You have to try their key lime ice cream sandwiches! Their key lime cookies are already amazing but what dessert isn't better with ice cream?! Somehow better than the pie! Workers are super nice too. Just wish they were closer to Tampa so I could go more! read more

This "famous key lime pie" is 4/10. Key lime flavor is weak, pie is too thin, the FAKE whipped cream is waaaayy too much - enough to cover the pie in a thick layer. It tastes Industrial, like convention food which explains the nasty whipped cream. Also, the pie filling itself is too stiff; it should just barely hold a shape, but this one is gelatinous like jello so they add too much gelatin/pectin. I saw them making cookies, but not sure the pies are made there anymore. This looks, feels and tastes like like convention buffet food. I'm guessing they use a co-packer facility which delivers the border-line frozen pies 1-2 a week. The orange cookies were great, but not going back since the pies leave MUCH to be desired. read more

JJ Gandy's pies is closed permanently for retirement after 43 years of serving amazing pies and baked goods. read more

J J Gandy's Pies - Sign showing they are permanently closed for retirement... - Bakeries Near Me - Palm Harbor, Florida

See all

Yum the best pies and so glad they reopened! Always send out of town friends there for pies to take home.

T he owners are very nice and it was bustling. We found the key lime pie too sweet and not enough burst of lime. Oatmeal cookie was too sweet too with a hard frosting sandwiched in between read more

J J Gandy's Pies - Bakeries Near Me - Palm Harbor, Florida

Wonderful bakery. Everything they make is out of this world delicous. Friendly staff. When you walk in the door, the smell of the baked goods is so yummy. read more

The pie's and cookies here are delicious I'm gonna miss this place like real homemade pie's. You can't find places like this anymore not just a big commercial bakery like the mystery bake good's at Publix or Winn-Dixie. Just old fashion bake goods. So where will Country boy restaurant get there pie's from now ???? read more

You're probably coming here for the key lime pie! You won't be disappointed! Lot of other options besides that too. Friendly people! read more

See all

The key lime cookies are out of this world, and it's worth going there even for just those alone omg

So sorry to announce: JJ GANDY's has closed!!! Note on door said the family business was retiring and thank all of us for our support!!! How could we not support the best pies ever!!! read more

THE best key lime pies in the area. Need to stop by during business hours (not open later) but so worth it. They have so much more in pies, cookies and desserts...but we can't stray for the Key Lime. So good I hand flew one all the way up to Louisville for a sweet birthday surprise for family! read more

Inside the green warehouse style building on the southbound side of Alt-19 is a little spot of heaven! The best key lime pie outside of key west! They have other flavors as well, as well as cookies and cakes. Not a huge selection of flavors, but, definitely quality over quantity! Now, I've lived in this area for 26 years and it is hard to beat Publix Bakery, but, for Key Lime pie, this place is so worth the drive! read more

So disappointed closed not mentioned on website. Our go to place for thanksgiving Not sure what's going on read more

J J Gandy's Pies - Taken 11/23/24 - Bakeries Near Me - Palm Harbor, Florida

We came here trying to get some pies for Pie Day, only to find out that they were closed as 3/14/22 happened to be a Monday. What pie shop closed on Pie Day???? So yeah, don't go on Mondays, but otherwise this is a great place to get some pies, especially their famous key lime pie. They also have a gluten free version that actually tastes pretty good, not at all an inferior substitute to the original as they often are. read more

See all

We bought the key Lime Pie and oh my it was DELICIOUS! Silky texture. Just right amount of Tangy & Sweet. It was also beautiful.

As a Pinellas County native, I'm surprised I never heard of this place until now. Their key lime pie lives up to the hype, with a perfect blend of sweet, tart, and oh-so-creamy! Probably the best I have ever had. Just 4 stars for now, as I have only had the pleasure to visit once. I'm looking forward to trying their other pies. read more

J J Gandy's Pies - They print "famous" on the box and their key lime pie definitely deserves it! - Bakeries Near Me - Palm Harbor, Florida

Insane that this gem is in my town! Order anything and you'll be thrilled. Order the key lime pie, pumpkin chiffon or coconut cream and you'll have gone to heaven. Order EARLY for holidays as even the best pie shop around needs a vacation every now and then. Love my town, local LQ read more

It's literally the best key lime pie I've ever had. I don't have a photo because by the time I think to take a pic, I've already eaten all of it read more

So delicious! We order a coconut crème pie for a coworker. They decorated it so beautifully and it was amazing! read more

Local place just found out between Palm Harbor and Tarpon Spring. Pie pie, all pie, sweet desert. The place is clean. Cake is good and super good price. We order coconut cream horn and 2 others, it's $2,75 each. Little cons: little too sweet for me. But rather than that it's all good. I'll be back here for sure. read more

See all

Stopped in for a Key Line pie. It was great and we will be back. Good folks and had an opportunity to talk with them. Very friendly.

Their key lime pie is the BEST but they also have other delicious items! They have gluten free key lime pies too!

