I made an out of town order 1 week in advance, as my family was spending a week up in Avila and celebrating my husbands birthday! Arroyo Grande Bakery was so easy to converse with and make the order. They helped with recommendations on which filling would work the best with the cake I chose and have to say it was a seamless and amazing process from order, to pickup to eating! We wound up ordering a larger 13x11 rectangular marble with chocolate mouse + vanilla cream filling! It was absolutely delicious and they were able to screen print some photos on the cake which I sent in advance! Everyone was very pleased! Highly recommend - thank you! read more

Arroyo Grande Bakery - Custom cake (marble with chocolate mouse and vanilla crème filling) - Bakeries Near Me - Arroyo Grande, California

This is a family favorite! Always delicious and beautiful! Cakes, Pies, Cupcakes (that are amazing), Cookies, and breads. Something for everyone! I've been coming to this bakery for decades. It's a locals "go to bakery". The attention to detail and helpful staff makes ordering something special as easy as possible. Cute shop that never disappoints! They even have a wide variety of cookie jars and beautiful wall hanging art. There's also handmade decorations. Simply a wonderful shop. You won't be disappointed here. read more

Arroyo Grande Bakery - White cake with raspberry whip cream filling and white buttercream frosting. - Bakeries Near Me - Arroyo Grande, California

See all

Quick review. Great service, Funky and eclectic decor all along the walls. Very cool spot for christmas ornament shopping! We snagged some thumbprints and a raspberry cupcake. Both were decent ! Good little spot to hit up after a nice lunch. read more

See all

Ordered a custom cake for my friend's birthday and they were able to create exactly what I described! I tried to order online at first, but the website wasn't working and hard to navigate-I ended up calling and they were super helpful and asked for details during the design process. When it was time for pick-up the cake they had so many other yummy treats that we couldn't resist trying. The cake itself was so good and moist! read more

Arroyo Grande Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Arroyo Grande, California

Wonderful owners and crew at Arroyo Grande Bakery. Their cakes and pastries are the best around. I wish the owners a "well deserved" retirement and future! read more

Amazing bakery. Helpful for m hello in designing cake, offering samples of filling and oh my goodness the design . read more

Arroyo Grande Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Arroyo Grande, California

My family always stop here for chocolate cream pie and Danish, while on vacation been coming here since the 1970 and today I stopped and the sign read .After 70 years the owners retired they closed their doors. read more

We ordered a Disneyland themed cake for my sister in law's baby shower. We were met with such excitement from the baker and staff! The cake was so perfect and tasted amazing!! We got white cake, half raspberry filling, half lemon. The guests were blown away!! Thank you for helping us make the day special! read more

Arroyo Grande Bakery - Cake - Bakeries Near Me - Arroyo Grande, California

See all

Favorite local bakery! They always have the best attention to detail. I went with what they recommended for flavor and filling. I didn't even have to show them a picture, I just described my theme and they NAILED it. Can't wait for our next bday celebration! read more

Arroyo Grande Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Arroyo Grande, California

See all

We ordered a cake in the morning and it was ready in the afternoon. Aubrey was super helpful. She recommended fillings and frosting that not only looked amazing but tasted delicious Decorations on the cake were very detailed and beautiful. One of the best cakes we've ever had. We also ordered custom sugar cookies that were beautifully decorated. Their customer service was excellent. read more

Arroyo Grande Bakery - Cake - Bakeries Near Me - Arroyo Grande, California

Arroyo Grande bakery is my go to bakery. I love that we have a local bakery that can do pretty much anything and make it look amazing and taste great! The bakers have many years of experience and it shows! read more

Arroyo Grande Bakery - Unicorn cupcake cake - Bakeries Near Me - Arroyo Grande, California

See all

As a Central Valley native planning a central coast wedding, I searched for 'wedding cakes near me' and discovered Arroyo Grande Bakery. I'm so glad I did! They did an excellent job on my cake, exceeding my expectations with their decorative skills. I gave them some silk flowers and let them work their magic, resulting in a stunning masterpiece that made my wedding day even more special. Thank you for creating such an unforgettable part of my celebration! read more

Arroyo Grande Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Arroyo Grande, California

Amazing cakes, pies, cookies, breads and friendly staff keep us coming back. They use high quality ingredients and make their baked goods with a lot of heart. The presentation of the baked goods is pretty impressive as well. read more

See all

Birthday cake beautifully decorated and delicious too! Thank you Arroyo Grande Bakery! read more

Arroyo Grande Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Arroyo Grande, California

I order all our occasion cakes here and they've never disappointed. I ordered a chocolate Bavarian cream cake today and my family loved it. They were closed last week so I'm glad they're open this week. The owner is so sweet and talented. read more

See all

Needed a Yule Log for Christmas and really appreciate I was able to place my order last minute. The result was impressive and festive. It was $90.00. read more

