Jim and Tiffany are Amazing, they remember all their customers by Name and work their butts off. Their yogurt is my favorite I always make sure I have $5 cash on me to be able to make the stop when I want. They do not have the same selections as larger yogurt shops but it's worth it and their toppings are a perfect variety, my favorite is a chocolate/vanilla swirl with warmed up brownie. Make sure you have Cash on you before you go by as they do not take cards. Not interested in yogurt they have a great selection of smoothies too, #13 is Amazing. read more

I've been coming here since I was a child and now I take my children here, the smoothies and yogurt have always been delicious! The owners are wonderful as well! read more

Owned and operated by a very nice family. The yogurt selection is pretty good, although it rotates so if you're looking for a particular flavor they may not have it every single time. The toppings aren't excessive, but they do have fresh fruit in the back that you have to ask for. I like to get fresh strawberries and brownie chunks on vanilla bean, cheesecake or berry yogurt. The smoothie I had from here was just okay. It tasted a littler powdery and not completely blended, although I did see them put fresh fruit in it. read more

It’s Really Yogurt - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Arroyo Grande, California

Peanut butter banana with protein #bomb I call in my orders probably 2 or 3 times a week sometimes twice a day, I'm always in a rush, I run in and leave money on the table grab my smoothing and go. Sure as many as I'm eating can't be super good for me but I'm pretty skinny And very healthy. Sometimes I'm very very very late but they freeze them, save them for me, the older couple is ALWAYS nice and smiles and treats everyone so well same goes for the young pretty blonde girl who works the later shifts. I come in and they know the drill, it's short but it's very nice that the wife and husband always give a compliment or ask how I'm doing. it's really great having a smoothie shop this close, that's THIS GOOD , THIS NICE , and SO CONSISTENT!!!!! thanks for being awesome guys! See you read more

Great yogurt and nice variety. I appreciated that the yogurt is prepared by the server. Much better infection control! The owners were very friendly and helpful. I will plan to back next time I visit! read more

I parked. I checked-in. I was stroked to try a non-chain froyo place. I about ran inside because I'm all about the FROYO. Plus, I'm not from the area so I trusted Yelp to steer me in the right direction. In hindsight, I should have done more research before schlepping myself here. Come to find out this place doesn't accept credit cards! I was so sad and walked out heavy hearted. The man behind the counter didn't even say, "Sorry." If I was from the area I'd have known to bring cash, but for an out-of-towner, it's the pits to be turned away. I was gladly going to give him my money. He obviously didn't need it! That's your choice to not accept credit cards, but what kind of service is this? He didn't even blink an eye. Guess he makes enough money as it stands. Who knows. All that excitement, all the build up, for nothing. I suggest you look around and find another place for FROYO. read more

The store excepts only cash and doesn't put that on the outside of the store they do not accept any card whatsoever very inconvenient. And a slight attitude. read more

I have been coming here since I was a kid, same workers, same amazing smoothies. I will forever love this place. Ag Eagle smoothie and a peanut butter ice cream with chocolate sprinkles are the best!! read more

I am a little flabbergasted reading the reviews for this place because the feedback indicates a totally different picture than my experience here. The good: The yogurt was very heavy and portion size was great - I didn't finish my medium cup because it was so much! Owners seem nice and service is good. The bad: The yogurt isn't really that good...it's ok. The toppings are extremely lacking if you're looking for fresh fruit or mochi. Mochi is packaged and the fruit is not fresh...it's sauce. Oh cash only... read more

Guys, this business is the best of the best. They are the sweetest people, and I've been going to them ever since I was a baby. They call my family by name every time we go in and I always feel so welcomed. Honestly, I'm scared this company is going to suffer due to the coronavirus. Even though this company has top quality froyo and smoothies, if no one can get there because of the isolation, they may not be able to keep their business alive. I hope everyone can be able to buy their products as much as they can before we can't go there anymore. They deserve it :) 11/10 would recommend read more

Great place with an amazing caring staff! I wish I still worked down the street, I'd be back every week!

Best smoothies ever! Whenever my dad is in town he makes me take him there They always remember my name and order, are incredibly kind and make delicious smoothies!!! Ingredients are super fresh! Clean and comfortable environment What else could you want? THESE ARE HANDS DOWN THE BEST SMOOTHIES IN CALIFORNIA read more

Been coming here since high school, so has my husband. The place is always clean and the service is always prompt and friendly. Product is exactly as described and consistent. I come here for the smoothies their menu is all bangers and I love their supps for a quick on the go meal replacement that isn't going to kill me with guilt read more

SO GOOD. Every flavor is delicious and the texture is like a cloud. The staff is super friendly and overall just a really positive atmosphere. Make sure you bring cash because it's cash only! :) read more

It really is yogurt, such good flavors! I recommend the shake sensation. This company deserves your business after hurting during covid!

Best yogurt store around. Local folks, great flavors and toppings. Tasty smoothies and wheat grass for a nutrition boost.

I love this little space for smoothies. They've apparently been around a LONG time and my partner actually used to come here back when he was in high school (10 years ago). I'm lactose intolerant and forgot my meds so I had to get dairy-free yogurt which costs extra. He wouldn't charge me for the dairy-free even after I insisted The prices are so fair, especially when you consider major chains that charge higher for the standard drink and then more for the smallest doses of "extras" (eg boosts and supps). The smoothies are also just dang good. Support local stores!! read more

This is a wonderful local frozen yogurt place that has been great for a long time! We stopped by for dessert tonight and we were greeted with a smile, great service, and even better frozen yogurt. We got two smalls, each with a mix in, and the total was $8 or so. We definitely are going to be frequenting this place as we have moved back to the area! read more

BEST SMOOTHIES EVER!!! You must try for yourself. Way BETTER than Jamba Juice. Doesn't even compare. And the price is much cheaper. Please support this shop. The owners are so nice and sweet!!! read more

The very best! The owners are so amazing and are there virtually all the time. They know our orders when we walk in the door! Smoothies are all great and made fresh. The yogurt, we think, is really the best tasting around. (We go for the warmed brownie in our froyo!) Consistently good- and not a chain!! Support local businesses!! read more

Best smoothie place in town! We love the owners! They're always so nice and every smoothie on the menu is so delicious!