Place to go for pies! Order early for the Holidays and expect a long line of cars for pickup - well worth the wait. Much easier at other times. read more

I have always heard wonderful things about this place so I came in for a pumpkin pie. The staff was very friendly and the price was on point but the pie was just ok. Will give it another try some other time. read more

Gandys is where the locals get their holiday pies. I first tried it when I moved here 22 years ago. Very, very good! Its a warehouse, not a restaurant. read more

The day of my visit to J J Gandy's there was a Pie Festival close to home. We didn't make it so the thought of pie was flashing in front of me calling my name. Well lucky for me, we were in the area of this place. I quickly forgot about the festival which probably was hot outside, long lines, pricey and not as good! J J Gandy's has been around for at least 30 years and they have pies, sweets, and breads galore. They are local too and if u have local key lime pies, you may be tasting it from here. We tried two pies: coconut cream pie and Oreo key lime. There are a lot of key lime options. Oh my sinful, but oh so memorable! Yes check them out! I feel like they r a bit off the beaten path, but so worth it! read more

See all

This place is incredible! This is the best key lime pie I have ever had! Perfect graham cracker crust, perfectly tart, and the homemade whipped cream is so creamy and delicious it balances out the tartness. We also had a three berry berry pie with cherry, raspberry, and blueberry and it was fantastic! Again the crust is perfection. Go get yourselves some pie from this fantastic place! read more

Best pies ever! I stop to get a cherry pie every time I am in the area. Perfect to take to family gatherings for the holidays.

Stopped by because my better half loves key lime pie that isn't too tart or too sweet. This one was the perfect balance of tart and creamy. Then you have a buttery crust! This Key Lime pie is amazing. I also bought some frozen slices draped in chocolate pops. Can't wait to attack them tomorrow. read more

Wow! Coconut Cream, pecan, of course famous key lime! Beautiful and tasty- a landmark in the region supplying many local restaurants and local markets. Fresh ingredients combined to create the classic deserts. If you have not tried them yet, worth the drive! read more

At long last I got my hands on one of JJ Gandy's famous key lime pies. For $6 I got a six-inch, pale yellow pie with a heap of whipped cream piled around the edges and plopped in the middle. I dug my fork into the edge of the pie, anticipating the feel of sweet and sour citrus cream against a thick, crisp wall of crust. It wasn't quite like that. What actually happened was an overwhelming poof of whipped cream and a flimsy crust that wrapped around a luscious limey filling. I tried a second bite without the whipped cream. Much better. The crust in the middle of the pie was crisper, but still thinner than I prefer. The cream was rich. In my life of pie I've noticed two schools of flavor for pies like cheesecake and key lime. There's rich, sweet cream filling and there's the kind with -- for lack of a better description -- a slight sourdough aftertaste. This pie falls into the second category, making it miss the mark of my kind of pie. I can't say I'd buy it again but, in all, it tasted decent enough for me to want to return to try Gandy's other sweet treats. read more

J J Gandy's Pies - 6" key lime pie for $6 - Bakeries Near Me - Palm Harbor, Florida

We have been ordering pies from JJ Gandy's for 3 decades! I don't have a favorite because they have quite a variety & all are delicious!

Although they are known for their pies (hello Key Lime, Pumpkin and Apple!) I am in love with their Key Lime Cookies. OMG! A delicious soft sugar cookie with key lime icing that is to die for. I've tried many treats and never been disappointed. They even carry a local fish spread that is quite scrumptious. read more

We stopped for a Key lime pie based on a recommendation of a local business who said they were the best around. The pies came in three sizes, kind of a personal pie that two people can eat (ha! As if) one for 4-6 people and the other pie which had eight servings. We ordered the medium sized pie, knowing that only one person would be eating that pie. My husband is kind of an expert when it comes to key lime pie and he rated this pie at 9.5 out of 10. Personally, I would give it a 10. A traditional graham cracker crust, relatively thin and not hard, a rich lime filling and a cream topping. It was delicious!! And because we were leaving Florida, it traveled to our home in a cooler where it was enjoyed again. We also bought a dozen key lime cookies - a shortbread cookie with lime frosting. Truly decadent. Delicious! read more

J J Gandy's Pies - Bakeries Near Me - Palm Harbor, Florida

See all

Tried this bakery for a dinner party. Picked up key lime and berry pies. Both were delicious. I noticed they also had key lime cookies. Wish I had tried them. read more

Best key lime pies I've ever had. We had JJ Gandy's pie for our wedding "cake" Love it here! read more

Hands down, the best key lime pie I've ever had. I request a J.J. Gandy's pie for pretty much every special occasion...they are just that good. The creamy texture of the filling is something I just can't create on my own. In addition, their key lime cookies and their key lime cake are almost as good as the pie! This year for my birthday, I had the pleasure of having a key lime cake. It was beautifully decorated, the cake was fluffy, and there was a healthy amount of key lime pie filling inside! Seriously, go order a key lime pie from J.J. Gandy's. Now. read more

See all

Very very nice and friendly ladies. I sooooooo wanted to love the pie we got a banana cream pie. Unfortunately, I didn't like it at all, no taste and very little banana. Tasted more like a banana pudding and I bought more bananas but it didn't help. read more

Hands down this place has the best key lime pie anywhere. What most people don't know is they also bake incredible custom cakes. The prices for the cakes are about what you would pay at your local grocery store. For my birthday, my wife had a pirate cake made with key lime filling and a mini key lime pie on top. My daughter went in to order her sweet sixteen cake. It was like an episode of cake boss. She wanted triangles suspended in mid-air. They were so patient trying to accommodate her while applying the laws of physics. These cakes came out great. see posted pics I went in the Sunday before Thanksgiving to order a custom cake they had to bake 3000 pies that week but they still accommodated me and baked me an awesome cake for my wife's birthday. These people are wonderful. If you are anywhere near Palm Harbor, FL, you need to visit them. read more

See all

As visitors from MN and lovers of key lime pie, we made our recent 5 day trip to FL a quest to try as many key lime pies as we could to find the best one. We tried 6 that came recommended from FB and the interwebs, and J. J. Gandy's came out the clear winner! Nice texture with the perfect tartness without being sour or bitter. I also loved that the pies come in different sizes. Since we only had 4 people, we didn't need a regular full-size pie, so the medium was prefect for us. The location itself is very unassuming. Reasonable prices. Can't wait to go back! read more