Arroyo Grande Bakery - Yule Log - Bakeries Near Me - Arroyo Grande, California

See all

Literally amazing cake!! I order from them 2 times a year!! Fantastic service and the price is very reasonable ! Perfect little bakery ! It smells awesome inside ! read more

Here again to rave about AG Bakery They are so talented and never disappoint. Adorable & Delicious read more

Arroyo Grande Bakery - "First Rodeo" themed cookies - Bakeries Near Me - Arroyo Grande, California

See all

We were so pleased with our gender reveal cake!! It was beautifully decorated and tasted amazing! Thank you AG Bakery! read more

Arroyo Grande Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Arroyo Grande, California

Ag bakery really delivered as usual.... I needed a large sloth themed cake for my baby shower. I talked to Casey and it was coming to the last minute and she was very patient and accommodating with all the back and forth phone calls. I told her what I wanted and she told me what she was able to do with the size and my ideas. I had another well known bakery tell me they couldn't do what I wanted but Casey was able to do it. She did exactly what I wanted and it turned out so cute!!! Not only did it look amazing but it tasted great!!! The cake was very moist and the filling was delicious, and I'm not a big fan of cake, but I have to say I can't get enough of this one. Highly recommend ag bakery! What a great experience!! read more

Arroyo Grande Bakery - Sloth sheet cake - Bakeries Near Me - Arroyo Grande, California

Disappointing. Staff is awesome. Confections are beautiful. Prices a bit high, in my opinion, but I am a bit of a cheapskate. The chocolate icing tastes *just like* Pillsbury frosting from a can. On some items it has been whipped and is airy, soft, and pale. But I'd bet money it came pre-made. Not that it tasted bad! I use those frostings all the time. But for the price I expected a rich buttercream. The decorative, brightly colored bits of frosting were the typical shortening-and-sugar. The cake, itself, was a good texture. But tasted just like a box cake mix. "Custard" filling is a whipped cream and custard blend. It's basically stabilized whipped cream with a yellow tint. Again, not the richness I expected. I really wanted to like them. :( read more

Terrific customer service and delicious cakes! I called the in the morning and asked to place a cake order which they said would be ready later that day. Such a seamless process. It took about ten minutes to pay and order over the phone and the cake itself looked great when I picked it up. I ordered whipped cream frosting, fresh strawberry and Bavarian cream for the fillings with white cake. It was exquisite. Highly recommend going to this bakery! read more

I have never had a bad experience with this bakery! I have ordered several special occasion cakes here and they ALL have been delicious and beautiful!! I have even given them a theme and they have always gone above and beyond my expectations with their work!! This is an excellent bakery especially for cake orders and their prices are very reasonable when compared to others. read more

Based on Yelp reviews I chose them to do my sons wedding cake. My son and his fiancé tasted cupcakes before deciding on vanilla cake with raspberry and cream filling and chocolate cake with a chocolate mousse. The cake wasn't as moist as I expected and the filling was too sugary sweet. The customer service is excellent and the employees are friendly. The cake was pretty and arrived on time. read more

Amazing service as always! This is an essential place to get all of your baked goods! My family has been coming here for years! Staff is so friendly and helpful, and the quality is always top notch! They made my wedding cake and every layer was so delicious and moist! I got compliments from everyone ! the entire cake went! 4th layer marble cake with Oreo Bavarian Cream 3rd layer Chocolate Cake with Reese's Bavarian Cream 2nd layer spice cake with butter cream 1st layer Carrot Cake with Cream Cheese read more

Arroyo Grande Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Arroyo Grande, California

Came here because we were craving dessert and didn't know exactly what we wanted. Everything looked so delicious! We decided on 2 chocolate chip brownie cookies and two regular chocolate chip cookies. Got to the car and tried the chocolate chip cookie! Omg! It was so good. Thin, soft and chewy. Had the BF go back to the bakery to by 6 more cookies! I regret not getting more! Will definitely be back here when in town. The chocolate brownies were good too but loved the chocolate chip cookies. read more

Arroyo Grande Bakery - Chocolate chip cookies - Bakeries Near Me - Arroyo Grande, California

I think about their thumbprints often! But you Can't go wrong with anything from here! Give it a try!

Local trying it - 1 white bread 8.99$ not worth it. Service was great no justification in that price 2 other bakeries have the same bread half the price it's hard to support business like this . Up charge cookies and cakes but bread is a staple. read more

Best bakery around. Home made treats that are irresistible. Old favorites like their apple pie and danish.

