This is my favorite pizza in Batavia. After living here for a few years, this was my go-to spot. We…read morewere back in town for the day hanging out and decided we needed to get some pizza before we went home. We ended up getting a few things which were all delicious. We got a large cheese and pep pizza, some wings, fried mozzarella, and some fried dough bites for dessert. The pizza here has been great and the service is always pretty quick. They have two sides of the restaurant with takeout on one, and dining on the other. The dining room is gorgeous and has such a great vibe to it. It feels upscale, yet cozy. If you're in Batavia and need a pizza, Main Street is the place to go.

They have daily deals and this was half a sheet plus wings. The wings were all good but our…read morefavorite was the bourbon and berry hot. The other flavors we got was also good. The pizza dough was my favorite since it is soft and fluffy. Flavor wise really nice and portion are huge. Service was great and definitely would come back!

First time here and Buffalo in general. Saw boxes of their pizza in our place of work that's why we…read morecame here. If locals order from thsi place and see them enjoy the food, we thought it might be good. Plenty of parking and on a Wednesday, very busy compared to other restaurants we have seen in the area. The server was bubbly and kept on checking on us. I enjoyed the pizza

The pizza here is like Chicago deep dish pizza without the pan: the risen dough is 3/4" high and…read morefilled like a pool with delicious sauce, cheese and toppings. It's an affordable feast! The service was also friendly and efficient. The place has been expanded with additions over the years from the original building. The high walls in one room are covered with old photos of the restaurant and surrounding Batavia area. You can feel the history here.

We were driving through Warsaw tonight around 8:30 hadn't ate yet ordered a pizza and wings to go…read more they told me 35 minutes took us 40 to get there the pizza was done but had to wait another 15 minutes for the wings. I was disappointed with the wait but then the food disappointed also. The crust was tough and I asked for medium buffalo wings and there was no heat at all. Spending almost $50 on pizza and wings and being disappointed. Disappointed customers

I love ordering their pizza just about every other week. They have the best thin crust pizza that…read morethey deliver hot and fresh right to my work. I love that they deliver and I don't have to leave the office. Staff is always very friendly.

Came with a larger party to Settler's, and I was impressed that they were able to get us in and out…read morewithin an hour even though they were on the busier side. Solid chicken tender sub and mac and cheese. My husband and I had to wait a little for these to come out even though everyone else's had hit the table, but we didn't mind since they were clearly being made fresh. Our waitress was friendly. Good stop for breakfast or lunch, and it was cool that they had a whole ice cream counter.

This recently updated location is a top tier terrific dining choice for everyone. Breakfast, lunch,…read moredinner? Great options await. Looking for something sweet? Definitely a great choice, ice cream, pie, cake... Yup, you guessed it, Settlers got it all. (The peanut butter pie, and carrot cake are straight up FIRE) Service is professional, warm, friendly and more importantly, QUICK. The ticket times from order to heal tend to be VERY brief. Moreover, this restaurant is VERY family friendly, has a warm, modern and welcoming vibe and low sticker shock prices that make a visit budget friendly. It's one of our family go-to restaurants in the Batavia area that has never once disappointed us when we visit.

ZERO STARS!!! Waited…read more25 minutes for a table. Sat for 20 minutes and no one even came over to ask for our drink order. Two tables that were seated after us got their drinks and ordered their food. We walked out.

Recently visited for the first time for trivia night. I punched the address into my GPS, and it had…read moreme park behind a building next door. Because this place is tucked back, I couldn't find it to save my life. You actually want to park and enter through the Batavia bootery. This info is just to help other YELPERS. Once I found this place, we were immediately seated, and were waiting on a 4th person. We were sat, and probably waited 30-40 minutes for someone to swing by and take our drink order. If we weren't there for trivia, I'm confident that we would've left. All of our drinks (lemonade and soda products) tasted off, and we all sent our drinks back. My lemonade was WAYYYYY TOOOOO sweet. We got water, and ordered food. Food was okay. I ordered loaded fries. They were okay, but those tasted off too like they were fried in old oil maybe? Waitress was nice and apologetic. I don't fault her for anything and felt a little bad for her. Not sure if I'll be back outside of trivia

Alright, here is the skinny on Andy's... If you want the…read morepizza to be AMAZING, not just good, you MUST order it "saucy" and with onions. Don't like onions? You'll like these ones. Unless you are straight up allergic to onions, they must be one of the toppings on your pizza. You can also count on Andy to deliver great wings, subs, and fried snacky bits. This is a dinner only, mostly takeout establishment. It's run by genuinely nice people who work to treat customers and community right. Definitely worth a visit.

I drive by this place once every couple weeks, and never even noticed it until a few weeks ago,…read moresince it's a small place, unassuming place, kind of off to the side and in the cut. Figured I'd stop in quick and grab a slice. Welp...they don't have slices! So instead I opted for a small meatball sub. Since Andy's doesn't have medium subs, only small and large, the "small" is actually more like a medium. It was fairly tasty and hit the spot. Pricing for their pizzas and subs is essentially on par with most local places that you'd find in Rochester or Buffalo. Hopefully I can stop in again to try more of their menu, although be aware that they are only open on evenings and not for lunch!

Working in the neighbor an hour away from home there was talk about this big bad pizza place in…read moretown. People raving about the buffalo chicken pizza. I decided to check it out. Oh my goodness the slices were huge! I'm talking gigantic! Like one slice is the size of most medium pizzas. The crust was nice and crispy. The regular cheese pizzas sauce was a little bit too sweet for me. They had a good selection of Strombolis and garlic knots also. I'll be back for the Stromboli! So I ordered the buffalo chicken and a slice of cheese. I was full off the one slice. Definitely a good deal at $12 for two slices and a drink.

The best pizza ever!! I love e their sweet sauce and crispy crust!. The pepperoni is perfect and…read morenot skimpy.

Chicken French is amazing! The Italian wedding soup & salad were good, as was the lemon cake. We…read moreordered to go & we're pleased with all aspects of our interactions.

We came here to celebrate my sister's birthday (her choice) and had such a great time. I started…read moreoff the night with an aperol spritz, which paired beautifully with one of their wood fired pizzas. My fiancé and I split the chicken bacon ranch which I highly recommend. The pizza plus an app is plenty of food for two people. Our server was friendly and efficient too. I would definitely come back here for a drink and pizza again.