Jim and Tiffany are the sweetest people you will ever meet! All of the staff at IRY are the best. The smoothies are amazing and the yogurt always hits the spot. I've been coming here for years and hope to continue for years to come! read more

Delicious and affordable smoothies (way better and cheaper than Jamba Juice)! The owners are the sweetest and they have so many great drinks to choose from. My favorite and their best seller is the AG Eagle. We've also had the Super Strawberry and California Cruisin but you really can't go wrong. If you're into wheatgrass shots, it's only $1.75! Maybe I've been in the big city too long (SF) but that is an amazing price for fresh wheatgrass. A must when you're in the area! :) YUM read more

Superstrawberry & Hawaiian Holiday + Ginseng Root!!! Super fast and decent prices love this place! Support local businesses!!!! read more

It’s Really Yogurt - Yeeee boi - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Arroyo Grande, California

I love the smoothies. Everyone is so nice and friendly. The hours are great. Just nice to do business with.

visited the area as tourist, and now I wish there's one near! Great yogurt and very friendly service! Thank you! I am sure we'll be back next time when we visit! read more

Super delicious smoothies and fro-yo. Great quality and selections for both. Would definitely recommend for any occasion

Every time hubby and I are in Grover Beach, one of our must do's is a visit to the world's finest fro-yo shop aka It's Really Yogurt. Today was one of those much anticipated visits and it did not disappoint. The shop is clean and tidy and the owners and staff always have a smile for all who enter. But, let's be honest, the main attraction is their delectable frozen yogurt! It is absolutely silky smooth and comes in many wonderful flavors. Today hubby had Vanilla swirled with Sea Salted Caramel with Oreo crumbles and I had Chocolate Milk Shake flavor with Oreo cookie crumbles. It was pure heaven! If you're ever in the area, do yourself a favor and visit It's Really Yogurt, then post your own yelp review! read more

Favorite smoothy in town! AG eagle no banana! it is the best! I get it every time and now have got my sister hooked as well. The owners are nice and often working when I go in. This is a fun little stop. Not great seating if your planning to stay there. I suggest taking it to go. but Cash only, Be prepared, and nothing bigger then a 20. read more

Pretty delicious yogurt. I dont like that they dont accept cards and have no atm hence 4/5 stars. Its easy to get card payment drvices nowadays snd would rather payba 59 cent fee or something. I had to go to 7-11 buy a 1.19 candy bar and then have cash back. Very inconvenient when I didn't want a candy bar but it was the cheapest thing. read more

It’s Really Yogurt - Medium!! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Arroyo Grande, California

See all

Probably the tastiest yogurt on the central coast. Rarely do I get flavors like Egg Nog, but I did here because the flavor was so rich and actually tasted like the flavor named. The pumpkin too was rich, flavorful and smooth. Toppings were fresh and plentiful too. The woman behind the counter was super warm and welcoming upon entering and offered samples of anything I'd like. Her charm was a huge plus! Great yogurt and I'll be back soon for more! read more

My husband tried the yogurt yesterday. We got the pistachio and very berry. Both flavors were very good!! My husband loves the pistachio and I love the very berry. The owner is very sweet! We did not have any cash with us and she waited patiently for us to get our money and pay. Will definitely come back soon! read more

Amazing smoothies and the owners are very sweet! Just wish they were open on Sundays too

Best frozen yogurt and smoothies in AG. The owners are super friendly too! Our favorites to order are the AG eagle ;banana splitz; the Cody and their choc/vanilla swirl fro yo. I always get the kids size in yogurt since the portions are generous. They have a much better price point than other smoothies places. The only downfall is its cash only but I always make sure I have some cash in my wallet in case I'm out and am craving a smoothie! read more

Best yogurt spot In 5 cites!!! The staff is amazing and the smoothies are sooooooo tasty stop by all the time and you should too!

Best flavor yogurt in town and the sweetest family they only take cash & check tho, I wish they took credit cards so badly!! So many days I drive by and want to go in but don't have cash. Pleaseeeee get a square reader!!! read more

Best smoothies and frozen yogurt in the five cities!! The yellow cake batter yogurt is to die for, and the AG Eagle smoothie is my favorite; but I sometimes get their 50/50 creamsicle smoothie, it's delicious! Also, the service is quick and very friendly and it's all great pricing! read more

Stop by the atm and get some yogurt or a smoothie from here! You won't need all the topping options other places have to offer because this place has the BEST tasting yogurt, nothing else compares! It's also the best value, you get a large serving for the price. But what I like most about this place are the owners, they know all their regular customers by name and are always so sweet to children. read more

Haven't been to this place in years and it's still as great as I remember! Perfect hot day for a nice cold smoothie and the owners are so sweet. Definitely worth crossing the five cities for read more

Cute little yogurt place. Staff is very welcoming and friendly. They have a great selection of smoothies and really delicious yogurts with a nice variety of toppings. Only downfall is it is CASH ONLY :( I never carry cash so today being my first time and not knowing, I had to go to 7/11 few stores down to get cash back which had a max limit of $10 so it limited my options of what to get. Today was my first experience and based on that $10 limit I did not get to taste some other yummy selections that I would've wanted to but I hope to next time. read more