FOOD: Finally got to try this place and both orders were so good. I got the shaken sensation and melon madness. Delicious, refreshing and not too sweet. Perfect for hot days! They offer bobas, milk teas and smoothies along with frozen yogurt with plenty of options for toppings. It seems like the flavors change from time to time. SERVICE: The man who helped me was very welcoming and nice. The service was quick (although I was the only customer during my visit) but I feel like there wouldn't be a great wait even with multiple customers. AMBIANCE: Small mom and pop shop. There are little stools with a bar counter, tables and chairs to sit and enjoy your yogurt or other snacks that can be bought at the store as well. Not a very big spot so depends on the visit it can get crowded. Most people seem to take it to go instead of sitting at the store. Plenty of parking but it is also a shared parking lot with other stores in the plaza so be aware. Highly recommend this local staple shop! Worth the price. I can't wait to go back! Support local! read more

It’s Really Yogurt - Menu + supplements options - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Arroyo Grande, California

See all

The best quality frozen yogurt of anywhere local. I've been coming here for years, since high school 2 decades ago. The owners are the sweetest people and they work really hard in this business. AG Eagle is the best tasting smoothie and a local favorite for AG High School's eagles mascot. Banana Splitz is my other favorite (chocolate amazingness). Tonight we just got fro yo and my husband got a PB smoothie. They accept Apple Pay now instead of cash only so that's awesome! read more

It’s Really Yogurt - Large vanilla/chocolate swirl with cookie dough topping and child's size vanilla/chocolate swirl with rainbow sprinkle topping - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Arroyo Grande, California

I said i can't decide if i want Boba or yogurt & she said we can put Boba on your yougurt. What!!!! I've never heard of that!!! It was sooooo good :-) read more

It’s Really Yogurt - Vanilla yogurt with boba - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Arroyo Grande, California

Service was great, but the yogurt was amazing next time I'm in town I'll be sure to stop in. Great selection of flavors. Thanks for a fun visit. read more

Second visit just as good as first. Ordered blueberry strawberry and raspberry smoothie. Asked them to add banana. Better smoothie ever in my international travels. Lots of menu choices. Great customer service. Clean. Check them out. read more

super yummy got a smoothie. perfect consistency and very yummy. easy to find the store and lots of parking will be going back here again read more

It’s Really Yogurt - A.G Eagle - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Arroyo Grande, California

See all

This place is and always has been the best smoothie/yogurt shop on the central coast. Been here at least fifty times and it has always been a locally owned family business. They use top quality fresh ingredients and supplements. Plus way better service and value than Jamba. read more

It’s Really Yogurt - #10 AG Eagle - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Arroyo Grande, California

We walked it. Had a sample and it wasn't that great. We like yogurt places where you make and prepare your own yogurt... very limited flavors. They don't have dairy free yogurts so we walked out. The sample didn't have a good taste so we chose a different place. read more

Sophia and Richard are the best. The yogurt and smoothies are the best you will find in the area period.

Best yogurt I've ever had, and their custom smoothies are made with fresh fruit and creamy yogurt. Nice and thick Not icey like most smoothies . A small mom & pop business with the friendliest owners and staff. After two or three visits, they know your name and treat you like family! read more

Love the place, and the people! Have been going there, for years, and will keep going. Don't know them personally, so this isn't really biased. I've looked for other yogurts, I like just as well, so far to no avail. We drive from Orcutt, just for a yogurt, once in a while. read more

Awesome yogurt, awesome service! Love supporting family-owned businesses and every time I try a new smoothie, it never disappoints!

This place was a surprise. It's a small business but it was fresh, tasty and best quality yogurt ever! Even the sugar free was so full of flavor and with no aftertaste at all! They were friendly and quick to serve it up! Don't miss out on this place ... unbelievably delicious! read more

Best frozen yogurt in the area . And 1/2 the price . Service is amazing they always it just the way you like it ! This place is a true hidden gem for frozen yogurt lovers. We are here 4 nights a week. 5 star and we highly recommend this spot . read more

It’s Really Yogurt - an ice cream sundae - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Arroyo Grande, California

See all

Me and my family have been coming here for years. The yogurt is incredible, but the customer service is even better. I highly recommend "Its Really Yogurt" to anybody who enjoys great Boba, fruit smoothies and amazing frozen yogurt. I also like to support small business as we want small businesses to stay in our town and thrive. read more

AMAZING. The smoothies are so good. Get the tropical ones there fire. The people are so nice the staff is great.

I have lived on the central coast for 21 years & this is truly the best frozen yogurt. If you grew up during the 80's the height of the fro yo experience, this is what you are looking for . The texture of the frozen yogurt is perfect , if you recall how amazing TCBY was , this is the closest you will find ! The owners are amazing too . Cash only . read more

The best yogurt shop! Get the Very Berry! You won't be sorry! The original owners sold the business to someone else but the new owner kept the old recipes! Love it! read more

Jim and Tiffany Rock! We've been going to them since they opened years ago. Awesome selection, tastes great, service is quick, and at reasonable prices. read more

My husband had been coming here for 15+ years and the shop hasn't changed. I tried one of their smoothies and it tasted just like Jamba Juice. They also offer 2 free boosts (just like JJ). I'm glad I checked out this little shop. It's not for the health nuts who are looking for cold pressed wheat grass shots, etc. but it is a nice option for a sweet treat and they do offer fresh squeezed juice as well. read more

