Stopped in to pick up a pizza from our favorite pizza place! Always greeted with a smile and a nice full restaurant. Our favorite pie is mushroom and meatball well done, and it was perfect! We'll be back! read more

9-4-24 Great little neighborhood pizza joint. Plenty of specialty slices available and quite a few tables to sit and enjoy your meal. The restaurant is very clean and well kept. Service was fantastic. The gentleman behind the counter had to be an owner. He was extremely passionate about pizza and offered some suggestions on what to try as well as a detailed explanation on a bunch of different items on display. Prices were reasonable as well. I love places like this. I tried a chicken caprese slice, chicken marsala slice, a regular and a Sicilian. They were all fantastic. Although it was my first time here, there's no doubt that I'll return. read more

See all

Walked in before heading to work and was greeted with a smile by a female at the front counter. Maybe Josephine? Lots of guys working to fulfill orders. Nice display case of drinks from bottled to canned sodas, Stewart's glass bottles, Snapples-galore and 2 liters fit for any family or party! My slice more than pleasantly surprised me! The dough was not too chewy, but fluffy. The bottom wasn't burnt, and had such a delicious crunch. Sauce was great and I will definitely be back next time I'm working in the area. The dining area is nice and clean, plenty of seating. Included pics of their whole menu! And the bite that I took that had me SOLD! read more

See all

Employees are very friendly and the pizza was excellent. Our pie was brought to our table and the slices served to us, which was nice. Very clean place with a bathroom. Tables well spaced. read more

Jack's Pizzeria - regular slice - Pizza Near Me - Island Park, New York

See all

The best pizza on Long Island! The best! Large slices, grease dripping, melted cheese and thin crust. Fantastic. It was nice and hot too. I'm a sucker for a pizza lunch with a soda. Jack's was a recommendation from a dear friend. She has never steered me wrong when it comes to food. She delivered here! When we walked in we placed our orders and sat down. The staff was amazing. Great conversation, smiles and hardworking. They seem to do a good amount of take out as well as eat in. The interior was so clean as well, parking in a side lot too. read more

See all

More like 3.5 stars. Solid, standard pizza place. I had a large Caesar salad (chopped) with grilled chicken. I asked for dressing mixed in. Dressing was not mixed in. Sigh. Calamari was good. I tried the chicken parm too and it was fine. read more

Jack's Pizzeria - Fried calamari - Pizza Near Me - Island Park, New York

See all

I have been a fan of pizza since I would sneak out of our projects, walk to Avenue L, and buy two 15 cent slices!! Jack's reminds me of that. Real old school pizza that's obviously been made from the best ingredients, by a master. read more

Food was the best I've had in my area, LB / Island park / Oceanside .. in awhile ! Chicken francese /nice portion & cooked perfecto . Angel hair perfect too! Shrimp parm hero , generous & great taste . Delivery right on schedule . Thank you read more

Had time to kill and was hungry for lunch and thought pizza would be good to try. Glad to see they sold warmed slices and not just whole pies. I got a traditional pepperoni slice, a piece of grandmas with just cheese and a Dr Pepper. Total came to 11 bucks. The pepperoni was the stand out, crispy crust, good blend of cheese, pepperoni tasted good too. Pleasant staff who were friendly and a lot of regular walk ins who made it feel like a good vibe all the way around. I'd love to have tried a whole pie with a combo as I'm sure it would be good read more

Happy Easter ! The BEST pizza and Italian food at this beautiful place! Fresh, large portions, excellent service! Happy Easter! I LOVE Nate & Josephine and the TEAM, they treat their customers with high respect, appreciation, best service. Just stop by and you'll get that good vibe, feeling part of their FAMILY. DELICIOUS Italian meals @ Jacks Pizza! Joanna Karanikolas read more

Great neighborhood pizzeria. Great tasting pizza and food options and also enjoy their chocolate cookies!

It's been years. Nearly 50 since O had a slice of pie here so expectations were high and driven by memories from my childhood. Still located in the same place though it's footprint has doubled over the last few decades, this is still the place where memories are made. Good, hot pies with dripping cheese and sauce. The flop dead on and the spices just right. Not much in the way of decor but that's not what you are here for is it? Grab a pie or a slice, the variety is much wider these days and inhale the smells and tastes of summer in an Italian beach town. read more

See all

Jack's pizza is an amazing place. The pizza they create is outstanding. The owner has created a wonderful menu and has trained people properly on how to cook and serve the food. read more

Was in the area for work. Pre-ordered a pie and garlic knots so it would be ready when we got there. It was ready within minutes of our arrival. At the time, I wasn't very hungry. I didn't get to try the pizza or garlic knots. Within 10 minutes, hunger strikes. I decided on a sausage and pepper hero. I went to the counter and placed my order. I was asked if I wanted garlic and oil or marinara. Garlic and oil of course. I told the lady at the counter that I was sitting with the big group and pointed to our table. I waited...and waited. Over 25 minutes went by. I went up to the counter to inquire about my food. It was in the bag and ready. The same lady at the counter said, "I was looking for you! I didn't know where you went..." I'm not sure how long it was sitting there..but I didn't go anywhere... The hero was tasty. Generous amount of sausage, and nicely cooked peppers and onions. It just wasn't that hot, as it had been sitting on the counter for an unknown amount of time. read more

