. read more

So the seafood is pretty cheap. The lobsters bisque wad the best I ever had. But I tried the scallop cakes, shrimp cakes, patio And cheese croquet, and something else and it wad nothing special aty all. Maybe if they were made fresh. I have yet to try there Manhattan clam chowder that's tomorrow. But ask the seafood is fresh not what anyone would expect from a seafood truck on a corner. And the door wad fresh also. The associate girl wad nice and helpful and gave me a sample cup of the bisque and that for me to buy it. I'll continue to go to the corner truck ppb sunrise in spring valley. Stir to far for me. read more

The huge sign that is basically the name of the store that says 10 tails for 20 dollars is a lie. Drove there only to be told that they do not honor it, and haven't for over 2 years. That's fine but take the sign down so your not falsely luring customers in. Also their prices are crazy high but to be fair we are in a pandemic. I wouldn't return. I prefer claws or any other market read more

Got lobster tails from here and when I took them out to cook them, they were all slimey and they smelled horrendous. Was unable to cook them. Waste of money read more

First time there Food was delicious and there was Plenty to eat and prices were good Both my wife and I ordered the Fishermen Platter one Broiled and One fried Will recommend to all my friends read more

Never again will EVER buy ANYTHING FROM THIS PLACE SMFH my family and I were soo disappointed with everything we got I spent $46 and the pasta Had no taste the baked clams were overcooked and cold and the lobste you can tell was old and overly recooked and definitely was in the freezer for months ‍ The only thing that was good was the guy that I spoke to but he definitely talked a good game cause he told me how my food was going to be cooked and made me really excited about eating what I ordered but it WAS THE WORST I EVER HAD IN MY LIFE. We tried to keep the leftovers of the linguine and clam sauce and one small lobster tail but had to throw it out because the entire fridge reeked of old seafood especially when we opened it read more

If you are looking for a great seafood meal that grandma made, this is your place. Homemade sauces and a great selection. This gem has been here 16 years and I'm at a loss that I never tried it. Best fish sandwich around! read more

This place deserves all the business in the world. Epitome of friendly local establishment. I always feel so appreciated and I am obsessed with their crab cakes. Also their giant shark is hilarious. Long live Island Fish! read more

Worst seafood place ever. Not only was the place extremely pricy the food was absolutely horrible. Here's what we ordered: 1. A dozen of oysters - they were warm, we were scared that we were going to get food poisoning afterwards. I should have known not to order them when I asked them what kind of oysters they were and they didn't know even though they only sell seafood. 2. Fried calamari - worst calamari we have everrrrr tasted. It was bland and rubbery. I can't respect a seafood place that can't get a simple appetizer like this right. 3. Shrimp & dill wrap - this was probably the most decent thing we ordered. With that being said, it was overpowered by dill. The fries were good though. read more

I absolutely love this place. It's legit, simple, and beyond convenient. I have always been a fan of their crab cakes, lobster bisque, and fresh fish selection. read more

Got DoorDash from here. They missed my steak fries with the stuffed flounder.Everything was extremely salty .

The food is BEYOND delicious My husband and I will definitely be a regular!!!! The cost is reasonable and well worth it!! I was simply amazed how Fabulously scrumptious the Lobster bisque soup & Linguini with shrimp and lobster platter was I Highly Recommend this establishment read more

Raw clams were fresh and tasty. However raw oysters were small and not as fresh as clams -- maybe just not a good timing here. The price is reasonable tho. read more

Going downhill. It's sad because I used to love the place. I rarely see the owner there anymore and maybe that's the problem. He really cared about quality and his customers. It seems like the people he's got there in his place are just phoning it in. It shows in the quality of food and service. A Shame. I hope the owner gets the place back into shape because it used to be a favorite that I'd recommend to everyone. read more

OMG! This place is so AWESOME! I don't even know where to start in terms of telling how great of an experience I had at Island Fish. Firstly, the seafood for sale is SUPER FRESH. I found the price to be average and well worth it. I did not feel at all that it was over-priced. The variety of seafood that is offered is great. From crabs, shrimps, fish, and their amazing fresh lobster tails. I bought 2 bags of snow crabs, 2 bags of Brazil lobster tails, 2 bags of local small lobster tails, and 3 pounds of flounder. All so FRESH and DELICIOUS! And I'm saving the best part for last. The best part of my experience at Island Fish that has made me go back is the superior customer service and staff led by the amazing Jordan. Jordan is, in my book, the epitome of what a business owner/leader should be. He made my family and I feel like we were family there. And not in a cheesy, "Mangia, mangia..." kinda way, but in terms of making us feel so welcome. But, really, the best thing about Jordan is his honesty. While most employees, when asked for recommendations, usually suggest the more expensive options, Jordan gave the most honest recommendations regardless of price. And it ended up being very valuable because they were so delicious. I can't rave enough of how awesome Jordan is. I have to be honest. Some places in Suffolk County can make minority folks like me feel a bit self-conscious or unwelcome. But NOT here! Literally, it felt like home here. From the friendly and honest staff to the delicious food options, this place is not to be missed. And, it is well worth the travel, if you don't live close. read more