It’s Really Yogurt - California cruising $5. Stopping in for my hubbys childhood fave - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Arroyo Grande, California

Fantastic place. Always good, always friendly--family business Cash only, so be aware read more

I don't have too many excuses to make my way from LA to Pismo Beach, but I found myself here on the drive home after a weekend stay in Morro Bay. A cold drink is a must in order to stay hydrated and give you something to as you drive down the picturesque California coast on a particularly hot summer day. It's Really Yogurt is a gem. Family-owned and staffed by a friendly couple at the time of my visit, it is located in a small plaza with plenty of parking. Once inside, you'll find several options for smoothies and frozen yogurt. With so many options, it was hard to choose just one. I settled on the AG Eagle! It's a delicious blend of fresh raspberries, strawberries, bananas, and oranges. It was $4.95 well spent! Bring cash though, as there is a sign that says No ATM, credit, or debit cards are accepted. There is a small seating area inside and a single table and chairs for customers outside. It's not the newest or most modern shop, but if you care more about the quality of the products, you won't go wrong here! So overall... The good: Loved the AG eagle smoothie! Great tasting fresh fruits, and friendly staff. Lots of options to fit your smoothie preferences! The bad: It's not a sparkling, brand new shop, so don't expect it to look as nice as a Yogurtland or Jamba Juice inside. The ugly: Bring cash. This place won't accept card and it doesn't have an ATM machine! read more

See all

Absolute favorite spot in town. Best smoothies and froyo available. And bonus coming here means you are supporting a local business.

Super sweet couple who I assume are the owners . This place is so nostalgic. I'm glad that this place is still up and running!

Best smoothie I've ever had hands down. AG EAGLE'S 3-4 days a week (#10 on the menu).California Cruisin' is also good but nothing near my go-to. AG Eagle's are all I order 99% of the time, alongside the rest of the locals who have been drinking the smoothies here since high school. Don't change the ingredients of their smoothies, just order what's on the wall and you'll see that they were right, and you were wrong to try and change it. Every single smoothie has been the same, the hours of business, how fast they can make my smoothie, a number 10 will cost me $6 total ; $4.95 + $1 tip a - keep the nickel, where to stand and wait and what to say to make the process painless, ththey only take cash, the names of the owners, the names of the smoothies, the names of every fruit on the framed picture on the wall.. read more

It’s Really Yogurt - Timeless wall menu. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Arroyo Grande, California

The best! Fresh ingredients, amazing prices, great selection & they will let you choose some flavors yourself! The owners are so sweet :) Always my go to place read more

It’s Really Yogurt - outside and peanut butter banana smoothie - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Arroyo Grande, California

Only place I'm aware of that has sugar free frozen yogurt. Fast friendly service and a great price.

I loved this smoothie place since senior year of high school back in 2010 and I still keep coming back.

Our first time here. Small yogurt shop but it delivers great yogurt and smoothies. Indulged in a large yogurt with toppings. My husband went with no toppings ‍. Several p were waiting for their smoothies and I heard one gal tell us they 'never' disappoint. She was correct. Now I know where to come when I'm looking for good frozen delights. read more

If you really want to help a small business, check this place out. The people there are so nice and the smoothies are delicious!

Me and the gf got smoothies here and let me tell you- it's better than Jamba Juice. We both killed our smoothies within 20 mins. If you're a fan of Jamba or fruit smoothies u won't regret coming here. Highly recommend to all smoothie lovers . read more

Excellent service and excellent frozen yogurt! I have been buying frozen yogurt at It's Really yYogurt for many years and have always been delighted. read more

Delicious yoghurt-y smoothies at an excellent price. Also service is incredibly fast! Always feels good to support a mom and pop shop :) read more

It’s Really Yogurt - a hand holding a cup of fruit smoothie - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Arroyo Grande, California

A friend recommended this place, on the corner of Grand & Halcyon, excellent Smoothie!

They have best yogurt and smoothies in the Five Cities area! The yogurt is so creamy and delicious!

Great smoothies and frozen yogurt can be had here! This shop is operated by a super friendly local family and I try to come in at least once a week. read more

This is THE BEST frozen yogurt shop in the county!!! I will only take my business to this friendly, family run/locally owned and awesome spot! They make great fresh smoothies with boosts of your choice too! But what I LOVE about it here is that they are THE ONLY place that serves a brand of fro-yo called Carbo-lite!!! Its low carb, low calorie, fat free and high in protein! Tastes incredible, rich and smooth every time! Keep up the awesome work, selection and customer service guys! ALL DAY HERE! read more

My goodness GREAT yogurt. Generous toppings. GREAT value! Definitely go!! Worth the drive!

Jim and Tiffany are Amazing, they remember all their customers by Name and work their butts off. Their yogurt is my favorite I always make sure I have $5 cash on me to be able to make the stop when I want. They do not have the same selections as larger yogurt shops but it's worth it and their toppings are a perfect variety, my favorite is a chocolate/vanilla swirl with warmed up brownie. Make sure you have Cash on you before you go by as they do not take cards. Not interested in yogurt they have a great selection of smoothies too, #13 is Amazing. read more

I've been coming here since I was a child and now I take my children here, the smoothies and yogurt have always been delicious! The owners are wonderful as well! read more