I ate takeout from Jack's a few times with my ex-boyfriend's mom and his uncle. He wasn't around for those times. I love their pizza. I guess it's like most pizzas on long island but I have no complaints about it and it's very tasty. Nice balance of dough, sauce and cheese which some pizza places mess up with. I'd eat Jack's again if I was around the area. read more

Horrible, in my opinion the food was bad, the pizza was soggy because of the grease and liquids coming out of it. I'm not sure what my overall is, The service was good I guess, but in my opinion it is bad. Very good pricing though 2/5 keep working hard workers! read more

Living in NY sets a high standard for pizza, I get that, but do yourself a favor and do not order a Sicilian pie or slice. The sauce isn't good and the slice is HUGE. I know Sicilian slices are supposed to be thicker, but good lord did I order a sheet cake? The slice is so thick that it can't even fit in their to go boxes or your mouth. Attached you'll see my first red flag for this place: ruined cheese. I can't speak for their other food, but if they can't make a good Sicilian than I don't want it. read more

Jack's Pizzeria - a pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Island Park, New York

Nothing Special - I was passing through the neighborhood and happened to pop inside; - I ordered a regular slice and a Sicilian slice. The Sicilian tasted very "Cake Like" - Regular slice was fair @ the very least. I suspect that this place is very popular with the Island Park locals - Otherwise, I think "Pizza Options" are limited in this "One Horse Town". - Plenty of better options across "The Channel" in Long Beach - But, than again - I'm more sure if their is sufficient "Potable Water" in that town. What was up with the stolen cocktail salt shakers that were floating around this place? Overall - didn't enjoy my visit. Would not make the trip! read more

Jack's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Island Park, New York

See all

I needed to have pizza delivered to an area park for a group outing. I called Jack's and placed my order the day before. My pizzas were delivered on time, piping hot and delicious. The pizza was just awesome! It was cheesy and the sauce was just the perfect blend of sweetness. I'll definitely be ordering from them again! read more

I love that they have cauliflower crust (gluten free), my favorite is the Cesar salad. The owner and staff are amazing!

Friendly neighborhood pizzeria with authentic Italian owners The food is always good and the staff is always friendly. They're quick, they're open pretty late and they don't mind delivering. They have plenty of tables and it's always clean. read more

Worst Sicilian on the planet! Served cold and taste like water! Straight doo doo! I had to throw it out! read more

The best Chicken Marsala pizza on Long Island. I've tried other places & no one can compare. read more

Jack's Pizzeria - The best Chicken Marsala pizza on Long Island! - Pizza Near Me - Island Park, New York

Covid time review- We went to Jacks last week after a walk at the beach and lucky enough to pick up the last pie and it was 6pm. It's only open for pick up right now, they bring the pizza outside. The pizza tasted great and the place looked clean from the window. Do go, grab a slice and support local business. We got plain cheese and couple slices of pepperoni. read more

Jacks has become my regular go to pizza spot, the reason they get five stars is because the pizza is great, food is fresh and most importantly the staff and owners make you feel welcome and take care of the community that they service. Great place to grab a slice or meal with family or friends. read more

See all

Very friendly service. Highly recommend for families. As a family of five we are always looking for good food at reasonable prices. Jack's has family deals, so we had a meal for 5, including soda, garlic knots, salad and a pizza, for under $25! The salad dressing was tasty, the garlic knots delicious, and the pizza very good but a little greasy. Looked like a varied menu. read more

See all

Their pizza is usually consistently good. Not always "crispy" as ordered but still good. Other pasta dishes were not very good. Will just stick with the pizza. read more

I live in Lynbrook but will travel for Great Pizza.... Great Food and exceptional Service. Every time I have called the employees are so polite... other businesses could learn from these guys. Highly Recommend the Rice Ball Parmigiana but then again I recommend all the food and definitely Jacks Pizza. read more

After a long day of running around and get soaked in the rain, my boyfriend and I decided that we deserved pizza. It's been a while since we've stopped by at Jack's. Maybe even over 6mths! Initially, being that we were hungry and wanted to see what slices they had available, we didn't notice they had a renovation until we were inside. They've expanded their seating area. There are more tables and chairs available for dine in now. It used to be a tiny space with about 4 tables and booth seats, now it's an open area with plenty of space to enjoy your dine in experience. My boyfriend and I ordered 3 specialty slices and some plain cheese slices. I had the chicken marsala and the mac and cheese slice. I was iffy about the mac and cheese thinking pasta on top of pizza might be too much. I was convinced when the staff said there are 5 types of cheese in the mac and cheese slice, I was sold! My boyfriend had the bbq chicken and 2 plain cheese slices. When we got home and opened the box, I saw 3 plain slices. Hmm.. an extra slice? I'm not complaining I went for the mac and cheese slice first thing! Took a bite and was blown away. It reminded me to the city's artichoke pizza slice, but not as creamy, just more cheesy! Thanks to the guy that recommended it! Chicken marsala is a pretty hefty pizza, but it was packed full of chicken and mushrooms. I tried a bite of my boyfriend's bbq chicken and that was good too! The plain is your classic cheese pizza, just enough pizza sauce and cheese. I would definitely comeback for more of their specialty slices! Only on my cheat days.. read more