I'm not going to leave you a list of prices or a menu like the review above, but I will tell u this: Always fresh, a bit pricey, however I'm willing to pay anything for the consistent quality and freshness they offer. All of the HOMECOOKED salads, potato croquets, and rice they have in the case are made daily. You won't be disappointed, this place would be a perfect candidate for diners, drive-ins and dives. A little hole in the wall joint with great food. *they also buy gold, a bit strange, but that would explain the Porsche parked outside. read more

Made a quick stop looking for a seafood salad. Had a great shrimp and dill salad that was perfect. The shrimp was perfectly cooked and proportionally seasoned mixed with fresh vegetables . Also, the owner couldn't have been nicer ! Fast service , good food and great price !! read more

Island Fish - Shrimp and dill salad - Seafood Markets Near Me - Farmingville, New York

Excellent food..excellent service..they treat u like family and make anything u want to go..prices are good and catering has been better than any other seafood establishment read more

For $12 you get a 1/2 tray of Rice & Potatoes and a full Roasted Chicken. It's not only an unbelievable deal, but more importantly, it tastes Great. I'm a big fan! read more

We ordered food for Christmas Eve. This is my only experience with this place and its probably their busiest night of the year, so review may not be a usual experience here. We ordered food to be ready at 4:00. We got there at 4:10 - the place was crowded with people who had apparently been waiting an hour. . .we ended up not getting the food until 5:15. They could not have been less organized. The impression I got was that the people working don't usually work there, were just were helping for the night. Honestly, it was comical how disorganized they were. On a positive note, most of the customers and staff kept their cool - even though everyone was very frustrated. The food was "ok" at best. read more

The food is amazing! Staff is friendly and service is great! I've always stuck to my linguine with white clam sauce but i want to try the other dishes. And the new england clam chowder - soo good! I've purchased their frozen king crab legs and the big shrimps that tastes and looks like a lobster tail - amazingly good!!! Must try! read more

Big time hidden gem! If you're a seafood lover this place is as good as it gets. Last week we ordered the Lobster risotto balls, absolutely amazing. Staff is super friendly, parking is a pleasure, and it's very easy to get to. Definitely recommended! read more

Great prices, fresh seafood, yummy prepared foods. The owner are really nice and helpful. They have a great shrimp ceviche they make, I think Thursdays and I love their lobster bisque. Ask for their homemade tarter sauce, you'll never buy it in the grocery store again! The lobster tails and crab legs are affordable and great for bbqs in the summer! I can't say enough nice things about this family owned business. read more

Got food from here twice. Pretty good! You would miss it going by if you werent looking for it. Parking lot is small, and they have a few tables to sit inside. The first time I ate there my salmon was supposed to by "in dill sauce" and I got it with a small dizzle over it. Now I just ask for extra sauce. The only other con is that it takes a while for the food to be made. When I called for take out, they told me 25-30 minutes, for two dishes, and when I got there @ 30 minutes, it still wasnt ready. I would def go back! read more

Excellent food and service! Very friendly and family oriented. I've stopped in for lunch and also have purchased frozen seafood to make at home. Can't wait. For cooler weather and the lobster bisque. Give it a try! read more

It's just okay. We've tried a few of their entrees and it wasn't anything special. The soup and bread bowls are super delicious. Everything else is meh. The fried calamari is awful. The texture is just like rubber and it has no taste. My husband likes the raw oysters but sometimes they don't have them. read more

Talk about a hidden gem!!! And it truly is hidden haha. I say so because you would never know from looking at this place the awesomeness that derives from within! I drove by many times without popping in. Until that one faithful day I did. Life changer. The pricing is pretty average from what you would find elsewhere, but, the quality of food is outstanding! They have a really nice selection of fresh and frozen seafood and ship in lobsters of enormous size. Also, they can prepare anything fresh you may be getting, or you can choose from different tasty treats they make in house like the crab cakes. The seafood is so fresh that when I shucked my clams they were moving around, a lot haha. You don't find quality like this very often. Super customer service as well! Go here! read more

The building that formerly housed the famous Tatay and Sons guitar workshop, now holds Island Fish, Farmingville's retail fishmonger. It's been here for a while, and be it fresh swimmers or crawlers, they have what you need. Littlenecks are $4 a dozen. Mussels, 2lbs. for $5. Frozen bags of king and snow crab legs are $25, lobster tails from the Bahamas and Maine: In addition to the usual behind-the-counter offerings, there are some great, prepared foodstuffs and seafood salads, all made on-site. Check out the crabmeat-stuffed lobsters ($10), and foil-lined baked clams ($11 per dozen). The great thing about this place is you can order-up to stay, and eat it here, sitting at the checkerboard tableclothed dinettes, using plastic bowls and utensils, the way it should be. This place is clean. They have a flatscreen to distract you while your food is prepped, or else try the lobster bisque which exceeds expectations. There is a beer and soft-drink fridge as well. . . help yourself, and pay on the way out. Take my advice and stop in when for a bite, next time you do your laundry next door (http://www.yelp.com/biz/horseblock-road-laundromat-farmingville#hrid:BxCBlx_Bq1d_7ubrIcT5OQ). read more

I went here for lunch on 7/20/17 with a coworker. I'm usually a bit skeptical about small, unknown, places, and I was about this place. This place was AWESOME! The lobster bisque was great! The lobster grilled cheese was outstanding! The portions are generous. This was a great find! The next time we are nearby, we will definitely be back. read more