Amazing bakery! The cakes are so fresh and delicious. I've ordered several times and they are very good and made my cake the same day I ordered. Staff is very helpful and willing to help and ensure you get the best. Thank you AG bakery. read more

I ordered 5 custom sugar cookies and paid $28, which I think is a good price considering the amount of effort that goes into each cookie. I called first and was told there was a same day turn around. When I arrived I was told they wouldn't be done till the end of the following day, which is fine I guess. The girls were relatively nice. My boyfriend picked up the cookies and honestly I was disappointed. The decorating appeared to be rushed and somewhat messy. There was black frosting smeared on some cookies. I understand this is an artform but at $5 a cookie I expected better. My family said the cookies tasted good though - I never tried them because I am gluten free & they said they do not have any gluten free options. read more

Arroyo Grande Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Arroyo Grande, California

They custom made a sheet cake 1/2 white cake with filling and 1/2 chocolate with filling , all iced to match. Everyone enjoyed trying the different flavors and Mom's 89th Birthday was a blast! read more

Arroyo Grande Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Arroyo Grande, California

Love AG Bakery! Cupcakes and cakes are soft, sweet and delicious. They custom make whatever you want. We have purchased several cakes from them over the years with 100% satisfaction. Most recently, the cupcakes we purchased we one of the best we've ever had! Staff are always friendly and professional. It's a gem in our neighborhood. read more

Arroyo Grande Bakery - Cupcakes were AMAZING to look at and even better to eat! - Bakeries Near Me - Arroyo Grande, California

AG Bakery created my wedding cake, and exceeded every expectation. It was the cake of my dreams and a huge hit at the wedding. I would not hesitate to recommend them for any occasion! read more

Arroyo Grande Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Arroyo Grande, California

AG Bakery is the best. Our family favorite is the coconut cake with coconut Bavarian cream. read more

Arroyo Grande Bakery - Coconut Cake with Bavarian Cream coconut filling... delightful! - Bakeries Near Me - Arroyo Grande, California

My son asked for a peach pie for his 10th birthday rather than a cake so we ordered one from Arroyo Grande Bakery. It was SO good!! Our group of 10 loved it and there were no leftovers! read more

In summary, if you want fresh, homemade, wholesome baked goods and don't mind paying extra or if this is an occasional treat, this bakery delivers. See below for details of review: I appreciate that all the items are baked from scratch and using real food ingredients. I just think that the items are overpriced because I bake myself from scratch and know better pricing. Think about Gina's piece of Cake in Santa Maria and make the items more expensive. They not only have cookies, cakes, tarts, pies and bread but also prepare cakes to order for special occasions. There is no seating in the locale so this is mostly a get and go place. The staff is polite, attentive and so is the owner. Check the discounted items rack for bread, cookies, cakes and pies on discounted prices. Quality of food is reasonable, just know that prices will be higher than average supermarket bakery. They do sale tea and coffee by the cup. We had a chocolate cupcake with chocolate frosting that was ok (but we do like darker chocolate at home) and some delicious Mexican Wedding cookies as well as a thumbprint cookie and a cup of tea. Might consider going back if seating was available. read more

See all

Very delicious! Was not able to keep cut pieces in tact. It fell apart and crumbled making it hard to serve but still everyone raved on the flavor. I ordered over the phone and emailed the photo & wording. What you see is the exact thing I emailed and was transferred to the fondant which covered the cream cheese frosting on top. The swirly colors on the border is non-edible curling ribbon which we removed. We had agreed upon black & silver but as you see it is multi color instead. I was ok with it, just saying if it matters to you, make sure you stress your colors. I wasn't told the price when I ordered. I was a bit surprised to see my card was charged $63 for this size cake. Undecided if would use them again. I live in Bakersfield and the occasion most likely won't present anyway. read more

Arroyo Grande Bakery - 1/4 sheet, carrot cake w/ cream cheese frosting & Bavarian cream filling. Fondant photo. - Bakeries Near Me - Arroyo Grande, California

I ordered a cake for my parents anniversary a few days in advance. The cake decorator took my order directly, so all the names were spelled correctly and she talked me through what tasted good/design. The cake was affordable and was under $25 for eight servings. The cake was delicious and my parents were really happy. I ordered an angel food cake with raspberry filling and whip cream frosting. It was beautifully decorated with red poinsettias. read more

Arroyo Grande Bakery - angel food cake with raspberry filling and whip cream frosting - Bakeries Near Me - Arroyo Grande, California

Just happened by spur of the moment! I was pleasantly surprised! The shop is immaculate! Tastefully decorated. A cookie jar collection to be envied! Options! Options! Options! Cookies, french horns, eclairs, cupcakes & custom-order cakes beautifully iced & trimmed with a master artist's precision! I noticed a number of smaller cakes, for two people. Cute toppers! Women love a little treasure like this as a surprise! *** HINT HINT GUYS*** We had a french horn that was so light & fluffy. Felt like I was floating. The chocolate eclair was excellent as well. I don't usually frequent bakeries but I just might make an exception for this one!!! I would absolutely LOVE to see some cannoli. I'd be in every week for those! read more

Arroyo Grande Bakery - French horn & a chocolate eclair YUM! - Bakeries Near Me - Arroyo Grande, California