Jack's Pizzeria - (Left) chicken marsala, mac and cheese, bbq chicken and 3 plain slices - Pizza Near Me - Island Park, New York

Simply put, the best pizza in town! The sauce is not acidic, the pies are big, the ingredients are fresh (no plastic fake mozzarella cheese!) and the service is great. Nothing more to say. read more

For our typical Friday night pizza take-out, we made the switch from East End to Jack's about a year ago and haven't looked back. Nothing against East End, they're perfectly fine pizza parlor; Jack's is a notch above because of their specials. The "Family Special # 1" is a great deal: regular pie, chicken roll, dozen garlic knots & 2-liter Coke for $21.95! Specials are meant to incentivize you to choose said business and this special does just that. Obviously all this would be moot if Jack's didn't serve up delicious food and have great customer service, which they do both in spades. You can tell they take pride in being a trusted establishment in Island Park and that's reflected in any/all the interactions I've had with them. read more

Unbelievable grandma pizza with burrata cheese. Excellent baby arugula and prosciutto salad with goat cheese and shaved Parmiasan cheese. ( ask for oil and vinegar on the side..,their dressing on the side had too much vinegar). Good service and fairly priced. read more

A pizzeria with a plethora of options. Multiple types of pizza, roles, calzones and they are delicious. The chicken bacon ranch slice seemed weird at first, but it was really good. The regular slice, the grandma slice and the white slice were all wonderful. They even had some stuffed artichokes, which I almost never see anymore and it was very good. My only gripe was that things weren't heated up enough even though we waited awhile, but the food is good enough that I won't focus on that. read more

this place was ok but just got new owners and omg what an improvement. Must have got a new cook cause the food from the kitchen is way better. the sauce is a million times better, the meatballs are huge and super tasty. As for the pizza, it's all great. My fav is the grandma. Also really good specialty slices (get the chicken bacon ranch) Plus they are always adding new items, I walked in the other day and boom- zeppoles!!! Soooo good. This place is way better then that other pizza spot across the street. Great food and friendly staff. read more

Jack's Pizzeria - chicken bacon ranch slice (close) chicken Marsala slice (far) - Pizza Near Me - Island Park, New York

Doesn't look like much when you walk past it, but truly a hidden gem. Parking lot with street parking as well! My friends and I came from pretty far and had spent the day at Robert Moses beach, we were starving. The original spot we went to was closed, we ended up driving over here because it was near and the reviews were excellent. Thank god we did! You walk into a warm welcoming and cozy feeling. Prices are fair and staff does well with recommendations. FOOD IS GREAT wish I took some pictures of the pasta/ziti/burgers/and pizza. We all got something different and tried each other's food, wasn't disappointed by a single tasting. Where they truly shine is the EXCELLENT SERVICE. It's unmatched. We went on a Friday night, two gentleman by the name of jack and another by chad (I believe those were the names) were the ones who greeted and took our order, placed us on a nice table that would fit our group. Chad (I think) was behind the counter taking orders and seemed busy but still made sure to keep passing by us to see how we were doing. They checked on us quite often to see if we were satisfied and needed anything else. Very well spoken, and kind gentleman. These guys treat you like family and it makes you wanna go back all the time, they even spoke to us for a few mins after our group dinner! Thank you Jacks for the hospitality, and providing an excellent dinner experience for my friends and I. read more

They have a new pizza. It is thick crust with "Luciano" sauce on top. It is SO good!!! It has chicken and cheese and spinach and other ingredients. Delicious!!! The staff is a friendly bunch! They smile and generally seem happy to be there. The son who is usually at the counter is cheerful and will banter with you. They make a great plain slice. My favorites are the Chicken Caprese slice and hamburger slice. Place is very clean and parking is easy. read more

Ordered a regular pie with extra cheese well done, was delivered hot and sloppy and well done! Was very pleased... delicious read more

Ordered a pie with meatballs Requested they make pie bottom crispy without making pie well done They did a great job delivering on that request Received a delicious pie that tasted great Highly recommend trying their pizza read more

This place is fantastic. The pizza is always fresh and tastes very good. The staff that works there are very nice. One of the top pizza places to go in the area. read more

Hit or miss. Quality has gone down over the past 2 years as the owner is usually not cooking anymore. Chicken cutlets seem to be precooked and are thin and dry lately read more